If you ever find yourself daydreaming about the perfect bite of fish or craving a platter of sweet, tender crab, Arlington, NY hides some pleasant surprises. Having spent far too many evenings here negotiating between crispy calamari and flaky salmon, I’ve learned not every seafood plate tells the same story—or swims in the same league. The secret is knowing which spots care just as much about what goes in your meal as you do about what lands on the table.
This collection guides you through the most reliable and respected places for seafood in Arlington, from cozy diners with plates piled high, to local gems tucked along the Hudson. Whether you follow flavor trails to a decades-old fish market or step into a bustling dinner scene with a catch-of-the-day special, you’ll find insight you can count on. Curious? Let’s chart a course through Arlington’s best spots and see what truly stands out.
Where to find the best seafood in Arlington, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Arlington, NY:
- Bonefish Grill – Closed
- Mariners on the Hudson
- Tasty Crab House
- Red Lobster
- Joe Willy S Fish
- Eveready Diner
- Tammy Honeyman
- Aladias Crab Cravings
- Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
- Billy Joe’s Ribworks
1. Bonefish Grill – Closed
Bonefish Grill in Poughkeepsie brought a fresh, modern approach to seafood before its doors closed. I can still recall the buzz over their signature Bang Bang Shrimp, a dish that paired crunch and spice in just the right way. For any seafood lover, this appetizer alone set the bar high.
What made Bonefish Grill different was its focus on clean flavors and creative twists. The restaurant offered everything from wood-grilled fish to refreshing salads. The service always felt a step above, and the menu promised variety without feeling overwhelming.
The best part was picking a fresh catch and customizing it with signature sauces. Even though Bonefish Grill is no longer open, the mark it left on Arlington’s dining scene is hard to forget.
2. Mariners on the Hudson
(845) 691-6011Call
Mariners on the Hudson brings the waterfront experience straight to your table. I still remember sitting outside at dusk, grilled fish on my plate while the lights flickered on along the water. Few places around Arlington offer a view this impressive, let alone with a menu dedicated to the fresh catch of the day.
The charm of Mariners isn’t just in the scenery. The kitchen serves up expertly prepared seafood, from delicate pan-seared salmon to perfectly seasoned shrimp platters. You can taste the freshness in every bite, especially if you order their catch of the day—it always feels inspired by the river just steps away.
Don’t skip the house-made chowder. It’s rich, loaded with tender seafood, and the kind of dish that lingers in your memory long after you’ve left the riverbank.
3. Tasty Crab House
(845) 454-2850Call
Tasty Crab House doesn’t try to hide what it does best. My first visit started with a roll of sleeves and ended with a table full of crab shells and satisfied smiles. This is the place to get a messy, memorable, and flavor-packed seafood meal—no frills required.
The standout here is the seafood boil. You get a choice of fresh crab, shrimp, and more, tossed in a bold house-made sauce with potatoes and corn. The seasoning isn’t shy, which means every bite has enough kick to keep you coming back for more.
If you’re in the mood for hands-on eating and generous seafood portions, Tasty Crab House turns a simple dinner into a feast worth savoring.
4. Red Lobster
Red Lobster’s appeal goes beyond its famous cheddar biscuits. I’ve stopped here for both casual dinners and family celebrations, and the atmosphere always feels relaxed and welcoming. Their consistent approach to classic seafood dishes makes it a go-to for many in Arlington.
The menu covers a lot of ground, but the Admiral’s Feast is a local favorite for a reason—think crispy fried shrimp, flounder, and a generous helping of sides. If you’re craving something with a lighter touch, the grilled salmon speaks to Red Lobster’s attention to quality and simple preparation.
Dependable, crowd-pleasing, and satisfying, Red Lobster keeps locals coming back for those reliable seafood staples.
5. Joe Willy S Fish
Joe Willy S Fish strikes a balance between classic comfort and fresh flavors. My last visit felt like a throwback to no-nonsense fish shacks, only with polished service and a menu that surprises. It sits just outside Arlington, so it’s worth the short drive for something memorable.
The real draw at Joe Willy’s is the fish and chips. Each piece arrives light, crispy, and never greasy—a testament to their careful technique. The grilled salmon also stands out, thanks to its flaky texture and vibrant seasoning.
Warm, unfussy, and sincere, Joe Willy S Fish is a spot for anyone who enjoys fresh seafood served without pretense or distraction.
