When it comes to seafood, Elkhart, IN, may not be the first destination that comes to mind, but this charming city has a surprisingly vibrant culinary scene waiting to be discovered. Tucked alongside lakes and rivers, Elkhart offers a variety of seafood spots that are sure to please even the most discerning palates. Whether you’re after a casual bite or a more sophisticated dining experience, there’s a seafood dish here that can satisfy your cravings.
On a recent visit, I took a deep dive into the local seafood offerings and was pleasantly surprised by the rich flavors and creative preparations. From the crisp, golden batter of fried fish to the vibrant, fresh ceviche that dances on your taste buds, every meal was a new adventure. With this guide, you’ll uncover the best seafood spots in Elkhart, each with its own unique charm and menu. Prepare to embark on a delicious journey that will make you rethink everything you thought you knew about seafood in this Midwestern gem.
Where to find the best seafood in Elkhart, IN
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Elkhart, IN:
- Chubby Trout
- Long John Silver’s
- Mariscos Don Miguel
- Long John Silver’s
- Smokin’ Fattys BBQ
- Essence Restaurant + Bar
- Mariscos La Korita
- Red Lobster
- 523 Tap & Grill
- Harold’s Chicken Shack
1. Chubby Trout
Chubby Trout is a hidden gem located right off the 80/90 toll road, attracting locals and business travelers alike. The atmosphere perfectly blends upscale dining with a casual vibe, making it an ideal spot to unwind after a long drive. With a diverse menu that features everything from hand-pattied burgers to an impressive sushi bar, there’s always something tempting for every palate.
During my visit, I couldn’t resist the fresh walleye – lightly battered and fried to perfection. It was accompanied by a zesty tartar sauce that elevated the dish even further. The variety of local craft beers on tap perfectly complemented the meal, enhancing the dining experience. For sushi lovers, the salmon rolls are a must-try, showcasing Chubby Trout’s dedication to quality and flavor.
2. Long John Silver’s
+1 574-293-2426
Long John Silver’s is a fast-food haven for seafood lovers in Elkhart. Located conveniently on Nappanee Street, it’s known for its commitment to serving genuine seafood sourced from the depths of the ocean. With wild-caught ingredients like Alaska pollock, salmon, and North Pacific cod, this spot offers a fresh twist on classic fast food.
On a recent trip, I indulged in their signature battered fish and chips, which were crispy on the outside and tender within. The flavor was outstanding, and each bite captured the essence of coastal dining. For an extra treat, the popcorn shrimp is a perfect side, offering a delightful crunch that pairs well with their zesty dipping sauces.
3. Mariscos Don Miguel
Mariscos Don Miguel is a delightful find for those craving a taste of Mexican seafood in Elkhart. Located on Toledo Road, this vibrant restaurant captures the essence of coastal flavors and cultural flair. With its welcoming atmosphere and colorful decor, it’s a perfect spot for both casual lunches and festive dinners.
On my visit, I was particularly impressed by their ceviche de camarón, featuring fresh shrimp marinated in lime juice and paired with crisp vegetables. It was a refreshing dish that truly highlighted the restaurant’s focus on quality seafood. Another standout is their fish tacos, which come with perfectly grilled fish and a zesty slaw, making for a deliciously satisfying meal.
4. Long John Silver’s
+1 574-575-4387
Located on Cassopolis Street, Long John Silver’s brings a flavorful seafood experience to Elkhart. With a focus on fresh ingredients, they pride themselves on sourcing seafood from real oceans, offering a menu rich in quality and choice. Their commitment to using wild-caught varieties like Alaska pollock, salmon, and North Pacific cod sets them apart in the fast-food scene.
During a recent visit, I enjoyed their classic fish and chips, which were perfectly battered and crispy, creating a satisfying crunch with every bite. The pieces were generous, making it a true value meal. Don’t miss out on the hush puppies, a delightful side that complements any seafood dish with its sweet flavor.
5. Smokin’ Fattys BBQ
Smokin’ Fattys BBQ is a unique spot in Elkhart where barbecue meets seafood, resulting in an eclectic menu that’s hard to resist. Located on Interchange Drive, this restaurant offers a relaxed atmosphere perfect for lunch or dinner. The fusion of flavors and the smoky aroma that fills the air create an inviting dining experience.
