Best Seafood in Rye, NY

Photo of Seafood in Rye, NY

Rye, NY has a knack for making seafood feel like a celebration. One visit here and you’ll realize this town treats the ocean’s bounty with respect, flavor, and just the right amount of flair. Imagine walking along Purchase Street as the salty air tempts you to step inside a bistro or two, each one promising … Read more

Best Seafood in Sayville, NY

Photo of Seafood in Sayville, NY

Searching for the best seafood in Sayville, NY is a bit like a treasure hunt: the town is small, the selection is vast, and the prize is always something fresh and flavorful. Locals make it an art form—matching crispy fried calamari with sunset views, or chasing down the sound of clinking oyster shells and laughter … Read more

Best Seafood in Goshen, NY

Photo of Seafood in Goshen, NY

There’s something irresistibly inviting about fresh seafood, especially when you find yourself in Goshen, NY—a town with a quiet but dedicated scene for lovers of shellfish and fillets. Whether you’re craving perfectly crisp fried fish or the tender bite of sushi, Goshen’s dining spots have a knack for bringing the ocean closer in landlocked Orange … Read more

Best Seafood in Ithaca, NY

Photo of Seafood in Ithaca, NY

Seafood in Ithaca hides in plain sight, tucked away in unassuming villages, cozy waterfronts, and lively supper clubs. If you’ve ever followed your nose down West Buffalo Street or caught the scent of grilled salmon drifting over Cayuga Lake, you already know a secret: Ithaca’s seafood scene is much more than a menu afterthought. Here, … Read more

Best Seafood in Seaford, NY

Photo of Seafood in Seaford, NY

Seaford is a quiet patch of Long Island, but ask any local where to find the best seafood and you’ll get an earful. I remember walking along Merrick Road on a cool afternoon, trailing the salty breeze that always seems to hint at fresh oysters, buttery lobster, and crispy fried fish. This neighborhood knows seafood. … Read more

Best Seafood in Hurley, NY

Photo of Seafood in Hurley, NY

Finding great seafood in Hurley, NY, is equal parts exploration and reward. Tucked between historic barns and sheltered forests, this small Hudson Valley spot harbors more flavor than a city block. I’ve wandered these back roads with a stubborn appetite, following the scent of broiled fish and the promising chatter of locals. Each spot along … Read more

Best Seafood in Medford, NY

Photo of Seafood in Medford, NY

In Medford, NY, seafood spots are a conversation topic all their own. Whether you’re craving classics like grilled salmon or searching for the perfect bowl of clam chowder, there’s always somewhere new to discover. I’ve spent many evenings chasing down the freshest catch, sometimes guided by the flicker of neon signs and sometimes by the … Read more

Best Seafood in Selden, NY

Photo of Seafood in Selden, NY

Craving the freshest catch in Selden, NY? You’ve landed in the right spot. Selden might not have an oceanfront view, but its seafood scene is surprisingly deep. From the subtle lure of perfectly grilled shrimp to the satisfying snap of a well-battered fish fillet, the area punches well above its weight. One evening, curiosity led … Read more

Best Seafood in Holtsville, NY

Photo of Seafood in Holtsville, NY

Nothing beats the anticipation of a good seafood meal, especially in a town like Holtsville, NY. When I first wandered through these local spots, I found more than just fish and shellfish — I stumbled upon a community that takes its catch seriously. There’s a real distinction between the places that treat seafood as an … Read more

Best Seafood in Mahopac, NY

Photo of Seafood in Mahopac, NY

Finding great seafood in Mahopac, NY is not a marathon through endless fried platters and overcooked shrimp. The area offers more than the usual suspects, and I still remember my first taste of Mahopac’s local catch—crisp calamari at a lakeside spot, followed by buttery flounder that was anything but ordinary. It was proof that you … Read more

Best Seafood in Fairview, NY

Photo of Seafood in Fairview, NY

Finding great seafood in Fairview, NY is a bit like discovering the perfect oyster hiding in a bed of pebbles—unexpected and deeply satisfying. Whether you’re a lifelong Hudson Valley local or just passing through, Fairview has a way of surprising diners with its range of seafood spots. My last visit led me on an informal … Read more

Best Seafood in Ridge, NY

Photo of Seafood in Ridge, NY

Finding great seafood in Ridge, NY feels a bit like searching for hidden treasure, but it’s far less risky and much tastier. I spent more than a few evenings dodging soggy fries and bland fillets before finally cracking the code to Ridge’s standout seafood scene. Good news: you don’t need to wade through a sea … Read more