Discovering the best seafood in Greenville, NC, is an experience best savored one bite at a time. Having explored local eateries and spoken with passionate chefs, I’ve come to appreciate how Greenville’s seafood scene balances tradition with innovation. Whether it’s a plate of fresh oysters, succulent shrimp, or a hearty fish fry, the city offers a range of options that satisfy every craving. My own visits have introduced me to hidden gems and longstanding favorites that showcase the region’s rich coastal flavors.
Through my journey, I’ve learned that choosing the right spot can elevate a simple seafood meal into a memorable experience. With careful attention to ingredient quality and preparation, Greenville’s restaurants consistently impress with their freshness and culinary flair. This guide aims to help you navigate the local scene confidently, highlighting establishments that stand out for their commitment to serving top-quality seafood in a welcoming atmosphere. Get ready to indulge in some of the finest seafood Greenville has to offer.
Where to find the best seafood in Greenville, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Greenville, NC:
- Cafe Duo
- Red Lobster
- 42 Fry
- Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
- Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
- The Gold Post Cafe
- Bonefish Grill – Closed
- Dixie Queen Seafood Restaurant
- Lupton Seafood Inc
- Mayflower Seafood
1. Cafe Duo
Tucked into the Lyndale Shoppes, Cafe Duo is a cozy Greenville favorite that quietly redefines what casual seafood dining can feel like. On my visit, the warm lighting and quiet hum of conversation set the tone for what turned out to be a standout meal. The vibe is thoughtful but never pretentious—exactly the kind of place you want to linger.
What makes Cafe Duo memorable is its fusion of creative American fare with rustic European touches. The couple behind the kitchen shares a clear passion for detail, which comes through in every dish. I tried their pan-seared scallops, served over a silky seasonal risotto—the kind of dish that stays with you long after the plate’s cleared.
If you’re venturing in for seafood, don’t miss the grilled Atlantic salmon or their catch-of-the-day special, which showcases local ingredients with elegance and restraint. It’s clear Cafe Duo values freshness and quality above all.
It’s not flashy, and that’s the point. Cafe Duo delivers quietly confident cooking, full of flavor and intention. It’s a spot you’ll want to return to before you’ve even left the parking lot.
2. Red Lobster
If consistency is king, then Red Lobster knows how to wear the crown. Nestled along South Memorial Drive, this spot brings a predictable kind of comfort that’s hard to dismiss. On my visit, the staff was relaxed and friendly, and yes—those Cheddar Bay Biscuits lived up to the hype. The atmosphere feels like a cross between a celebratory dinner and a laid-back afternoon out.
What keeps Red Lobster relevant is its broad appeal and reliably fresh fare. I tried their grilled shrimp skewers and garlic butter salmon, both prepared with care and served promptly. They don’t overthink the food—it’s straightforward, satisfying, and flavorful.
Seafood lovers looking for variety should explore their Create Your Own Combination platter. It’s a clever way to sample more than one favorite without second-guessing your pick.
Red Lobster delivers dependable seafood with a side of nostalgia, making it an easy choice for both first-timers and loyal diners alike.
3. 42 Fry
Tucked into a modest strip on East 10th Street, 42 Fry doesn’t try to impress with flash—it lets the food do the talking. The vibe is casual, but the flavors are anything but. On my visit, the kitchen was humming, and the scent of seasoned batter and fresh seafood filled the air.
What sets 42 Fry apart is its focus on crispy, golden-fried seafood that’s never greasy or overdone. The fried flounder was flaky and light, and the jumbo shrimp had just the right snap. Each plate came out hot, with sides that actually felt thought-out—like their seasoned fries and tangy slaw.
If you’re unsure where to start, go for the Seafood Platter. It’s a solid intro to what 42 Fry does best: simple, well-executed seafood that hits the spot.
4. Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen
Located conveniently on South Memorial Drive, Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen carries a rich tradition of fresh, quality seafood that dates back to 1969. My visit revealed a clean, approachable atmosphere that’s perfect for quick, satisfying meals. The staff was friendly, and the smell of seasoned fried fish greeted me right as I entered.
What makes Captain D’s stand out is its commitment to serving freshly prepared seafood at an accessible price. The battered fish fillets and shrimp basket impressed with crispness and flavor. The menu’s focus on simplicity and quality reflects its longstanding reputation in Greenville.
For seafood that’s dependable and well-made, I recommend their Famous Fish Sandwich. It’s a classic that encapsulates the essence of Captain D’s—fresh fish, great value, and satisfying to the last bite.
5. Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar delivers bold Southern-style seafood boils with a casual, down-to-earth vibe. Located off SW Greenville Blvd, it’s a local spot that embraces messy hands and flavorful memories. The interior is lively, making it easy to settle in with friends for a long, satisfying feast.
The menu centers around the classic boil: custom seafood combos tossed in rich Cajun seasoning, served with corn, potatoes, and choice of sauce. Try the shrimp and snow crab boil—the balance of heat and flavor reflects Hook & Reel’s signature style. For something crisp, the fried catfish basket stands out for its light, golden texture and clean finish.
Hook & Reel isn’t about fine dining; it’s about flavor-packed comfort food made to be shared. It’s where seafood feels just right.
6. The Gold Post Cafe
(252) 758-2719Call
Nestled on West 5th Street, The Gold Post Cafe is a charming spot known for its warm atmosphere and classic seafood offerings. During my visit, I appreciated the friendly service and the cozy, unpretentious setting that feels like a neighborhood favorite. The aroma of seasoned seafood promised a satisfying meal ahead.
