Seafood cravings come and go, but finding a plate worth remembering is an adventure in itself. Over the years, I’ve sampled my way through Hagerstown’s seafood scene, tasting everything from quietly stacked crab cakes to shrimp dishes so fresh you’d think you could still hear the ocean. If, like me, you judge a town partly by the quality of its fried catfish or who brings in the best catch of the day, you’re in the right place.
Hagerstown has a handful of places where seafood isn’t just a menu filler—it’s the headline act. Some spots lean into the classic Maryland affair with Old Bay spice and heaps of crab, while others surprise with creative twists or just good old-fashioned comfort food. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, this selection promises more flavor and less fuss. Get ready to dig into the best seafood in Hagerstown, MD—one forkful at a time.
1. Schula’s Grill and Crab
Schula’s Grill and Crab has the feel of a local favorite, and for good reason. On my last visit, I slid into a sunlit booth, hungry for seafood that didn’t taste mass-produced. I wasn’t disappointed. Schula’s is known for its generous menu and the kitchen’s willingness to flex for special requests.
What makes this spot off John F Kennedy Drive special is the balance of house-crafted flavors with classic Maryland charm. Their crab cakes have earned the local badge of honor, voted Best Crab Cake in the region. They’re packed with flaky meat and practically zero filler, served broiled to a golden finish.
If you’re not in the mood for crab, their blackened tilapia and the shrimp and scallop linguine are worth a try. Freshness is the theme here—every dish truly delivers. No surprise, Schula’s keeps locals coming back for more.
2. Chic’s Seafood
Chic’s Seafood brings a sense of nostalgia to Hagerstown’s seafood lineup. The place reminds me of classic Eastern Shore spots, where every table seems to be on a first-name basis with the staff. Service is brisk but always friendly, and takeout is a local ritual for many regulars.
The menu hinges on freshness, with fried fish sandwiches and platters that come out hot and crisp every time. Their broiled seafood options are excellent for those looking for something lighter, though the battered cod and creamy coleslaw continually steal the show.
If you want to sample their best, try the generous seafood platter—piled high with shrimp and cod, it’s the kind of meal that fills you up without trying too hard.
3. Nick’s Airport Inn
Nick’s Airport Inn is one of those places you remember long after you leave. My first meal there kicked off with a loaf of warm bread and a promise of things to come. This is a spot where elegance and comfort sit side by side. You’ll find everything from scratch, with a focus on local produce and top-tier seafood.
The crab cakes are a must—jumbo lump crab, clearly handled with care, just enough seasoning to let the seafood shine. It’s the sort of dish that doesn’t need a hard sell. If you’re in the mood for something with a bit of ceremony, the fresh catch of the day is always treated respectfully, whether grilled or broiled.
Dining at Nick’s feels special but never stuffy. The staff is happy to talk through options and make recommendations. It’s a top pick for seafood in Hagerstown, especially if you value classic technique and thoughtful service.
4. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Hagerstown manages to turn a chain experience into something that feels reliably comforting. I’ve ducked in more than once on rainy afternoons craving the familiar warmth of their cheddar biscuits and a menu that covers all the classics. The place is bright, easy-going, and always bustling with locals and travelers alike.
The seafood here is about consistency. The grilled salmon is an easy favorite—simple, healthy, and always cooked just right. The shrimp scampi delivers a good balance of flavor and lightness, making it ideal if you’re after something satisfying without going overboard.
Red Lobster works well for a laid-back meal, especially when you want a spot that can handle groups or families with ease.
5. Stadium Grill & Tavern
There’s something about Stadium Grill & Tavern that feels casual and unpretentious. I’ve dropped in for a quick bite and ended up lingering over a meal, thanks to the buzz from the regulars and the easygoing staff. This spot strikes a balance between neighborhood pub and seafood destination.
Their seafood menu is short but focused—the grilled salmon and broiled whitefish stand out for their freshness and flavor. No frills, just well-prepared classics that are both comforting and satisfying. Sides like fresh veggies and seasoned rice round things out nicely.
