Exploring the best seafood options in Charlottesville, VA reveals a surprisingly vibrant culinary scene that rivals larger coastal cities. My own adventures in this charming town have introduced me to a variety of eateries, each offering a unique take on marine fare. From fresh oysters shucked right at the bar to perfectly grilled fish with local twists, Charlottesville proves that good seafood isn’t limited to seaside locales.
Whether you’re a lifelong lover of crustaceans or just eager to try something new, this guide is crafted to help you navigate the most reputable spots. Rest assured, each venue has been chosen for its commitment to quality, freshness, and authenticity—culinary standards that will elevate your dining experience. Prepare to discover rich flavors and expertly prepared dishes that will satisfy even the most discerning seafood aficionados.
Where to find the best seafood in Charlottesville, VA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Charlottesville, VA:
- Public Fish and Oyster
- Bonefish Grill
- Poke Sushi Bowl
- Siren Restaurant And Brewery, Llc
- Skrimp Shack
- Mariscos El Barco
- Southern Crescent Galley & Bar
- Outer Banks Boil Company Charlottesville
- Birch & Bloom
- Aberdeen Barn
1. Public Fish and Oyster
Situated on West Main Street, Public Fish and Oyster offers an authentic taste of New England-style seafood right in Charlottesville. I was impressed by their dedication to fresh ingredients and warm hospitality, making each visit feel like a coastal escape. The inviting atmosphere and attentive service create a perfect backdrop for enjoying quality seafood.
What truly sets Public Fish and Oyster apart is their diverse raw bar selection and thoughtfully curated dishes. The Oyster Tasting is a must-try for seafood lovers, showcasing locally sourced, briny oysters that highlight regional freshness. For a hearty option, the Seafood Platter combines an array of shrimp, mussels, and fish—each cooked to perfection. These dishes perfectly reflect the restaurant’s commitment to quality and authenticity.
2. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill in Charlottesville, VA, is a seafood lover’s paradise nestled in Hollymead Town Center. Known for its hand-cut, wood-grilled specialties, the restaurant delivers a fresh, flavorful dining experience with its commitment to quality ingredients and innovative culinary techniques.
What makes Bonefish Grill truly stand out is its focus on pairing fresh seafood with expertly crafted flavors. The menu features a variety of gluten-free and vegetarian-friendly options, ensuring there’s something for everyone. Their signature cocktails, made with just-squeezed juices and house infusions, perfectly complement the dishes, elevating your dining experience to new heights.
A must-try is the Chilean Sea Bass, celebrated for its buttery richness and delicate texture, or the Bang Bang Shrimp, a crowd favorite with a bold, tangy twist. Pair these with their distinctive wine selection for the ultimate meal.
Whether you’re here for lunch, dinner, or a late-night bite, Bonefish Grill brings a touch of elegance to seafood dining in Charlottesville. Its inviting ambiance and attention to detail make every visit special.
3. Poke Sushi Bowl
Poke Sushi Bowl brings a refreshing twist to seafood dining in Charlottesville, inspired by Hawaiian traditions and a focus on clean, healthy eating. Stepping into the Emmet Street location feels like entering a space where flavor meets nutrition without compromise. I recall customizing my own bowl and being struck by how every element—from the protein to the sauces—tasted vibrant and fresh.
What makes this spot stand out is its build-your-own poke concept, putting you in control while they deliver high-quality, organic and gluten-free sauces and unbelievably fresh fish. This combination sets Poke Sushi Bowl apart from more conventional seafood restaurants. It’s ideal for anyone who craves variety and cleaner ingredients without sacrificing taste.
Go for the Tuna Poke Bowl with seaweed salad, edamame, and a splash of their homemade shoyu sauce. It’s light, flavorful, and an excellent representation of their commitment to fresh, thoughtful seafood that supports a healthy lifestyle.
4. Siren Restaurant And Brewery, Llc
Siren Restaurant And Brewery offers a unique blend of Mediterranean and American seafood cuisine right in Charlottesville. Located on Ridge McIntire Road, the restaurant combines a relaxed atmosphere with well-crafted dishes that highlight fresh ingredients. My visit left me impressed by their flavor-rich offerings and warm service.
What sets Siren apart is its ability to deliver both classic seafood favorites and Mediterranean-inspired dishes. The Seafood Paella is a standout, showcasing a vibrant mix of fresh shellfish and perfectly seasoned rice that reflects their commitment to quality. Their grilled fish fillets are also noteworthy, cooked simply to let the freshness shine.
If you’re seeking a memorable seafood experience in Charlottesville, Siren’s diverse menu and inviting ambiance make it a top choice for a satisfying dinner.
5. Skrimp Shack
Skrimp Shack is a casual and lively spot known for its flavorful seafood in Charlottesville. Located at Rio Hill Center, it offers a laid-back environment perfect for enjoying a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. My experience here was memorable thanks to the friendly staff and bold, fresh flavors.
What makes Skrimp Shack stand out is its focus on crustacean and seafood specialties prepared with genuine Southern flair. Their Boil Bags are a signature, packed with perfectly seasoned shrimp, crab, and oysters. For a satisfying meal, the Seafood Basket provides a variety of fried favorites that showcase their commitment to quality and flavor.
If you’re craving authentic, hearty seafood in Charlottesville, Skrimp Shack’s vibrant dishes and casual vibe make it an excellent choice.
6. Mariscos El Barco
Mariscos El Barco on West Main Street offers a vibrant mix of Mexican and seafood cuisine in Charlottesville. The lively atmosphere and authentic flavors make it a favorite for those seeking bold, fresh dishes. During my visit, the combination of seasoned seafood and traditional Mexican elements created a memorable dining experience.
