Peoria, IL, may not be on every seafood lover’s radar, but it packs a punch with a diverse selection of spots serving up fresh and flavorful dishes. Whether you crave the simple joy of fish and chips or the delicate artistry of sushi, this city has something to satisfy every palate. Ready your taste buds as we explore Peoria’s best seafood options that promise to take you on a delightful culinary journey.
Throughout my time here, I’ve uncovered hidden gems that not only serve quality seafood but also create a welcoming atmosphere. Each restaurant offers its own unique twist, ensuring there’s always something new to try. From casual dining to vibrant buffets, you’re bound to find a favorite in this lineup. So, grab your fork and let’s dive into the top seafood spots in Peoria that are just waiting to be discovered.
Where to find the best seafood in Peoria, IL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Peoria, IL:
- The Fish House
- BIG JJ Fish & Chicken
- Long John Silver’s
- Hong Kong Sushi Buffet
- Dixon’s Seafood Shoppe
- Joe’s Crab Shack
- Red Lobster
- Jonah’s Seafood
- Alexander’s Steakhouse
- PO-Boys
1. The Fish House
At The Fish House, located on N University St, seafood takes center stage in a warm and inviting atmosphere. This spot manages to blend a cozy dining experience with a menu that highlights fresh, quality ingredients. It’s not just a meal; it’s a chance to enjoy the depths of flavor that the ocean offers in every bite.
What truly sets The Fish House apart is its extensive menu, accommodating everyone with vegetarian-friendly and gluten-free options. The attentive service enhances the overall experience, making it a favorite among locals.
When you visit, don’t miss the Coconut Shrimp—perfectly crispy and served with a tangy dipping sauce. Also, the Grilled Salmon, tender and seasoned just right, showcases their commitment to high-quality seafood. Each dish reflects the restaurant’s dedication to flavor and technique, sure to keep you coming back for more.
2. BIG JJ Fish & Chicken
BIG JJ Fish & Chicken, located on N University St, brings a unique twist to Peoria’s seafood scene with its combination of fried fish and chicken. The casual vibe draws diners looking for hearty meals without the fuss. This place feels like home, often filled with friendly faces and the enticing aroma of sizzling seafood.
What makes BIG JJ stand out is their commitment to flavor and generous portions. You won’t leave hungry here. The menu features a variety of fried seafood options that are crispy yet juicy, catering to all appetites.
Be sure to try the Catfish Nuggets, which are perfectly seasoned and come with a side of their tangy tartar sauce. The Fried Shrimp is also a must, offering a satisfying crunch with every bite. It’s casual dining at its finest.
3. Long John Silver’s
Located on N. Knoxville Avenue, Long John Silver’s is a familiar name for seafood lovers seeking quick and satisfying meals. With a commitment to sourcing wild-caught seafood from real oceans, this spot ensures quality in every dish. The casual ambiance makes it perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner.
What truly stands out at Long John Silver’s is their dedication to variety. Their menu isn’t just about fried fish. It showcases a range of seafood options that are both flavorful and accessible.
While you’re there, don’t miss the classic Fish and Chips, featuring crispy batter that envelops perfectly cooked fish, or the Grilled Salmon, which offers a healthier yet delicious alternative. Both dishes are testament to their focus on quality seafood.
4. Hong Kong Sushi Buffet
Located on N University Street, Hong Kong Sushi Buffet is a paradise for sushi enthusiasts and seafood lovers alike. This vibrant buffet promises an eclectic mix of flavors and dishes, allowing diners to sample a wide range of Japanese and Asian-inspired seafood. It’s an experience that feels like a culinary adventure in every visit.
What really makes Hong Kong Sushi Buffet stand out is the sheer variety available. With a multitude of options, you can indulge your cravings without overspending. The lively atmosphere enhances the enjoyment, making it a great spot for gatherings.
When you’re there, the Salmon Sashimi is a must-try, showcasing freshness and precision in each slice. Pair it with the California Rolls for a satisfying meal that highlights the buffet’s commitment to high-quality seafood. Each dish reflects the culinary passion that keeps diners coming back.
5. Dixon’s Seafood Shoppe
Dixon’s Seafood Shoppe, located on N University St, has proudly served Peoria for over a century, earning its reputation as the go-to source for fresh seafood. This family-owned shop, now in its fourth generation, emphasizes quality and service, ensuring that every visit feels personal. The extensive selection showcases everything from lobster to exotic game.
What sets Dixon’s apart is its unwavering commitment to exceptional quality. This is where you’ll find not only fresh and frozen seafood but also prepared delights like smoked fish and soups, perfect for those looking to impress at home.
When you stop by, be sure to grab the Fresh Lobster for a special dinner or the Homemade Crab Cakes, which are renowned for their flavor and freshness. Each dish reflects the shop’s dedication to high-quality seafood.
