Craving the freshest catch in Selden, NY? You’ve landed in the right spot. Selden might not have an oceanfront view, but its seafood scene is surprisingly deep. From the subtle lure of perfectly grilled shrimp to the satisfying snap of a well-battered fish fillet, the area punches well above its weight.
One evening, curiosity led me off the main drag into a spot that claimed to do seafood right. A few minutes later, I was picking crab meat with friends, each bite confirming that Selden’s seafood game is strong and varied. No two places serve the same experience—there’s always a new flavor or local favorite. This guide highlights the best spots, each with its own style, charm, and fresh catch. Dive in and get ready to meet your next go-to seafood order.
Where to find the best seafood in Selden, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Selden, NY:
- Zara Pizza & Restaurant
- Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips
- Machi Sushi
- Harbor Crab
- Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
- Lombardi’s on the Bay
- The Cull House
- The Monster Crab
- Popei’s Clam Bar
- Island Fish
1. Zara Pizza & Restaurant
Zara Pizza & Restaurant bends tradition in the best way. You’ll find more than just classic pizzas and pasta here—the seafood is a hidden gem. On one visit, I started with their grilled shrimp and lemon herbs. Each bite was fresh and left a memorable zing.
Zara’s seafood linguine stands out, loaded with tender calamari, juicy shrimp, and a sauce that tastes like someone in the kitchen actually cares. The prices keep your wallet happy, while the Mediterranean spin brings a layer of flavor that others miss.
Sure, the pizza is good, but seafood fans will want to linger over the fish specials or the shrimp scampi. Everything here is hearty, honest, and never fussy.
2. Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips
Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips knows its audience: those who want crisp, golden bites without pretense. There’s something comforting about their classic seafood baskets. The fish here arrives hot, wrapped in a crunchy coat that never feels greasy.
I once grabbed the combo platter after a long day. The flaky white fish and chunky fries hit the exact note of nostalgia and flavor I needed. It’s a simple menu, but what they do, they do well.
If you’re new, start with the signature fish and chips. It’s quick, satisfying, and consistent—hard to deny when you’re after tradition done right. Sometimes, basic is exactly what you want.
3. Machi Sushi
Machi Sushi feels like a quiet retreat tucked into a busy corner of Selden. The fish here is always pristine, sliced to order, and full of clean flavor. Once, I sat at the bar and watched the chef work—there’s clear skill behind each roll.
If you’re looking for something fresh, the salmon avocado roll and yellowtail scallion roll are particularly well balanced. Every piece melts fast, with zero filler and plenty of real seafood.
The menu steps beyond basic maki, too. The chef’s special sashimi platter is a showcase of color, texture, and taste. Machi never overloads dishes with sauce or extras. Here, seafood stays the star.
4. Harbor Crab
Harbor Crab gives off that waterfront vibe you crave—no boat required. This place masters the art of laid-back seafood with just the right hint of celebration. The night I visited, a band played while platters of steaming shellfish circled the table.
Their crab legs and coconut shrimp are both standouts, served hot and never skimping on portion. You get freshness and a fun mix of textures with every dish. The restaurant’s two-level space can turn a simple meal into a mini event.
If you want to sample Harbor Crab’s greatest hit, go for a classic shrimp cocktail or their seasonal grilled fish specials. It’s the kind of spot that makes seafood the star, every single time.
5. Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant is the kind of spot that knows how to make you feel like a regular, even on your first visit. The casual setting and friendly crew mean you can kick back and focus on what matters: the seafood.
I once stopped in for a quick lunch and ended up lingering over a bowl of their signature clam chowder. It’s rich, briny, and loaded with tender clams—a clear standout. Portions are generous, so come hungry.
If you’re in a decision rut, try their baked stuffed flounder or classic fried shrimp. Popeis keeps things straightforward, letting the freshness of the catch take the spotlight every time.
6. Lombardi’s on the Bay
Lombardi’s on the Bay manages to blend Old World charm with waterfront relaxation. The sparkling bay views elevate any dinner, and the menu only adds to the appeal. Sitting by the window during sunset, I was served a plate that felt almost too good to eat.
