When seeking the finest seafood in Selma, AL, it’s essential to find spots that serve fresh, flavorful catches with sincerity. Over the years, I’ve discovered that the best seafood joints here blend tradition with a touch of innovation, offering dishes that satisfy both comfort and curiosity. From crispy fried fish to perfectly seasoned shrimp, these eateries capture the essence of local seafood without the fuss.
What sets Selma’s seafood scene apart is the commitment to quality and community. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, finding a restaurant that combines great taste with warm service can turn an ordinary meal into a memorable experience. Read on to uncover some of the top places where you can indulge in seafood that truly hits the mark. Your next favorite seafood dish might be just a few stops away.
Where to find the best seafood in Selma, AL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Selma, AL:
1. Captain D’s
Nestled at 1516 W Highland Ave, Captain D’s has earned a reputation for serving up fresh, flavorful seafood with a comforting American twist. During my visits, I’ve found their menu consistently reliable, offering a satisfying balance between classic fried favorites and lighter options. The inviting atmosphere makes it a go-to spot for both lunch and dinner.
What truly sets Captain D’s apart is their fresh seafood quality and generous portions. Their hook-and-harpoon style dishes showcase the best of what the coast has to offer. I recommend trying their battered fish fillets or the shrimp platter — both highlight the restaurant’s commitment to crispy, well-seasoned seafood. These dishes reflect their dedication to flavor and freshness, making every bite worth returning for.
2. American Wings & Seafood
(334) 505-7086Call
American Wings & Seafood, located at 2584 US Highway 80 W, offers a unique blend of flavors that cater to seafood lovers and wing enthusiasts alike. During my visit, I appreciated the vibrant atmosphere and friendly service that make it a welcoming spot for casual meals. Their menu showcases fresh seafood alongside classic American wings, providing something for everyone.
What makes American Wings & Seafood stand out is the quality and variety of their dishes. I highly recommend trying their crispy shrimp or oysters, which highlight their seafood’s freshness. The wings are also a must-try, with bold flavors and a satisfying crunch. Combining quality ingredients with a relaxed setting, this restaurant captures the essence of quick, flavorful meals in Selma.
3. Tally-Ho Restaurant
(334) 872-1390Call
Located at 509 Mangum Ave, Tally-Ho Restaurant offers a diverse menu that combines American comfort food with a touch of French, Cajun, and European influences. My visit revealed a family-friendly atmosphere where the warmth of home cooking is evident in every dish. The restaurant’s variety makes it perfect for those seeking hearty, flavorful meals.
What makes Tally-Ho special is its dedication to quality and authenticity. I recommend trying their seafood dishes like the shrimp creole or fried catfish, which showcase their commitment to fresh ingredients and bold flavors. With options for takeout and a welcoming vibe, Tally-Ho stands out as a versatile spot for memorable meals in Selma.
4. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Located at 1516 W Highland Ave, Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen has been a staple in Selma since 1969. During my visit, I appreciated the quick service and the inviting, family-friendly atmosphere. Their menu features a wide array of fried and grilled seafood options, making it easy to find something satisfying for every palate.
What sets Captain D’s apart is its focus on quality and variety. I recommend trying their crispy fish fillets or the flavorful shrimp platter. The side dishes, such as hush puppies and Southern green beans, perfectly complement the seafood. Whether for a casual lunch or dinner, Captain D’s delivers reliable, tasty seafood with consistent quality.
More Things to Try in Selma, AL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best seafood restaurants in Selma, AL?
A: Top choices include Captain D’s, American Wings & Seafood, and Tally-Ho Restaurant. Each offers a variety of fresh, flavorful seafood options suited to different tastes.
Q: Are there seafood places with quick service in Selma?
A: Yes, Captain D’s is known for its fast service, making it ideal for a quick seafood meal. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen focuses on efficient, family-friendly dining.
Q: Do these restaurants offer dine-in and takeout options?
A: Many, including Tally-Ho Restaurant and Captain D’s, provide both dine-in and takeout services for added convenience.
Q: Are there seafood restaurants that cater to families?
A: Absolutely. Captain D’s and Tally-Ho Restaurant are family-friendly spots with menu options for all ages, ensuring a comfortable dining experience.
Q: What seafood dishes are popular in Selma?
A: Fried fish, shrimp, and oysters are common favorites, often served with classic sides like hush puppies and coleslaw, reflecting local flavor and freshness.