Amarillo, Texas, may be known for its hearty steaks and barbecue, but the seafood scene here is surprisingly vibrant. As someone who has explored the culinary landscape of this city, I can assure you that there are hidden gems waiting to be discovered. From fresh oysters to flavorful shrimp dishes, the options are diverse and satisfying. Each restaurant offers a unique twist on seafood, making it an adventure for your taste buds.
In this guide, we will dive into the best seafood spots in Amarillo. Whether you are a local or just passing through, these establishments promise quality and flavor. You’ll find everything from casual eateries to more upscale dining experiences. So, if you’re ready to embark on a seafood journey that will leave you craving more, keep reading. The perfect dish is just around the corner.
Where to find the best seafood in Amarillo, TX
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Amarillo, TX:
- Scott’s Oyster Bar
- Drunken Oyster
- The Lazy Gator
- Red Lobster
- Sam’s Southern Eatery – Amarillo
- Macaroni Joes
- Pho 84
- X- Steakhouse
- Cellar 55
- Fat Cat Fish & Grill
1. Scott’s Oyster Bar
Tucked away on Paramount Boulevard, Scott’s Oyster Bar is a no-frills seafood joint with a big local following—and for good reason. The moment I stepped onto the breezy patio and caught a whiff of sizzling seafood, I knew I was in for something special. It doesn’t scream for attention, but it certainly earns it.
What makes Scott’s stand out is its focus on fresh, simply prepared seafood. The oysters, chilled and briny, arrive perfectly shucked, and the catfish is fried to a crisp without being heavy. If you’re in the mood for something light, their grilled shrimp is packed with flavor and served just right.
This isn’t fine dining—it’s better. It’s laid-back, honest, and consistent. If you’re hunting for the best seafood in Amarillo that leans into comfort over pretense, Scott’s delivers. Go with friends, order a little of everything, and don’t rush.
2. Drunken Oyster
At The Drunken Oyster, dining feels less like Texas and more like a detour through the French Quarter. With its gas lanterns, weathered brick, and moody jazz hum, the setting alone raises your expectations. The night I stepped inside, the place was buzzing, filled with folks cracking shells and sipping on cold drinks. It wasn’t hard to see why.
What sets this spot apart is the balance between rich Southern flair and consistently fresh seafood. The chargrilled oysters are a staple—perfectly smoky, topped just enough to complement without overpowering. Their seafood gumbo is another highlight, carrying layers of bold flavor in every spoonful. It’s easy to see why many locals keep this place in rotation.
Whether you’re diving into a platter of blackened fish or just nibbling on shrimp, The Drunken Oyster delivers quality that lives up to the vibe. Come hungry and stay a while—this place isn’t trying too hard, and that’s exactly the charm.
3. The Lazy Gator
Stepping into The Lazy Gator felt like stumbling upon a low-key treasure. The dining area was relaxed, the service unhurried, and the focus clearly on delivering satisfying food without overcomplicating things. It’s the kind of place you visit when you’re craving comfort with depth.
What makes The Lazy Gator worth noting is its knack for dishing up bold flavor with consistency. Their blackened tilapia hits just the right balance of spice and smoke, while the fried shrimp basket is generous, golden, and satisfying without the grease overload. It’s simple food done well—and with heart.
They stay true to Southern roots without being heavy-handed. Every dish feels crafted rather than just cooked. Whether you’re eating in or grabbing takeout, The Lazy Gator offers seafood that’s honest and unpretentious, exactly how it should be.
4. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Amarillo is a go-to spot for those seeking reliably fresh seafood. From the moment I entered, the inviting aroma of butter and spices set the tone for a satisfying meal. The staff’s friendly service makes every visit feel welcoming and effortless.
What truly distinguishes Red Lobster is its dedication to quality. The lobster tail is tender and flavorful, and their garlic shrimp delivers a perfect combination of seasoning and juiciness. Both dishes showcase the restaurant’s commitment to sourcing fresh, high-quality seafood.
This chain’s blend of classic dishes and dependable freshness makes it a favorite. Whether dining in or ordering takeout, Red Lobster offers a consistent experience — a solid choice for seafood lovers in Amarillo.
5. Sam’s Southern Eatery – Amarillo
Tucked along Teckla Blvd, Sam’s Southern Eatery in Amarillo delivers Southern comfort with a Louisiana twist. The vibe is casual, the service warm, and the portions made for serious appetites. It’s the kind of place where you can roll in solo or with the entire family and walk out full and satisfied.
What sets this spot apart is the authenticity of its seafood fare, especially in a town more known for steak than shrimp. I once dropped in for a quick bite and left plotting my next visit before I’d even finished the catfish.
Go for the Jumbo Shrimp platter or the Whole Fried Catfish. Both are boldly seasoned and served in generous portions, showcasing the soul of Southern-Creole cooking done right.
