Finding the best seafood in Merrillville, IN is a bit like going on a treasure hunt, but with the delicious reward of fresh shrimp or perfectly crispy fish fillets waiting at the end. I still remember strolling down Broadway one cloudy afternoon, the crave for golden fried catfish guiding me through a row of buzzing local joints and quiet, tucked-away gems. Merrillville may surprise you with its variety—each spot seems to know just how to blend charm with solid culinary skills.
Whether you’re after classic fried fare, crave something straight from the grill, or want seafood dressed up in elegant sauces, there’s a place on this list that can hit the mark. The trick, as always, is knowing where to look. Stick with this guide, and you’ll have the inside scoop on places that know the art of great seafood—no guesswork needed, just pure satisfaction.
1. Red Lobster
Red Lobster at 1450 E 82nd Ave is Merrillville’s mainstay for those who like their seafood classic and consistent. The warm, nautical vibe is the sort of place that makes you linger, especially when the scent of fresh biscuits hits your table.
I’ve stopped in more than once after a long drive, and their Admiral’s Feast rarely disappoints. It’s a generous plate stacked with fried shrimp, bay scallops, and fish. If you want something from the grill, try the Wood-Grilled Salmon—juicy and with just enough char to make it special.
Red Lobster stands out for its wide range of gluten-free options and the reliable service that makes dining easy. When you want straightforward, well-prepared seafood, it’s a dependable pick.
2. Simply Seafood
Simply Seafood at 5516 Broadway feels like the sort of place you discover from a tip whispered by locals. I stopped here after hearing about their massive shrimp baskets—a decision I didn’t regret. The staff serve up unfussy, hearty seafood, perfect for lunch or a relaxed dinner.
The menu is stacked with tempting choices, but the jumbo shrimp are the star. Each one is cooked to order, with a crisp breading that gives way to juicy, flavorful meat. The catfish nuggets also deserve a nod for their tender flake and rich taste.
Simply Seafood stands out for its focus on freshness and generous portions. Whether you’re a regular or just passing through, it’s a spot that treats classic seafood right.
3. Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant- Merrillville
Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant at Southlake Mall offers a different kind of seafood experience. With polished dining rooms and the hum of conversation, it’s equal parts buzz and relaxation. I once spent an afternoon tasting their seasonal seafood specials—the pairing with crisp white wine was spot-on.
Start with the Thai Lettuce Wraps with seared ahi tuna. They’re light yet packed with layers of flavor. For a main, the Pan-Roasted Barramundi stands out. The fish is tender, flaky, and served with a vibrant mix of fresh vegetables.
What sets Cooper’s Hawk apart is the care in pairing wine with each dish. If you want to treat seafood as the star of a slow, memorable meal, this is the place to linger.
4. Long John Silver’s
Situated on 61st Avenue, Long John Silver’s takes you straight to the heart of classic fast-casual seafood. My visits here always start with the distinct aroma of frying batter—a comfort if you’re in the mood for a quick, no-nonsense meal.
The menu’s highlight is the wild-caught Alaska pollock, served up crisp with a hint of salt and plenty of crunch. The grilled salmon is another solid pick for those who want something on the lighter side, with its flaky texture and subtle smokiness.
What sets Long John Silver’s apart is the value: big portions of dependable seafood, served fast. When you’re craving something both familiar and satisfying, this spot never overcomplicates things.
5. White Castle
White Castle at 1 E 81st Ave is known for its iconic sliders but also surprises seafood lovers with a few worthy options. I ended up here late one evening when everything else had closed, and the Seafood Nibblers saved the night—tiny bites that are crispy and satisfying.
If you’re looking for something different, try the fish sliders. Each one features fried fish topped with tartar sauce, tucked in their famous soft buns. They’re bite-sized and easy to share or to claim as your own guilty pleasure.
White Castle stands out for speed and the comfort of classic, affordable food. When you need seafood without the wait or fuss, this is your spot for something fast and familiar.
6. J Ginger’s
+1 219-769-6311
J Ginger’s on US Highway 30 takes a classic approach to seafood, steak, and hearty American fare. I first wandered in during a rainy afternoon and found the atmosphere relaxed but polished—a hidden pocket where families gather and locals grab a leisurely meal.
