Seafood in Ithaca hides in plain sight, tucked away in unassuming villages, cozy waterfronts, and lively supper clubs. If you’ve ever followed your nose down West Buffalo Street or caught the scent of grilled salmon drifting over Cayuga Lake, you already know a secret: Ithaca’s seafood scene is much more than a menu afterthought. Here, the catch-of-the-day could change your whole perspective on dining upstate.
Over the years, I’ve tasted my way through cracked crab, oyster platters, and flaky fish tacos across this city. Whether you crave a classic clam bake, crave the flavors of Asia, or are simply after a lobster roll that lives up to the hype, Ithaca has something to satisfy your curiosity—and your appetite. Ready to dive in? Let’s explore the best seafood spots in Ithaca that blend flavor, freshness, and a little lakeside charm.
Where to find the best seafood in Ithaca, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Ithaca, NY:
- The Boatyard Grill
- Maxie’s Supper Club and Oyster Bar
- The Antlers Restaurant
- Pete’s Cayuga Bar
- Kelly’s Dockside
- Taste of Thai Express
- Glenwood Pines
- Tokyo Hibachi
- Doug’s Fish Fry
- Ron Don’s Village Pub
1. The Boatyard Grill
Overlooking Cayuga Lake, The Boatyard Grill is where I first understood how a perfect view can make a seafood dinner feel like a mini vacation. The energy is relaxed but lively, lifted by sunset light, boat masts, and the scent of the grill.
What draws people in, besides the view, is the promise of seafood that’s delivered fresh daily. The grilled salmon here is a standout, beautifully tender and tinged with a smoky char. If you visit, consider the Lake Fish entrée or the jumbo shrimp skewers—simple, satisfying, and full of flavor.
The Boatyard Grill isn’t just about food; it’s a whole Ithaca memory. The staff handles everything smoothly, and the menu includes plenty for vegetarians and gluten-free diners, so no one misses out.
2. Maxie’s Supper Club and Oyster Bar
If Ithaca has a hidden slice of New Orleans, it’s definitely Maxie’s Supper Club and Oyster Bar. The moment you walk in, the energy buzzes, and you can tell this place is serious about seafood. I dropped by on a rainy Thursday, craving oysters—what arrived was a plate of the freshest, most briny shells I’ve tasted north of the Gulf.
Maxie’s is famous for its raw bar and seafood boils. A bowl of gumbo brings a little Southern comfort to the Finger Lakes, and the catfish is fried to crispy perfection. I always go for the shrimp and grits—it’s creamy, bold, and never disappointing.
Vegetarian and gluten-free guests aren’t left out, making this spot easy to visit with a group. For late-night cravings or a lively dinner, Maxie’s feels like a party you’ll want to join more than once.
3. The Antlers Restaurant
The Antlers Restaurant feels like a cozy retreat, tucked just east of downtown where comfort takes center stage. The cabin-like décor sets the scene for a meal that’s as relaxed as it is delicious. When I visited on a chilly evening, the warmth inside felt instantly welcoming.
This place has earned a loyal following for its honest, homestyle cooking. The broiled haddock is a signature dish—delicate, flaky, and always cooked just right. If you’re feeling adventurous, the seafood scampi is loaded with bright flavors and a touch of garlic.
Antlers keeps things classic but never boring, with a focus on consistency and friendly service. Vegetarian and gluten-free options ensure everyone can find something to savor here.
4. Pete’s Cayuga Bar
In the heart of downtown, Pete’s Cayuga Bar offers a low-key atmosphere that’s all about good seafood and great company. My first visit here was an accidental find, but it quickly became one of my go-to spots for no-fuss, flavorful plates.
Pete’s shines with a simple, straightforward menu. The standout is definitely the fried fish sandwich—crispy on the outside, juicy inside, and served with classic sides. There’s a certain comfort in their fish and chips too, which feels just right after a long day wandering Ithaca’s Commons.
