Finding the best seafood in Franklin Square, NY can feel like chasing the perfect wave—equal parts thrilling and rewarding. On my first visit, I was skeptical. Often, someone touts a “hidden gem” and you land up with soggy fish sticks. But Franklin Square proved me wrong. The local favorites here treat seafood with respect and a knack for flavor, whether you prefer classic fried clams or crave bold, modern twists on old favorites.
Navigating so many menus takes curiosity and, sometimes, a sense of humor when facing a mountain of options. I dug in — tasting, comparing, and asking the locals what made each spot unique. The results? A guide that makes it easy to find exactly what you’re in the mood for, whether it’s a piled-high lobster roll, a delicate fillet of fish, or a seafood feast for two. Ready for seafood that’s worth your time? Dive in—your perfect meal might be just around the corner.
Where to find the best seafood in Franklin Square, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Franklin Square, NY:
- Trotters Bar & Grill
- Trident Seafood Grill
- Lobster Pound
- New Seafood Galaxy
- Palomino’s Restaurant
- Rachel’s Waterside Grill
- Harbor Seafood
- Prime Catch Seafood Grill & Bar
- Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams
- Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc
1. Trotters Bar & Grill
Trotters Bar & Grill sits at the heart of Franklin Square, blending classic pub comfort with an unexpected touch of seafood flair. My first time, I was drawn in by the steady hum of locals and the aroma of crisp, golden fish and chips wafting from the kitchen. Here, it’s easy to relax—service is warm and unhurried, with a genuine feel that turns first-time diners into regulars.
What makes Trotters stand out is how seafood gets the same careful treatment as their burgers and steaks. Try the grilled salmon—moist, perfectly seasoned, and finished with a squeeze of lemon. For sharing, order the calamari, battered just right. Each plate feels thoughtfully prepared, making you appreciate the balance between homestyle favorites and fresh, quality seafood. Trotters proves good fish doesn’t need to be fancy, just well done.
2. Trident Seafood Grill
(516) 887-1137Call
Trident Seafood Grill keeps things refreshingly simple, but the food tells a richer story. I wandered in on a rainy afternoon, in search of comfort food, only to discover a spot trusted by locals for both its friendly vibe and its skill with seafood. The charm here is authentic—just honest cooking and portions that feel generous, not overwhelming.
The grilled shrimp is a standout: lightly seasoned and never rubbery, it’s served with fresh veggies that complement rather than overwhelm. Another favorite is the seafood pasta, where seafood takes center stage and the sauce is there for support. Trident’s approach shows in every bite—fresh ingredients and a focus on letting flavors shine.
If you lean toward simple, well-cooked seafood and a laid-back setting, Trident won’t let you down.
3. Lobster Pound
(516) 922-5708Call
Lobster Pound offers that rare blend of no-frills atmosphere and seafood done right. My first trip was motivated by a craving for a real lobster roll, the kind that tastes like summer even on a gray day. Walking in, you sense right away this isn’t about trend; it’s about tradition and fresh catches.
The lobster roll is the headliner—striking the right balance between tender meat, light mayo, and a classic split-top bun. If you’re feeling more adventurous, try their steamed clams. Both dishes let the ingredients take the lead, tasting like they were plucked from the water that morning.
Simple, honest, and served with a side of genuine friendliness, Lobster Pound keeps fans coming back for “just one more bite.”
4. New Seafood Galaxy
(516) 872-9773Call
New Seafood Galaxy is one of those neighborhood fixtures where you can spot regulars dropping by with quiet confidence. My first visit there was a pleasant surprise—I was welcomed like family, and the briny scent of the counter made me instantly hungry. They strike a balance between fish market freshness and comfort-food execution, proving that you don’t need white tablecloths for a stellar seafood meal.
The fried whiting platter stands out—flakes of tender fish tucked in a crisp, golden shell with just enough seasoning to keep things interesting. If you prefer your meals lighter, opt for their grilled tilapia, which always tastes fresh from the dock.
At New Seafood Galaxy, dishes are simple, sides aren’t an afterthought, and freshness is the daily guarantee.
5. Palomino’s Restaurant
Palomino’s Restaurant mixes Italian comfort and American classics under one roof, which means the seafood options come with a tasty twist. When I stopped in, I noticed families crowding tables and laughter bouncing off the walls—a clear sign that this place knows how to keep guests happy. The service is relaxed but attentive, making it easy to settle in for a long, leisurely meal.
Order the seafood linguine for a dish that delivers on flavor and generosity. Mussels, clams, and shrimp come together in a fragrant sauce that feels both homestyle and restaurant-worthy. If you want something lighter, the grilled salmon is a go-to, always cooked just right.
Palomino’s offers a menu where seafood is never an afterthought, and every visit feels like a return to somewhere familiar.
