If you’ve ever found yourself tracing the banks of the Hudson River in search of that perfect plate of seafood, Hyde Park might surprise you. From casual crab shacks to white-tablecloth spots with river views, this corner of upstate New York is a quiet haven for seafood lovers. I remember my first outing here—a friend insisted the only things finer than Eleanor Roosevelt’s pies were the oysters at a tucked-away local haunt. The oysters lived up to their reputation, and Hyde Park got its hooks in me.
Knowing where to go means everything. This guide offers tested favorites, new gems, and a few under-the-radar standouts—each spot chosen for flavor, freshness, and atmosphere. Whether your craving leans toward classic fried fish or inventive sushi rolls, you’ll find something here to satisfy every seafood palate. Let’s dive in and explore what Hyde Park has to offer, one plate at a time.
Where to find the best seafood in Hyde Park, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Hyde Park, NY:
- Eveready Diner
- Red Lobster
- Mariners on the Hudson
- Tasty Crab House
- Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
- Bonefish Grill – Closed
- Joe Willy S Fish
- Aladias Crab Cravings
- Tammy Honeyman
- Stonehedge
1. Eveready Diner
Don’t let the retro chrome exterior fool you—Eveready Diner is more than a blast from the past. Inside, the vibe is cozy and welcoming, with locals sliding into booths for reliable comfort food and a solid seafood lineup. I still remember my first visit: sunlight bouncing off a cherry-red jukebox, the smell of fried fish drifting through the air, and friendly chat that never feels rushed.
The diner’s seafood menu is quietly superb. The fried fish sandwich comes flaky and golden, perfectly paired with coleslaw. If you want something heartier, the broiled haddock delivers mild flavor with a buttery finish. Unlike trendier spots, Eveready keeps things classic—fresh ingredients, generous portions, and no fuss.
Don’t skip the clam chowder. It’s rich without being heavy, with tender clams that actually taste like the sea. Every dish feels like a little nod to Hyde Park’s river-town roots, making Eveready Diner an easy pick for seafood in a relaxed, local setting.
2. Red Lobster
Red Lobster has a way of making seafood reliable and approachable. My visits here usually start with the famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits—warm, savory, and strangely irresistible. This is the spot where families gather for casual celebrations or quick weeknight treats, with a menu that always focuses on freshness.
The Today’s Fresh Fish menu is worth a look. You’ll find rotating selections like salmon, trout, or cod, each grilled or broiled to order. For something classic, the grilled shrimp skewers are a favorite—lightly seasoned and never rubbery. Red Lobster’s style is all about consistency and plenty of choice.
If you’re in the mood for comfort, try the seafood linguini. The shells are loaded with sweet crab and plump shrimp. It’s a taste of the coast, served up right in Poughkeepsie.
3. Mariners on the Hudson
(845) 691-6011Call
Mariners on the Hudson offers a waterfront dining experience that’s tough to beat in the Hudson Valley. On my first visit, I ate on the patio while the sun dipped behind the bridge and the river shimmered—a reminder that food tastes better with a view. Even a rainy afternoon here feels special, thanks to walls of glass and the rhythmic sound of passing trains.
Seafood is the undisputed star. Their grilled salmon is fork-tender and lightly seasoned to let the freshness shine. If you’re feeling adventurous, try the fisherman’s stew—a comforting medley of tender fish and shellfish that seems to capture the river’s best in one bowl.
Don’t overlook the catch-of-the-day specials. These are always thoughtfully prepared and give you a true sense of what the kitchen does best. It’s the perfect place for a laid-back lunch or a memorable dinner, surrounded by the best views in town.
4. Tasty Crab House
(845) 454-2850Call
If you crave seafood with a side of fun, Tasty Crab House is hard to resist. My first visit turned into a bit of a feast—gloves on, bib tied, and the aroma of cajun spices promising a good time. This isn’t a quiet, formal place. Instead, it’s lively and hands-on, with a menu built for seafood lovers who don’t mind getting a little messy.
The signature seafood boils are where Tasty Crab House shines. Choose crab legs, shrimp, or mussels tossed in their house sauces. The garlic butter is decadent, but the Cajun blend brings serious flavor and just enough heat. Each boil lands at the table in a steaming bag, filled with corn and potatoes for a complete meal.
If you go, make the seafood boil your main event. It’s the purest expression of the restaurant’s playful spirit and focus on freshness.
5. Gadaleto’s Seafood Market
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market is a rarity—a fish market and casual eatery rolled into one, with a reputation that’s built on freshness. My trip here was motivated by locals insisting it was the only place for “real” seafood. Walking past cases of glistening fish, I knew this family-run spot takes quality seriously.
The menu at Gadaleto’s is refreshingly straightforward. The fish and chips are light on batter, letting the fresh cod speak for itself. For those seeking variety, their broiled seafood platter is a highlight, mixing tender shrimp with flaky fish and just the right touch of lemon and herbs.
