There’s a surprising truth about Fredericksburg, TX—it’s not just a haven for Hill Country charm and German heritage. Somehow, this small town draws seafood lovers from well beyond the Texas borders. That’s something you notice the moment you walk into a local spot and catch the aroma of fresh grilled fish or hear stories of secret family recipes. I once wandered these streets as a skeptic, convinced that superb seafood only comes from the coast. One forkful of delicate catfish changed my mind for good.
Finding the best seafood in Fredericksburg can feel like uncovering a well-kept secret. With standout crab cakes, buttery shrimp, and inventive twists on Gulf classics, the town’s dining scene is more than a pleasant surprise. Planning your next meal gets easy—if you know where to look. Let’s get acquainted with the local favorites that have turned Fredericksburg into a must-try spot for seafood in Texas.
Where to find the best seafood in Fredericksburg, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Fredericksburg, TX:
- Catfish Haven
- Andy’s Steak & Seafood Grille
- Martini’s Seafood House
- Navajo Grill
- Cabernet Grill Texas Wine Country Restaurant
- Nury’s On Main
- Hill Top Cafe
1. Catfish Haven
Catfish Haven sits right on Main Street and quietly stakes its claim as a favorite among locals craving fresh, hearty seafood in Fredericksburg. The first time I visited, the friendly service set the tone—think classic Hill Country welcome paired with genuine pride in each dish.
What makes Catfish Haven memorable? The fried catfish is light and crisp, with a cornmeal crust that’s worth talking about. Pair it with hush puppies and a zesty tartar sauce, and you’ll understand why regulars treat this spot like a best-kept secret.
While seafood headlines here, the menu also offers family-style comfort and a nod to regional flavors. If you’re searching for classic Southern dishes in a relaxed, homey setting, Catfish Haven delivers every time. Don’t miss their signature catfish platter—it captures everything this place does right.
2. Andy’s Steak & Seafood Grille
(830) 997-3744Call
Andy’s Steak & Seafood Grille quietly earns its spot on any Fredericksburg food tour. The rustic vibe is as inviting as the menu, which pays equal attention to land and sea. I found myself there on a weeknight, and the buzz of happy diners set the scene for a memorable dinner.
This is a true local gem where the seafood holds its own. The grilled tilapia stands out, moist and skillfully seasoned. Pair it with sautéed vegetables for a light yet satisfying meal. Their shrimp platter is generous too, each bite bringing a taste of the Gulf right into the Hill Country.
If you want a spot that covers your seafood cravings with care and flavor, Andy’s is an easy pick. Service here feels unhurried and personal, making repeat visits hard to resist.
3. Martini’s Seafood House
Martini’s Seafood House offers a lively take on seafood in the heart of Fredericksburg. The moment I walked in, the energy was infectious—live music, a comfortable crowd, and the briny scent of fresh oysters in the air. It’s the kind of spot where you can lose track of time, sharing plates and sipping drinks well into the evening.
This restaurant’s reputation for freshness isn’t just talk. The oyster platters are a top pick, crisp and cold, and shucked with care. For something a little warmer, try their seafood pasta or the Cajun-seasoned grilled fish. Both showcase the kitchen’s knack for bold flavors without overwhelming the main ingredients.
If you’re looking for a place that feels both festive and devoted to the craft, Martini’s is hard to top. Every visit feels special, thanks to the thoughtful menu and a team that seems to enjoy serving you as much as you’ll enjoy eating here.
4. Navajo Grill
Navajo Grill blends upscale comfort with a laid-back vibe, making it a natural choice for those chasing standout seafood in Fredericksburg. The ambient dining room invites you to linger, but it’s the thoughtful menu that holds your attention. I ended up here for a happy hour, only to stay through dinner—drawn in by aromas drifting from the open kitchen.
The grilled redfish is a house favorite, flaky and finished with a delicate touch that lets the freshness shine through. Their seafood is always carefully handled, showing both restraint and creativity. Seafood salads and seasonal specials keep things interesting for repeat diners.
If you’re after a memorable seafood experience with a Hill Country twist, Navajo Grill is an easy pick.
5. Cabernet Grill Texas Wine Country Restaurant
Cabernet Grill Texas Wine Country Restaurant is where fine dining meets Hill Country grace. Tucked just outside the bustle of downtown, this restaurant feels like a quiet retreat. My first visit was for a celebration, and it delivered all the right notes: polished service, a candlelit patio, and a menu full of elegant options.
Seafood gets special treatment here. The pecan-crusted redfish is crisp, nutty, and plated with finesse. There’s a thoughtful touch to every dish, from the buttery sauces to the fresh herbs sprinkled on top. The combination of Texas wines and bold seafood flavors creates pairings you’ll remember long after you leave.
If you want sophistication without stuffiness, Cabernet Grill is a rewarding pick for any seafood lover in Fredericksburg.
6. Nury’s On Main
Nury’s On Main brings a vibrant, international twist to Main Street’s seafood offerings. My last lunch here felt like a little escape—quiet patio, friendly faces, and a menu full of surprises. The fusion of Mexican traditions and local ingredients means every dish is a treat for both the eyes and the palate.
There’s a playful spirit at Nury’s that comes through in the seafood options. The Veracruz-style fish is a standout, topped with tangy tomato and olives, balancing bold flavors with a delicate touch. Their shrimp ceviche is bright and refreshing, perfect for a sunny day.
If you’re in the mood for creativity and generous portions, Nury’s On Main is a must-try when exploring seafood in Fredericksburg.
7. Hill Top Cafe
Hill Top Cafe is Fredericksburg’s quirkiest landmark, blending hill country attitude with a knack for soulful seafood. My first visit felt like stepping into someone’s creative living room—live music, bold décor, and a menu that hops from Greek to Cajun-inspired favorites.
Here, you’ll find unexpected flavors layered with care. The Gulf shrimp étouffée is a local legend, perfectly spiced and comforting. Their Greek-style fish, lightly grilled and drizzled with lemon and herbs, comes straight from the owner’s heritage.
If you love a dash of personality alongside your meal, Hill Top Cafe’s seafood won’t disappoint. It’s the place to slow down, savor something different, and enjoy food that tells a story.
More Things to Try in Fredericksburg, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the freshest seafood in Fredericksburg, TX?
Many local favorites, like Catfish Haven and Martini’s Seafood House, serve seafood delivered regularly—freshness is a point of pride at both spots. For elegant options, try Cabernet Grill.
Are there casual seafood restaurants in Fredericksburg?
Absolutely. Andy’s Steak & Seafood Grille and Nury’s On Main offer a relaxed atmosphere where you can enjoy classic seafood plates without any fuss.
Which seafood dishes are unique to Fredericksburg?
The catfish platters at Catfish Haven and Gulf shrimp étouffée at Hill Top Cafe bring local flair. These spots blend regional ingredients with Southern and Cajun influence.
Do local seafood restaurants offer non-seafood options?
Yes. Most seafood restaurants here also serve steaks, salads, and vegetarian sides—making them easy picks for mixed groups.
Are reservations needed for seafood restaurants in Fredericksburg?
For weekend dinners at popular places, like Cabernet Grill or Navajo Grill, booking ahead is smart. Casual spots may allow walk-ins but can fill up fast during busy seasons.