19 Irresistible Fish Pie Recipes to Try Today

Looking for a comforting fish pie to warm up your next meal? Here are 19 delicious recipes that are easy to make and full of flavor.

Fish pies are a delightful, comforting dish perfect for any occasion. With their creamy sauces and flaky fish, they bring warmth and satisfaction to your table.

Imagine biting into a golden mashed potato crust, revealing a mix of smoked and unsmoked fish in a rich sauce. These recipes offer a balance of depth and freshness that makes each bite a festive treat.

Whether you’re looking for a quick family dinner or a dish for a dinner party, fish pies are versatile and easy to make. From classic British versions to dairy-free options, there’s a recipe to suit every palate.

Dive into our collection of fish pie recipes and discover how simple it is to create a cozy, delicious meal. Your family will love the cheesy, comforting flavors, and you’ll appreciate the ease and simplicity of preparation.

1. Fish Pie (for Easter!)

Flaky fish is poached with fragrant onion cloves, then baked under a golden mashed potato crust swimming in a rich, creamy sauce made from that flavor-packed broth. A mix of smoked and unsmoked fish gives every bite a perfect balance of depth and freshness, making it a festive favorite—not just for Easter!

Read the Recipe: Fish Pie (for Easter!)

2. Family meals: Easy fish pie recipe

This easy fish pie is perfect for a quick family dinner or for freezing toddler-sized portions. Simply cook and mash potatoes, prepare a creamy sauce with fish and vegetables, layer everything in a dish, top with cheese, and bake until golden and bubbly.

Read the Recipe: Family meals: Easy fish pie recipe

3. Fish Pie

This cozy Fish Pie is a creamy mash-up of cod, salmon, and halibut baked with vibrant veggies in a rich white sauce, then crowned with fluffy cheddar-topped mashed potatoes. It’s a simple, satisfying dish that brings family together for a warm and flavorful dinner!

Read the Recipe: Fish Pie

4. British Fish Pie With Smoked Salmon, Shrimp, and Mashed Potatoes

Firm cod, smoked salmon, and shrimp are cooked in a creamy sauce and topped with browned mashed potatoes. This comforting dish offers a delightful mix of flavors and textures with a buttery crust of potatoes instead of pastry.

Read the Recipe: British Fish Pie With Smoked Salmon, Shrimp, and Mashed Potatoes

5. Easy British Fish Pie

This British Fish Pie is a cozy, comforting dish that combines tender, flaky fish poached in a flavorful fish stock, mixed with leeks and herbs, then topped with creamy mashed potatoes and a sprinkle of cheese. It’s an easy, budget-friendly one-pot meal that looks impressive and is perfect for casual family dinners or even a dinner party—simply bake until golden and serve with fresh greens!

Read the Recipe: Easy British Fish Pie

6. Easy Fish Pie

This Easy Fish Pie is a delicious, hearty dish that’s perfect for both dinner parties and family dinners, with kids loving its cheesy, comforting flavors. Simply bake white fish, shrimp, and a creamy cheese sauce together, then top with mashed potatoes and bake until golden and bubbling for a satisfying meal that pairs beautifully with a fresh green salad or steamed broccoli.

Read the Recipe: Easy Fish Pie

7. Fish Pie [cooking.nytimes.com]

This fish pie is a cozy dish where gently poached fish is mixed with a creamy white sauce, topped with buttery mashed potatoes, and baked until golden. It’s rich, comforting, and perfect for both kids and dinner parties when jazzed up with white wine, light cream, and saffron.

Read the Recipe: Fish Pie [cooking.nytimes.com]

8. British-inspired fish pie

This British-inspired fish pie is a cozy and flavorful dish made with white fish, smoked salmon, and a creamy sauce, all tucked under a golden layer of puff pastry. Quick to assemble and rich with smoky depth, it’s perfect for entertaining or just warming up a chilly night.

Read the Recipe: British-inspired fish pie

9. Fish Pie [www.seasonsandsuppers.ca]

Creamy fish pie is a cozy dish made with whitefish, shrimp, and scallops, all wrapped in a smooth, cheesy white sauce and topped with buttery mashed potatoes. It’s easy to prep ahead and bake at dinnertime for a warm, comforting meal.

