Seafood cravings come with high standards and everyone knows not every shrimp, scallop, or snapper deserves your attention. In Floral Park, NY, the hunt for great seafood is a real adventure. I’ve found myself walking block after block, following the scent of sizzling garlic and butter, determined to skip the bland and get straight to the best. Truth is, I’ve spent more than one evening here debating grilled salmon versus classic fish and chips, and have tasted both subtle and bold flavors that linger long after the plate is cleared.
If you want the kind of seafood that keeps you plotting your next meal before you’ve even left your seat, you’re in the right place. This guide steers you past the generic and straight to truly satisfying plates. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, the next gem for your taste buds is somewhere on this list. Get ready to discover seafood that’s fresh, skillfully prepared, and memorable.
Where to find the best seafood in Floral Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Floral Park, NY:
- Crabtrees Restaurant
- Cajun Crab Shack
- Righthouse Seafood
- Torigo Japanese Restaurant
- Flavor fusion
- Rachel’s Waterside Grill
- Harbor Seafood
- Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc
- Gera’s Cakes
- Hook & Reel
1. Crabtrees Restaurant
Crabtrees Restaurant might look unassuming from the outside, but inside, it’s a pleasant surprise. This spot does Mediterranean and Continental flavors with skill, making it a real draw for seafood fans. I’ve sat at a cozy table here, losing track of time over garlicky shrimp and lively conversation—there’s something about the place that slows you down in the best way.
The staff never rush you, and they know their seafood. For a real taste of Crabtrees, try the grilled branzino—it arrives moist, flaky, and kissed with olive oil and herbs. The seafood linguine is also a standout, with each bite rich in flavor. Their fresh options suit everyone, from simple grilled fish to creative chef specials.
2. Cajun Crab Shack
Cajun Crab Shack packs plenty of flavor into every corner of its menu. When I walked in, the aroma of spices had me hooked before I even sat down. The atmosphere is easygoing, making it a great spot to roll up your sleeves and let the good times—and seafood—begin.
The place stands out by keeping things lively and unpretentious. Butter, garlic, and tangy Cajun spices are all in play, making each bite memorable. I always order the snow crab legs, tossed in Cajun seasoning. They’re messy and worth every napkin. The shrimp boil is also a favorite, loaded with plump shrimp and vegetables that soak up the house blend.
Expect hearty, satisfying plates that deliver real boldness with every forkful.
3. Righthouse Seafood
Righthouse Seafood specializes in letting their fish do the talking. The first time I visited, the simple, clean setup reminded me that good seafood doesn’t need distractions. You can sense their commitment to freshness the moment you step in.
It’s the kind of place where regulars swap stories at the counter, catching up while their orders are packed. I recommend trying their classic grilled fish fillet—delicate, never over-seasoned, and always cooked just right. The jumbo shrimp platter is another highlight, offering generous portions and a pleasing, natural flavor.
If you want straight-up, honest seafood with no frills, this is a local go-to. Reliability like this is tough to find anywhere else.
4. Torigo Japanese Restaurant
Torigo Japanese Restaurant quietly delivers some of Floral Park’s most memorable seafood moments. The first time I ducked inside, I was greeted by the understated buzz of regulars and the careful hand of a sushi chef who takes pride in every slice. The laid-back, family-friendly vibe makes lingering easy.
What stands out here is the steady dedication to freshness. Slicing your own wasabi and enjoying it with sashimi and nigiri quickly becomes a habit. The salmon sushi is buttery and soft, and their yellowtail roll is always spot-on—clean, bright, and expertly rolled.
If you’re after sushi that lets natural flavors shine and a sense of calm, Torigo delivers every time. Good seafood is an experience, not just a meal, and this place proves it.
5. Flavor fusion
Flavor fusion spices up Floral Park with a playful take on Indo-Chinese cuisine. Walking in, I noticed the air thick with warm spices and laughter from families who clearly know this place well. It’s refreshing to find seafood with such bold, aromatic twists.
The standout here is the Chili Fish: tender white fish, tossed in a glossy, spicy sauce that lights up the taste buds. The Shrimp Fried Rice is another favorite—balanced, flavorful, and never greasy, with plump shrimp in every bite.
What makes Flavor fusion memorable is the way it manages comfort and a hint of adventure in each dish. If you crave seafood that’s anything but boring, this spot lives up to its name.