The menu offers familiar comforts, but the grilled salmon stands out. It arrives perfectly flaky, with a smoky char that lingers just long enough. Their seafood pastas are also worth exploring, generously portioned and rich without being heavy.
What makes J Ginger’s memorable is the attention to detail, from the friendly service to the way each plate feels thoughtfully prepared. It’s a spot to settle in for a meal that feels both neighborly and a touch refined.
7. House Of Kobe – Merrillville
House Of Kobe on Broadway mixes dinner with a performance, thanks to teppanyaki chefs who turn every meal into a show. My first visit came with a celebratory mood—there’s something memorable about watching seafood tossed and seared right in front of you.
If you’re in the mood for something light but packed with flavor, try the grilled shrimp teppanyaki. The shrimp arrives hot, tender, and perfectly seasoned. Those looking for more variety can order the seafood combo, which often includes scallops and white fish grilled to bring out fresh, subtle flavors.
House Of Kobe stands out for its fresh ingredients and interactive dining. When you want a meal that’s as entertaining as it is delicious, it’s hard to beat this local favorite.
8. MastersQue BBQ & Seafood Restaurant
(219) 525-5401Call
MastersQue BBQ & Seafood Restaurant on E 81st Ave merges smoked barbecue flavors with standout seafood. I first dropped by on a weekend, pulled in by the aroma rolling from the kitchen. The eclectic menu hits a sweet spot for those craving both sea and smoke.
The catfish nuggets here are a must—lightly seasoned, fried until golden, and sturdy enough to hold their crunch. The crab legs add something extra, served with seasoning that’s bold but not overpowering.
MastersQue stands apart for bringing barbecue and seafood together in a relaxed, no-pressure setting. It’s a go-to when you want flavor without fuss, and the portions make sure you never leave hungry.
9. El Salto Restaurant
El Salto Restaurant, located on E Lincoln Hwy, brings vibrant Mexican flavors to Merrillville’s seafood scene. My first visit was on a quiet weeknight, and the colorful plates alone set the mood for a great meal. The setting is casual but filled with energy from start to finish.
Try the camarones a la diabla—shrimp in a bold, spicy sauce that packs just the right kick. The tilapia Veracruzana is another standout, featuring flaky fish simmered with tomatoes, olives, and capers for a balanced, satisfying dish.
El Salto shines by blending classic Mexican cooking with fresh seafood, creating a menu that’s both familiar and a little adventurous. Each visit feels like a mini getaway, plate by plate.
10. Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant- Merrillville, IN
Located in Southlake Mall, Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant in Merrillville, IN is a spot where seafood goes upscale, and every bite comes with a well-chosen wine. I set aside a whole evening here once, moving from the tasting room straight to a cozy dining table—each course felt like its own little celebration.
The Blackened Ahi Tuna appetizer is wildly flavorful, with spice that mingles perfectly with their signature white blend. For a main, try the Pan-Seared Barramundi: the fish is golden on the outside, delicate inside, and plated with seasonal vegetables that show off Cooper’s Hawk’s modern style.
What sets this place apart is how effortlessly it combines fresh seafood, inventive preparations, and an unmatched wine list. Time slows down here, making it easy to savor every forkful.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Merrillville, IN?
Merrillville has quite a few seafood spots with different styles. Favorites include Simply Seafood for jumbo shrimp, House of Kobe for teppanyaki and sushi, and MastersQue for a mix of barbecue and seafood. You’ll also find reliable chains like Red Lobster.
Are there any seafood restaurants with takeout or delivery?
Yes, many seafood restaurants offer takeout or delivery. Simply Seafood, MastersQue BBQ & Seafood, and Red Lobster all have these options available for quick, convenient meals at home.
Where can I find halal seafood in Merrillville?
While most traditional seafood dishes are halal by default, it’s best to call ahead and confirm with the restaurant, especially regarding preparation and shared cooking spaces. Simply Seafood and other independent spots are usually open to answering questions about their kitchen practices.
Which seafood restaurants are good for families or groups?
House Of Kobe is entertaining for all ages with its tableside show. Red Lobster and Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant also provide comfortable seating and flexible menu options, making them easy for group dining.
Do any seafood places in Merrillville offer gluten-free options?
Yes, both Red Lobster and Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant have dedicated gluten-free menus or options available—just ask your server for guidance.