6. Rachel’s Waterside Grill
(516) 546-0050Call
Rachel’s Waterside Grill sits along Freeport’s Nautical Mile, just a short drive from Franklin Square, offering fresh catches with a scenic view. My first visit was timed perfectly for sunset, and the water view nearly competed with the food for attention. This spot stands out for its balance—upscale enough for a celebration, yet relaxed and inviting for any night out.
The blackened mahi mahi is worth every bite, flaky and well-seasoned without being overpowering. Seafood purists will love the jumbo lump crab cakes, full of sweet crab and lightly crisped to golden brown. Sides and sauces never overpower the star ingredients, letting the seafood shine.
Rachel’s keeps things fresh, flavorful, and just a little bit special, no matter the occasion.
7. Harbor Seafood
Harbor Seafood has a well-earned reputation for both quality and value, which is clear from the steady stream of regulars. I first walked in thanks to a tip from a friend and left a convert—the market atmosphere and knowledgeable staff make the whole experience refreshingly straightforward. If you’re serious about fresh, this place will not disappoint.
The broiled flounder quickly became a favorite, always arriving flaky with just the right touch of seasoning. Their shrimp cocktail is bright, tender, and generous with the portion. Every dish spotlights the natural flavors, resisting the urge to overcomplicate good seafood.
For anyone craving the straightforward joy of seafood done right, Harbor Seafood hits the mark every time.
8. Prime Catch Seafood Grill & Bar
Prime Catch Seafood Grill & Bar showcases a diverse menu that manages to appeal to both purists and culinary explorers. I first visited after hearing neighbors rave about their whole grilled fish, and the buzz is deserved. The space hums with lively conversations and the scent of lemon and herbs hanging in the air.
The whole grilled branzino sets the standard, arriving perfectly charred and moist, with a fresh squeeze of citrus bringing every bite to life. If you’re dining in a group, their pot of PEI mussels is a hearty, shareable starter that never feels skimpy. The attention to detail and market-fresh approach show up in every dish.
Whether you want a reliably fresh classic or something a little different, Prime Catch delivers on both fronts with casual confidence.
9. Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams
Bigelow’s New England Fried Clams feels straight out of a coastal road trip, thanks to its no-frills charm and focus on classic seafood fare. On my first visit, I realized you don’t need oceanside views when the food is this nostalgic. The energy is lively, with regulars chatting over trademark baskets of golden-fried seafood.
The fried clams are the main event—light, tender, and never greasy, capturing that unmistakable New England flavor. For something a little different, try their fried scallops, which manage to stay juicy beneath their crunchy coating.
Each plate at Bigelow’s keeps the spotlight firmly on quality seafood and straightforward seasoning, making this spot a must for fans of crispy, satisfying classics.
10. Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc
(718) 465-1388Call
Hung Cheung Kitchen Inc might look unassuming from the outside, but inside, there’s a loyal crowd and a steady rhythm of takeout orders. I first picked up dinner here after a tip from a friend, and the freshness of the seafood dishes pleasantly surprised me. The atmosphere is laid-back, with service that keeps things moving smoothly.
The steamed fish with ginger and scallions is a must—excelling at that balance between delicate, subtle flavor and just enough aromatics. For a quick bite, the shrimp with broccoli never misses, packed with crisp vegetables and a sauce that isn’t too heavy.
Hung Cheung Kitchen is proof that satisfying, standout seafood doesn’t need to be dressed up to make an impression.
More Things to Try in Franklin Square, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Franklin Square, NY?
Some local favorites include Trotters Bar & Grill, Lobster Pound, Prime Catch Seafood Grill & Bar, and New Seafood Galaxy. Each offers a unique take, ranging from classic fish and chips to fresh lobster rolls and whole grilled fish.
Are there any halal-friendly seafood options in Franklin Square?
Most seafood spots feature plenty of pescatarian-friendly choices, such as grilled fish and shrimp, but it’s always smart to ask about preparation methods to ensure ingredients meet your needs. Many restaurants are happy to accommodate upon request.
What seafood dish should I try first in Franklin Square?
You can’t go wrong with a classic like fried clams at Bigelow’s, a lobster roll from Lobster Pound, or whole grilled branzino at Prime Catch. These dishes highlight what each spot does best—simple, fresh, and full of flavor.
Is takeout available at most seafood restaurants in Franklin Square?
Yes, nearly all the local seafood restaurants offer easy takeout options, perfect for a casual night in or a picnic in the park.
Can I find fresh, not frozen, seafood in Franklin Square?
Absolutely. Markets like Harbor Seafood and New Seafood Galaxy pride themselves on daily deliveries and market-fresh selections, so you can enjoy everything from fillets to shellfish at their peak.