6. Macaroni Joes
Step into Macaroni Joe’s, and Amarillo feels a little closer to Tuscany. This locally loved spot blends rustic charm with an inventive menu that leans Italian but isn’t boxed in by tradition. The wine list? Let’s just say it’s impressively curated without being intimidating.
What makes it shine for seafood lovers is its take on dishes like the Chilean Seabass. Light, delicate, and perfectly seared, it’s the kind of plate that doesn’t rely on overcomplication—just great ingredients and thoughtful execution.
I once visited after a long day of driving and left with a new favorite. Their Blackened Bayou Pasta, minus any haram additions, hits a bold note with its spiced seafood medley and creamy sauce.
Pair your meal with a staff-recommended vintage. You’ll leave full, not just from the food, but from the experience itself.
7. Pho 84
Located on SW 34th Ave, Pho 84 is a hidden gem in Amarillo that brings the vibrant flavors of Vietnam to the heart of Texas. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, making it a perfect spot for a quick meal or a leisurely dinner with friends.
What sets Pho 84 apart is its dedication to authentic Vietnamese cuisine. The seafood pho is a must-try, featuring a rich, aromatic broth filled with fresh shrimp and fish, making it a comforting choice any time of year. I remember my first visit, where the fragrant spices and fresh herbs transported me straight to Vietnam.
Don’t miss the grilled shrimp spring rolls as a starter; they’re light, refreshing, and pair beautifully with the house-made dipping sauce. Pho 84 is a delightful culinary escape that seafood lovers in Amarillo shouldn’t overlook.
8. X- Steakhouse
Located at Town Square Blvd, X- Steakhouse redefines the dining experience in Amarillo with its commitment to quality and excellence. The ambiance is upscale yet welcoming, making it an ideal spot for special occasions or a memorable night out.
What truly sets X- apart is its attention to detail in every dish. While known for its steaks, the grilled salmon is a standout seafood option that showcases their culinary expertise. It’s perfectly cooked, flaky, and paired with seasonal vegetables that enhance its flavor.
During my visit, the staff’s genuine hospitality made the experience even more enjoyable. I recommend starting with the seafood bisque, which is rich and comforting, setting the tone for a delightful meal.
X- Steakhouse is a must-visit for anyone seeking a refined dining experience in Amarillo.
9. Cellar 55
Cellar 55 offers a modern take on Amarillo’s classic steakhouse experience with a strong focus on seafood as well. Located on Civic Circle, the place combines a sleek ambiance with attentive service that makes every visit feel special. My first meal there left a lasting impression thanks to the perfect balance of sophistication and comfort.
Their seared scallops are a highlight—golden on the outside, tender inside, served with seasonal accompaniments that bring out the natural sweetness. The lobster tail is another must-try, showcasing freshness and expert preparation.
Whether you’re hungry for steak or craving top-notch seafood, Cellar 55 delivers consistently. It’s a go-to for those who want quality and variety in one elegant setting.
10. Fat Cat Fish & Grill
+1 806-373-8460
Tucked along Dumas Drive, Fat Cat Fish & Grill is a no-frills spot that knows exactly what it does best—fresh, Southern-style seafood served hot and hearty. It’s the kind of place where the portions are generous, the service is warm, and the food speaks for itself.
What stood out on my visit was the catfish platter—crispy, golden, and seasoned just right. It came with hush puppies and coleslaw that balanced the richness of the fish. The grilled tilapia was another standout, light yet flavorful, and cooked to flaky perfection.
Fat Cat doesn’t try to be trendy. It focuses on quality, consistency, and comfort. If you’re after authentic seafood in Amarillo, this is a solid bet that delivers every time.
More Things to Try in Amarillo, TX
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Amarillo?
Some of the top seafood spots include Cellar 55, known for its elegant atmosphere and fresh dishes, and Fat Cat Fish & Grill, which offers hearty Southern-style seafood. X- Steakhouse also features excellent seafood options alongside their renowned steaks.
2. Is seafood in Amarillo fresh?
Yes! Many restaurants in Amarillo prioritize sourcing fresh seafood. Places like Cellar 55 and Fat Cat Fish & Grill are known for their commitment to quality and freshness, ensuring a delightful dining experience.
3. What seafood dishes should I try in Amarillo?
When in Amarillo, don’t miss the grilled salmon at X- Steakhouse or the seared scallops at Cellar 55. The catfish platter at Fat Cat Fish & Grill is also a local favorite!
4. Are there any seafood options for those with dietary restrictions?
Absolutely! Many seafood restaurants in Amarillo offer gluten-free and healthy options. Always check with the staff for specific dietary needs, as they are usually happy to accommodate.
5. Can I find seafood takeout in Amarillo?
Yes, many seafood restaurants, including Fat Cat Fish & Grill, offer takeout options. It’s a great way to enjoy delicious seafood from the comfort of your home!