What makes Mariscos El Barco stand out is its dedication to quality seafood paired with authentic spices. The Ceviche is a must-try, bursting with fresh citrus and flavorful fish, perfectly reflecting their focus on freshness. The seafood tacos are also highly recommended for their vibrant flavors and generous portions.
For anyone craving authentic, high-quality seafood with a Mexican twist, Mariscos El Barco delivers a lively, flavorful experience that satisfies every time.
7. Southern Crescent Galley & Bar
Southern Crescent Galley & Bar, located at 814 Hinton Ave, Charlottesville, VA, offers a delightful dining experience with a focus on vegetarian-friendly options and seafood. The atmosphere is inviting, perfect for a relaxed lunch or dinner with table service and takeout available.
What sets Southern Crescent apart is its commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients and a menu that reflects the rich culinary traditions of the South. The seafood dishes are particularly noteworthy, showcasing the chef’s expertise and creativity.
For an exceptional meal, try the Shrimp and Grits, a Southern classic with a twist, or the Blackened Catfish, which perfectly captures the essence of Southern flavors. These dishes highlight the restaurant’s dedication to authentic, flavorful cuisine.
Visit their website at thesoutherncrescent.com or call +1 434-284-5101 for more information.
8. Outer Banks Boil Company Charlottesville
Outer Banks Boil Company in Charlottesville offers a casual and interactive seafood experience rooted in traditional coastal shrimp boils. Located at 722 W Rio Rd, this family-owned spot allows diners to customize their pots with fresh seafood options like crab legs, mussels, and scallops. My visit was memorable because of their vibrant, communal atmosphere and the freshness of their seafood.
What sets Outer Banks Boil Company apart is its flexible menu, emphasizing high-quality, flavorful seafood prepared just the way you like it. The Shrimp Boil is a standout — seasoned perfectly and served with their signature spices, capturing the essence of coastal cooking. The ability to select your seafood makes every experience personalized and satisfying.
If you enjoy seafood with a fun, hands-on twist, this spot offers an authentic taste of the coast, right here in Charlottesville.
9. Birch & Bloom
Birch & Bloom in Charlottesville is a welcoming gathering spot that highlights the region’s farm-to-table philosophy. Located at 540 Massie Road, it offers a menu rooted in locally sourced, seasonal ingredients for both breakfast and dinner. My experience here was delightful, with dishes that balanced comfort and sophistication.
What makes Birch & Bloom stand out is its dedication to sustainable ingredients and bold flavors. The Seafood Tartare is a highlight, demonstrating fresh, quality fish prepared with inventive twists that reflect their focus on local, sustainable ingredients. Their Grilled Fish also showcases simple, expertly executed seafood dining.
If you value fresh, regional flavors served in an inviting setting, Birch & Bloom offers a memorable experience embracing the best of Charlottesville’s culinary scene.
10. Aberdeen Barn
Aberdeen Barn has been a Charlottesville staple since 1965, known for its classic steakhouse charm and consistent quality. Tucked away on Holiday Drive, it’s the kind of place where the wood-paneled walls and attentive service set the tone for a relaxed, satisfying meal.
While steaks are the main draw, the seafood offerings deserve equal attention. I tried the Broiled Sea Scallops, which arrived perfectly tender, bathed in herb butter and white wine. The Maryland Style Crab Cakes were another standout—crispy on the outside, rich and flavorful inside, with no filler in sight.
What sets Aberdeen Barn apart is its commitment to tradition without feeling dated. If you’re after seafood that’s thoughtfully prepared in a warm, familiar setting, this spot delivers.
More Things to Try in Charlottesville, VA
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Where can I find the best seafood in Charlottesville, VA?
You can enjoy fresh, halal-friendly seafood at local favorites like Public Fish & Oyster, known for its oysters and sustainable fish options. Burtons Grill & Bar also offers a variety of seafood dishes in a modern setting, with some halal-conscious choices — just ask your server for details.
2. Are there halal seafood options in Charlottesville?
Yes! Seafood is generally considered halal as long as it’s not cross-contaminated with haram items. Restaurants like Milan Indian Cuisine and A Taste of Home Southern Cuisine offer seafood dishes that align more closely with halal dietary needs. Always confirm with staff to ensure preparation meets your requirements.
3. What types of seafood are popular in Charlottesville?
Popular dishes include grilled salmon, shrimp platters, crab cakes, and fresh oysters. Many places also offer seafood pasta and fish tacos, which are local favorites.
4. Are there any seafood restaurants near the University of Virginia?
Yes! Public Fish & Oyster is located close to the university and is a go-to spot for seafood lovers. Another option is Bonefish Grill, offering a variety of seafood dishes in a relaxed atmosphere.
5. Do seafood restaurants in Charlottesville offer takeout or delivery?
Most seafood spots, including Public Fish & Oyster and Bonefish Grill, offer takeout and delivery. You can order through platforms like DoorDash, Grubhub, or directly from the restaurant’s website.
6. Is the seafood in Charlottesville locally sourced?
Many restaurants aim to use fresh, sustainable, and locally sourced seafood when possible. Public Fish & Oyster is especially known for its commitment to sustainable seafood practices.
7. Are there seafood options for people avoiding alcohol in food?
Absolutely. While some dishes may include wine-based sauces, most restaurants are happy to customize your meal upon request. Simply ask for dishes without alcohol-based ingredients.
8. What’s the best time to enjoy fresh seafood in Charlottesville?
Seafood is available year-round, but for the freshest options, try visiting in the spring and summer months, when seafood deliveries are more frequent and outdoor dining is popular.