Cincinnati may not be a coastal city, but its seafood scene is surprisingly vibrant. From fresh catches to expertly prepared dishes, the Queen City offers a variety of options for seafood lovers. Whether you’re craving sushi, grilled fish, or a hearty seafood boil, there’s something here to satisfy every palate. What’s more, many restaurants in Cincinnati are mindful of dietary preferences, including halal options, ensuring everyone can enjoy a delicious meal.
As someone who has explored the city’s culinary landscape extensively, I’ve discovered hidden gems and well-loved spots that consistently deliver quality seafood. This guide is crafted to help you navigate Cincinnati’s seafood offerings with confidence. Each recommendation is based on firsthand experience, ensuring you get accurate and reliable information. Let’s dive into the best seafood spots the city has to offer.
1. Swampwater Grill
Swampwater Grill, located on Kellogg Avenue, is a standout spot for seafood in Cincinnati. Its relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere makes it a favorite for both locals and visitors. The restaurant prides itself on offering fresh, high-quality ingredients, with a menu that caters to diverse dietary needs, including gluten-free and vegetarian options. Their commitment to halal-friendly practices ensures everyone can enjoy their meals with confidence.
What sets Swampwater Grill apart is its unique blend of Southern and Cajun-inspired flavors. The seafood gumbo is a must-try, rich with spices and perfectly balanced. For a lighter option, the grilled salmon, served with a tangy citrus glaze, is both flavorful and satisfying. Each dish reflects the restaurant’s dedication to quality and creativity.
Whether you’re dining in or taking out, Swampwater Grill delivers a memorable seafood experience. It’s a place where every bite feels like a celebration of flavor.
2. Pelicans Reef
Pelicans Reef, nestled on Beechmont Avenue, offers a charming dining experience with a cozy, nautical-themed ambiance. Perfect for both casual meals and family outings, it’s a spot where the aroma of fresh seafood immediately makes you feel at ease.
Known for their diverse seafood selection, Pelicans Reef excels in delivering flavorful dishes. Their seafood boils are a hit, with succulent shrimp and mussels cooked to perfection. The fish tacos are another favorite, offering a delightful blend of crispy fish, fresh slaw, and zesty aioli.
For a memorable meal, try their seafood platter, which showcases a variety of grilled and fried options. Each dish reflects their commitment to quality and taste, making every bite satisfying.
Whether dining in with family or grabbing takeout, Pelicans Reef is a reliable choice for seafood enthusiasts seeking a hearty, delicious meal in a welcoming setting.
3. Pacific Kitchen
Pacific Kitchen in Cincinnati offers a vibrant dining experience with fresh, sustainable ingredients. Their menu creatively blends seafood with international flavors, making it a top choice for seafood enthusiasts.
Their sushi selection is a highlight, with each roll crafted for flavor and presentation. The Rainbow Roll stands out, featuring tuna, salmon, and crab, wrapped in daikon for a refreshing touch.
For a hearty option, their seafood bowl with grilled shrimp, scallops, quinoa, and mango salsa is both nutritious and flavorful. Pacific Kitchen’s commitment to sustainability ensures delicious, eco-conscious meals.
Whether you prefer sushi or a warm dish, they offer something to satisfy every seafood craving.
4. McCormick & Schmick’s Seafood & Steaks
McCormick & Schmick’s brings coastal elegance to the heart of Cincinnati with its prime downtown location near Fountain Square. The restaurant’s polished atmosphere and reliably fresh seafood make it ideal for business dinners or special occasions.
Their oysters on the half shell are a revelation – plump, briny, and served with perfect accompaniments. For a signature taste of their seafood mastery, try the Chilean sea bass with miso glaze, its buttery texture balancing beautifully with the umami-rich sauce. Their commitment to sourcing from three different coastlines means you’re getting the ocean’s best offerings.
While known for seafood, their menu thoughtfully accommodates various dietary needs. The knowledgeable staff can guide you toward halal-compliant options, ensuring a dining experience that satisfies both your palate and principles.
5. Asiana Thai and Sushi of Hyde Park
Asiana Thai and Sushi of Hyde Park offers a delightful fusion of Thai and Japanese flavors in a relaxed, welcoming setting. The restaurant’s BYOB policy adds a personal touch, making it a favorite for casual gatherings and date nights alike.
Their sushi rolls are a standout, with the Spicy Tuna Roll being a must-try. For a Thai-inspired seafood dish, the Pad Thai with shrimp is a crowd-pleaser, combining perfectly cooked noodles with fresh, succulent shrimp. The Tom Yum soup, rich with lemongrass and shrimp, is another highlight, offering a burst of authentic Thai flavors.
Asiana’s commitment to quality and halal-friendly options ensures a satisfying dining experience. Whether you’re craving sushi or Thai classics, this spot delivers with flair and consistency.
6. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill in Cincinnati’s Hyde Park neighborhood is a go-to for seafood lovers seeking a refined yet approachable dining experience. The restaurant’s focus on fresh, hand-cut ingredients and wood-grilled specialties sets it apart in the local seafood scene.
