Choosing seafood in East Hills, NY can feel like a treasure hunt—minus the soggy map. This part of Long Island is a magnet for those who crave the briny freshness of the ocean without the fuss. I’ll admit, I was once someone who eyed any seafood that wasn’t fried with suspicion. But after sampling my way through countless crab cakes, grilled fillets, and buttery shellfish in the East Hills area, I found myself converted.
You’re not looking for the ordinary. You want where the locals go, the hidden stars, the fresh catches and the places that balance atmosphere and flavor. I’ve sifted through every rumor, quizzed every fishmonger, and even braved a “mystery special” or two to bring you real options—no bland platters, just honest recommendations. If your cravings steer you toward the ocean side of the menu, you’re right where you should be. Dive in.
Where to find the best seafood in East Hills, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in East Hills, NY:
- Atlas New World Bistro
- Roslyn Seafood Gourmet
- Singleton Seafood Shack
- Carlyle Seafood Shack
- Vincents Clam Bar
- Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt
- Reede Intl Seafood Corp
- Taste Goodz
- Gera’s Cakes
- Joe’s Crab Shack
1. Atlas New World Bistro
Atlas New World Bistro delivers more than just a meal—it’s a passport to global flavors and a sanctuary for seafood lovers in East Hills. Tucked inside the historic Roslyn Hotel, this spot exudes style with its sleek design and a mesmerizing back-lit onyx bar. The menu fuses international inspirations with the freshness you want from great seafood.
The charred octopus stands out, tender and expertly seasoned, hinting at both Mediterranean finesse and local pride. The seared scallops are another favorite—sweet, juicy, and plated with thoughtful artistry. I once lingered over the branzino, crisp-skinned and flaky, thinking that this is what coastal dining is meant to be.
Service is polished without being stiff, making Atlas ideal for a relaxed evening or an impressive date night. For anyone looking to widen their seafood horizons without leaving East Hills, Atlas feels like a world-class find.
2. Roslyn Seafood Gourmet
(516) 484-7944Call
Roslyn Seafood Gourmet keeps things refreshingly simple and honest. The market doubles as a restaurant, so the seafood on your plate is as fresh as the catch arrives. One visit, I watched a chef filet a glistening fillet right behind the counter—minutes later, it was on my plate, still shimmering with flavor.
This spot is known for its expertly grilled salmon and buttery lobster tails. Both deliver pure, clean flavors without unnecessary fuss. Order the herb-crusted flounder if you’re after something light yet satisfying; it melts in your mouth and pairs well with their simple slaw.
Easy curbside pickup and no-contact delivery show they value their customers’ comfort. Roslyn Seafood Gourmet is for those who believe the best seafood needs little adornment—just a skillful touch and great ingredients.
3. Singleton Seafood Shack
(516) 609-0300Call
Singleton Seafood Shack feels like the place you stumble on by accident and never forget. It sits snug along Shore Road, echoing the laid-back charm of an old-school fish shack, but with kitchen skills that say otherwise. On a breezy evening, the salty air mixed with the crackle of fresh fish on the grill made this spot feel like a quick escape to the shore.
Their grilled shrimp skewers are a standout—they’re smoky, juicy, and served with a squeeze of lemon for that sunny punch. Singleton’s clam chowder is velvety and packed with flavor, without being heavy. If you’re feeling indulgent, the broiled cod brings out what local fish can be at its best.
There’s nothing fancy about Singleton, which is exactly why regulars come back. Here, you taste the sea in every bite—simple, satisfying, and always fresh.
4. Carlyle Seafood Shack
(516) 399-2207Call
Carlyle Seafood Shack turns a casual meal into something memorable. Just a short drive from East Hills, it feels like a well-kept secret on Prospect Avenue. I remember settling in on their patio, sun dropping low, and the sound of laughter mixing with the aroma of grilled seafood. It’s the kind of place locals whisper about to friends who actually care about what’s on their plate.
The crab-stuffed flounder is a must-try—delicate, rich, and brimming with sweet, fresh flavors. For a lighter touch, the grilled branzino comes out perfectly tender with crispy skin that crackles under your fork. If you’re into sides, their seasonal veggies complement the seafood without competing for attention.
Everything feels hand-crafted, from their sauces to the friendly, easy atmosphere. Carlyle makes a case for skipping the frills and focusing on what tastes right out of the sea—every single time.
5. Vincents Clam Bar
(516) 279-4477Call
Vincents Clam Bar brings a bustling, old-school energy to the seafood scene near East Hills. The aroma from the kitchen always reminds me of family gatherings—big tables, plenty of laughter, and dishes meant for passing around. Vincents has a knack for making everyone feel like a regular, even on your first visit.
The linguine with white clam sauce is the classic you shouldn’t skip—briny, garlicky, with just enough bite in the pasta to let every clam shine. If you’re in the mood for something lighter, the broiled salmon arrives perfectly cooked with a touch of citrus. The calamari is crisp and tender, no rubbery rings in sight.