Read the Recipe: Fish Pie [www.seasonsandsuppers.ca]

10. Classic New England Fish Pie Recipe

Imagine a cozy fish pie with a flaky white fish, tender leeks, sweet parsnips, and bright peas swimming in a creamy white sauce. This comforting dish is topped with a cheddar-y horseradish and buttermilk mashed potato crust, which crisps up perfectly in the oven for a delightful finish.

Read the Recipe: Classic New England Fish Pie Recipe

11. Jamie Oliver’s Fantastic Fish Pie (Dairy-Free & Gluten-Free)

This dairy-free, gluten-free fish pie is a cozy twist on Jamie Oliver’s classic, made simpler with fewer pans and more veggies. It’s creamy from coconut milk, packed with frozen white fish, and easy to adapt for low FODMAP diets—a total win for weeknight dinners!

Read the Recipe: Jamie Oliver’s Fantastic Fish Pie (Dairy-Free & Gluten-Free)

12. Easy Fish Pie {with Crunchy Cheese Topping}

This Easy Fish Pie has a cheesy mashed potato topping, a simple sauce, and requires no pre-cooking of the fish. Just assemble and bake for a delicious, comforting meal that’s perfect for busy days or batch cooking.

Read the Recipe: Easy Fish Pie {with Crunchy Cheese Topping}

13. Easy British Fish Pie [mission-food.com]

This cozy British Fish Pie is a creamy mix of flaky white fish, salmon, smoked fish, and peas, all tucked under a fluffy mashed potato crust. Poaching the fish in milk makes the sauce extra rich and smooth, while a touch of lemon zest keeps it fresh and bright.

Read the Recipe: Easy British Fish Pie [mission-food.com]

14. Jamie Oliver’s 5 Ingredient Crazy Simple Fish Pie

This easy fish pie uses just 5 ingredients—smoked haddock, spring onions, spinach, Cheddar cheese, and filo pastry—and takes under 30 minutes to make. Simply soak the fish, cook the veggies, layer everything in a pan, top with pastry, and bake until golden and bubbly.

Read the Recipe: Jamie Oliver’s 5 Ingredient Crazy Simple Fish Pie

15. How to make fish pie

Make a creamy fish pie by cooking smoked haddock, cod, and prawns in a flavorful, herby milk sauce with leeks, peas, and parsley. Top with buttery mashed potatoes, bake until golden, and serve with steamed vegetables for a comforting meal.

Read the Recipe: How to make fish pie

16. Rick Stein’s classic fish pie recipe

Rick Stein’s classic fish pie is a comforting and crowd-pleasing dish made with fresh fish, creamy nutmeg-infused sauce, and golden mashed potato enriched with egg yolk. For a finishing touch, serve it hot with garden peas and a crisp glass of Chardonnay—pure satisfaction in every bite.

Read the Recipe: Rick Stein’s classic fish pie recipe

17. Jamie Oliver’s fantastic fish pie recipe

Jamie Oliver’s fantastic fish pie is a comforting dish made with creamy mashed potatoes, tender chunks of fish, spinach, and a flavorful mustard-cheese sauce. Simply layer everything, add boiled eggs, top with buttery mash, and bake until golden brown for a hearty, delicious meal.

Read the Recipe: Jamie Oliver’s fantastic fish pie recipe

18. Easy Fish Pie [vikalinka.com]

This easy fish pie is a warm and comforting dish made with a creamy sauce, flaky fish, and fluffy mashed potatoes, perfect for cold nights. It’s simple to customize with your favorite fish and vegetables, and most of the ingredients are likely already in your kitchen.

Read the Recipe: Easy Fish Pie [vikalinka.com]

19. Puff Pastry Topped Fish Pie Recipe – Rick Stein’s Simple Suppers

This easy fish pie is topped with puff pastry for a delicious twist on a classic, making it simple to prepare and bake in just 25-30 minutes. Poached fish, rich sauce with cheese, wine, and parsley, plus shrimp, all go into a dish topped with golden pastry—just slide it into the oven and enjoy a hearty, fuss-free meal!

Read the Recipe: Puff Pastry Topped Fish Pie Recipe – Rick Stein’s Simple Suppers