Finding great seafood in Fairview, NY is a bit like discovering the perfect oyster hiding in a bed of pebbles—unexpected and deeply satisfying. Whether you’re a lifelong Hudson Valley local or just passing through, Fairview has a way of surprising diners with its range of seafood spots. My last visit led me on an informal tasting tour through riverfront classics and unexpected gems, where dishes ranged from butter-brushed salmon to the crispiest calamari I’ve tasted this side of the Hudson.
If you love the fresh tang of the ocean or crave a cozy fish fry, this roundup brings you Fairview’s top seafood destinations—each with its own specialty and charm. Expect everything from family-owned markets offering freshly-shucked shellfish, to waterfront dining that turns an ordinary meal into an occasion. Hungry yet? Get ready to meet Fairview’s best seafood, one forkful at a time.
Where to find the best seafood in Fairview, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Fairview, NY:
- Mariners on the Hudson
- Eveready Diner
- Tasty Crab House
- Red Lobster
- Bonefish Grill – Closed
- Joe Willy S Fish
- Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
- Aladias Crab Cravings
- Tammy Honeyman
- Billy Joe’s Ribworks
1. Mariners on the Hudson
(845) 691-6011Call
Perched right on the river’s edge, Mariners on the Hudson offers the kind of view you want to linger over. Relaxing on their patio as the sun dips behind the bridges, you almost forget you’re so close to town. The gentle soundtrack of lapping water and passing trains pairs well with a plate of, say, their classic broiled salmon—delicate, juicy, and never overdone.
What makes this spot special isn’t just the scenery. Freshness is their signature, and seafood arrives to your table simply prepared, letting flavors shine. On my last visit, I savored a forkful of their shrimp scampi, its buttery sauce hinting at lemon and herbs in all the right ways. The fried calamari also hits all the marks: crisp, tender, without a trace of greasiness.
Go for the seafood, stay for the riverside calm.
2. Eveready Diner
Eveready Diner is a classic spot just outside Fairview that wins you over the moment you slide into a chrome-trimmed booth. The retro decor pairs nicely with a menu that never tries too hard. What you get here is comfort—especially when it comes to their seafood staples.
The diner surprises with a crisp, golden fish fry that’s light, flaky, and served with all the familiar fixings. I still remember the first bite: the crunch was just right, and the fish beneath was perfectly cooked. Their grilled salmon, seasoned with a house blend, is another steady favorite. It’s always fresh and pairs well with a side of their signature fries.
If you want seafood served up with a side of nostalgia, this place gets it right.
3. Tasty Crab House
(845) 454-2850Call
If you crave bold flavors and a lively atmosphere, Tasty Crab House stands out in Poughkeepsie’s seafood scene. The vibe here crackles with energy, making it easy to lose track of time as you dig in. I still remember rolling up my sleeves for one of their famous seafood boils, the table soon a cheerful mess of shells and laughter.
The real reason to visit is their build-your-own seafood boil. Choose from crab, shrimp, and more, then pick a sauce—garlic butter always wins my vote. Everything arrives piping hot and perfectly spiced. Their snow crab legs are sweet and meaty, the kind of dish that needs nothing but a squeeze of lemon and good company.
Come hungry, and bring your friends.
4. Red Lobster
Red Lobster is that familiar seafood haven where a stack of Cheddar Bay Biscuits lands on your table before you can even crack a menu. It’s reliable, bustling, and always feels like a treat, whether you’re after a casual lunch or a slightly fancier family dinner. I still remember splitting a platter of steamed shellfish with friends and realizing it’s hard not to smile when you’re armed with a lobster cracker.
The menu’s highlight here is the Ultimate Feast, which packs crab legs, shrimp, and a tender piece of fish onto one plate. If you’re a fan of lobster, the live Maine lobster is freshly prepared, buttery, and never disappoints. Seafood here is consistent, with flavors that balance tradition and comfort in every bite.
You’ll leave full—possibly with a biscuit or two for the road.
5. Bonefish Grill – Closed
Bonefish Grill once brought a touch of refinement to the Route 9 dining strip, blending a relaxed atmosphere with a knack for seafood that few could match. On my last visit, the glow from their open kitchen and whispers of fresh herbs made every meal feel just a little special. The staff was always welcoming—a place that felt easy to settle in for the evening.
The star of the show was often their grilled fish specials; perfectly seared, always fresh, and served with inventive sides. Their Ahi tuna steak was a standout—rich and silky against bright citrus. Light but memorable. While Bonefish Grill has since closed its doors, its reputation for quality and attention to detail still lingers in the memories of local seafood lovers.