Their seafood risotto was creamy, studded with shrimp and scallops that tasted just-plucked-from-the-sea. Everything here is artfully plated, so your eyes get a treat before your first bite. Classic Italian flavors meet fresh local seafood in the best way.
If you’re in the mood for indulgence, the broiled Atlantic salmon or the branzino fillet are both smart choices. Lombardi’s builds an experience—each dish feels like a celebration.
7. The Cull House
The Cull House feels like a local legend, serving Sayville since 1977. This spot finds a sweet spot between cozy and lively, with a menu that stays true to the classics. I stopped by after hearing locals rave, and it lived up to every bit of praise.
The broiled flounder melts in your mouth, balanced with just a hint of lemon and buttery herbs. Every seafood platter here seems crafted for maximum freshness and flavor, without being showy.
If you’re new, try the clam bake or a platter of shrimp scampi. Cull House’s steady popularity isn’t a fluke—their commitment to quality seafood is clear in every bite.
8. The Monster Crab
The Monster Crab injects a bit of fun and flair into Holtsville’s seafood scene. This is the place for anyone who likes to get a little messy while chasing bold flavors. My first time here, I rolled up my sleeves for a seafood boil and didn’t regret it.
The signature seafood boils come with your choice of seasoning, where the garlic butter really brings everything together. Freshness is obvious—each crab leg, potato, and kernel of corn steams with flavor.
If you’re feeling adventurous, order the combo platter for a true feast. The Monster Crab doesn’t hold back on spice, size, or overall experience. Bring friends and extra napkins—for good reason.
9. Popei’s Clam Bar
Popei’s Clam Bar in Coram brings a refreshing sense of energy to the seafood lineup. Every dish feels as if it’s straight from the docks, prepared with skill and a bit of signature flair. On my last visit, the dining room was filled with the comforting aroma of fresh shellfish.
The standout here is their baked clams—tender, herbed, and perfectly golden. They’re a popular pick for locals and first-timers alike. The menu covers everything from fried fish combos to crowd-pleasing shrimp platters.
If you like variety, try a seafood sampler to taste the range Popei’s offers. This spot combines casual comfort with honest, recognizable flavors—an easy pick for seafood lovers.
10. Island Fish
Island Fish is part fish market, part casual eatery, and all about freshness. What sets it apart is the way you can see seafood going from display case to plate—nothing sits around here. I once picked out my fillet at the counter and had it grilled on the spot.
The grilled salmon and broiled tilapia are always tender and bursting with clean, bright flavor. The sides lean simple, keeping the focus on that just-caught taste. You never feel rushed, so it’s easy to linger over your meal.
If you’re craving something classic, try the fish and chips or baked cod. Island Fish delivers unfussy, quality seafood at prices that invite repeat visits.
More Things to Try in Selden, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants around Selden, NY?
Some top choices include Zara Pizza & Restaurant for Mediterranean seafood dishes, Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips for classic fried fish, and Machi Sushi for fresh sushi rolls. You’ll also find local favorites like Popei’s Clam Bar and The Cull House for more traditional seafood options.
Are there any seafood spots in Selden with takeout or delivery?
Yes. Many places, such as Arthur Treacher’s Fish & Chips, Machi Sushi, Popei’s Clam Bar, and Island Fish, offer easy takeout and delivery options, making a seafood meal at home just a call or click away.
Which seafood restaurants have options for people who don’t eat shellfish?
Most restaurants offer shellfish-free plates. Try Zara Pizza & Restaurant’s grilled salmon or Machi Sushi’s vegetarian rolls. It’s always smart to ask the staff if you have specific dietary needs.
Where can I find fresh seafood markets in and near Selden?
Island Fish doubles as a market, letting you pick up fillets or prepared dishes. There are also local seafood shops like Long Island Seafood and The Fish Store that focus on super fresh catches.
Do any seafood restaurants offer gluten-free dishes?
Yes. The Cull House has a gluten-free menu, and many other spots will adjust your order—just ask. Grilled fish or simple sashimi at Machi Sushi are naturally gluten-free choices.
Are there any waterfront seafood restaurants near Selden?
You’ll find great views at Harbor Crab and Lombardi’s on the Bay in nearby Patchogue. Both pair their seafood menus with scenic bay dining for something a little special.