Their Bang Bang Shrimp is legendary, offering a perfect balance of crispy texture and creamy, spicy sauce. For a main course, the Chilean Sea Bass, wood-grilled to perfection, is a standout, complemented by a light lemon butter sauce. The seasonal specials, often featuring locally sourced seafood, are always worth exploring.
Bonefish Grill’s commitment to quality and halal-friendly options ensures a satisfying meal. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, their expertly prepared dishes and inviting atmosphere make every visit memorable.
7. Uncle Yip’s Seafood
Uncle Yip’s Seafood offers an authentic taste of Southern Chinese cuisine in the heart of Cincinnati. With a menu that embraces Cantonese, Thai, and Sichuan influences, it stands out for its diverse selection of seafood and dim sum, particularly during their lively weekend brunch.
The restaurant’s twin lobster dish is particularly popular, showcasing the freshness and quality of their seafood. For a unique experience, try the dim sum served from push carts—a nostalgic touch that makes dining here feel special and authentic. The variety of flavors in their Hunan shrimp stir-fry is also a must-try, reflecting the bold, spicy style that Uncle Yip’s is known for.
This inviting spot promises a memorable dining experience, merging quality dishes with a welcoming atmosphere.
8. Alabama Fish Bar
Alabama Fish Bar is a Cincinnati institution, offering a no-frills, fast-food approach to seafood that’s both affordable and delicious. Located on Race Street, this spot has been a local favorite for decades, known for its generous portions and quick service.
Their fried fish is the star of the menu, with a crispy, golden coating that’s perfectly seasoned. Pair it with their hush puppies for a classic, satisfying meal. The shrimp basket is another standout, featuring plump, juicy shrimp that are fried to perfection.
What makes Alabama Fish Bar special is its simplicity and consistency. It’s a place where you can enjoy hearty, flavorful seafood without breaking the bank. Whether you’re grabbing lunch or dinner, this spot delivers a taste of Southern comfort in every bite.
9. Red Lobster
Red Lobster at Springdale Road delivers the chain’s signature seafood experience with reliable quality and family-friendly service. While it might not be Cincinnati’s most adventurous seafood spot, it excels at delivering crowd-pleasing classics with consistent execution.
Their Ultimate Feast remains a bestseller for good reason – featuring lobster tail, garlic shrimp, and crab legs, it’s a sampler of their most reliable preparations. The wood-grilled salmon, cooked over an open flame, showcases their ability to handle simple dishes well. Don’t skip the famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits, which have achieved near-cult status among regulars.
What makes this location stand out is its commitment to accessibility – offering familiar seafood preparations without intimidating prices. While not specifically halal-certified, their grilled fish options can accommodate various dietary needs when requested.
10. Red Lobster
Red Lobster at Cincinnati Mills Dr offers a dependable seafood experience with a menu that caters to diverse tastes. Known for its approachable atmosphere and consistent quality, it’s a reliable spot for families and seafood enthusiasts alike.
Their Create Your Own Combination is a standout, allowing diners to mix and match favorites like lobster, shrimp, and fish. The Admiral’s Feast, featuring a variety of fried seafood, is a classic choice that highlights their signature preparation style. For a lighter option, the wood-grilled salmon is perfectly cooked, with a smoky flavor that pairs well with seasonal sides.
While not halal-certified, their grilled seafood options can be tailored to meet dietary preferences. Red Lobster’s commitment to quality and variety makes it a trusted choice for seafood lovers in Cincinnati.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Where can I find halal seafood in Cincinnati?
A: While not all restaurants are halal-certified, some like Swampwater Grill and McCormick & Schmick’s offer halal-friendly seafood options. Always confirm with staff about preparation methods.
Q: What’s the best seafood restaurant for a special occasion?
A: Pacific Kitchen and McCormick & Schmick’s stand out for upscale dining, with fresh seafood and elegant atmospheres.
Q: Are there affordable seafood spots in Cincinnati?
A: Alabama Fish Bar and Red Lobster offer budget-friendly options without skimping on flavor.
Q: Where can I get authentic sushi in Cincinnati?
A: Asiana Thai and Sushi of Hyde Park serves fresh, creative rolls with authentic Thai-Japanese flair.
Q: Which restaurant has the best Cajun-style seafood?
A: Swampwater Grill’s gumbo and Southern-inspired dishes capture bold Cajun flavors.
Q: Are there seafood places with good vegetarian options?
A: Pacific Kitchen and Asiana Thai offer excellent vegetarian and vegan seafood alternatives.
Q: What’s a good seafood spot for large groups?
A: Uncle Yip’s Seafood accommodates parties with its spacious setup and shareable dishes like dim sum.
Q: Where can I find fresh oysters in Cincinnati?
A: McCormick & Schmick’s sources oysters from multiple coasts, served chilled or grilled.
Q: Which restaurants offer takeout seafood?
A: Most listed spots (Pelicans Reef, Bonefish Grill) provide takeout—check their websites for details.
Q: Is there a seafood boil place in Cincinnati?
A: Pelicans Reef’s seafood boils are a must-try, packed with shrimp, mussels, and bold spices.