Service is quick and friendly, fitting the lively vibe. For tradition done right and flavors built on fresh seafood, Vincents is a local staple that always delivers.
6. Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt
Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt is where true seafood fans shop when they want freshness without fuss. Walking in feels more like a bustling market on the docks than a typical restaurant. I once watched a regular haggle good-naturedly with the staff over a particularly beautiful fillet of snapper—proof that quality draws a loyal crowd.
The grilled whole fish is a standout here—simple, expertly seasoned, and served up with all its natural juices locked in. You can also pick up their jumbo shrimp or shell-on clams to cook at home, which is perfect if you love experimenting with fresh ingredients.
Prices stay reasonable and the selection always impresses. For East Hills foodies who like to know exactly where their seafood comes from, this market delivers authenticity and taste in every bite.
7. Reede Intl Seafood Corp
(516) 365-0265Call
Reede Intl Seafood Corp is one of those under-the-radar gems where the focus is all on the seafood. The setup isn’t fancy, but the freshness is unmistakable. The first time I dropped by, the counter buzzed with regulars swapping tips about the day’s best catch—a sure sign you’ve stumbled onto a local favorite.
Their striped bass is exceptional—firm, flaky, and full of clean ocean flavor. If you’re into shellfish, pick up their live clams or mussels and bring a taste of the sea straight to your own table.
Everything is cash-only, but prices and portions make the extra stop at the ATM more than worth it. Reede Intl is for those who appreciate simplicity and quality in every bite.
8. Taste Goodz
(718) 678-7878Call
Taste Goodz might fly under the radar, but those in the know keep its number on speed dial. The no-frills setup is all about the flavor, not the fuss. On my last visit, I noticed how the chef greeted each customer by name and still found time to chat about the best way to enjoy fresh-cooked fish.
The grilled salmon is a can’t-miss—tender, with a pleasant char that brings out its natural sweetness. Their shrimp platters are generous, perfectly spiced, and over-deliver on freshness. If you’re ordering sides, their sautéed veggies pair well with almost anything on the menu.
Service here feels genuinely personal—more like visiting a friend’s kitchen. For takeout that never disappoints, Taste Goodz stands out on the East Hills seafood map.
9. Gera’s Cakes
(516) 307-9195Call
Gera’s Cakes is a cozy spot where Peruvian comfort food and local favorites come together. The inviting aroma hit me before I’d even finished parking. While their name hints at desserts, this place surprises with a full menu featuring authentic Peruvian fare and seafood options you won’t find elsewhere nearby.
The ceviche here is the standout—citrusy, ultra-fresh, and brimming with tender fish and sweet red onions. Their chupe de camarones (shrimp chowder) is flavorful and warming, perfect for those chilly East Hills evenings. Each dish showcases the bright flavors and careful balance typical of Peruvian cooking.
Every visit feels like you’re being welcomed into a family kitchen. For those wanting seafood with a twist, Gera’s Cakes offers both comfort and adventure on a single plate.
10. Joe’s Crab Shack
Joe’s Crab Shack is where fun and fresh seafood go hand in hand. The lively, relaxed atmosphere is just what you’d expect from a spot with “shack” in the name—families in bibs, friends cracking crab legs, and a soundtrack of laughter. My first time here, I left with hands messy and spirits high.
Order the steamed crab buckets for the full Joe’s experience—they’re generous, loaded with crab, corn, and potatoes, and easy to share. The blackened fish tacos are another favorite, bringing a little heat and a lot of flavor without heaviness.
Friendly service ties it all together. For those in East Hills seeking casual seafood that’s satisfying and shareable, Joe’s Crab Shack delivers every single time.
More Things to Try in East Hills, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants near East Hills, NY?
A few standouts include Atlas New World Bistro, Singleton Seafood Shack, Vincents Clam Bar, and Roslyn Seafood Gourmet. Each spot offers its own atmosphere and signature dishes, from Mediterranean-inspired branzino to classic linguine with clams.
Where can I get the freshest seafood in East Hills?
Seafood Emporium Fish Mkt and Reede Intl Seafood Corp are local favorites for fresh fish and shellfish. Both markets let you shop for your own catch or enjoy a simple, expertly prepared meal.
Are there seafood options for takeout or delivery?
Yes, many places like Taste Goodz and Roslyn Seafood Gourmet offer takeout and curbside pickup. Joe’s Crab Shack and some markets also have easy takeout for a quick seafood fix at home.
Which seafood dishes are most popular in East Hills restaurants?
Crowd-pleasers include grilled salmon, clam chowder, grilled shrimp skewers, crab-stuffed flounder, and fresh ceviche. Most local restaurants shine when it comes to classic preparations with top-quality ingredients.
Can I find Mediterranean or Latin seafood specialties in East Hills?
Absolutely—Atlas New World Bistro and One North Mediterranean Soul offer Mediterranean-inspired dishes, while Gera’s Cakes features authentic Peruvian seafood like ceviche and chupe de camarones.
