Seafood cravings in Brookville are more than a passing whim. If you’ve ever savored a forkful of fresh flounder by the Long Island Sound, you know the search for great seafood can turn obsessive. The good news? Brookville’s hidden kitchens and bistros never disappoint—provided you know where to look. Over the years, I’ve followed the scent of lemon and dill into bustling fish markets, elegant dining rooms, and cozy beachside shacks. Each place promised something special and, more often than not, delivered.
Finding the best seafood means knowing more than a catchy name. It’s about generous portions, vibrant flavors, attentive service, and honest freshness—no fuss, no flash, just what matters. Whether you’re after plump oysters, tender calamari, or classic grilled snapper, I’ve sorted through the options, skipped the hype, and created a shortlist. This guide isn’t just a list; it’s the distilled wisdom of countless meals and a little local obsession. Hungry? Let’s get you where you need to go.
Where to find the best seafood in Brookville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Brookville, NY:
- Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt
- Canterbury’s Oyster Bar & Grill
- Opus Steakhouse
- Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
- Atlas New World Bistro
- The Mansion at Oyster Bay
- One North Mediterranean Soul
- Yankee Lobster Inc
- Chesapeake Seafood & Crab Corp
- Taste Goodz
1. Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt
You never forget the first whiff inside Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt. There’s a clean brininess in the air—a good sign for any seafood spot. This market makes you feel like an insider, even if you’ve just wandered in for the first time.
What sets this place apart is freshness. The counters overflow with shiny eyes and firm-fleshed fish straight from the docks. I once picked out whole red snapper here and, with a few tips from the staff, turned it into a memorable family dinner.
Looking for standouts? The wild-caught flounder is a reliable choice, delicate and flaky. If you love shellfish, their littleneck clams never disappoint; steamed with herbs, they taste like summer itself.
Service is brisk but helpful. If unsure, ask—the team here knows their stuff and will steer you to the finest catch of the day.
2. Canterbury’s Oyster Bar & Grill
Walking into Canterbury’s Oyster Bar & Grill in Oyster Bay feels like joining an old friend for a meal. The atmosphere strikes a balance between lively and relaxed, with polished wood and a genuine local crowd.
What puts Canterbury’s on the map is the oyster selection. Always fresh, never muddled by unnecessary toppings, their oysters are icy and briny—perfect for purists. Last visit, I tried the classic dozen on ice; each bite tasted like a cold ocean breeze.
Don’t bypass the grilled scallops. Tender and expertly charred, they reflect the kitchen’s skill. For a heartier choice, the pan-seared fluke catches the essence of Long Island, brightened with lemon and herbs.
The staff knows both seafood and service. They’re quick to pair the right dish with your taste, making each meal here consistently memorable.
3. Opus Steakhouse
If you stroll into Opus Steakhouse expecting only steak, you’re in for a surprise. The sleek glass walls, marble fireplace, and gentle hum of conversation set the stage for meals that linger in your memory. Even the bread service feels deliberate and refined.
Opus excels at seafood with Mediterranean flair. I still remember my first bite of their grilled branzino—perfectly crisp skin, soft flakes of white fish, simply accented with olive oil and lemon. The chilled seafood platter, an impressive spread of oysters and shrimp, is an ideal starter for sharing.
If you want a main with more heft, the miso-glazed sea bass brings together sweet and savory in each smoky forkful. Even the sides, from charred vegetables to light salads, keep the focus on freshness and clean flavors.
The staff keep everything flowing smoothly, making a dinner here feel both special and easygoing. Opus proves seafood can shine in a steakhouse setting.
4. Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar is where things get rowdy—in a good way. The energy hits you as soon as you step inside, thanks to the cheerful crowd and the aroma of garlic butter wafting from every table.
This isn’t just dinner; it’s an experience. My first boil left me elbow-deep in a bag of steaming, spiced shrimp with corn and potatoes. There’s a certain joy in donning a bib and cracking open crab legs with friends or family.
The seafood boils are the main attraction. Choose your favorite shellfish, your preferred level of heat, then loosen up and let the flavors take over. Try the clams and shrimp boil, drenched in Cajun seasoning, for the most authentic taste.
Everything tastes bold and fresh, and the staff know how to keep your hands clean and your spirits high.
5. Atlas New World Bistro
Atlas New World Bistro stirs up the routine with flavors from every corner of the globe. Inside the Roslyn Hotel, the space is chic and welcoming—a spot that feels both elegant and comfortable.
What sets Atlas apart is its adventurous menu. You’ll find classic Atlantic seafood reimagined with international twists. The first time I dined here, I took a chance on the miso-glazed cod—melt-in-your-mouth tender, with gentle umami notes that lingered long after the last bite.
The seafood risotto is also a highlight. Plump shrimp and scallops soak up every bit of saffron and herb. It’s the type of dish that feels both lavish and down to earth, reflecting the bistro’s creative spirit.
Atlas delivers global flair without losing sight of quality or freshness, making it a destination for anyone bored with the usual seafood routine.
