Best Seafood in Tarpon Springs, FL

Eating seafood in Tarpon Springs is less like dining out and more like slipping into a long-standing coastal tradition. Here, Greek heritage meets fresh Gulf flavors in a town where fishing boats float within sight of your table and old-time markets pack their counters with the day’s catch. On some visits, I’ve watched the sun glint off the water while biting into tender grilled octopus or sharing oysters with friends—each meal, a small adventure.

If you want the best seafood in Tarpon Springs, you’re in the right place. This isn’t a list that tosses around generic spots; every restaurant here has earned its spot on the lineup. Whether you crave fish cooked the old Greek way with a drizzle of lemon, or something newer like poke overflowing with flavor, you’ll find plenty worth more than just one trip. Curious where to start? Let’s dive into the best places to eat seafood in Tarpon Springs, with a few surprises along the way.

1. Rusty Bellies Waterfront Grill

Rusty Bellies Waterfront Grill feels like a hidden gem, where the water laps right outside and the smell of the sea mingles with grilling fish. Owned by generations of the Russell family, it blends Tarpon Springs’ fishing roots with good food and genuine hospitality. The daily catch goes from boat to table, so freshness is guaranteed.

One meal I can’t forget was their grouper sandwich—crisp outside, flaky inside, with just enough lemon and house-made sauce. For a true local taste, go for the stone crab claws when in season or their fresh Gulf shrimp, landed on the family’s own boats. Each dish here tells the Russell story, offering a slice of Tarpon Springs tradition with every bite.

2. Captn Jack’s Bar and Grill

Captn Jack’s Bar and Grill sits right on the Anclote River, giving you a front-row seat to Tarpon Springs’ legendary sunsets. The vibe here is relaxed and friendly, just the place you want to linger with friends or family. I remember sitting upstairs on a breezy night, jazz in the background and plates of seafood arriving one after another.

The real magic happens when you dive into their Captain’s Platter—a medley of flounder, shrimp, scallops, and a tender crab cake, all expertly cooked. For lighter fare, the Firecracker Shrimp Tacos pop with just the right kick. Of course, the Grouper Sandwich is a local must. Captain Jack’s blends easy-going charm with seriously good seafood, making every meal a mini vacation.

3. Tarpon Turtle Grill & Marina

Tarpon Turtle Grill & Marina has that breezy island feel, right on the shore of Lake Tarpon. Whether you pull up in your boat or stroll in and grab a patio seat, the vibe invites you to slow down and savor the moment. The scenery here feels almost cinematic—think palm trees, sparkling water, and a relaxed crowd soaking in the sun.

I still remember an afternoon spent here, Caribbean music playing as I tried their Gulf Grouper Tacos and Shrimp Rice Bowl. Both delivered on flavor, each bite tasting fresh and full of coastal flair. If you’re craving something classic, the Blackened Fish Sandwich is another highlight. Tarpon Turtle balances fun, fresh seafood with waterfront views—an easy favorite for locals and visitors alike.

4. Dimitri’s on the Water Greek Restaurant

Dimitri’s on the Water Greek Restaurant brings true Greek flavor to the heart of Tarpon Springs’ Sponge Docks. Sunlight glimmers on the river outside, while inside, the atmosphere buzzes with lively conversations and the aromas of Mediterranean spices. Every visit feels like you’re part of an extended family gathering. Once, I lingered over lunch here, watching fishing boats drift by as platters arrived fresh from the kitchen.

The highlight is always their whole grilled fish, prepared simply with lemon, olive oil, and herbs. If you want to sample signature Greek seafood, try the chargrilled octopus or sea bass—both dishes let the ingredients shine. Dimitri’s stands out for its mix of authenticity, waterfront charm, and the unmistakable taste of the Mediterranean brought right to Tarpon Springs.

5. Pelican Point Seafood of Tarpon Springs

Pelican Point Seafood of Tarpon Springs isn’t your typical seafood market—it’s a showcase for the region’s freshest catches, where local fishermen are the stars. Strolling past their overflowing counters, you can sense how close you are to the source. The staff are generous with advice, quick to share tips for the perfect grill or bake.

I once picked up fresh Gulf shrimp here and made a simple sauté at home that tasted like a restaurant delight. Their daily selection of grouper fillets and stone crab claws is unbeatable if you love to cook. For anyone who wants to experience Tarpon Springs’ seafood scene straight from the source, Pelican Point is the place. The focus on sustainability and local pride shines with every order.

