Fresh seafood in Fayetteville, GA isn’t just a menu choice—it’s a beloved local tradition. Every corner seems to offer a new spot with the promise of crackling fried fish, buttery shrimp, and platters so appetizing you’ll debate sharing with anyone. On my last seafood crawl through Fayetteville, the blend of Southern charm and surprising flavors turned a simple meal into a real event. One moment, you’re cracking crab legs with friends; the next, you’re discussing whether hush puppies truly count as the perfect side (they do).
Searching for the best seafood here isn’t about blindly picking the most popular place but uncovering those local gems that quietly outshine big names. From homey cafés to lively, bustling grills, each place on this list has its own character and loyal following. Ready to find your next favorite seafood spot—or maybe spark a bit of friendly argument over who serves the best hush puppies in town? You’re in the right place.
1. The Juicy Crab
The Juicy Crab isn’t your typical chain seafood spot. Step inside, and you’ll immediately sense the vibrant New Orleans spirit that the Chen family brought to Fayetteville. Here, seafood boils with bold flavors are the main event, and there’s a fun messiness that’s part of the experience—no one judges sauce-stained fingers.
What makes The Juicy Crab stand out is the way they let you customize your seafood adventure. Choose your catch—snow crab legs, shrimp, or mussels—and then pick a seasoning blend. Their signature Juicy Special turns even simple shrimp into something unforgettable. I once ordered the snow crab with mild seasoning, and the balance of spice and citrus had me considering a second round.
Don’t skip the boiled combos. They’re piled high with corn and potatoes, bringing Southern comfort to every bite. If you want to see why locals keep coming back, grab a seafood boil bag and dive in.
2. City Cafe & Bakery
City Cafe & Bakery is where Fayetteville meets Europe in a cozy, sunlit dining room. On my last visit, I settled into a corner table by the window and couldn’t help but notice the string of regulars getting greeted by name—that’s the kind of warmth you’ll find here. The menu draws from both continental and German roots, so you get tradition with a twist.
Fresh seafood features pop up often, and their pan-seared tilapia deserves a mention. The light herbs and crisp pan finish let the fish shine without fuss. Pair it with their homemade bread and suddenly lunch feels like a treat.
Don’t miss the bakery after your meal. Take home a loaf or a pastry; you’ll be glad you did. City Cafe & Bakery is comfort food, done with quiet style.
3. Village Cafe
Village Cafe brings a little extra polish to Fayetteville’s dining scene. I remember my first meal there—a peaceful evening with soft lighting and the kind of service where the waiter remembers your name. This spot takes pride in fine dining, and it’s clear from how plates arrive: well-presented, generous, and always fresh.
Their seafood selection is impressive, with grilled salmon and shrimp scampi standing out. The salmon comes with just enough char to add flavor, balanced by tender vegetables. The shrimp scampi is tossed in a delicate garlic sauce that somehow never overpowers the natural sweetness of the shrimp.
With its consistent quality and inviting atmosphere, Village Cafe has earned its loyal following. If you’re after a quiet night with memorable seafood in a relaxed but elegant setting, this is your answer.
4. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen is where you go for fast, satisfying seafood without any fuss. The first time I stopped in, I was greeted by the friendly staff and the nostalgic scents of hush puppies frying in the kitchen. This spot has a loyal crowd thanks to its dependable value and welcoming, family-style feel.
Their classic battered fish is a local favorite—golden on the outside and flaky within. If you’re feeling a little adventurous, try the grilled white fish or fried shrimp platter. Each dish is prepared to order, so it always tastes fresh.
You can count on quick service and a reliable menu, making Captain D’s an easy choice for a seafood fix in Fayetteville, whether you’re eating in or taking out.
5. This Is It! Southern Kitchen & Bar-B-Q
This Is It! Southern Kitchen & Bar-B-Q feels like Fayetteville at its most flavorful. The mix of barbecue and seafood draws you in, but it’s the home-style service that makes you linger. My first visit was for lunch, but the scent of sizzling fish and smoked spices had me planning a return for dinner before I’d finished my plate.
Their fried whiting and southern-spiced tilapia stand out for their freshness and generous seasoning. The sides are classic—think collard greens, creamy mac and cheese, and seasoned rice. It’s a place where every table gets a little taste of the South, and every meal feels like tradition.
If you crave seafood with real southern flair, this spot delivers. Don’t skip the daily specials; they often highlight the best of what’s coming out of the kitchen.