6. The Mansion at Oyster Bay
The Mansion at Oyster Bay serves old-world grandeur on a plate, surrounded by classic Gold Coast scenery. Stepping inside the estate, you feel the hush of careful detail and hospitality, with stunning views out every window.
The seafood here reflects its elegant setting. I once attended a celebration featuring their pan-seared halibut—delicate, moist, and matched perfectly by seasonal vegetables. Every element felt carefully chosen to please, without a hint of fussiness.
Their shrimp cocktail is simple but top-tier; the shrimp are plump and sweet, the sauce bold but balanced. For a special dinner, the grilled salmon is also a reliable standout—seared just right, buttery without being heavy.
The Mansion at Oyster Bay excels at atmosphere, taste, and a sense of occasion, making every seafood meal feel like a rare treat.
7. One North Mediterranean Soul
One North Mediterranean Soul lives up to its name, weaving sun-soaked flavors through its entire menu. The setting dazzles with rich wood, mosaic tile, and a din that hints at lively conversation and lingering meals.
The Mediterranean approach to seafood is front and center. My first visit brought grilled branzino—moist, perfectly salted, touched with just enough lemon and olive oil to transport you straight to the Aegean. Their seafood paella mixes tender shellfish with fragrant saffron rice, elevating each bite without overcomplicating the dish.
Starters here matter too. The octopus, charred until smoky-tender, stands out for how simply it’s treated—never chewy, just hearty and flavorful.
One North delivers seafood that’s fresh, vibrant, and full of character, perfect for anyone craving something beyond the ordinary.
8. Yankee Lobster Inc
(516) 922-5708Call
Yankee Lobster Inc is a pure seafood spot—no bells, no distractions, just robust flavors from the ocean. The aroma of fresh shellfish greets you before you even get through the door, hinting at the treasures waiting inside.
Lobster is the centerpiece here, and it’s done right. My meal of steamed lobster—cracked tableside and brimming with natural sweetness—still stands out in my memory. The lobster roll is classic, stuffed to the edges, and comes dressed only with a hint of lemon and herbs, pure and satisfying.
Their clam chowder is also worthy of attention, creamy without being heavy, each spoonful delivering a true taste of the sea.
Yankee Lobster Inc wins you over by focusing on straightforward quality, letting the seafood speak for itself every time.
9. Chesapeake Seafood & Crab Corp
(516) 681-2722Call
Chesapeake Seafood & Crab Corp thrives on bringing a straight-from-the-dock freshness to Jericho. The vibe is decidedly no-frills, letting the seafood’s quality take center stage from the moment you walk in.
The blue crabs here are legendary. I still recall a lazy weekend afternoon spent cracking open a pile of steamed blue crabs, each bite full of sweet meat and subtle brine. It’s messy in the best possible way.
If you’re not up for rolling up your sleeves, go for their shrimp cocktail—always firm, always cold, and spot-on with homemade sauce. The whole fish options rotate based on availability, but you can’t go wrong letting them recommend whatever is freshest.
Chesapeake delivers authentic seafood with an unpretentious spirit, making it a favorite for loyal regulars and newcomers alike.
10. Taste Goodz
(718) 678-7878Call
Taste Goodz is the kind of understated place you might walk past—until the scent of spiced seafood tempts you back. Tucked away in Westbury, it delivers big flavors in a low-key setting where the food does all the talking.
The menu offers a playful mix of classic and inventive seafood dishes. My first visit started with their fried fish sandwich, golden and crisp outside, each bite juicy and well-seasoned. For something a little lighter, the grilled shrimp platter hits the spot—tender, never rubbery, and finished with just enough citrus and herbs to make it pop.
Don’t let the simple setting fool you. Each dish carries care and delivers on flavor, making this a reliable option for any weeknight craving.
Taste Goodz stands out by packing quality into every order and surprising you with just how good casual seafood can be.
More Things to Try in Brookville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants are best for fresh fish in Brookville, NY?
Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt and Chesapeake Seafood & Crab Corp are top choices for the freshest catch. Their offerings come straight from local suppliers, so quality is always a safe bet.
Are there seafood spots with outdoor dining near Brookville?
Yes, several places like Sandbar and The Mansion at Oyster Bay offer lovely outdoor seating. These venues pair great food with relaxing views, especially during warmer months.
What are the most popular seafood dishes in Brookville?
Grilled branzino, lobster rolls, oysters on the half shell, and shrimp platters are local favorites. Many restaurants offer their own twists, so try a few for variety.
Are there any Mediterranean or Cajun seafood options?
One North Mediterranean Soul specializes in Mediterranean seafood, while Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar delivers satisfying Cajun boils for those who like their seafood bold and spicy.
Do Brookville seafood restaurants offer takeout or catering?
Absolutely. Most places, including Yankee Lobster Inc and Atlas New World Bistro, provide takeout. The Mansion at Oyster Bay caters for events, ensuring high-quality seafood at any gathering.
