Fort Myers, Florida, is a seafood lover’s paradise, where fresh catches and creative dishes dance together on your plate. Growing up here, I’ve spent countless afternoons savoring dishes that showcase the rich bounty of the Gulf. From delicately fried shrimp to robust fish tacos, every meal tells a story of local flavors and culinary craftsmanship. Whether you’re an avid angler or just someone who loves to indulge in ocean delights, you’ll find plenty of options that take seafood to tantalizing new heights.
Navigating the seafood scene in Fort Myers can be a delicious adventure, but some spots truly stand out. Imagine biting into a perfectly grilled fish while watching the sunset over the water, or enjoying a vibrant ceviche as the sun dips below the horizon. In this guide, I’ll share the best seafood restaurants in Fort Myers, each offering unique dishes and a warm atmosphere that invites you to linger. Get ready to explore a delicious array of flavors that will elevate your dining experience to a whole new level.
Where to find the best seafood in Fort Myers, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Fort Myers, FL:
- Cape Cod Fish Company
- Salty Papa’s Shrimp House
- Izzy’s Fish and Oyster
- Shrimp Shack
- Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market
- Clam Bake
- University Grill
- Blue Pointe Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill
- Bonefish Grill
- Pinchers
1. Cape Cod Fish Company
Cape Cod Fish Company captures the essence of New England seafood right in Fort Myers. With its cozy indoor and outdoor seating, it invites diners to enjoy a casual meal near the beach. The blend of flavors from Northeastern favorites transported to the Gulf Coast creates a unique dining experience.
One standout dish is the Fried Ipswich Whole Belly Clams—crispy and perfectly seasoned, they highlight the restaurant’s commitment to authenticity. Don’t miss the Lobster Rolls, either; they’re a delightful celebration of fresh lobster meat tucked into a soft, buttery roll.
Having savored their Chowder, I can attest to its rich, creamy texture paired with hints of fresh clams. Cape Cod Fish Company isn’t just about food; it’s about bringing delightful coastal traditions to Florida, making each bite a nostalgic journey.
2. Salty Papa’s Shrimp House
+1 239-482-7272
See Menu
Salty Papa’s Shrimp House is a true gem for seafood lovers, exuding a welcoming, casual vibe perfect for Southwest Florida. As a local favorite, it’s clear that they pride themselves on serving only the freshest ingredients, promising no chain restaurant offerings here. Each dish is a reflection of dedication and culinary craft.
Don’t leave without trying the Charleston Shrimp & Grits. Its creamy texture and perfectly spiced shrimp are nothing short of indulgent, representing the Southern twist that makes this place stand out. The Red Creole Jambalaya is another must; it’s packed with rich flavors and fresh seafood that truly warms the soul.
With a diverse menu that caters to various tastes, including vegan and gluten-free options, Salty Papa’s showcases a commitment to quality and sustainability, ensuring every visit is a delightful culinary adventure.
3. Izzy’s Fish and Oyster
Located in the heart of Fort Myers, Izzy’s Fish and Oyster is a delightful spot that brings a touch of New England charm to the Florida seafood scene. The relaxed atmosphere makes it perfect for both casual lunches and special dinners. With a mission to serve fresh seafood daily, this restaurant draws in seafood enthusiasts from near and far.
A standout selection here is the Oyster Bar, offering a variety of fresh oysters that are sure to impress. Pair them with a zesty cocktail sauce for a burst of flavor. Don’t miss the Clam Chowder, which perfectly balances creaminess and a rich seafood essence that reflects the restaurant’s commitment to quality.
Consequently, Izzy’s Fish and Oyster is a must-visit for anyone craving a fresh taste of the ocean with an inviting twist.
4. Shrimp Shack
For a laid-back dining experience, Shrimp Shack is a gem in Fort Myers that serves up casual seafood with a local twist. Operating since 1997, this restaurant has garnered a loyal following, earning accolades as the best seafood spot in Lee County for 14 consecutive years. The friendly atmosphere and dedicated service set it apart from the rest.
The Lite Eaters menu offers fantastic value at $10.99, making it a great choice for those looking to enjoy quality seafood without breaking the bank. Don’t overlook their famous fried shrimp; crispy, succulent, and full of flavor, they embody the essence of what the Shrimp Shack is all about.
If you’re in a rush, take advantage of the convenient drive-thru for quick pick-up. Shrimp Shack is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in delicious local flavors.
5. Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market
Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market is a unique dining experience in Fort Myers, seamlessly blending an in-house fish market with an elegant dining area. As you walk in, the freshness of the seafood is evident, showcasing an impressive selection of local Gulf catches. It’s a spot where quality and local sourcing truly shine.
The Grouper is a must-try; expertly prepared, it’s a true highlight of Florida’s culinary offerings. Pair it with the renowned New England chowder, which balances creamy richness with flavorful clams, making it a comforting favorite.
Whether returning for the Stone Crabs in season or indulging in the delectable Shrimp Bisque, diners leave with a sense of warmth and satisfaction, making Prawnbroker a standout choice in Fort Myers.