6. Eveready Diner
Eveready Diner is where nostalgia and comfort come standard. Every time I’ve stopped in, there’s a steady hum of conversation, silver gleaming under neon lights, and a menu that stretches well beyond breakfast. Hidden among the classics, you’ll find some surprisingly good seafood plates.
The grilled salmon and crab cakes are highlights. They’re both made fresh and served with care, reflecting the diner’s knack for turning simple ingredients into satisfying meals. The portions are generous, making it easy to leave with both a full stomach and a sense of contentment.
For a laid-back meal that doesn’t skimp on taste, Eveready always feels like the reliable choice, especially for seafood in a classic setting.
7. Tammy Honeyman
(845) 236-2700Call
Tammy Honeyman is the kind of neighborhood seafood spot that feels genuinely personal. On my last visit, there was a sense that someone in the kitchen put real care into every plate. The atmosphere is as friendly as it gets, with staff who seem to remember returning faces and favorite orders.
The standout here is the grilled fish, expertly seasoned and cooked to perfection. There’s also a rotating selection of fresh seafood specials, so the menu never feels stale. Each dish reflects a commitment to quality and consistency, which can be hard to come by.
If you’re passing through Marlboro, Tammy Honeyman is a detour that delivers on both flavor and hospitality with every visit.
8. Aladias Crab Cravings
(845) 419-9175Call
Aladias Crab Cravings is the spot where seafood cravings turn into genuine events. My introduction came at a catered event, where platters overflowing with crab caught everyone’s attention. What’s remarkable about this place is the way it brings both variety and flavor to every spread.
The obvious choice is the crab boil, which arrives steaming, generously seasoned, and piled high with sides. Every piece of crab is tender, and the seasoning adds a punch without overpowering the main ingredient.
If you’re looking for seafood that’s perfect for sharing or want to give a gathering an upgrade, Aladias brings artistry and warmth to the table. It’s seafood with celebration in every bite.
9. Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market feels like a treasure chest for seafood lovers. On my first walk inside, I was met with rows of pristine, ice-packed fillets and the kind of aroma that signals real freshness. This family-owned spot handles both the market and eatery sides, a rarity in the area.
If you want to cook at home, the selection of fresh fish rivals anywhere in Hudson Valley. For a quick bite, their grilled salmon sandwich is a standout—delicate, flavorful, and a prime example of what happens when quality ingredients meet expert handling.
With staff eager to answer questions and guide you to the day’s best catch, Gadaleto’s creates an experience where quality is more than a promise—it’s standard practice.
10. Billy Joe’s Ribworks
Billy Joe’s Ribworks builds its reputation on bold flavors and a lively waterfront atmosphere. When I first visited, the riverside views and the energy of the open dining space made it feel like a break from routine. While barbecue is center stage, their seafood offerings shouldn’t be overlooked.
The highlight is the grilled shrimp platter, where the smokiness from the grill amplifies the sweetness of the shrimp. The kitchen’s use of fresh ingredients means seafood dishes hold their own, even in the company of house-smoked classics.
You can enjoy your meal outside when the weather is right, which only adds to the experience. For a night out with friends and a craving for seafood, Billy Joe’s fits the bill.
More Things to Try in Arlington, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near Arlington, NY?
Some favorites include Mariners on the Hudson, Tasty Crab House, Joe Willy S Fish, and Gadaleto’s Seafood Market. Each spot offers its own flavor and style.
Do any seafood places in Arlington offer fresh fish markets?
Yes, Gadaleto’s Seafood Market stands out for both its fresh selection and dine-in options. It’s perfect for picking up a fillet to cook at home or sitting down for a fresh meal.
Where can I find great seafood platters or boils in the area?
Tasty Crab House and Aladias Crab Cravings are well-known for their generous boils packed with crab, shrimp, and flavorful spices. Order a seafood platter for something that’s easy to share.
Are there good casual seafood spots for families?
Red Lobster and Eveready Diner are both family-friendly, with relaxed atmospheres and menus everyone can enjoy. Both offer reliable seafood options for groups of any age.
What’s a must-try seafood dish in Arlington?
The seafood boil from Tasty Crab House or the catch of the day at Mariners on the Hudson are both excellent picks. Freshness and flavor make these dishes memorable.