During my visit, I was drawn to their seafood platter, which included succulent shrimp skewers and smoked fish. The rich, smoky flavors combined beautifully with the fresh seafood. Also, don’t skip the BBQ shrimp tacos—the perfect blend of sweet and savory, highlighting the restaurant’s creative culinary approach.
6. Essence Restaurant + Bar
Essence Restaurant + Bar is a culinary gem located along Nibco Parkway in Elkhart, offering a sophisticated dining experience that combines creativity with impeccable service. This establishment stands out for its focus on showcasing expertly crafted dishes and a thoughtfully curated list of wines and spirits, making it ideal for an elegant night out.
During my visit, I was captivated by the seared scallops, beautifully plated and paired with a velvety beurre blanc sauce. Each bite was both rich and refined, truly reflecting the restaurant’s dedication to quality. Additionally, their seafood risotto is a must-try, with luscious cream and fresh seafood that creates a comforting yet upscale dish.
7. Mariscos La Korita
Located on Osolo Road, Mariscos La Korita is a vibrant seafood restaurant that brings the flavors of Mexico to Elkhart. The menu is packed with authentic dishes that celebrate the bounty of the ocean, offering a delightful dining experience for seafood lovers.
During my time there, I indulged in their campechano ceviche, bursting with fresh seafood and zesty lime, making it a refreshing appetizer. The grilled fish tacos are another standout, providing a perfect balance of flavor and texture. Each bite encapsulates the restaurant’s commitment to quality and authenticity, showcasing their unique approach to seafood.
8. Red Lobster
Red Lobster is a familiar name in the realm of seafood dining, and its Elkhart location on Brittany Court upholds the brand’s reputation for quality and family-friendly atmosphere. With a menu that ranges from classic favorites to innovative dishes, Red Lobster caters to everything seafood enthusiasts could desire.
On my recent visit, I couldn’t resist trying their ultimate feast, which featured a generous selection of lobster tail, snow crab, and shrimp scampi. Each component was cooked to perfection, showcasing the restaurant’s dedication to freshness and flavor. The Cheddar Bay biscuits are a must-have side, perfectly flaky and buttery, making them the ideal accompaniment to any seafood meal.
9. 523 Tap & Grill
Located on South Main Street, 523 Tap & Grill is a delightful bistro that combines American classics with a Mediterranean flair, offering a diverse menu that appeals to various tastes. The intimate setting makes it perfect for a quiet lunch or an evening out with friends, complemented by an extensive drinks selection, including craft beers and fine wines.
During my visit, I savored the grilled salmon, which was beautifully seasoned and served over a bed of flavorful couscous. This dish highlighted the restaurant’s commitment to freshness while showcasing Mediterranean influences. Additionally, the seafood risotto is a must-try, as it bursts with flavor and creamy texture, making it a cozy choice any time of year.
10. Harold’s Chicken Shack
Harold’s Chicken Shack, located on Benham Avenue in Elkhart, IN, is the go-to spot for comfort food lovers craving fried chicken and seafood. With an inviting atmosphere and a menu that caters to all appetites, it stands out as a community favorite. Their focus on bold flavors and generous portions has garnered a loyal following.
During my visit, I was blown away by their signature
More Things to Try in Elkhart, IN
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Elkhart, IN?
Some of the top seafood spots include Chubby Trout, Long John Silver’s, and Mariscos Don Miguel. Each offers unique dishes, with options ranging from fresh fish to Mexican seafood specialties.
2. Is seafood fresh at Elkhart restaurants?
Yes, many restaurants in Elkhart pride themselves on using fresh, locally sourced seafood when available. Places like Red Lobster and Essence Restaurant + Bar are known for their quality ingredients and attention to freshness.
3. Are there seafood options for non-seafood eaters?
Absolutely! Many seafood restaurants in Elkhart offer a variety of other options, including chicken and beef dishes, making it easy for everyone to find something they enjoy.
4. Do seafood restaurants in Elkhart offer takeout?
Most seafood restaurants, like Harold’s Chicken Shack and 523 Tap & Grill, provide takeout services, allowing you to enjoy delicious meals at home.
5. Are there gluten-free seafood options available?
Yes, many places, including Chubby Trout and Essence Restaurant + Bar, offer gluten-free choices for those with dietary restrictions. Always check with your server to confirm crossover and preparation methods.