Cleveland’s waterfront breeze may tempt anyone to crave seafood, but knowing where to find the city’s finest catches can feel tricky. Whether you’re after freshly shucked oysters, sizzling grilled fish, or something a bit more creative, this city serves up flavors as diverse as its neighborhoods. Cleveland’s seafood spots range from polished downtown grills to eclectic local haunts, and finding that perfect plate is half the adventure.
I’ve spent more evenings than I care to count chasing the subtle snap of a well-cooked scallop or the clean brine of a just-opened clam from Lake Erie to the Cuyahoga. The quest: find seafood that’s as memorable as the skyline after sunset. In this guide, you’ll find the places locals whisper about and newcomers return to. Ready to discover the standout seafood joints Cleveland has to offer? Let’s dive in.
Where to find the best seafood in Cleveland, OH
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Cleveland, OH:
- Blue Point Grille
- Marble Room Steaks and Raw Bar
- Alley Cat Oyster Bar
- Mallorca
- The Bourbon Street Barrel Room
- Don’s Lighthouse
- Nauti Mermaid
- Lindey’s Lake House
- Tomo Hibachi and Sushi
1. Blue Point Grille
Blue Point Grille knows how to make an impression. The giant windows cast the downtown skyline in a way that’s almost as striking as the seafood on your plate. I remember the first time I tried their Blue Point oysters—icy cold, impossibly fresh, and the sort of bite that makes you pause before the next.
This spot doesn’t coast on reputation alone. Signature items like the Nag’s Head Grouper deliver a clean, flaky tenderness that never disappoints. The lobster bisque is a classic starter with a creamy depth that hints at old-school luxury.
Freshness drives the menu here, and their sourcing is second to none in Cleveland. For a true taste, the oysters or grouper are where Blue Point’s skill shines brightest.
2. Marble Room Steaks and Raw Bar
Marble Room Steaks and Raw Bar is where old-world glamour meets contemporary style. The setting—a grand, restored bank—sets the tone for a dining experience that feels extraordinary from the moment you walk in. My first visit, the chandeliers almost stole my attention, but the seafood quickly became the main event.
The raw bar here is a mosaic of shimmering oysters, pristine shrimp, and delicate crudo. Sampling the seafood tower is like touring the best waters in a single sitting. Each shell and slice shows the kitchen’s careful sourcing and preparation.
Their sushi rolls are also a standout, proving that the Marble Room doesn’t just serve seafood—it celebrates it. For a memorable meal, start at the raw bar then follow with a classic sushi roll.
3. Alley Cat Oyster Bar
Alley Cat Oyster Bar sits perched on the water in The Flats, offering sweeping river views and a lively vibe. I still remember one Saturday afternoon, watching boats glide past while the sun hit a tray of oysters just right. The seafood here tastes as fresh as the breeze off the water.
Oysters are the star, every shell arriving cold and bright with a subtle brininess that keeps you reaching for one more. The shrimp cocktail stands out, and their Lake Erie walleye sandwich is a nod to Cleveland tradition—lightly battered, crisp, and flaky.
This is a spot that takes simple seafood seriously. Whether you’re after a casual meal or a sunset dinner, Alley Cat makes it easy to linger a bit longer.
4. Mallorca
Mallorca feels like an instant ticket to the Mediterranean, right in downtown Cleveland. The rich aroma of olive oil and garlic always hits as you walk in, setting the stage for something special. My first paella here was a revelation—brimming with sweet, plump shrimp and tender fish, each grain of rice soaked with saffron.
The seafood paella truly shines, showcasing the chef’s flair for Spanish classics. If you want another taste of the sea, go for the grilled fish of the day, expertly prepared and presented with subtle flavors. The dining room buzzes with the gentle comfort of hospitality perfected across generations.
Mallorca excels at balancing bold Mediterranean flavors with local seafood. For anyone craving warmth, generosity, and a plate full of the ocean’s best, this spot delivers.
5. The Bourbon Street Barrel Room
The Bourbon Street Barrel Room brings the energy of New Orleans right into Cleveland’s Tremont neighborhood. The split-level space always buzzes, and I still remember walking in on a Sunday—the live band, conversation, and faint spice in the air blend into something lively.