6. Rachel’s Waterside Grill
(516) 546-0050Call
Rachel’s Waterside Grill adds a bit of vacation to everyday life with its breezy atmosphere and water views. The first time I visited, the sun bounced off the water while a platter of seafood made its way to my table, turning an ordinary day into something memorable. Here, fresh ingredients are a given, and the staff takes pride in every plate.
If you’re torn on what to order, the Grilled Salmon never disappoints—perfectly cooked and topped with a lively sauce. For a shareable bite, try the Seafood Platter. It’s a clever mix of grilled and broiled offerings that highlight the kitchen’s skill.
This is the kind of place where every table feels like the best seat in the house, and the menu matches the view.
7. Harbor Seafood
Harbor Seafood holds a quiet confidence, serving seafood that’s consistently fresh and never fussy. My first time here, I was struck by how many regulars chatted away while picking out what’s clearly the best catch in town. This isn’t just a restaurant—it’s where seafood fans and cooks fill their fridges, too.
The baked flounder is a real winner, tender and rich with subtle herbs. If you lean toward something lighter, the grilled shrimp skewers hit the mark with their smoky edges and clean flavor. Both show off just how good simple, well-chosen ingredients can taste.
This is the spot when you want that market-fresh flavor—whether you dine in or grab your favorites to cook at home.
8. Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc
(718) 465-1388Call
Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc keeps things simple but tasty, delivering classic Chinese seafood dishes to loyal neighborhood fans. The first time I ordered takeout from here, the packaging was nearly as generous as the portions inside. There’s a local, no-nonsense charm about this place that makes every meal straightforward and satisfying.
What sets it apart is the consistency. The steamed fish with ginger and scallion proves that fresh, subtle flavors can compete with bolder fare. The shrimp with mixed vegetables offers a crisp, light meal that still feels hearty, with plenty of plump seafood in each bite.
If you appreciate quality without pretension and like your seafood in reliable, comforting dishes, Hung Cheung Kitchen fits the bill every time.
9. Gera’s Cakes
(516) 307-9195Call
Gera’s Cakes surprises most first-timers: it’s far more than a bakery. Tucked in Mineola, it showcases authentic Peruvian flavors alongside seafood gems. The warm, casual setting invites you to linger, whether you’re stacking plates with friends or grabbing a quick bite solo. I stumbled on this spot during a rainy afternoon and left with an upbeat mood and a belly full of flavor.
The standout seafood dish is the Ceviche de Pescado. Citrusy, zesty, and fresh, it’s a plate that reminds you why simple ingredients shine. Also worth trying is the seafood chaufa—a Peruvian take on fried rice, loaded with shrimp and fish, each bite layered with just the right spices.
If you want seafood that’s energetic and rooted in tradition, Gera’s delivers.
10. Hook & Reel
Hook & Reel brings Southern energy to Valley Stream with seafood boils that encourage you to ditch the fork and dig in. The first time I visited, gloves and bib were my uniform. It felt almost festive—the air buzzing with clatter and happy chatter as tables were piled high with steaming bags of shellfish.
Where this place shines is in the endless customization. Pick your catch, choose a seasoning blend (the house Cajun is a strong contender), and select your spice level. The shrimp boil with corn and potatoes is a must, swimming in sauce and still piping hot from the kitchen. For a tangy kick, their garlic butter snow crab proves hard to ignore.
Hook & Reel is for anyone hungry for seafood that’s both interactive and full of flavor.
More Things to Try in Floral Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of seafood are popular in Floral Park, NY?
Shrimp, flounder, salmon, and crab are favorites, thanks to the area’s diverse range of restaurants. You’ll also find creative dishes like seafood fried rice and sushi rolls.
Which seafood restaurants in Floral Park offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Crabtrees Restaurant is known for its gluten-free and vegan options, and several spots can accommodate special dietary needs if you ask the staff directly.
Are there any local seafood markets in Floral Park?
Yes, spots like Main St Fish Market and Merrick Fish Store offer fresh daily catches and a range of take-home seafood.
Is fresh seafood available year-round in Floral Park?
Absolutely. Most seafood spots pride themselves on serving fresh, quality ingredients, regardless of the season.
Can I find halal or kosher seafood options in Floral Park?
Some restaurants can cater to halal or kosher requirements upon request. Always confirm with the staff before ordering to be sure.