If you like to cook at home, the market side offers daily catches—ideal for your next kitchen adventure. But the true local secret here is their chowder: creamy, packed with flavor, and always piping hot. Gadaleto’s is the kind of place where quality never wavers.
6. Bonefish Grill – Closed
Once a favorite for seafood with a modern twist, Bonefish Grill in Poughkeepsie has sadly closed its doors. I remember my last visit: low lights, the scent of wood-grilled fish, and smart service that kept the mood relaxed yet polished. It was the kind of place where every meal felt like a small occasion.
Bonefish Grill earned its reputation with nuanced seafood dishes. The Chilean sea bass was always a standout—delicate, flaky, and perfectly roasted. Their Bang Bang Shrimp balanced spice with a creamy sauce, a mix that drew crowds every night.
If you were lucky enough to dine here, you know the care they put into fresh ingredients and inventive flavors. While it’s now part of local memory, Bonefish Grill’s influence still lingers in the way other spots approach seafood in the area.
7. Joe Willy S Fish
Joe Willy’s Fish brings a touch of salty air to Wappingers Falls, thanks to its casual, nautical vibe and focus on ultra-fresh seafood. My first stop here felt like stumbling onto a local favorite—friendly, a little quirky, and always bustling at dinner. There’s a sense that everyone knows each other, and the menu delivers comfort alongside creativity.
The standout at Joe Willy’s has to be the fish tacos. They’re light, crisp, and finished with tangy slaw that balances each bite. If you’re craving something classic, their fried shrimp basket never disappoints—plump shrimp in a crisp coating served piping hot.
The menu also features grilled seafood options for those seeking lighter fare. Each dish arrives with a sense of pride and nostalgia, proving Joe Willy’s is serious about quality and local flavor.
8. Aladias Crab Cravings
(845) 419-9175Call
Aladias Crab Cravings is a hidden gem for those who take their crab seriously. My visit was a hands-on affair, each table alive with the satisfying crack of shells and laughter among friends. There’s a homegrown charm to this place that encourages you to roll up your sleeves and dive right in.
The highlight is the signature crab boil. Generous crab legs arrive steeped in a secret blend of spices, with flavors that lean bold without masking the sweetness of the meat. Sides like corn and potatoes round out the experience, creating a meal that feels both festive and comforting.
If you’re in the mood for something different, try the crab cakes—lightly crisped and packed with tender crab. Aladias hasn’t forgotten what makes seafood fun: great taste, good company, and a little bit of a mess.
9. Tammy Honeyman
(845) 236-2700Call
Tammy Honeyman is the kind of seafood spot you hear about from someone in the know. My first meal here felt like joining a local tradition, with a menu that’s focused, unfussy, and all about freshness. The atmosphere is relaxed but never dull, thanks to a steady stream of regulars and the hum of friendly conversation.
The standout dish is definitely the broiled haddock. It’s dependable, moist, and seasoned just enough to enhance the natural flavor. The shrimp scampi also gets high marks—light, garlicky, and served with a side of crisp greens for balance.
Tammy Honeyman proves that simple can be memorable, delivering the kind of straightforward seafood that puts quality front and center with every plate.
10. Stonehedge
Stonehedge combines classic steakhouse comfort with a thoughtful seafood selection, nestled in a serene spot along Route 9W. My dinner there began with a sunset view and the sense that this is where locals mark special occasions—or celebrate a Friday night. The interior echoes old-school charm, the menu reflecting both tradition and flexibility.
The standout? Their seafood linguine. It’s generous, filled with shrimp and fresh-caught fish all tossed in a light tomato sauce that lets the seafood shine. The broiled salmon is another favorite—moist and slightly smoky from the grill, complemented by seasonal vegetables that remind you it’s all about fresh, quality ingredients here.
Stonehedge is the answer when you want fine dining without the fuss, blending local hospitality and reliable seafood favorites in the heart of the Hudson Valley.
More Things to Try in Hyde Park, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants are closest to Hyde Park, NY?
Some of the nearest options include Eveready Diner, Mariners on the Hudson, and Tasty Crab House. Each offers a distinct setting and seafood style—casual diner classics, scenic river views, or lively shellfish boils.
Are there any seafood markets in the area?
Gadaleto’s Seafood Market in New Paltz stands out for fresh fish and prepared seafood dishes. It’s a favorite for those who prefer to cook at home or want takeout you can trust.
What dishes should I try for a great local seafood experience?
Start with clam chowder or a seafood boil from Tasty Crab House, and don’t miss the broiled haddock at Eveready Diner or the daily fish specials at Mariners on the Hudson. These picks deliver on both quality and local flavor.
Do any seafood restaurants offer vegetarian or non-seafood options?
Many local seafood spots, including Eveready Diner and Stonehedge, have menu choices for vegetarians or non-seafood eaters. Sides, salads, and pasta dishes are usually on offer.
Is it necessary to reserve a table at popular seafood restaurants in Hyde Park?
Reservations aren’t always required, but they’re a smart idea for spots like Stonehedge or Mariners on the Hudson, especially on weekends or holidays when tables fill up fast.