The cafe’s strength lies in its fresh, well-prepared seafood and comforting dishes. I recommend the shrimp and grits, which showcases a perfect blend of southern tradition and seafood freshness. For a lighter option, their fried scallops offer a crispy, tender bite that’s hard to beat.
What makes The Gold Post stand out is its consistent quality and welcoming mood—ideal for a casual lunch or dinner with family or friends.
7. Bonefish Grill – Closed
Although Bonefish Grill in Greenville has closed, it left a lasting impression with its elegant, yet accessible atmosphere. During my visits, I appreciated the focus on fresh, sustainably sourced seafood paired with a refined but relaxed vibe that appealed to a wide range of diners. The menu was consistently well-curated, highlighting simplicity and quality.
Bonefish’s signature dishes, such as the Bang Bang Shrimp and blackened mahi-mahi, exemplified their dedication to flavorful, beautifully prepared seafood. The emphasis on health-conscious options like salads and lighter fare made it a versatile choice for many.
What stood out was their commitment to pairing seafood with a full bar, including a fine selection of wines and cocktails, elevating the dining experience. Though no longer open, Bonefish Grill set a high standard for seafood dining in Greenville.
8. Dixie Queen Seafood Restaurant
Tucked away on Mills Road, Dixie Queen Seafood Restaurant offers a warm, family-friendly setting with an emphasis on hearty, Southern-style seafood. During my visit, I enjoyed the inviting atmosphere and attentive service that made me feel right at home. The menu features generous portions and familiar flavors.
The standout dishes include the fried fish fillets and shrimp platter, both skillfully prepared with crispy, flavorful batter. Their commitment to quality Southern comfort food makes their seafood dishes both satisfying and authentic. The restaurant’s relaxed vibe is perfect for casual family dinners or quick lunch stops.
If you’re after dependable seafood that feels like a true taste of Greenville, Dixie Queen delivers with consistency and charm.
9. Lupton Seafood Inc
(252) 215-5277Call
Tucked away on Arlington Boulevard, Lupton Seafood Inc is a go-to market and seafood spot for locals seeking fresh and high-quality seafood. My visit revealed a vibrant atmosphere filled with the aroma of freshly caught fish and shellfish, making it clear that freshness is their top priority. It’s a place where you can buy seafood to prepare at home or enjoy a quick, satisfying meal.
The highlights include their fresh fish fillets and crab legs, both expertly handled and full of natural flavor. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction makes Lupton Seafood stand out in Greenville’s seafood scene. Whether shopping or dining, you can rely on their offerings to be top-notch and authentic.
If you want a taste of Greenville’s coastal bounty, Lupton Seafood Inc is a dependable choice that highlights the area’s best seafood traditions.
10. Mayflower Seafood
(252) 940-7262Call
Located on Kittrell Farms Drive, Mayflower Seafood offers a straightforward, no-frills dining experience focused on fresh, flavorful seafood. During my visit, I appreciated the friendly atmosphere and consistent quality that makes it a reliable choice for diners seeking classic seafood dishes. The restaurant’s simple setup puts the spotlight on the food.
Their fried shrimp and catfish fillets stand out for their crispy exterior and tender interiors, showcasing their commitment to quality. The menu emphasizes freshness and traditional Southern flavors, making each dish satisfying and authentic. It’s an ideal spot for a quick, comforting seafood meal.
If you’re craving dependable, well-prepared seafood in Greenville, Mayflower Seafood is a solid option worth exploring.
More Things to Try in Greenville, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Greenville, NC?
Some of the top-rated spots include 42 Fry, Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar, Red Lobster, and The Juicy Crab Winterville. For a more local, no-frills experience, Mayflower Seafood and Dixie Queen Seafood Restaurant are also popular.
2. Where can I find halal or haram-free seafood options in Greenville?
While most seafood is generally considered halal, it’s best to ask about preparation methods and avoid dishes that include alcohol or non-halal meat. Restaurants like Cafe Duo and West End Seafood focus on fresh, simple ingredients, which may be more suitable.
3. Are there any seafood markets in Greenville for fresh catch?
Yes, Lupton Seafood Inc and Shore to Door Seafood are known for offering fresh, locally sourced seafood. These are great options if you prefer to cook at home.
4. Which seafood places are good for families?
Captain D’s Seafood Kitchen and Red Lobster are family-friendly chains with kid-friendly menus and casual atmospheres. The Seahorse also offers a comfortable setting with hearty portions.
5. What’s the best place for a seafood boil in Greenville?
Hook & Reel Cajun Seafood & Bar is a go-to for customizable seafood boils with options like shrimp, crab legs, and corn. Their signature sauces are a local favorite.
6. Are there any seafood restaurants with vegetarian options?
Yes, places like Cafe Duo and The Seahorse offer vegetarian sides and entrees, making them suitable for mixed-diet groups.
7. Do any seafood restaurants in Greenville offer takeout or delivery?
Most do. 42 Fry, The Juicy Crab, and Captain J Seafood offer takeout, and many are listed on delivery apps like DoorDash or Uber Eats.
8. What seafood dishes are most popular in Greenville?
Favorites include fried shrimp, catfish fillets, seafood boils, and grilled white fish. Southern-style sides like hush puppies and coleslaw are common pairings.
9. Are there any upscale seafood dining options in Greenville?
Cafe Duo offers a more refined experience with New American cuisine that includes seafood dishes. Plank Road Steak House also features seafood options in a more upscale setting.
10. What’s the best time to visit seafood restaurants in Greenville?
Weekday evenings and weekend lunches are ideal for avoiding crowds. For freshest catch, early dinner service is often best.