6. Bayou Bistro & Tiki

Bayou Bistro & Tiki is where you want to be for a laid-back island escape in Tarpon Springs. The waterfront setting creates that classic “tiki bar” vibe, where toes tap to live music and laughter carries over the water. One morning I dropped by for brunch and ended up staying through lunch—there’s just that much to enjoy.

Seafood lovers should try their crab-stuffed flounder or the shrimp and grits, which bring Southern flavor with a local twist. Their fish tacos are always fresh and zesty, a great pick for a casual meal by the water. Bayou Bistro & Tiki excels at relaxed, unfussy seafood—perfect for anyone who likes their meal with a view and a cool breeze.

7. The Hawaiian Poke Place

The Hawaiian Poke Place offers a refreshing spin on Tarpon Springs seafood with vibrant flavors and an easygoing atmosphere. It’s the kind of spot you find yourself visiting on a whim, then craving again the next day. I still remember my first bowl here—ultra-fresh, colorful, and layered with great textures.

For a no-fuss lunch or dinner, their classic poke bowl with ahi tuna, salmon, or shrimp is the standout. If you like mixing things up, their build-your-own option lets you pile on your favorite toppings and sauces. From the first bite, it’s all about big flavor and satisfying freshness. The Hawaiian Poke Place brings light, modern seafood to Tarpon Springs in the tastiest way possible.

8. Acropolis Greek Taverna – Tarpon Springs

Acropolis Greek Taverna – Tarpon Springs brings the lively spirit of Greece right to Dodecanese Boulevard. The setting buzzes with conversation, music, and the tantalizing scent of grilling seafood. One night, I watched friends break into spontaneous dance between plates of food—a scene that captures the restaurant’s contagious energy.

The seafood here holds its own alongside the classics. You can’t go wrong with their grilled octopus—tender, smoky, and drizzled with olive oil and lemon. The seafood pasta bursts with shrimp and scallops, perfect for sharing. Acropolis excels at balancing fresh seafood with bold Mediterranean flavors, making every meal feel like a celebration. For an authentic taste of Greece, right in Tarpon Springs, this taverna delivers.

9. Currents Restaurant

Currents Restaurant makes fine dining approachable in the heart of old Tarpon Springs. Polished but never stuffy, it’s the kind of place where you feel well cared for from the first bite to the last. I once sat near the window, watching the world go by while savoring one of the best seafood dinners I’ve had in town.

Their pan-seared grouper is a house favorite—delicate, bright, and paired with seasonal vegetables. Fish lovers should also try the shrimp and scallop risotto: creamy, comforting, and skillfully balanced. Currents leans into creative preparations using the best local seafood, setting itself apart with thoughtful flavors and impeccable presentation. For a special night out, it’s a reliable pick.

10. H’ours Creole Smokehouse

H’ours Creole Smokehouse infuses Tarpon Springs with a taste of New Orleans, weaving Cajun and Creole flavors into every dish. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the rich aroma of smoky spices and soul food favorites. One visit left me daydreaming about their creative seafood menu for days afterward.

If you want something that captures their spirit, order the blackened catfish or shrimp and grits. Both dishes are bold, hearty, and perfectly seasoned, showcasing the kitchen’s flair for Southern comfort. H’ours stands out for blending local seafood with Louisiana classics—a combo that keeps taste buds guessing and brings something new to Tarpon Springs’ dining scene.

Frequently Asked Questions

What seafood is Tarpon Springs famous for?
Tarpon Springs is known for its fresh Gulf grouper, shrimp, stone crab, and Greek-style seafood dishes. Grouper sandwiches and grilled fish are local staples, often starring on menus around town.

Are there halal or haram seafood options in Tarpon Springs?
Most seafood in Tarpon Springs, such as fish, shrimp, and crab, is considered halal. Standard restaurant dishes generally avoid haram ingredients in seafood, but it’s always smart to ask your server for preparation details if you have concerns.

Is there a best time of year for fresh seafood in Tarpon Springs?
You’ll find fresh seafood year-round, but stone crab season runs October to May, and shrimp boats are most active in late spring and fall. Grouper is plentiful throughout the year.

Can I buy fresh seafood to cook at home?
Yes. Pelican Point Seafood and several other local markets sell fresh catches daily. Look for shrimp, grouper, and crab—great for home cooking.

Which restaurants have waterfront dining?
Rusty Bellies Waterfront Grill, Tarpon Turtle Grill & Marina, Dimitri’s on the Water, and several others offer beautiful views with your meal.

Are there options for gluten-free or vegetarian seafood dishes?
Many restaurants provide gluten-free and vegetarian options. Menus often highlight these dishes, so ask your server for recommendations tailored to your needs.