Looking for seafood in Rochester is a bit like going on a treasure hunt—minus the risk of pirates or soggy maps. There’s something quietly thrilling about unearthing a well-prepared plate of fresh fish or a batch of crispy shrimp. I still think about the day a local handed me a plate of grilled sea bass at a tucked-away spot on Monroe Avenue. The combination of bold flavors and the comfort of the setting was enough to convert even my most landlocked friend into a seafood fan. Rochester’s seafood scene is as diverse as it is delicious, with each place offering a distinct personality, from bustling markets to elegant waterfront tables.
Sorting out the true gems from the ordinary takes more than glancing at a menu. Over the years, I’ve sampled my way through casual joints, flashy grills, and inviting bars—always looking for that perfect blend of freshness and flair. Whether you crave classic clam chowder or adventurous seafood boils, this guide serves up the details on where to find the best bites in town. Stick around for picks that go beyond the surface and leave no stone—or shell—unturned.
1. Masters Seafood
Masters Seafood feels more like a tradition than just a storefront on Long Pond Road. My first visit there was simple: I was told to trust the classic fried haddock, and I left with a new favorite. The unpretentious setting and focus on freshness make each order a guaranteed win.
The shop doubles as a market and eatery, so you can grab today’s catch to cook at home or let them handle the frying. There’s something special about watching the team prepare your meal, knowing it started as a whole fish just minutes before.
Be sure to try their fried clams or lightly battered shrimp. Both embody the local, straightforward style—no fuss, just quality. Value hunters and seafood purists will appreciate this spot for its classic dishes and wallet-friendly prices.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on Jefferson Road might be a national name, but it holds its own in Rochester’s seafood lineup. I once went for a celebratory dinner and ended up discovering the addictive nature of their cheddar biscuits—a detail regulars will tell you not to skip.
The atmosphere walks the line between bustling and cozy, great for families and larger groups. They keep their standards high with a menu full of ocean classics, and you can taste that commitment in each bite.
The Ultimate Feast is a table favorite for a reason. Crab legs, shrimp scampi, and tender whitefish cover all the bases. For those craving something simple, the grilled salmon is consistently tender. Order extra biscuits if you know what’s good for you.
3. Lasalle Steak & Crab
(585) 482-5740Call
Lasalle Steak & Crab feels like a hidden gem on Empire Boulevard, and those who know it tend to keep it on the short list for special occasions. My visit started with a quiet table by the window and a plate of perfectly prepared crab legs—it turned into an evening worth repeating.
The atmosphere walks the line between upscale and relaxed, making it just as suitable for date night as it is for a dinner with friends. You’ll notice attention to detail, both in service and presentation.
Crab legs and their shrimp cocktails are standouts. Both dishes capture what makes Lasalle unique: fresh ingredients, prepared with minimal fuss, letting the seafood shine. If you’re looking for subtlety and richness in every bite, this is the place.
4. McFadden Fish and Chips Restaurant
(585) 464-0001Call
The aroma of fried fish drifting from McFadden Fish and Chips on West Main Street tells you you’re in the right place before you even step inside. I stopped in on a rainy afternoon, drawn by a tip from a neighborhood local, and ended up with the crispiest haddock I’ve tasted in Rochester.
This spot delivers classic comfort, focusing on the essentials without overcomplicating things. It’s a place where friendly service meets hot baskets straight from the fryer.
The haddock fish and chips is a must, perfectly battered and flaky inside, but don’t skip the hushpuppies or corn fritters for a true Rochester twist. Each bite sums up what McFadden does best: honest, satisfying seafood with plenty of local character.
5. Wall Street Bar & Grill
Wall Street Bar & Grill gives off the energy of a city hangout with a splash of sophistication. My last visit was for a weeknight dinner, and the seafood selection caught me off guard—in the best way. The bar area buzzed with conversation, and the kitchen sent out plate after plate of fresh, flavorful dishes.
This spot stands out for great seafood without the pretense. It’s casual, but every plate looks and tastes like someone cared. The crowd is a good mix—after-work regulars, couples, and friends talking late into the evening.
The blackened salmon is a favorite for its bold flavor and perfect sear. Their seafood pasta is another top pick; it’s loaded but not heavy, letting each ingredient come through. Wall Street makes eating seafood in the city feel easy and inviting.
6. Boston Fish Market & Seafood
(585) 266-2277Call
Boston Fish Market & Seafood keeps things old-school on Hudson Ave, and that’s its charm. My first visit was out of curiosity, but the hustle behind the counter and steady stream of regulars told me this wasn’t an ordinary fish shop. The freshness in the display cases sets a high standard for Rochester’s seafood scene.