6. Clam Bake
Clam Bake is a delightful seafood destination in Fort Myers that captures the very essence of coastal dining. The laid-back atmosphere invites guests to savor their meals while emphasizing fresh, local ingredients. From the moment you walk in, the aroma of the ocean welcomes you, setting the stage for a memorable dining experience.
A must-try dish is the Steam Clam Bake, featuring a delightful mix of clams, shrimp, and other seasonal seafood steamed to perfection. Served with a side of drawn butter, this dish showcases the restaurant’s dedication to flavor and quality.
For a satisfying end to your meal, their key lime pie is a refreshing touch, perfectly balancing sweetness and tartness. Clam Bake stands out for its commitment to fresh seafood in a relaxed, inviting setting.
7. University Grill
+1 239-437-4377
University Grill offers a sophisticated take on the bar and grill experience in Fort Myers. This upscale venue seamlessly combines a vibrant atmosphere with a menu that tempts your taste buds. With a fine selection of aged meats and fresh seafood, it caters to a diverse clientele seeking quality in every bite.
The Seafood Risotto is a standout, featuring creamy Arborio rice infused with the flavors of the sea, complemented by shrimp and scallops cooked to perfection. Another highlight is the blackened Mahi Mahi, which bursts with flavor and perfectly captures the restaurant’s dedication to fresh ingredients.
The University Grill is more than just a meal; it’s an experience where quality and ambiance come together, making every visit memorable.
8. Blue Pointe Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill
Blue Pointe Oyster Bar & Seafood Grill redefines the seafood dining experience in Fort Myers. With a focus on fresh ingredients from the North Atlantic, Pacific Coast, Great Lakes, and Gulf of Mexico, this restaurant offers seafood enthusiasts a culinary paradise. The contemporary setting, complete with a full raw bar and a welcoming outdoor patio, makes it a perfect spot for any occasion.
Start your meal with a selection from the raw bar; their oysters are particularly praised for their freshness and quality. For a main course, the grilled Mahi Mahi topped with seasonal vegetables showcases the restaurant’s commitment to vibrant flavors and presentation.
Blue Pointe stands out for its dedication to providing a refined yet relaxed seafood dining experience, ensuring every guest leaves satisfied.
9. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill is a staple in Fort Myers, renowned for its commitment to quality and fresh ingredients. As you step into this local gem, you’re greeted with a vibrant atmosphere that invites you to indulge in delightful seafood offerings. The restaurant prides itself on hand-cut, wood-grilled specialties that leave a lasting impression.
One must-try dish is the Bang Bang Shrimp; it offers a perfect blend of crispy shrimp with a sweet and spicy sauce that keeps you coming back for more. The grilled Atlantic salmon is another favorite, cooked to perfection and accentuated with seasonal vegetables.
With a diverse menu that caters to various dietary preferences, Bonefish Grill stands out as the go-to spot for high-quality seafood in Fort Myers.
10. Pinchers
Pinchers offers an authentic taste of Southwest Florida, where the focus on fresh seafood is evident in every dish. With local fishermen supplying the catch directly from the Gulf, dining here feels like a true coastal experience. The vibrant atmosphere complements the dedication to quality, making it a great spot for seafood lovers.
A must-try is the Stone Crab, celebrated for its sweetness and served with a side of rich, tangy mustard sauce that enhances its flavor. Don’t miss the Grouper Tacos, either, featuring perfectly grilled fish dressed with fresh toppings that highlight the dish’s simplicity and quality.
Pinchers stands out for its commitment to local seafood, ensuring that every meal feels fresh, flavorful, and distinctly Floridian.
More Things to Try in Fort Myers, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Fort Myers?
Some of the top seafood spots include Cape Cod Fish Company, Salty Papa’s Shrimp House, and Prawnbroker Restaurant and Fish Market. Each offers a unique menu and atmosphere that showcases the freshness of local catches.
2. Is the seafood in Fort Myers fresh?
Absolutely! Many restaurants, like Pinchers, source their seafood directly from local fishermen, ensuring that dishes are made with the freshest ingredients. This commitment to freshness makes dining experiences in Fort Myers exceptional.
3. Are there vegetarian or vegan seafood options available?
Yes! Most seafood restaurants in Fort Myers offer gluten-free, vegetarian, and vegan options. Dishes often include vegan seafood substitutes or fresh, seasonal vegetables prepared in delicious ways.
4. What seafood dishes should I try in Fort Myers?
Don’t miss out on the Grouper, Stone Crab, and Shrimp Tacos. These dishes are local favorites and reflect the area’s culinary strengths, showcasing the flavors of the Gulf.
5. Can I take seafood to-go in Fort Myers?
Many places, like Prawnbroker, offer take-out options for their seafood dishes. This allows you to enjoy fresh seafood at home or on the go.
6. When is the best time to eat seafood in Fort Myers?
You’re likely to find great seafood year-round, but visiting during the Stone Crab season (October to May) is particularly rewarding as it offers the best availability of these local delicacies.
7. Are there happy hour specials for seafood?
Yes! Many seafood restaurants in Fort Myers, like Salty Papa’s, have happy hour specials where you can enjoy discounted drinks and appetizers, making it a great time to sample different dishes.
Feel free to ask if you have more questions about the seafood scene in Fort Myers!