Looking for the best seafood near Peach Lake, NY is a bit like searching for buried treasure, except you don’t need a map—just a good appetite and a sense of adventure. I remember my first visit to a tiny seafood spot tucked away near the water. The smell of fresh fish and a perfectly grilled lobster tail convinced me that the lake holds some culinary secrets. Every place had its own story, some with a rustic charm, others with a modern twist, but all delivered flavors that stayed with me long after I’d left the table.
This guide is built from firsthand bites, local tips, and more than a few cravings on rainy afternoons. If you want to discover real seafood gems that won’t disappoint, you’re exactly where you need to be. From classic fish fries to creative shellfish dishes, I’ve sifted through the options to bring only the true best. Whether you’re a homegrown fan or just passing through, you’ll find something here keen enough to reel you in for another visit.
Where to find the best seafood in Peach Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Peach Lake, NY:
- Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish
- Red Lobster
- Royal Guard Fish and Chips
- Rick’s Seafood
- J and M Seafood
- Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc
- Mt Kisco Seafood
- Mt Kisco Smokehouse
- Royal Fish & Chips
- Lobster Pot Studio & Gallery
1. Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish
Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish sits in an elegant farmhouse setting at 100 Titicus Rd, North Salem, just a ten-minute drive from Peach Lake. Their focus on just-hauled seafood and produce grown right outside the door sets the standard high. When I visited, the oyster bar was a revelation—cold, briny, and impossibly fresh.
I never skip the roasted whole fish, so simply prepared you taste the lake in every bite. The chilled seafood platter is a local favorite, especially for anyone craving variety. Here, seafood isn’t just an entrée; it’s a celebration of the season.
This spot is more than a restaurant. It’s a testament to local flavor and meticulous sourcing that keeps regulars coming back.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Danbury is where people around Peach Lake go when they crave a classic seafood feast without fuss. It’s a place for families, celebrations, and comfort meals on quiet weeknights. I still remember the first time I tried their shrimp—tender, buttery, and cooked just right, with those warm Cheddar Bay Biscuits by my side.
The Ultimate Feast is their main event, featuring tail-on shrimp, luscious lobster, and delicate whitefish. The Wood-Grilled Salmon is another solid choice, served with seasonal veggies and a touch of char.
Red Lobster stands out for its consistency and cheerful service. When you want a variety of seafood prepared reliably, this spot delivers every time. Grab some extra biscuits for the road—you’ll thank yourself later.
3. Royal Guard Fish and Chips
Royal Guard Fish and Chips on Main Street brings classic seafood to downtown Danbury with no pretension. The moment you walk in, you notice the aroma of freshly fried fish—not greasy, but golden and crisp. I once stopped by on a rainy afternoon; their battered fish fillets made the day feel warmer.
The true star here is the traditional fish and chips. Each piece arrives hot and flaky, accompanied by thick, hearty fries. If you want something light, the fried shrimp plate showcases their knack for crisp coatings and tender bites.
Royal Guard stands out for its quick service, fair prices, and no-nonsense approach to seafood. For pure, comforting fish and chips, this is the place to try.
4. Rick’s Seafood
(845) 621-2489Call
Rick’s Seafood on Route 6 in Mahopac is a haven for those who want their catch as fresh as it gets. The counter feels old-school, and the staff always seem ready to chat about today’s best catch. One afternoon, I watched someone leave with a bag of steam rising from their just-prepared takeout—proof they don’t keep plates waiting.
The baked stuffed sole is a personal favorite, featuring tender fish wrapped around a delicate crab filling. For a classic approach, try the broiled scallops—sweet and perfectly cooked every time.
Rick’s stands out by blending the attention of a fish market with the care of a family-run kitchen. Every meal here tastes like someone’s looking out for your next bite.
5. J and M Seafood
(203) 748-6337Call
J and M Seafood, on Padanaram Road, is where people in the know pick up seafood that tastes like it just came off the boat. I once stopped in for a quick meal and left wishing I’d grabbed extra for later—the freshness is hard to beat. There’s a straightforward, no-frills charm that makes you feel right at home.
The New England clam chowder is always creamy, and full of tender clams. The grilled swordfish steak is another highlight: hearty, juicy, and gently seasoned to let the flavor shine.
With a balance of quality and value, J and M Seafood stands out for anyone who wants a relaxed meal and genuine, ocean-fresh fare near Peach Lake.
6. Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc
(914) 666-6929Call
Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc has been serving fresh fish in Mount Kisco since 1894, and you can sense the tradition the moment you walk in. I remember my first visit—welcomed by the aroma of simmering seafood and walls lined with family photos, making it feel more like a friendly kitchen than a restaurant. Their market selection changes daily, a sign that freshness is a true priority here.
Their pan-seared sea bass is a standout, boasting a crisp golden crust and tender, flaky center. The seafood risotto is another highlight, packed with clams, shrimp, and a delicate broth that brings everything together.
What sets Conte’s apart is a respect for ingredients and time-honored recipes. If you want to taste the legacy of Peach Lake seafood, this is where to start.
7. Mt Kisco Seafood
Mt Kisco Seafood is a staple for those who want both market-fresh catches and expertly prepared dishes in one spot. The first time I wandered in, I was struck by the sparkling display of fish—everything looked like it was caught that morning. The helpful staff love to share tips and seasonal picks, creating a laid-back, local vibe.
The grilled salmon is a must; it’s consistently moist and perfectly charred, letting the natural flavors shine. Their shrimp cocktail is another highlight, served chilled and crisp with zingy sauce that wakes up your palate.
Mt Kisco Seafood stands out for blending a classic fishmonger’s attention to freshness with a cozy, inviting eatery. For seafood around Peach Lake that tastes as pure as the water nearby, this place is the real deal.
8. Mt Kisco Smokehouse
Mt Kisco Smokehouse brings a different kind of seafood experience to Peach Lake fans—one that’s steeped in smoky flavor and old-fashioned craftsmanship. My first taste of their smoked salmon was a revelation: silky, deeply flavored, and always sliced to order with just the right amount of salt.
This spot stands out for its range of house-smoked specialties, each with distinctive texture and nuanced seasoning. The whitefish salad is a hidden gem, blending delicate flakes with a light, creamy touch. Bringing a platter to a gathering is guaranteed to impress, since their products always feel a cut above.
Mt Kisco Smokehouse is all about patience and precision, transforming classic seafood into something memorable. It’s the place for anyone who loves subtle complexity and tradition on their plate.
9. Royal Fish & Chips
Royal Fish & Chips on Stony Hill Road offers a refreshing twist on classic seafood, making it a favorite for those craving something both familiar and a bit different. On my first visit, the friendly team steered me toward their bestselling fish and chips, which delivered a light, crisp batter and moist fish inside—seriously hard to resist.
The menu goes beyond basics with options like grilled shrimp platters and well-seasoned fries, catering to anyone looking to brighten up a weekday dinner. The kitchen’s Mediterranean influence keeps things vibrant yet simple, bringing out the natural flavors in every dish.
Royal Fish & Chips stands out for its consistent quality and relaxed atmosphere. It’s a reliable bet whenever you want no-nonsense seafood, freshly made and served with heart.
10. Lobster Pot Studio & Gallery
Lobster Pot Studio & Gallery is a quirky spot in Redding that fuses the love of art and seafood in one memorable location. My first visit felt more like stepping into a creative haven than a typical seafood stop, with vibrant artwork all around and the aroma of lobster drifting through the air.
Their lobster rolls balance buttery rolls with chunks of sweet, fresh lobster—a combination that speaks of both care and local pride. For something lighter, the house seafood salad offers a medley of flavors, perfect for a laid-back lunch surrounded by paintings and sculptures.
What sets this place apart is the marriage of culture and cuisine, making every meal here as much a feast for the senses as for your appetite.
More Things to Try in Peach Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top-rated seafood restaurants near Peach Lake, NY?
Popular choices include Purdy’s Farmer & The Fish for farm-to-table seafood, Rick’s Seafood for market-fresh options, and Mt Kisco Seafood for perfectly grilled fish and shellfish.
Are there any seafood spots with takeout or delivery?
Yes. Rick’s Seafood, J and M Seafood, and Mt Kisco Seafood all offer takeout. Some, like Red Lobster, provide delivery and online ordering for added convenience.
Where can I find seafood markets close to Peach Lake?
Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc, Mt Kisco Seafood, and J and M Seafood have markets where you can buy fresh fish, shrimp, and more to prepare at home.
What’s the best spot for a casual seafood meal with family?
Red Lobster and Royal Guard Fish and Chips are both easygoing and family-friendly, with menus that appeal to a broad range of tastes.
Are there seafood restaurants with vegetarian or non-seafood options?
Many places, including Red Lobster and Sugo Gastrobar, offer salads, pasta, and other dishes if seafood isn’t your pick for the night.
