Few places rival the quiet charm of Spring Hill, FL, when it comes to seafood that’s fresh, flavorful, and never pretentious. Tucked along the Gulf Coast, this area draws in those who love pristine oysters, gulf shrimp, and flaky white fish—even if they’re just passing through on a weekend. My own introduction to Spring Hill’s seafood scene started with a local legend: a plate of grouper so tender it barely needed a fork. From that moment, I was hooked, and curiosity pulled me deeper into the local favorites and hidden gems scattered throughout Spring Hill.
If you’ve ever been curious whether the best seafood hides behind neon signs or polished patios, I’ve done the legwork—fork in hand—for you. I set out to sample everything from the big-name chains to the family-run spots where menus live in local memory. This guide brings together all the standouts, whether you’re after a classic basket of fried fish or something you’ve never tried before. If you want the real scoop on where to find the most satisfying seafood in Spring Hill, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best seafood in Spring Hill, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Spring Hill, FL:
- Bayport Inn
- Red Lobster
- Long John Silver’s | A&w
- The Grill at Silverthorn
- Mermaid Lounge and Eatery
- Captain D’s
- Kally K’s Steakery & Fishery
- My Nanny’s Restaurant
- Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
- Trader Bay Seafood Company
1. Bayport Inn
Bayport Inn sits tucked away near the water, making it a classic stop for those hungry for real coastal flavor. On my last visit, a late afternoon breeze and the promise of fresh seafood drew me in. It’s the kind of spot where you feel instantly at home—no frills, just good food and a casual vibe.
What sets Bayport Inn apart is how it balances relaxed charm with a menu full of fresh-caught choices. The shrimp basket and grouper sandwich both reflect the area’s Gulf Coast roots, each bringing out briny sweetness without fuss.
If you like seafood with honest flavor, go for the blackened fish platter. Each bite tastes like it came straight off a boat. With gluten-free and vegetarian options, the menu keeps everyone happy without losing focus on what matters most.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Spring Hill delivers the comfort of consistency and the familiar glow of its iconic lighthouse logo. I’ve dropped in during busy weekends and quiet weekdays; either way, the staff keeps things welcoming and efficient. It’s a spot made for hearty seafood without any guesswork.
What makes this location stand out? The menu covers a spectrum—from classic, buttery grilled shrimp to generous portions of snow crab. For me, the Create Your Own Seafood Trio is the go-to: a little adventure on one plate, never short on flavor.
Don’t skip their signature garlic shrimp scampi. It comes out sizzling and fragrant, always reminding you why Red Lobster has turned into a seafood mainstay in Spring Hill. Table service is swift and friendly, so you can focus on enjoying every bite.
3. Long John Silver’s | A&w
Long John Silver’s | A&W brings a dash of nostalgia to Spring Hill, pairing speedy service with warm, fried classics. I remember racing through errands and stopping here for a quick fix of crispy fish, never disappointed by the crunch or the price.
This spot stands out for its commitment to wild-caught seafood. Alaska pollock and North Pacific cod headline the menu, prepared golden and crisp. The batter-to-fish ratio always lands just right.
For a taste of what Long John Silver’s does best, order the 2-piece fish meal. Simple, hot, and satisfying. Their hushpuppies and natural-cut fries round things out. It’s comfort food for anyone craving fuss-free seafood that actually tastes like the real thing.
4. The Grill at Silverthorn
The Grill at Silverthorn offers a polished dining experience without feeling stuffy. I tried it after a round of golf and was surprised by how creative and thoughtful the seafood menu turned out to be. Every detail, from the lighting to the attentive service, sets the tone for something special.
This restaurant stands out with its flexible menu—think gulf shrimp scampi with house-made pasta and seasonal catch-of-the-day specials. Each plate highlights careful sourcing and a playful approach to flavor.
Looking for a standout dish? Opt for the pan-seared salmon, served perfectly flaky with complementary sauces. It’s the kind of meal that makes you want to linger, enjoying every bite in the country club setting.
5. Mermaid Lounge and Eatery
Mermaid Lounge and Eatery carries the right blend of whimsy and authenticity, tucked quietly on Commercial Way. My visit turned into an unexpectedly relaxed afternoon spent among locals, swapping stories over seafood baskets and iced tea. It’s the kind of neighborhood spot where the staff feels like friends.
