Finding remarkable seafood in Pueblo, CO isn’t as tricky as you might think. Tucked away between the mountains and the plains, Pueblo surprises with a handful of restaurants that put a genuine spin on ocean fare. Whether you crave sushi that seems to melt on the tongue or wild-caught catfish that reminds you of a southern backyard fish fry, you’ll find something to satisfy each craving. I once spent an afternoon here hopping between spots along Northern and Highway 50, eating calamari tacos and grilled shrimp that gave my so-called “seafood snob” palate a run for its money.
Pueblo’s seafood scene isn’t about pretense, but freshness and skill. Each place on this list brings something special—thoughtful preparation, unexpected pairings, and just the right pop of flavor. If you think “mountain town” can’t deliver a solid seafood plate, prepare to be pleasantly surprised as we run down the best spots for prawns, poke, and more.
1. Blue Ocean Japanese Restaurant
Blue Ocean Japanese Restaurant brings a polished sushi bar vibe to the heart of Pueblo. With a cozy spot on Union Avenue, this place offers meticulously crafted rolls and ultra-fresh sashimi that might make you forget how far you are from the coast. The staff handles orders with real care, keeping the atmosphere friendly but never rushed.
My first taste here was the Salmon Lovers Roll—each piece reminded me how good fresh fish can be when balanced with delicate rice. The eel avocado roll and classic miso soup both live up to their reputation. Blue Ocean’s menu goes beyond just sushi, offering shrimp tempura that’s crisp and light every time.
Those who like choices will appreciate the vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free options. For an easy top pick, try the chef’s special nigiri for a quick tour of their best cuts.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on North Elizabeth Street is the go-to spot for familiar, no-surprise seafood in Pueblo. The restaurant balances a casual setting with a solid range of classic dishes. Table service is attentive, and the menu offers everything from light lunch options to full seafood feasts.
One memorable visit started with their signature shrimp—lightly seasoned, always cooked just right. If you’re unsure where to begin, the Grilled Salmon New Orleans delivers just the right blend of spice and flavor. Their takeout service makes for a convenient dinner fix after a long week.
The Cheddar Bay Biscuits are always a must, complementing the freshness of their main courses. Red Lobster stakes its claim in Pueblo with reliable quality and a comfortable atmosphere for groups or solo diners alike.
3. Big Blue Seafood Market
Big Blue Seafood Market is part fresh counter, part no-frills eatery, and all heart. Step inside and you’re met with a display case brimming with today’s best wild-caught choices. What really stands out here is the freshness and the friendly staff who know their stuff.
My top memory: cracking open a soft-shell crab sandwich while chatting with regulars who swear by the catfish basket. Their shrimp po’ boy comes piled high with crisp, juicy shrimp—hard to find fault with anything fried here.
If you want local flavor, order the fish tacos. Each one channels the laid-back style of a coastal shack, right in Pueblo. This spot makes seafood approachable, tasty, and consistently satisfying.
4. Captain D’s
Captain D’s brings quick, budget-friendly seafood to Pueblo’s north side. This spot makes it easy to satisfy a craving for fried fish or grilled options without a long wait. The restaurant keeps things straightforward, perfect for a simple lunch or convenient takeout.
My go-to order is the battered fish plate—golden, flaky, and always piping hot. The butterfly shrimp packs plenty of crunch, and the hush puppies have a subtle sweetness that pairs well with tangy slaw.
For grilled fans, the tilapia is light yet filling. Captain D’s is a smart pick for those days when you want solid seafood on the fly, no fuss required.
5. Twenty One Steak
Twenty One Steak sits right on Pueblo’s Riverwalk, blending a polished setting with a kitchen run by local talent. The restaurant feels both welcoming and upscale, making it perfect for celebrations or a quiet night out. Chef Michael Degenhart’s commitment to quality is clear on every plate.
I once splurged on their scallops—each one perfectly seared with a buttery finish, proof that the kitchen handles seafood as well as its renowned beef. The grilled salmon is another stand-out, arriving juicy with a citrus glaze that feels equal parts refined and comforting.
If you want to experience seafood at its best in Pueblo, trust the kitchen’s featured catches and daily specials. Twenty One Steak turns a seafood dinner into an occasion.
6. Habanero’ss Mexican Grill
Habanero’ss Mexican Grill delivers a lively blend of Mexican flavors and seafood favorites, right on Pueblo’s busy North Elizabeth Street. The restaurant feels like a local secret—casual, colorful, and always upbeat. Service is fast, and the staff never skimps on hospitality.
I ordered the shrimp fajitas on a friend’s recommendation. They arrived sizzling with plenty of bell peppers and onions—each bite as bright as it looked. The tilapia tacos also stand out, served with a fresh slaw that gives them an extra kick.
If you’re up for something different, try the seafood enchiladas for a blend of tender shrimp and creamy sauce. Habanero’ss Mexican Grill proves that Pueblo’s seafood scene pairs perfectly with a little spice.
7. Habeneros’s Mexican Grill
(719) 542-6678Call
Habeneros’s Mexican Grill is an easy stop for bold flavors and unexpected seafood choices in Pueblo. This spot draws regulars for its friendly staff, speedy service, and a menu that stretches well beyond standard taqueria fare.
On my last visit, the fish tacos delivered—lightly grilled tilapia tucked into warm tortillas, topped with fresh pico and a tangy sauce. The shrimp burrito is another crowd-pleaser, packed with plump shrimp and just the right amount of heat.
With prices that don’t break the bank, Habeneros’s lets you try more than one plate. It’s a great pick when you want your seafood with a side of Pueblo’s best Mexican comfort food.
8. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen offers Pueblo a taste of classic seafood done right, without the coastal price tag. The menu hits all the nostalgic notes—perfect for anyone craving a reliably satisfying meal. This spot is easy to find on North Freeway, with a casual atmosphere that suits quick bites or family visits.
I’ve always been partial to their wild-caught white fish—it arrives crisp and flaky, great with their seasoned fries and a side of hush puppies. The grilled salmon is another solid choice, especially when you want something filling but still light.
Friendly service and decades of seafood tradition make Captain D’s standout. If you want classic American seafood at a good value, this kitchen delivers every time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of seafood dishes can I find in Pueblo, CO?
You’ll find a bit of everything—from fresh sushi and classic fried fish to shrimp tacos and grilled salmon. Many places add their own twist, with Southwestern flavors or house-made sauces.
Are there any seafood places in Pueblo that offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Yes. Spots like Blue Ocean Japanese Restaurant and Twenty One Steak offer gluten-free and vegetarian options alongside their seafood menus.
Where can I get seafood takeout in Pueblo?
Most seafood restaurants listed—including Captain D’s, Red Lobster, and Big Blue Seafood Market—offer takeout for lunch and dinner.
What’s the best place for seafood on a budget in Pueblo?
Captain D’s and Big Blue Seafood Market are popular for tasty seafood at lower prices, without sacrificing quality.
Which Pueblo seafood restaurants are good for families or groups?
Red Lobster and Captain D’s both provide plenty of space, friendly service, and kid-friendly menu choices.