This place is both a trusted market and a reliable takeout stop. You can browse today’s catches, or let them turn your pick into a satisfying, hot meal. The staff readily offers advice if you’re not sure what to try.
The fried fish sandwich draws a loyal following, but grilled tilapia and fried scallops are also reliable choices. You taste the quality, whether you’re grabbing dinner or stocking up for home.
7. Harbor Seafood
(585) 471-5769Call
Harbor Seafood on East Ridge Road has a quiet confidence that’s easy to like. My first meal there was a spontaneous weekday lunch, sparked by a friend’s tip. We landed on a platter of grilled fish and left plotting our return, impressed by both the portions and freshness.
The vibe is cozy and relaxed, with staff who know their seafood. Prices sit comfortably in the middle, making this spot both accessible and satisfying for repeat visits.
The grilled fish combo plate is the standout. It offers a mix of flaky fish that captures Harbor Seafood’s focus on simple, quality cooking. Add a side of their crisp fries for a classic, reliable Rochester seafood experience.
8. Captain Jim’s Fish Market
Captain Jim’s Fish Market is one of those places that locals swear by and newcomers remember. My first visit was prompted by a Rochester native who claimed nothing compared to Captain Jim’s fried fish sandwich. She was right—the fish was flaky, well-seasoned, and generous.
The market layout means that you’re surrounded by today’s selections as you order, adding an extra layer of assurance to the freshness. The line moves quick, and staff keep things friendly and efficient.
Try the classic fried haddock or one of their hearty seafood platters. Both offer a taste of Captain Jim’s straightforward approach—good ingredients, no shortcuts. If you want tradition with a side of Rochester charm, this spot delivers.
9. Juicy Seafood
Juicy Seafood delivers a fun, come-as-you-are vibe on Winton Road that’s tough to ignore. Walking in with a group of friends, we were greeted by the unmistakable aroma of garlic butter and lively chatter—a sign you’re in a spot where seafood is meant to be enjoyed hands-on.
This place lives up to its name with bold flavors and messy, satisfying seafood boils. Bibs are readily offered, and you’ll want one by the time your order arrives, steaming hot and loaded with sauce.
Go for the crawfish or shrimp seafood boil with Cajun seasoning. The spice level is customizable, and the flavors are just right, giving every bite a punch. It’s casual, a little noisy, and unmistakably fun—a highlight for group outings.
10. Super Crab Juicy Seafood
Super Crab Juicy Seafood brings a lively energy to the Henrietta Shopping Center that’s hard to resist, especially when you catch the aroma of their signature boils. My visit was on a whim, lured in by the crowd and the mountain of shellfish gleaming in brightly colored spices.
The menu focuses on customizable seafood boils that come out piping hot. You pick your seafood, seasoning, and heat level—so each experience feels personal and a bit adventurous.
The snow crab legs with garlic butter are a clear highlight. They arrive juicy and packed with flavor, soaking up the robust sauces Super Crab does so well. If you enjoy a little spectacle with your meal, this spot is pure entertainment—and delicious, too.
More Things to Try in Rochester, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Rochester, NY for a casual meal?
Some of Rochester’s favorites for a laid-back seafood fix include Captain Jim’s Fish Market, McFadden Fish and Chips, and Juicy Seafood. Each spot offers a relaxed vibe and satisfying plates without any fuss.
Where can I find the freshest seafood in Rochester, NY?
Markets like Boston Fish Market & Seafood and Masters Seafood are known for their day-of-fresh catches. Both double as markets and takeout spots, letting you see the quality up close before placing an order.
What local seafood dishes should I try in Rochester?
Fried haddock sandwiches, seafood boils, and grilled tilapia are local staples. Try the fried haddock at McFadden’s or Captain Jim’s, or opt for a seafood boil at Juicy Seafood for a more hands-on experience.
Are there family-friendly seafood restaurants in Rochester?
Red Lobster and Wall Street Bar & Grill are both crowd-pleasers for groups and families. The menus offer plenty of options so everyone at the table leaves happy.
Is it possible to get takeout seafood in Rochester?
Absolutely. Masters Seafood, Boston Fish Market & Seafood, and Super Crab Juicy Seafood all offer fast, convenient takeout that doesn’t skimp on quality.
Which seafood spots in Rochester offer healthier, grilled options?
For lighter plates, head to Harbor Seafood, Wall Street Bar & Grill, or Lasalle Steak & Crab. They each offer excellent grilled fish alongside richer menu classics.
Do these seafood restaurants cater to special occasions?
Yes. Lasalle Steak & Crab and Bernard’s Grove are local favorites for birthdays, anniversaries, and celebrations, combining great seafood with a memorable atmosphere.