What makes this place shine is how fresh and approachable the food is. The fried shrimp plate lands hot, lightly battered, and never greasy. Their seafood is simple and true to the Gulf Coast style.
If you’re hunting for pure comfort, order the fish and chips. It’s golden, crisp, and made for dipping. Mermaid Lounge proves you don’t need flash or fuss to deliver great seafood right in Spring Hill.
6. Captain D’s
Captain D’s on Mariner Blvd is all about quick comfort that doesn’t cut corners. I remember easing into a booth and finding the menu packed with seafood classics, perfect for a casual lunch or early dinner.
They set themselves apart with a focus on consistently hot, crispy fish. The grilled white fish is an underrated choice, full of flavor and refreshingly light compared to typical fried fare. Their hush puppies and seasoned rice are solid sides that round out the meal.
For those craving simple seafood done right, the classic fish and shrimp meal showcases what Captain D’s does best. Portions are generous and the kitchen turns out each order reliably every time.
7. Kally K’s Steakery & Fishery
(352) 683-1364Call
Kally K’s Steakery & Fishery has the neighborhood feel that turns occasional visits into a habit. My first stop was on the recommendation of a local who raved about their seafood and salad bar, and it delivered on both counts—generous, fresh, and always welcoming.
The family-owned atmosphere stands out here. The menu is huge, but the broiled fish platter is a winner for those who like their seafood light but still full of flavor. The kitchen keeps each element simple and lets the freshness shine.
If you’re looking for comfort, consider the stuffed flounder. It’s rich, flaky, and a real crowd-pleaser, just like Kally K’s friendly staff. You can taste why this place is considered a Spring Hill staple.
8. My Nanny’s Restaurant
My Nanny’s Restaurant might look unassuming, but it’s home to the kind of food and hospitality that locals keep quiet—just so the line stays short. My first breakfast here grew into a full morning, thanks to friendly service and the buzz of regulars who clearly treat this spot as their second home.
There’s a special delight in the fresh fish sandwiches and rotating seafood specials on the lunch menu. Both deliver a satisfying balance of flavor and comfort—a true nod to old Florida charm.
For something classic, go for the fried fish basket. It arrives golden and crisp, made just the way you hope. My Nanny’s makes sure you leave with a smile and a plan to return soon.
9. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen makes seafood accessible and fuss-free for anyone craving a quick, hearty meal. I visited on a whim one evening and was greeted with the unmistakable scent of crisp fish straight from the fryer—one of those aromas you never outgrow.
This location stands out for consistently serving hot, freshly prepared seafood in a laid-back setting. Their attention to friendly service is a bonus, whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout.
If you’re making your first order, try the grilled white fish or their fish and shrimp combo. Portions are generous, the flavors classic, and the atmosphere casual—even on the busiest nights, Captain D’s manages to keep things comforting and reliable.
10. Trader Bay Seafood Company
Trader Bay Seafood Company feels more like a community secret than just another market. The first time I swung by, it was for fresh shrimp, but one look at the bubbling platters had me seated and ordering lunch on the spot. Here, everything carries that unmistakable taste of the Gulf.
What makes this spot unique is the blend of market freshness and a casual kitchen serving generous, no-nonsense portions. Whether you want to cook at home or eat on their sunny deck, it suits both moods.
For a real taste, order the grouper sandwich or shrimp platter. Each dish lets the quality seafood shine with minimal fuss, capturing the laid-back spirit of coastal living in Spring Hill.
More Things to Try in Spring Hill, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best place for fresh seafood in Spring Hill, FL?
You’ll find fresh seafood at several spots, but local favorites like Bayport Inn and Trader Bay Seafood Company stand out for their fresh catch and relaxed atmosphere.
Which restaurants offer gluten-free seafood options?
Bayport Inn, The Grill at Silverthorn, and many chain spots like Red Lobster usually offer gluten-free options—just ask your server for details.
Are there casual, family-friendly seafood restaurants?
Absolutely. Captain D’s, My Nanny’s Restaurant, and Long John Silver’s cater to families and serve up simple, approachable seafood.
Where can I get seafood takeout in Spring Hill?
Most seafood restaurants in Spring Hill offer takeout. Trader Bay Seafood Company, Captain D’s, and Mermaid Lounge and Eatery are especially popular for meals on the go.
What are must-try seafood dishes in the area?
Don’t miss the grouper sandwich, shrimp platters, and blackened fish. Each captures the local Gulf Coast style with fresh, bold flavors.