Finding great seafood in Centereach, NY, is a little like treasure hunting. The area’s seafood spots range from easygoing clam shacks to bustling grills. Each place has its own style, and I’ve tasted my way through everything from soft-shell crab sandwiches to elegant shellfish platters. You don’t have to know the tides or the fishing boats to enjoy fantastic, fresh flavor in Centereach.
Whether you want a lobster roll that’s buttery but not too rich, or a pile of perfectly crisp fried shrimp, this list will steer you in the right direction. I’ve sifted through old favorites and hidden gems, gathering the best of the best—so you don’t have to second-guess your next bite. Go ahead and explore; you’re in good hands.
Where to find the best seafood in Centereach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Centereach, NY:
- Voodoo Crab
- White Castle
- Harbor Crab
- the main catch
- Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
- Lombardi’s on the Bay
- The Cull House
- Red Lobster
- Bonefish Grill
- The Monster Crab
1. Voodoo Crab
Voodoo Crab has a knack for seafood boils that bring people together. It’s a place where you can get hands-on, cracking open crab legs and scooping out tender meat, all in a lively setting. I’ve sat elbows-deep in sauce here more than once, surrounded by friends sharing buckets of shrimp and snow crab.
The standout dish is their signature seafood boil. It’s fully customizable, letting you pick from crab, shrimp, clams, or mussels, with bold Cajun-inspired sauces. For a local favorite, try the blue crab—sweet and rich, seasoned just right.
Portions are hearty, and everything tastes fresh. If you’re after fun and flavor without fuss, Voodoo Crab never disappoints.
2. White Castle
White Castle in Centereach is mostly famous for its sliders, but don’t overlook the seafood options tucked into their menu. I popped in during Lent once and found their Fish Sliders surprisingly satisfying. The fillets are golden, mild, and sized just right for eating with one hand.
If you’re craving something crunchy, try the Fish Nibblers. These bite-sized pieces are lightly breaded and perfect for a quick bite or sharing with friends. It’s not luxury seafood, but it’s fresh, hot, and hits the spot when you want a fast, easy meal.
Service is quick, and the atmosphere is familiar and relaxed. For casual seafood that doesn’t pretend to be anything else, White Castle has its charms.
3. Harbor Crab
Harbor Crab in Patchogue is a spot where you can loosen up and enjoy good seafood near the water. I once spent an afternoon here, watching the boats and biting into a crispy fish sandwich. The setting is upbeat, with nightly live music and plenty of energy, especially on weekends.
The coconut shrimp is a crowd favorite—plump, sweet, and just crunchy enough. Their stuffed sole is also a strong contender, showing off the kitchen’s knack for classics. For groups, the shellfish sampler brings great variety to the table.
Service is friendly and the vibe is relaxed, making it a nice spot for a laid-back meal with friends or family. If you enjoy dining dockside, it’s easy to see why Harbor Crab draws a loyal crowd.
4. the main catch
(631) 486-8864Call
The main catch in Commack feels like a celebration of Long Island’s bounty. I dropped in for lunch one rainy day, and the flavors brightened things right up. The crew here takes pride in using only top-grade seafood, and you can taste it in every bite.
The fluke is a must-try, delicate and flaky, served simply to let its freshness shine. Their oysters and clams come straight from local waters and are handled with care. For something comforting, their seafood stew delivers robust flavors and lots of variety.
The service is warm and quick, giving you the chance to relax with friends or family. For anyone searching for high-quality, local seafood, the main catch stands out with a clear focus on freshness and flavor.
5. Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant in Sayville is a spot where seafood doesn’t need fancy extras to impress. You walk in and the vibe is easygoing, with locals chatting over generous platters. I remember a family dinner here that turned into a friendly debate over who ordered the best dish.
The fried clam strips are a classic, crisp outside and tender inside. They nail simple fish dishes too—think broiled flounder that’s flaky and light. For a bit of variety, their combo platters let you mix and match shrimp, scallops, and more.
Portions are plentiful, and prices are friendly. From quick lunches to group dinners, Popeis makes it easy to enjoy seafood that’s comforting and fresh every time.
6. Lombardi’s on the Bay
Lombardi’s on the Bay offers a refined take on seafood, with sweeping water views that set the scene for something special. I once celebrated a milestone here and found it hard to decide what was better—the catch of the day or the sunset over the bay. This spot blends Italian charm with Long Island freshness in a way that feels both upscale and welcoming.