6. Joe Willy S Fish
Joe Willy S Fish feels like the kind of hidden spot only the locals know—a true seafood shack in all the best ways. Step inside and you’ll find a welcoming, unfussy space that smells temptingly of fresh catch. I’ve dropped by more times than I can count, and the service always makes you feel like part of the family.
What sets Joe Willy’s apart is the way they handle the classics. Their fried flounder sandwich hits that magic balance of golden crunch and flaky fish, while the clam chowder is hearty enough to stand alone. Both dishes highlight the kitchen’s focus on quality and simplicity over frills.
If you’re after hearty, honest seafood that doesn’t overpromise, this is your spot.
7. Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
For those who take seafood seriously, Gadaleto’s Seafood Market is a standout in New Paltz. This family-run shop has the warm, bustling feel of a true neighborhood market, and after just one visit, you understand why it’s a local favorite. I remember popping in for a quick bite and leaving with a bag of just-caught fish, plus dinner inspiration for a week.
The magic here is twofold: a pristine selection at the market counter and a menu of prepared dishes that showcase those same fresh ingredients. Their grilled salmon platter shines—flaky, flavorful, and simply seasoned. The fish tacos are a crowd-pleaser, balancing crisp cabbage and house-made salsa with perfectly cooked fish.
Come for take-home fillets, stay for a casual meal you’ll want to repeat.
8. Aladias Crab Cravings
(845) 419-9175Call
When you’re in the mood for crab and nothing less, Aladias Crab Cravings delivers. This spot is tucked away in Wallkill, but seafood seekers in Fairview know it’s worth the short trip. When I first visited, the scent of spiced seafood filled the air and the anticipation quickly turned into satisfaction.
The menu zeroes in on their specialty—plump, perfectly cooked crab legs bathed in savory sauces. Each bite delivers juicy, sweet flavor without any fuss. The crab boil platters are a hands-on feast perfect for those who like their seafood straightforward and generous.
If you want your next seafood meal to feel like a celebration, Aladias knows how to set the table.
9. Tammy Honeyman
(845) 236-2700Call
Tammy Honeyman blends the welcoming vibe of a neighborhood spot with a focus on fresh, no-fuss seafood. Tucked in Marlboro, it’s a spot where regulars and newcomers mingle over plates that celebrate flavor over flash. The first time I stopped in, I was struck by how relaxed and unpretentious the space felt—just good food, simply served.
The standout here is the pan-seared sole: lightly seasoned, flaky, and full of natural taste. It pairs well with a side of steamed vegetables, keeping things light but satisfying. Their shrimp cocktail also deserves a mention for its cool, crisp quality and that bit of zest from house-made sauce.
For a meal that feels both comfortable and refined, Tammy Honeyman hits the mark.
10. Billy Joe’s Ribworks
Billy Joe’s Ribworks is often a go-to for barbecue, but their seafood holds its own and then some. The riverfront setting, with patio seating overlooking the Hudson, brings just the right mix of laid-back fun and eye-catching views. I’ve found it’s a perfect spot for unwinding with friends or catching a lively weekend crowd.
The surprise here is the blackened catfish—spiced to perfection, flaky, and just enough heat to keep things interesting. Paired with fresh sides, it offers a Southern twist that suits the relaxed vibe. The grilled shrimp skewers land at your table charred and juicy, with flavors that won’t get lost in the crowd.
If you want barbecue and seafood with a river breeze, Billy Joe’s is an easy pick.
More Things to Try in Fairview, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Fairview, NY?
Top choices include Mariners on the Hudson, Gadaleto’s Seafood Market, Joe Willy S Fish, and Tasty Crab House. Each offers something different—fresh catches, classic fried options, and lively seafood boils.
Do any Fairview seafood spots serve halal or vegetarian seafood options?
Menus in Fairview focus on fresh fish, shellfish, and vegetarian-friendly sides. Gadaleto’s and many diners offer veggie-based salads and sides. For halal-specific seafood, it’s best to call ahead and check with each restaurant.
Which seafood dishes are must-tries in Fairview?
The broiled salmon at Mariners on the Hudson, fish fry at Eveready Diner, build-your-own boil at Tasty Crab House, and fish tacos at Gadaleto’s all come highly recommended for their taste and quality.
Are there any seafood markets with fresh catch available in Fairview?
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market in New Paltz is known for its high-quality selection of fresh fish and shellfish available for home cooking, as well as prepared meals if you want to eat on the go.
What’s the most scenic spot for seafood dining near Fairview?
Mariners on the Hudson stands out for its riverside tables, sweeping views of the Hudson, and relaxing patio. It’s a favorite for anyone who loves good seafood and a local sunset.
