The search for top-notch seafood in Bloomington, IN leads to some surprisingly impressive options. As someone who’s spent too many evenings debating menus and quietly judging every shrimp, I know a thing or two about finding that perfect, savory bite. Bloomington’s seafood scene is a mix of classic favorites, local gems, and creative surprises. The variety means you never have to settle for just one type of seafood experience.
Whether you’re on the hunt for delicate sushi, plump scallops, or skillfully grilled fish, Bloomington delivers a range of taste and texture that keeps things interesting. With a fork in one hand and curiosity in the other, I’ve explored the best spots in town so you don’t have to play culinary roulette. If you’re curious where to start, read on—your new favorite seafood dish might be waiting just up the block.
1. Red Lobster
Red Lobster sits comfortably on East 3rd Street, offering a familiar anchor for seafood lovers in Bloomington. Consistency is Red Lobster’s true charm—you always know what you’re getting, and sometimes that’s exactly what you want after a long week.
The Cheddar Bay Biscuits deserve their cult following, melting in your mouth with each bite. If you’re in the mood for a classic, the wood-grilled salmon always arrives tender and tasty. Red Lobster’s Ultimate Feast also turns an ordinary evening into something worth remembering, with fresh shrimp, snow crab legs, and succulent lobster tail sharing the spotlight.
The atmosphere is relaxed, perfect for a casual meal or group dinner. For dependable seafood staples and that unbeatable biscuit, Red Lobster continues to deliver every time.
2. No Coast Reserve
(812) 822-1341Call
No Coast Reserve brings a splash of big-city energy to the heart of downtown Bloomington. This spot excels at serving fresh seafood with a creative twist, making dinner here feel like an event rather than just a meal. My first bite of their pan-seared scallops left me wondering if I’d somehow wandered into a coastal bistro by mistake.
The daily catch is always worth exploring, with local specials that highlight the chef’s skill. I’d recommend the grilled mahi-mahi, which captures the clean, bold flavors that No Coast Reserve does best. The plating alone is enough to make your dinner feel special.
For anyone interested in inventive seafood that goes beyond the ordinary, No Coast Reserve is a standout in Bloomington’s food scene.
3. Sushi Bar
Sushi Bar has earned a loyal following near Indiana University with its laid-back vibe and reliable sushi. When I dropped in for a quick lunch, the generous portions and friendly staff made the experience feel easy and welcoming.
The spicy tuna roll is a crowd favorite, packing just enough heat and freshness in every bite. If you’re in the mood for variety, the chef’s choice nigiri puts the freshest cuts on display, highlighting their commitment to quality seafood.
Sushi Bar stands out for its affordable prices and quick service, making it the perfect go-to either for a casual bite or to satisfy a sushi craving between classes. It’s unpretentious, flavorful, and won’t empty your wallet.
4. Che Bello
Che Bello adds an Italian flourish to Bloomington’s seafood scene, right in the heart of downtown. This spot feels warm and intimate—perfect for when you want something a bit special yet relaxed. My most memorable meal here started with house-made focaccia and ended with the kind of seafood pasta that lingers in your mind for days.
The linguine with shrimp stands out for its tender shellfish and rich, garlicky sauce that’s comforting without being heavy. If you’re interested in trying something different, the grilled fish special changes often but always showcases fresh flavors and careful technique.
Che Bello’s menu makes great use of simple ingredients and bold flavors, pairing them in ways that feel both classic and inventive. It’s a satisfying stop for anyone craving Italian-style seafood in Bloomington.
5. House Of Hunan Chinese Restaurant
House Of Hunan Chinese Restaurant brings the bold flavors of Szechuan, Hunan, and Mandarin cuisine to Bloomington. This spot stands out for its generous portions, speedy service, and wide selection, making it a favorite for both dine-in and takeout. My first time there, I was hooked by the aroma of garlic and ginger as soon as I walked in the door.
The shrimp with broccoli is a solid choice, with crisp vegetables and delicately cooked shellfish in a savory sauce. If you want something spicy, the seafood delight offers a mix of scallops, shrimp, and vegetables—all balanced with just a touch of heat.
Budget-friendly and reliable, House Of Hunan is ideal for those craving satisfying Chinese seafood dishes in a casual setting.
6. Bobby’s Colorado Steak House
(812) 332-7552Call
Bobby’s Colorado Steak House is where Bloomington locals go when they want familiar comfort food with a dash of old-school charm. This spot feels equal parts steakhouse and neighborhood gathering place, perfect for unwinding after a long day. The salad bar has a reputation of its own, but it’s the seafood that deserves a closer look.
The grilled salmon is always cooked just right, flaky and never dry, with a hint of smokiness. If you’re looking for something indulgent, the shrimp scampi blends garlic and herbs over pasta for a satisfying finish. Both showcase Bobby’s commitment to quality, even in a landlocked town.
With cozy booths and live entertainment, Bobby’s is an easy choice when you’re in the mood for seafood that’s hearty and unpretentious.
7. Sweet Grass Restaurant
(812) 333-1043Call
Sweet Grass Restaurant brings a touch of comfort and Southern-inspired cooking to Bloomington’s seafood offerings. This place has an easygoing vibe, making it perfect for a laid-back meal with friends or family. I wandered in one afternoon craving something different and left with a new favorite spot.
The blackened catfish stands out—perfectly seasoned and served hot, it’s a dish that manages to be both simple and memorable. Their grilled tilapia is another highlight, offering mild, fresh flavors that pair well with their homemade sides.
Affordable prices and generous servings make Sweet Grass a popular pick for locals looking for seafood with a homestyle twist. It’s comforting, flavorful, and always reliably good.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Bloomington, IN?
Bloomington has a variety of spots. Some of the best include Red Lobster for classics, No Coast Reserve for creative dishes, Sushi Bar for affordable sushi, and Che Bello for Italian-inspired seafood.
Are there restaurants in Bloomington, IN with fresh seafood options?
Yes, No Coast Reserve is known for dishes featuring weekly fresh catches, while Che Bello and Sushi Bar offer seafood made to order, ensuring freshness every time.
Which seafood dishes should I try in Bloomington?
Popular picks include shrimp linguine at Che Bello, blackened catfish at Sweet Grass, grilled salmon at Bobby’s Colorado Steak House, spicy tuna rolls at Sushi Bar, and shrimp with broccoli at House Of Hunan.
Where can I find affordable seafood in Bloomington, IN?
Sushi Bar and House Of Hunan both offer budget-friendly seafood dishes without skimping on quality or flavor.
Are there any seafood restaurants near Indiana University?
Yes, Sushi Bar is a favorite close to campus, offering quick service and generous portions for students and locals alike.
