Imagine savoring the freshest catch of the day, prepared with meticulous care and bursting with flavors that transport you straight to the coast. Fayetteville, NC, a city known for its vibrant culture and rich history, is also home to some of the most delightful seafood experiences you’ll ever encounter. Whether you’re a lifelong resident or just passing through, the seafood joints here promise a culinary adventure that you won’t soon forget. From succulent shrimp to expertly grilled fish, the seafood offerings in Fayetteville are nothing short of spectacular.
Let me take you on a journey through the best seafood spots in Fayetteville, where each bite tells a story of the ocean’s bounty and local culinary artistry. As someone who has explored every nook and cranny of this charming city in search of the perfect seafood dish, I can assure you that the treasures I am about to unveil will leave your taste buds tingling with delight. Prepare to be intrigued and enticed as we dive into the heart of Fayetteville’s seafood scene, where tradition meets innovation on every plate.
Where to find the best seafood in Fayetteville, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Fayetteville, NC:
- 316 Oyster Bar
- Hudson Bay Seafood
- Bonefish Grill
- Captain Jerrys Seafood
- North Atlantic Fish and Chips
- Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
- Peadens
- NY Supreme Steamers
- Red Lobster
- Crab Du Jour
1. 316 Oyster Bar
Located at 316 Owen Drive, 316 Oyster Bar offers a cozy yet lively spot to indulge in fresh seafood. From my visits, what sets this place apart is its genuine commitment to quality and community atmosphere. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, you’ll find the staff friendly and attentive.
Their extensive selection of oysters is a must-try, showcasing the freshness Fayetteville’s seafood scene is known for. I recommend trying the Oysters Rockefeller—rich, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. For a heartier option, the Seafood Platter delivers a variety of local favorites, reflecting their dedication to serving quality, local ingredients in every dish.
2. Hudson Bay Seafood
Hudson Bay Seafood on Ramsey Street is the kind of place that doesn’t need flash to impress. It’s unpretentious, consistent, and always generous with portions. I’ve stopped in more than once after a long day, and the comfort of their fried seafood never disappoints. The atmosphere is relaxed, and the service feels like you’re being looked after by neighbors.
What makes Hudson Bay stand out is its focus on hearty, traditional seafood done right. The bone-in flounder is a standout—crispy on the outside, tender inside, and full of flavor. If you’re in the mood for variety, the fried seafood combo plate offers a satisfying mix that captures the essence of Southern coastal cooking.
It’s a spot where locals return for a reason: reliable food, fair prices, and a no-fuss dining experience that hits the mark every time.
3. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill on Glensford Drive brings a polished, modern edge to Fayetteville’s seafood scene. From the moment you step in, it feels upscale yet unfussy—a space where wood-grilled flavors take center stage. On one visit, I sat near the open kitchen and watched the chefs prepare dishes with precision and flair, a testament to their expertise and pride in each plate.
What makes Bonefish Grill shine is its consistent execution and focus on high-quality ingredients. The Grilled Chilean Sea Bass is a standout: delicate, buttery, and cooked to perfection over an open flame. If you’re exploring, consider the Dynamite Shrimp appetizer—crispy with just the right amount of heat, a true reflection of their bold flavor profile.
Its blend of refined technique and thoughtful preparation makes Bonefish Grill more than just a chain—it’s a reliable go-to for satisfying seafood in Fayetteville.
4. Captain Jerrys Seafood
Captain Jerry’s Seafood on S Reilly Road is a Fayetteville staple that leans into tradition without losing its charm. The space is casual and family-friendly, with a menu that speaks to anyone craving classic Southern seafood. I’ve dropped in more than once for a quick lunch and always left satisfied—and full.
What sets Captain Jerry’s apart is its generous portions and no-nonsense approach to flavor. The fried flounder is a standout—lightly battered, crisp, and flaky inside. If you’re looking for variety, the broiled scallops and shrimp combo is a solid pick, offering a lighter yet flavorful option that still delivers on richness.
Service is quick, and the food is made to order, which means it arrives hot and fresh. It’s the kind of place that doesn’t try too hard because it doesn’t have to—the food speaks for itself.
5. North Atlantic Fish and Chips
North Atlantic Fish and Chips on Bragg Boulevard offers a taste of the UK right here in Fayetteville. The cozy, welcoming atmosphere pairs well with their menu of classic fish and chips, which I find consistently satisfying. The crispy batter and tender fish remind me of seaside shores, making each bite a small escape.
What makes this spot truly stand out is its authentic British style and attention to detail. I recommend trying the cod and chips, perfectly golden and light. For a different flavor, their battered haddock delivers that satisfying crunch and flaky fish that keeps me coming back.
This restaurant balances quality ingredients with nostalgic comfort—ideal for anyone craving reliable, well-executed seafood with a touch of tradition.
6. Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar, located at 1498 Skibo Rd, Fayetteville, NC, brings the vibrant tradition of Southern seafood boils to life. Known for its bold flavors and lively atmosphere, this spot is perfect for anyone craving fresh seafood with a Cajun twist. Whether you’re gathering with friends or dining with family, the experience is deliciously messy and unforgettable.
What sets Hook & Reel apart is its signature seafood boil, where you customize everything from the seasoning to the spice level. The friendly staff ensures every visit feels like a celebration, and the dishes are served fresh and piping hot. The restaurant’s cozy ambiance makes it a go-to destination for lunch, dinner, or special occasions.
If you’re unsure what to order, start with the Build Your Own Seafood Boil, packed with options like shrimp, mussels, and crab legs. Pair it with their garlic butter sauce for a flavor explosion. For a lighter option, the Cajun fries and shrimp baskets are crowd-pleasers. Every dish reflects Hook & Reel’s dedication to quality and authenticity, offering a true taste of Southern seafood in Fayetteville.
Hook & Reel is more than a meal – it’s an experience. Join the fun, dig in, and savor the flavors that make this spot an essential stop for seafood lovers.
7. Peadens
Peadens, located at 1600 McArthur Rd in Fayetteville, NC, is a cozy local gem known for its Southern-style comfort food and warm hospitality. From the moment you step in, the friendly staff and family-friendly ambiance make you feel right at home. Whether you’re dining in or grabbing takeout, the service is consistently welcoming and efficient.
What sets Peadens apart is its commitment to classic, no-frills cooking that’s full of flavor. The atmosphere is relaxed, with highchairs available for families, and plenty of seating for a laid-back meal. It’s a popular spot for locals who appreciate hearty meals made with care.
If you’re a seafood lover, don’t miss the fried flounder platter or grilled shrimp, both perfectly seasoned and cooked to perfection. These dishes reflect Peadens’s Southern roots and dedication to quality.
8. NY Supreme Steamers
Tucked into FSU Plaza on Murchison Road, NY Supreme Steamers brings a bold Northeastern flair to Fayetteville’s seafood scene. The vibe is casual, but the flavors are anything but ordinary. It’s the kind of place where the steam rising from your tray is as inviting as the friendly staff behind the counter.
What sets this spot apart is its focus on steamed seafood done right—no heavy sauces, just fresh ingredients and smart seasoning. The menu leans into simplicity, letting the seafood speak for itself.
Go for the shrimp and crab leg combo or the garlic butter mussels. Each bite delivers that clean, briny taste seafood lovers crave. It’s a solid pick for anyone seeking authentic, no-fuss seafood in Fayetteville.
9. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on McPherson Church Road delivers dependable seafood in a polished, sit-down setting. It’s one of those spots where the experience feels familiar in the best way. The service is well-paced, making it ideal for both casual dinners and family outings.
What gives this location its edge is the consistency—fresh flavors and generous portions that don’t waver. The menu is broad but focused, offering everything from lighter options to hearty seafood platters.
I still think about the Wood-Grilled Atlantic Salmon with its subtle smoky flavor, and the Garlic Shrimp Scampi which nails that delicate balance of butter and herbs. These dishes showcase Red Lobster’s knack for keeping things simple yet satisfying.
Gluten-free choices and reliable table service round out the reasons it remains a go-to for seafood in Fayetteville.
10. Crab Du Jour
See Menu
Crab Du Jour on Ramsey Street offers a relaxed, no-fuss atmosphere perfect for seafood lovers seeking bold flavors. From my visits, I appreciate their dedication to serving fresh, high-quality seafood with a focus on variety and customization. The lively setting makes it a popular spot for friends and families alike.
What makes Crab Du Jour stand out is its signature approach to seafood boils and shellfish, allowing diners to choose their own seasoning and spice level. The freshness and generous portions make every dish memorable.
I recommend trying the crab boil with Old Bay seasoning or the shrimp and sausage combo. These dishes perfectly reflect their style—fresh, flavorful, and designed for shared enjoyment.
Crab Du Jour combines quality with a fun, communal dining experience that keeps Fayetteville coming back for more.
More Things to Try in Fayetteville, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some popular seafood restaurants in Fayetteville, NC?
A: Some top options include 316 Oyster Bar, Bonefish Grill, Crab Du Jour, and Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar. These spots offer a variety of fresh seafood prepared with different styles, from casual to refined.
Q: Are there seafood spots that cater to families in Fayetteville?
A: Yes, places like Peadens and Crab Du Jour are family-friendly, featuring spacious seating and menu options suitable for children, making them good choices for a relaxed family dinner.
Q: Do Fayetteville seafood restaurants offer gluten-free options?
A: Some restaurants, such as Red Lobster and Bonefish Grill, provide gluten-free dishes or modifications, but it’s best to ask staff for specific menu items when ordering.
Q: Can I get seafood to go in Fayetteville?
A: Absolutely. Many restaurants, including Bonefish Grill and Hook & Reel, offer takeout and delivery options for those who want to enjoy fresh seafood at home.