The seafood gumbo here is packed with layers of heat and depth. You get shrimp, delicate fish, and okra in a broth that’s smoky and rich, finished with perfectly cooked rice. Seafood fans should also try the crawfish étouffée, with its savory, peppery sauce and tender crawfish tail meat.
This is the spot for anyone craving Southern comfort with a seafood twist. Each dish has the kind of soul that can only come from a chef who knows his roots.
6. Don’s Lighthouse
Don’s Lighthouse pairs Cleveland’s vintage charm with panoramic views of Lake Erie. I once went after a storm, and the sky cleared just in time to spotlight a table by the window—it’s the kind of setting that heightens every bite.
The broiled Lake Erie walleye defines Great Lakes seafood tradition, arriving moist, flaky, and minimally dressed to let the fresh fish shine. Their crab-stuffed shrimp is another standout, packing impressive flavor into each bite.
Don’s reputation for quality is built on consistency and care with local catch. Whether it’s a quiet lunch or a celebratory dinner, there’s always something impressive on the menu for seafood lovers.
7. Nauti Mermaid
Nauti Mermaid is where Cleveland’s casual side meets coastal comfort. The quirky, nautical-themed interior has a laid-back vibe that makes you feel far from the city’s hustle. I discovered it on a rainy afternoon and ended up staying for hours, drawn in by both the cozy atmosphere and the menu.
The blackened fish tacos are a crowd favorite, served with fresh toppings and just the right kick. Their clam chowder is creamy but never heavy, packed with tender clams and a subtle smokiness that lingers pleasantly.
Nauti Mermaid proves seafood doesn’t need formality to impress. It’s a go-to for satisfying, well-executed dishes and an atmosphere that turns an ordinary meal into an outing to remember.
8. Lindey’s Lake House
Lindey’s Lake House brings a breezy lakeside vibe right to the heart of the Flats. The first time I sat out on their patio, it was clear this was the kind of place where food and setting work together—sunlight, river views, and a relaxed crowd add up to easy enjoyment.
The Firecracker shrimp is a must, tossed in a spicy sauce that’s bold without overwhelming the delicate seafood. For something with a local twist, the grilled fish tacos offer crisp textures and dynamic flavors that keep every bite interesting.
At Lindey’s, shareable plates and laid-back fun are as much a draw as the menu. It’s perfect for anyone after simple, well-crafted seafood with waterfront flair.
9. Tomo Hibachi and Sushi
Tomo Hibachi and Sushi brings a flash of modern Japan to Cleveland’s Warehouse District. The interior feels sleek but warm, with sizzling hibachi tables on one side and artful sushi rolls on the other. Watching chefs at work—knives flickering, flames rising—was as memorable as the dishes themselves.
The sushi menu is where Tomo shines, with melt-in-your-mouth salmon and crisp, perfectly rolled maki. If you’re after a real show, choose the hibachi-grilled shrimp—tender and seared with expert timing right in front of you.
The fusion of fresh ingredients and skilled preparation makes Tomo a favorite for seafood fans. Whether you’re seated at the sushi bar or drawn into the hibachi spectacle, it’s always a feast for the senses.
More Things to Try in Cleveland, OH
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood is Cleveland known for?
Cleveland highlights fresh catches from Lake Erie, such as walleye and perch. Many restaurants also feature oysters, shrimp, and seasonal specials sourced from both coasts.
Are there any halal-friendly seafood restaurants in Cleveland?
Several seafood restaurants offer halal-friendly options, with menus focused on fish, shellfish, and vegetarian fare. It’s best to call ahead for details about preparation and ingredients.
Where can I find waterfront seafood dining?
Places like Alley Cat Oyster Bar and Lindey’s Lake House offer riverfront and lakeside seating, pairing fresh seafood with great views of Cleveland’s waterfront.
What are the best seafood dishes to try in Cleveland?
Signature picks include Lake Erie walleye, oysters on the half shell, seafood paella, and creative sushi rolls at local favorites.
Do seafood restaurants in Cleveland have vegetarian or gluten-free options?
Most spots feature vegetarian and gluten-free choices, from salads to thoughtfully prepared vegetable and grain dishes.