Finding great seafood in Hurley, NY, is equal parts exploration and reward. Tucked between historic barns and sheltered forests, this small Hudson Valley spot harbors more flavor than a city block. I’ve wandered these back roads with a stubborn appetite, following the scent of broiled fish and the promising chatter of locals. Each spot along the way revealed its own specialty—from tender, just-caught fillets at classic diners to surprising global twists at bistros hiding in plain sight. My favorite memory might be that quiet afternoon at a roadside market, where the owner handed me a paper basket of crispy-fried haddock and winked, knowing I’d found something special.
What you’ll discover is more than a checklist of places to eat. Each seafood spot on this list brings something distinct to the table: family recipes carried over generations, inventive sides, fresh-from-the-dock options, and menus designed for all tastes. I’ve tasted, compared, and sifted through word-of-mouth favorites and unexpected local gems to give you an honest tour of Hurley’s best seafood. Let’s get into the details—because if there’s anything more satisfying than a well-cooked meal by the water, it’s knowing exactly where to find it.
Where to find the best seafood in Hurley, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Hurley, NY:
- Red Lobster
- Eveready Diner
- Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
- Mariners on the Hudson
- Woodnotes Grille
- Mariner’s Harbor
- Ship To Shore American Bistro
- Bistro To Go
- Chops Grille
- Dietz Stadium Diner
1. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on Miron Lane in Kingston is a favorite for many seafood seekers near Hurley. The setting is easygoing, with roomy booths and the comfort of predictability—a welcome relief after a long week. Service is prompt, and the atmosphere has a gentle buzz, perfect for a casual lunch or an unhurried dinner.
What makes this spot stand out is consistency. You’ll know that the fish is always flaky and the portions reliable. My go-to is the Wood-Grilled Atlantic Salmon, which arrives with a buttery char and fresh sides. The Shrimp Scampi, rich and garlicky, also impresses seafood lovers year after year.
For those craving variety, try a crab or lobster platter, assembled with care and ideal for sharing.
2. Eveready Diner
Eveready Diner in Hyde Park feels like stepping into a mid-century postcard, but with far more flavor. The chrome and neon exterior promises comfort, and the menu delivers—especially for seafood fans touring the Hurley area. I once visited late on a chilly evening, drawn in by the bustle and the scent of fried fish drifting through the door.
What makes Eveready Diner memorable is its sense of generous tradition. The portions are hearty and the dishes taste homemade. Try the fried sole platter, coated in a crisp, golden crust, or the broiled salmon topped with fresh herbs. Both showcase a careful balance of freshness and nostalgia.
It’s an ideal spot for relaxed meals with friends, where the seafood feels as nostalgic as the jukebox tunes playing overhead.
3. Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market in New Paltz is the kind of place where you can literally smell the ocean the moment you step in. Family-owned and focused on freshness, this spot blurs the line between market and eatery, offering top-tier seafood right in the heart of the Hudson Valley. My first visit landed me a seat next to locals chatting about today’s catch, a sign you’re in the right place for quality fish.
What sets Gadaleto’s apart is its dedication to sourcing and preparing the freshest seafood around. The grilled swordfish steak is a standout—thick, flavorful, and expertly cooked. The classic New England clam chowder brims with clams and creamy goodness, a perfect comfort food pick.
If you’re serious about seafood, Gadaleto’s lets you taste how good simple and honest can be.
4. Mariners on the Hudson
(845) 691-6011Call
Mariners on the Hudson offers something rare—a front-row seat to river life. Perched right on the water, this spot delivers more than a meal; it creates an experience. I remember an evening watching boats drift by, the sun sliding behind the Poughkeepsie skyline as I settled in with a plate of perfectly grilled fish.
The scenery is unbeatable, but the menu matches it step for step. Try the pan-seared trout, crisped just right and delicately seasoned. The seafood stew brings together local catches for a dish that feels hearty and bright at once.
Whether you’re there for a date night or a leisurely lunch, Mariners crafts every plate with care—and a side of riverside calm.
5. Woodnotes Grille
Woodnotes Grille captures the wild beauty of the Catskills and brings it to the plate. This isn’t just another resort restaurant—it’s where local charm and fresh, native ingredients turn classic seafood dishes into memorable meals. I once stopped in on a misty afternoon, drawn by the promise of inventive flavors and a menu shaped by the seasons.
Woodnotes stands out for its commitment to “Catskill Creative Cooking.” Their trout almondine is a gem, featuring delicate fish caught locally, topped with buttery sliced almonds, and set off with bright herbs. The charred octopus, light and deeply flavorful, reflects the kitchen’s imaginative side.