The broiled sea bass stands out for its clean flavors, while the seafood risotto brings together local shellfish and rich, creamy rice. If you’re into classics, try the linguine with clams, perfectly balanced with a garlic-white wine sauce.
Service is polished, yet never stuffy, making it easy to relax and enjoy an evening out. For a special occasion, Lombardi’s on the Bay is a taste of the good life, right by the shore.
7. The Cull House
The Cull House has a relaxed, old-school feel that makes it easy to settle in and savor good seafood. I first stopped here on a rainy evening and was drawn in by the cozy, nautical vibe and the steady hum of conversation from regulars. This place has earned its reputation for reliable quality and generous portions.
The calamari is cooked just right, crisp and tender without being greasy. Their broiled cod is another winner, offering a clean, mild flavor that speaks to their focus on fresh ingredients. For something with a little zing, try the shrimp scampi, served in a garlicky sauce over pasta.
Service is attentive without rushing you. The Cull House is where you go for that local touch—steady, classic, and always satisfying.
8. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Ronkonkoma delivers exactly what you’d expect: classic seafood amid a laid-back, family-friendly setting. I’ve found myself here more than once after a busy week, lured in by the promise of warm Cheddar Bay Biscuits and a solid seafood fix. There’s a sense of familiarity that keeps regulars coming back.
The Ultimate Feast is a star, stacking lobster, shrimp, and scallops onto one generous platter. The wood-grilled salmon is another good pick, flaky and well seasoned, highlighting Red Lobster’s knack for reliable favorites.
Staff is attentive, quick with a refill and always ready with a smile. If you want consistency and a little indulgence, Red Lobster checks every box.
9. Bonefish Grill
(631) 724-4012Call
Bonefish Grill at Smith Haven Mall plays up the idea that seafood can be both inventive and approachable. I’ve popped in after shopping sprees and always found their menu offers something a little different from your usual chain experience. The vibe is stylish but not stiff, letting you relax and focus on the food.
The Bang Bang Shrimp has a cult following—crispy, spicy, and just a bit tangy, it’s easy to see why. For a main, the grilled sea bass stands out for its gentle seasoning and perfect, flaky texture. Their fish is always fresh, and the kitchen doesn’t overdo it with heavy sauces.
Service is smooth and unrushed, making it easy to linger over dinner. For fun, flavorful seafood in Centereach, Bonefish Grill is tough to beat.
10. The Monster Crab
The Monster Crab is all about hearty portions and a no-nonsense approach to seafood boils. My first trip there was a messy, laughter-filled dinner—with everyone tucking into piles of shellfish, sleeves rolled up, conversation punctuated by the sound of cracking shells. It’s a spot where flavors come bold, not subtle.
The Cajun seafood boil is a signature move, allowing you to customize with blue crab, shrimp, or snow crab, all drenched in your choice of sauces. The garlic butter and spicy options shine brightest, coating each piece with satisfying flavor.
It’s lively, casual, and perfect for group outings. If you love digging in with both hands and walking away full, The Monster Crab has you covered.
More Things to Try in Centereach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants are closest to Centereach, NY?
Top picks include Voodoo Crab, Bonefish Grill, and Claws Seafood Inc, each within a short drive. These spots cover everything from classic fried fish to Cajun boils.
Are there seafood restaurants in Centereach that offer takeout?
Yes, most local seafood restaurants like Voodoo Crab and Island Fish offer takeout options, so you can enjoy fresh catches at home.
Where can I find fresh, locally-sourced seafood in Centereach?
The main catch and Fresh Catch Market & Grill are favorites for locally-sourced seafood. They focus on quality and seasonal selections from Long Island waters.
Which seafood spots are good for groups or families?
Harbor Crab, The Monster Crab, and Red Lobster are all known for relaxed vibes and generous seating, making them good choices for group meals.
Can I find seafood restaurants with waterfront views near Centereach?
Lombardi’s on the Bay and The Cull House both feature waterfront dining nearby, pairing scenic vistas with impressive seafood menus.
Are there budget-friendly seafood restaurants in the Centereach area?
For value, White Castle offers affordable seafood options, while Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant is known for generous portions at fair prices.