6. Royal Stix
Royal Stix is where Fayetteville meets a blend of Asian flavors. Every visit feels like a mini getaway, with a menu that spans bright sushi rolls to comforting steamed seafood entrees. I stopped by on a rainy afternoon and was quickly won over by the crisp tempura and the steady buzz of content diners around me.
Their sushi menu is full of bright flavors, but if you’re here for seafood, start with the shrimp and vegetable tempura. It’s light, fresh, and not greasy. Larger plates like the steamed shrimp with ginger sauce showcase delicate cooking and let the seafood truly shine.
Royal Stix is a solid pick if you like your seafood with an Asian twist. The menu is broad enough for everyone, but the seafood lovers never leave disappointed.
7. This Is IT Barbeque & Seafood
This Is IT Barbeque & Seafood has mastered the art of southern comfort food. The energy here is always high, and the aroma of barbecue sauce and seasoned fish makes it tough to order just one dish. On a recent visit, I watched locals breeze in and out, each walking away with big plates and even bigger smiles.
The baked tilapia and fried whiting are popular choices, cooked to order and always full of flavor. Pairing either with sides like collard greens or macaroni and cheese captures that soulful Southern meal.
Homemade desserts and a rotating menu of daily specials keep things lively. If you want that home-cooked taste with convenience, this place delivers every time.
8. Miller’s Ale House
Miller’s Ale House is the spot where gatherings turn lively, especially when there’s a game on. It strikes a balance between a laid-back sports bar vibe and a menu packed with more than just the basics. I ended up here on a weekend, surrounded by laughter and the comforting sizzle of kitchen action.
Seafood lovers will appreciate the zesty zinger shrimp and the grilled salmon. The zinger shrimp offers a spicy kick without overwhelming freshness, while the salmon comes out perfectly cooked and pairs well with their seasonal veggies or simple rice.
Miller’s stands out for its consistency and energy. Whether you’re here for a casual meal or catching up with friends, you’ll find the seafood options satisfying enough to keep you coming back.
9. Catering by This Is IT
(678) 817-7757Call
Catering by This Is IT brings the soulful flavor of Fayetteville’s favorite dishes straight to your event. I once tasted their food at a lively family reunion, and the seafood platters were the first trays emptied. There’s something special about having Southern comfort food served with that unmistakable hospitality.
Their fried and baked seafood options stand out, especially the whiting and tilapia. Sides like seasoned rice and collard greens round out the meal and keep guests full and happy. Everything arrives fresh, still warm, and full of bold flavor.
If you’re looking to impress at your next gathering, their seafood selections will definitely start a conversation and get those compliments rolling in.
10. The Georgia Shrimp Company
The Georgia Shrimp Company blends Southern hospitality with a touch of international flair. On my first visit, the inviting, relaxed setting made it feel like a friend’s house—if your friend had a passion for brilliant seafood. The welcoming staff set the tone for an unrushed meal, letting flavors and conversation take center stage.
Seafood arrives fresh throughout the week, and it shows in the specials. Don’t miss their namesake shrimp, often the star in spicy, well-balanced sauces. The grilled fish dishes are another highlight, prepared with subtle South African influences that give each bite something a little extra.
For anyone who loves seafood celebrations, The Georgia Shrimp Company is an easy favorite. Leave room for their daily fresh fish special—it’s what regulars talk about most.
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants are most popular in Fayetteville, GA?
Some favorites include The Juicy Crab for customizable boils, City Cafe & Bakery for European-inspired plates, and The Georgia Shrimp Company for globally influenced seafood. Local chains like Captain D’s and This Is It! Southern Kitchen & Bar-B-Q are also crowd-pleasers.
Are there any seafood spots in Fayetteville, GA, with a Southern twist?
Yes, This Is It! Southern Kitchen & Bar-B-Q blends seafood with classic Southern sides and spices. Captain D’s and local takeout favorites also serve up fried and grilled seafood dishes with that regional flavor.
Which restaurants in Fayetteville, GA have the freshest seafood?
The Georgia Shrimp Company is known for seafood delivered several times a week. Spots like The Juicy Crab allow you to select your catch and seasoning, so freshness is a big part of the draw.
Are there healthy seafood options in Fayetteville, GA?
Definitely. Look for grilled salmon, tilapia, or white fish at Village Cafe and Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen. Many restaurants offer sides like vegetables or salads to keep things light.
Can I find good seafood takeout or catering in Fayetteville, GA?
Yes. Catering by This Is IT and City Cafe & Bakery are go-to choices for events. Most restaurants, including The Juicy Crab and Captain D’s, offer takeout and family-friendly meal options.