Seafood in Colorado Springs was once a punchline, reserved for the brave or slightly reckless. But lately, finding stellar seafood here is less about boldness and more about insider knowledge. From buttery lobster tails to spicy Cajun shrimp, the city’s best kitchens are upping their game and coaxing flavors out of the Rockies you might not expect.
My earliest foray into Colorado Springs’ seafood scene involved a plate of grilled salmon that changed my view entirely. It was simple, fresh, and tasted as if someone’s coastal grandmother had just passed down her secret recipe. If you’ve ever wondered how a landlocked city can serve up such impressive seafood, you’re in for a treat. This guide serves the details hot and fresh, so keep reading to find your next favorite spot.
Where to find the best seafood in Colorado Springs, CO
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Colorado Springs, CO:
- Carlos Bistro
- Bonny And Read
- Bonefish Grill
- Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar
- Red Lobster
- Red Lobster
- Luchals
- Captain D’s
- The Juicy Seafood
- Captain D’s
1. Carlos Bistro
Carlos Bistro feels like a secret gem, quietly tucked away with mountain views that almost steal the show. The warm greeting from Carlos himself is more than just hospitality—it sets the tone for a relaxed, elegant meal. The seafood selection is where the magic happens. I still remember a plate of Chilean sea bass, perfectly crisp on the outside, buttery inside—easily the most memorable fish I’ve tasted in Colorado Springs.
Order the pan-seared sea bass or the chef’s daily seafood special for a taste of their philosophy: let quality ingredients shine. Attention to detail and balanced flavors come through in every bite. Dining here blurs the line between a special occasion and a weeknight treat—a rare trick in any city.
2. Bonny And Read
+17198964145
See Menu
Bonny And Read takes seafood seriously, giving Colorado Springs a true taste of the coast. Walk in, and you’ll notice the nautical décor and lively atmosphere—a rare blend that feels both upscale and comfortable. During my last visit, the staff answered every question about their catch, underscoring how much pride they take in their menu.
The oysters on the half shell deserve early mention, fresh and briny, transported straight from the coast. If you want something richer, try the pan-roasted halibut, paired thoughtfully with seasonal vegetables. Each dish lands on the table with clear attention to detail and freshness.
For anyone craving quality seafood in Colorado Springs, Bonny And Read invites you to sit, savor, and linger a little longer than planned. It’s that convincing.
3. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill manages to pack a coastal punch, even in a shopping center setting. There’s a comforting hum of conversation inside, and the scent of wood-grilled seafood draws you in. My first taste of their Bang Bang Shrimp was a revelation—crispy, just spicy enough, and surprisingly light.
If you’re after elegance, the grilled rainbow trout is a standout, kissed by open flames and perfect for a simple night out. The staff are quick with pairing suggestions, and the menu leans into freshness rather than fuss.
Bonefish Grill proves that consistency and care matter. For anyone searching for reliable seafood in Colorado Springs with a side of warm service, this spot delivers every time.
4. Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar
Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar sets the bar high, both for freshness and for a laid-back, lively vibe. Stepping in, you’re greeted with an open kitchen and the kind of laughter that comes from tables sharing seafood platters. My last dinner here began with their raw oyster sampler—each one cold, sweet, and impossibly fresh for Colorado.
The menu leans into bold flavors. The blackened catfish brings just the right amount of spice, and the crab legs are tender and perfectly sweet. It’s a place that makes seafood an experience, not just a meal.
For diners with a passion for sustainability and serious flavor, Jax Fish House fits the bill with style and substance.
5. Red Lobster
Red Lobster fills with the welcome scent of butter and the gentle clink of plates piled high with seafood. It’s a familiar stop in Colorado Springs for classic favorites that never try to be anything but satisfying. My go-to here? The grilled salmon—smoky, moist, and plated with fresh sides.
The shrimp scampi is another winner, tossed in garlic and olive oil, delivering comfort in every bite. Red Lobster’s Endless Shrimp is hard to resist, perfect for those who like to switch up flavors from plate to plate.
If you crave a casual, unstuffy seafood experience that covers all the bases, Red Lobster knows exactly how to deliver. Sometimes a classic is just what the night calls for.
6. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on N Academy Blvd delivers that same easygoing charm the brand is known for, but with a dash of local hospitality. Whether it’s a family get-together or a low-key weeknight treat, you’ll find the atmosphere comfortably familiar. My last visit included the grilled tilapia, which was flaky, mild, and paired well with simple sides.
Seafood classics here are as reliable as ever. The wood-grilled shrimp skewers offer a smoky flavor and a generous portion perfect for sharing or keeping all to yourself. Their menu is designed to please those with a taste for straightforward, well-prepared plates.
For seafood in Colorado Springs that goes down easy—no fuss, just flavor—this Red Lobster location is a safe bet.
7. Luchals
Luchals brings real soul to the heart of Colorado Springs, serving up family-style portions and a sense of neighborhood comfort you don’t always find downtown. Here, seafood feels generous and unpretentious, perfect for sharing over laughs and late-night stories. Last time, I dove into their catfish platter—crispy on the outside and tender inside, classic but never dull.
If you’re in the mood for something lighter, the grilled salmon is simple, flaky, and lets the main ingredient shine. Sides here are just as hearty, rounding out each meal with a southern touch.
For anyone chasing that home-cooked vibe with their seafood in Colorado Springs, Luchals makes every plate feel personal.
8. Captain D’s
Captain D’s is a no-nonsense spot for fast, flavorful seafood that doesn’t skimp on comfort. Walk in, and you’re greeted by the familiar aroma of battered fish and warm hush puppies. My usual order is the grilled white fish platter, which hits the spot with its clean flavor and flaky texture.
The fried shrimp is another highlight—crispy, satisfying, and served up quickly, perfect for a lunch break or casual dinner. Their sides, from seasoned rice to green beans, help round out the meal.
Captain D’s stands out for approachable seafood in Colorado Springs that works when you’re craving something relaxed, affordable, and reliably tasty.
9. The Juicy Seafood
The Juicy Seafood delivers a true hands-on dining experience in Colorado Springs, perfect for anyone who likes to get a little messy with their meal. There’s a buzz every night, with tables spread out under piles of napkins and plastic bibs. My first boil bag here was a revelation—sweet snow crab legs, juicy shrimp, and hearty corn all tossed in their signature seasoning.
The seafood boil is the star—pick your favorites, choose your spice level, and dig in. The freshness holds up, and the flavors are as bold as you want them to be. Sides like potatoes and corn round out the feast.
If you’re chasing a lively, communal seafood spot, this is where to settle in and crack some shells.
10. Captain D’s
Captain D’s at Integrity Center Point keeps things simple and satisfying, making good seafood accessible for every appetite. Every visit feels easy—no fancy rituals, just friendly service and hot plates arriving fast. My pick here is the battered fish tenders; crispy but never greasy, paired with classic sides for a familiar comfort.
The butterfly shrimp also stands out for its crunch and sweet flavor, always consistent and perfect with a house-made dipping sauce. Their seafood is reliably fresh for a quick meal or takeout run.
For anyone craving hassle-free seafood in Colorado Springs, Captain D’s covers weekday lunches, family dinners, and anytime you want something straightforward but tasty.
More Things to Try in Colorado Springs, CO
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants in Colorado Springs are known for fresh catches?
Jax Fish House & Oyster Bar and Bonny And Read are both praised for flying in fresh seafood daily, offering options that rival coastal cities. These spots highlight quality and robust flavor.
Are there halal or pescatarian-friendly seafood options in Colorado Springs?
Most local seafood restaurants offer pescatarian meals, and many clearly label their menu. While halal-certified seafood is rare, grilling and pan-searing are common prep methods to request if you want a clean option.
Which places have gluten-free or vegan seafood choices?
Carlos Bistro, Bonefish Grill, and Bonny And Read offer gluten-free and vegan options. Servers are usually happy to recommend safe selections if you mention your preferences.
Can I find casual seafood in Colorado Springs?
Casual, family-friendly picks include Captain D’s, The Juicy Seafood, and Red Lobster. Relaxed settings and approachable prices make them popular for quick bites or group outings.
What should I try for a unique seafood experience in Colorado Springs?
Order an oyster sampler at Jax Fish House or a custom seafood boil at The Juicy Seafood. These dishes bring a sense of adventure, letting you taste a range of flavors in one sitting.