If you’re looking for a meal that hits all the right notes without a fuss, Stadium Grill & Tavern keeps things tasty and laid-back. It’s a local go-to for seafood done right.
6. Zach Greenlee’s Trackside Steak and Seafood
Zach Greenlee’s Trackside Steak and Seafood mixes small-town ease with a focus on fresh ingredients. On my last visit, I arrived expecting steak, but ended up tempted by the seafood selection—an unexpected perk at a spot known for its chops. The vibe here is relaxed, while the staff keeps things moving with genuine smiles.
The broiled sea scallops are a highlight—plump, lightly seasoned, and served with sides that don’t steal the show. Their flaky whitefish entrée is another crowd-pleaser, offering a simple take that lets the quality shine through. Salads and veggies complement the main dishes without fuss.
Trackside makes seafood approachable and reliable, perfect for those evenings when you want a touch of classic dining without anything overly fancy.
7. Cameron’s Seafood
Cameron’s Seafood is a dependable choice when you want to bring home something fresh and flavorful. I often swing by on busy nights when cooking isn’t in the cards, and I never regret it. It’s a straightforward seafood shop that puts freshness first, with cases full of daily catch ready for your dinner table.
Their steamed shrimp is the real deal—plump, seasoned just enough, and perfect for a quick meal. For something more substantial, the grilled fish platters and jumbo crab legs always look tempting and taste even better.
Cameron’s is also great for families thanks to generous portions and easy takeout. You get all the flavor without the wait, making it one of Hagerstown’s top stops for fuss-free seafood.
8. Potomac Seafood of Hagerstown
Potomac Seafood of Hagerstown is one of those under-the-radar places that rewards repeat visits. I first stumbled in while searching for something new, and was drawn in by the aroma of fresh seafood. This market is all about quality—what you see in the display is what you get wrapped up to take home.
The fresh fish fillets are the stars here, especially the wild-caught options. I’ve had great luck with their flounder and catfish—everything is cleaned and prepped on-site, making dinner prep a breeze.
If you’re after shellfish, the shrimp and blue crabs are good bets. Potomac Seafood makes home-cooked seafood accessible, whether you’re cooking for one or many. For a low-fuss, high-reward dinner, this spot is tough to beat.
9. J & D Meats
J & D Meats is more than just a butcher—it’s a one-stop spot for fresh seafood in Hagerstown, tucked into a local strip mall. I stopped in on a friend’s recommendation and was surprised by the range behind the counter. The staff is helpful and knows their products, always ready to steer you toward the best seasonal picks.
Their salmon fillets and tilapia stand out for freshness, often delivered straight from trusted suppliers. You can have your seafood portioned to order, perfect for family meals or smaller gatherings.
J & D also stocks shrimp and seasonal catches, making it easy to plan a seafood night at home. For quality and convenience, it’s a hidden gem in Hagerstown’s growing seafood landscape.
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants are most popular in Hagerstown, MD?
Schula’s Grill and Crab, Chic’s Seafood, and Nick’s Airport Inn are among the local favorites, celebrated for their freshness and variety. Each offers its own style, from classic Maryland crab dishes to laid-back platters.
Where can I find the best crab cakes in Hagerstown?
Schula’s Grill and Crab and Nick’s Airport Inn both have top reputations for crab cakes made with real lump crab and minimal fillers, staying true to Maryland’s proud crab heritage.
Are there any seafood markets in Hagerstown with take-home options?
Yes. Cameron’s Seafood, Potomac Seafood, and J & D Meats all offer fresh catch, shellfish, and fillets for home cooking. These spots are great for stocking up on ingredients or picking up a ready-to-eat meal.
Can I find healthy seafood options in Hagerstown?
Most restaurants and markets listed offer grilled, broiled, and steamed choices. Look for salmon, tilapia, or shrimp prepared with lighter seasoning to keep things healthier without sacrificing taste.
Which restaurants are good for families or groups?
Red Lobster is popular with families thanks to its spacious seating and crowd-pleaser menu. Schula’s and Stadium Grill & Tavern also work well for group outings and casual get-togethers.