6. Joe’s Crab Shack
Situated on SW Water St, Joe’s Crab Shack is a lively destination for seafood lovers looking to indulge in a fun and casual dining experience. With a coastal vibe and an extensive menu, this restaurant captures the essence of seafood dining while welcoming everyone with open arms. It’s a great spot for family gatherings or casual nights out with friends.
What truly makes Joe’s stand out is the vibrant atmosphere paired with enthusiastic service. The energetic feel creates a festive backdrop perfect for diving into a seafood feast.
When visiting, don’t miss the Classic Steam Pot, packed with crab, shrimp, and sausage. The Fish and Chips are another fantastic choice—crispy and generously portioned, they perfectly showcase Joe’s commitment to quality seafood in a relaxed setting.
7. Red Lobster
Red Lobster, located on N Sterling Ave, stands as a staple in the seafood dining scene of Peoria. With its family-friendly atmosphere and extensive menu, it captures the hearts of diners looking for both quality and variety. This establishment balances casual dining with a touch of sophistication, making it ideal for any occasion.
What sets Red Lobster apart is its dedication to fresh seafood and commitment to flavor. Their knowledgeable staff is always ready to guide you through the menu, enhancing the dining experience.
Be sure to try the Beachside Platter, featuring a delicious combination of shrimp, crab, and fish, perfect for sharing. The Cheddar Bay Biscuits are a must alongside your meal—a warm, buttery treat that perfectly complements any seafood dish.
8. Jonah’s Seafood
(309) 694-0964Call
Jonah’s Seafood, located on N Brandywine Dr, offers a cozy and welcoming atmosphere perfect for seafood aficionados. This restaurant prides itself on serving fresh seafood while maintaining a casual vibe that makes every meal enjoyable. When you step inside, you can feel the dedication to quality right away.
What sets Jonah’s Seafood apart is its focus on providing a straightforward menu filled with classic seafood dishes. This no-nonsense approach allows the flavors of the ingredients to shine, making each dish a delightful experience.
Don’t miss the Fried Catfish, which boasts a crispy exterior and tender inside—an iconic highlight on their menu. The Seafood Pasta is another standout, featuring a rich sauce that complements the fresh shrimp and scallops beautifully.
9. Alexander’s Steakhouse
Alexander’s Steakhouse, nestled on Alexander Ave, offers a unique blend of seafood and steakhouse favorites in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Part of the renowned Mercedes Restaurants group, this eatery emphasizes quality across an expansive menu. It’s the kind of place where you can celebrate special occasions or enjoy a cozy dinner.
What sets Alexander’s apart is its commitment to freshness and variety. Alongside their seafood specialties, the salad bar boasts a colorful array of fruits and vegetables, nudging diners toward healthy options without sacrificing taste.
When visiting, don’t overlook the Shrimp Cocktail—perfectly chilled and served with a zesty sauce. Pair it with the Grilled Salmon, which highlights their expertise in seafood preparation, ensuring each bite is rich and flavorful.
10. PO-Boys
Located on N Frostwood Pkwy, PO-Boys offers a unique blend of Cajun and Creole influences in a laid-back setting perfect for a casual meal. The vibrant atmosphere captures the essence of bayou culture, making every dining experience feel like a mini getaway.
What makes PO-Boys stand out is their focus on hearty, flavorful dishes that are both satisfying and affordable. It’s an inviting spot where everyone feels welcome to relax and enjoy good food.
When you’re there, the Fried Catfish Po-Boy is a must-try, featuring crispy fried fish tucked into a soft roll that perfectly captures the restaurant’s essence. Pair it with the Seafood Gumbo for a warm, comforting option that showcases their culinary flair.
More Things to Try in Peoria, IL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Peoria, IL?
Some of the standout seafood spots include The Fish House, Joe’s Crab Shack, and Red Lobster. Each offers a unique experience, from casual dining to a more vibrant atmosphere.
2. Is there good sushi in Peoria?
Yes, you can find excellent sushi at places like Hong Kong Sushi Buffet and Happy Fish Sushi. Both offer diverse options, catering to all sushi lovers.
3. Are there seafood options for vegetarians?
While seafood inherently isn’t vegetarian, many restaurants in Peoria, like The Fish House, offer vegetarian-friendly dishes, ensuring everyone can find something to enjoy.
4. Can I find gluten-free seafood options in Peoria?
Absolutely. Many seafood restaurants, such as The Fish House, provide gluten-free options, making it easier for those with dietary restrictions to enjoy a meal out.
5. What seafood dish should I try in Peoria?
Definitely try the Fried Catfish at places like PO-Boys or the Grilled Salmon at Alexander’s Steakhouse. Both dishes are local favorites that highlight the culinary excellence of Peoria’s seafood scene.