Every dish tells a story of the region—fresh, thoughtful, and a true celebration of Hudson Valley seafood.
6. Mariner’s Harbor
Mariner’s Harbor commands a prized spot on Kingston’s historic waterfront, and the riverside views come standard with every dish. This is one of those places where you lose track of time, caught up in conversation and the soft buzz of boats docking nearby. My first visit was on a spring afternoon, and I still remember the freshness in both the air and the seafood platter in front of me.
What sets Mariner’s Harbor apart is its mix of classic comfort and culinary polish. The lobster roll is a staple, generously filled and lightly dressed to highlight the sweet meat. Also try the pan-seared scallops—tender, beautifully presented, and served with seasonal sides that underscore simple, skillful cooking.
Perfect for special occasions or relaxed meals where the view is as good as the food.
7. Ship To Shore American Bistro
Ship To Shore American Bistro blends old-school flair with a spark of modern creativity right along Kingston’s waterfront. The menu is ambitious but comforting, and the bustling vibe hints at just how well-loved this spot is. My last dinner here felt like an occasion, with friendly staff guiding me through their seafood highlights.
This bistro stands out for its focus on classic dishes, each elevated by thoughtful details. The ahi tuna tartare is fresh and bright—an excellent start if you want to taste something special. For a main, the grilled Atlantic salmon nails that balance of smoky and succulent, nestled alongside local vegetables that shift with the seasons.
You can count on Ship To Shore when you want a meal that feels both familiar and unlike anything you’d make at home.
8. Bistro To Go
Bistro To Go is the kind of place where you genuinely look forward to takeout. Just off Route 28, this spot marries convenience with chef-driven flavors and local ingredients. During a busy week, a stop here never disappoints—quick service, friendly faces, and meals that taste anything but rushed.
What makes Bistro To Go memorable is its commitment to healthy, high-quality options. The herb-crusted salmon stays crisp on the outside and juicy in the center, paired with seasonal vegetables. The seafood stew is another standout—rich, brimming with shrimp and fish, and ideal for chilly Hudson Valley evenings.
Perfect for a picnic or a weeknight dinner, Bistro To Go proves takeout doesn’t have to be boring or predictable.
9. Chops Grille
Chops Grille on John Street brings a modern twist to the classic steak-and-seafood house. The bustling dining room gives off a festive vibe, making every dinner feel like an event rather than a routine meal. My first trip here started as a search for good steak but quickly turned into a love for their seafood options.
Chops Grille’s seafood is worth a detour, even if you came for the grill. The Seared Scallops are rich and perfectly caramelized, while the Grilled Swordfish takes on just the right amount of smoky flavor from the kitchen’s open flame.
If you’re looking for upscale seafood with flair in the heart of Kingston, this is the place to linger.
10. Dietz Stadium Diner
Dietz Stadium Diner brings a classic twist to uptown Kingston, blending old-school diner charm with a menu that seems to stretch on for miles. It’s the sort of place you stumble into for a quick bite and end up lingering over seconds, especially if seafood is your aim. My last drop-in was a rainy afternoon that quickly brightened thanks to the warm buzz inside and a plate of crisp fish and chips.
What makes this diner stand out is its comfort-first approach paired with truly fresh seafood options. The broiled sole is always tender and served with just enough lemon. The shrimp basket—crisp, not greasy—comes with plenty of homemade slaw and a tempting side of fries.
Dietz Stadium Diner is where you find hearty portions, good company, and seafood that feels just right after a long day.
More Things to Try in Hurley, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top seafood restaurants near Hurley, NY?
The area boasts a great selection, including Mariner’s Harbor, Gadaleto’s Seafood Market, Woodnotes Grille, and Ship To Shore American Bistro. Each offers its own spin on classic and modern seafood favorites.
Which place has the freshest seafood in Hurley, NY?
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market is known for its ultra-fresh, market-sourced fish and daily specials. You can buy seafood to cook at home or enjoy something hot from their kitchen.
Are there any waterfront seafood restaurants near Hurley?
Yes, Mariner’s Harbor and Mariners on the Hudson both offer waterfront dining, giving you river views alongside your meal.
Where can I find takeout seafood near Hurley?
Bistro To Go provides excellent takeout options, with a menu that features healthy and flavorful seafood prepared fresh each day.
Do local seafood restaurants in Hurley have vegetarian or gluten-free dishes?
Many do—spots like Woodnotes Grille and Bistro To Go offer vegetarian sides and gluten-free menu items to complement their seafood dishes.
What’s the best place for a family-friendly seafood meal?
Red Lobster and Eveready Diner are great choices for families with their welcoming atmosphere, kids’ menus, and reliable seafood classics.