If you’re after an unfussy, satisfying seafood meal, Pete’s delivers quality without the frills. It’s the kind of place you keep coming back to whenever you need a break from the ordinary.
5. Kelly’s Dockside
Kelly’s Dockside is the kind of place where breakfast lovers and seafood fans find common ground. Nestled along Taughannock Boulevard, the spot feels laid-back and local, drawing you in with the gentle buzz of conversation and the aroma of fresh coffee. My Sunday mornings here always include a stroll by the water, followed by a comforting meal that hits all the right notes.
One bite of their seafood omelet and you’ll understand why regulars keep coming back. The grilled fish tacos are another standout—bright flavors, crisp veggies, and just the right touch of heat make them an easy favorite.
What sets Kelly’s Dockside apart is its casual charm and ability to deliver satisfying seafood no matter the time of day. If brunch with a lake view sounds like your kind of morning, this is your next stop.
6. Taste of Thai Express
If you’re craving bold flavors and fresh seafood, Taste of Thai Express will win you over fast. The energy here is always upbeat and the staff knows how to keep the atmosphere easygoing. I stumbled in after a long day and was immediately revived by the inviting smells coming from the kitchen.
This spot is famous for its shrimp pad Thai—saucy, a little sweet, and flavorful with every bite. The seafood curry is filled with tender scallops and plump shrimp, simmered in fragrant coconut and spices. Both dishes highlight their skill at transforming classic Thai recipes with local ingredients.
With a huge menu covering both vegan and gluten-free needs, Taste of Thai Express is a crowd-pleaser, perfect for dinner with friends who all want something just a little bit different.
7. Glenwood Pines
Glenwood Pines has long been a local favorite for its relaxed vibe and lakeside location. You’ll find families, students, and old friends all sharing tables, especially when the sun sets over Cayuga Lake. My first trip here ended with a spontaneous lakeside stroll, full from a classic, satisfying meal.
Seafood lovers should start with the crab cakes—crispy on the outside and packed with sweet crab. The fried scallops are light, not greasy, and pair well with hand-cut fries that come hot and golden. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the fish sandwich is both reliable and tasty.
Glenwood Pines makes you feel right at home, with big portions and unfussy, flavorful plates that remind you of family gatherings by the water.
8. Tokyo Hibachi
(607) 277-8888Call
When you want your meal to be as lively as your company, Tokyo Hibachi is the place to go in Ithaca. The sizzling grills, fast-moving chefs, and table-side theatrics turn dinner into a show. My first hibachi experience here left me with a grin almost as big as my appetite.
The highlight is the shrimp hibachi: juicy, tender shrimp cooked right before you, with colorful veggies and perfectly seasoned rice. If sushi is more your style, their rolls are consistently fresh and vibrant—try anything with crab or eel for a savory treat.
Tokyo Hibachi sticks to the basics but delivers them well. Every visit promises a fun atmosphere and seafood that’s cooked just right, making this spot perfect for groups or celebrations.
9. Doug’s Fish Fry
Doug’s Fish Fry has earned its reputation as a must-try spot for seafood lovers around Ithaca. I remember my first visit for the aroma alone—light, crispy batter and the unmistakable scent of fresh fish being fried just behind the counter.
The real draw is the classic fish fry: golden, crunchy, and never greasy, served with a choice of sides. The fried shrimp basket also stands out for its light coating and juicy shrimp, perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner.
Doug’s doesn’t overcomplicate things. Every dish tastes home-cooked and comforting, which explains why so many locals keep coming back whenever they need a simple, well-done seafood fix.
10. Ron Don’s Village Pub
Ron Don’s Village Pub is where small-town charm meets hearty seafood meals, and it’s the kind of place you want to share with family and friends. I first stopped here on a whim and found myself drawn in by the cozy, familiar atmosphere and friendly faces behind the bar.
The menu is packed with favorites, but the beer-battered fish and chips is a winner—crisp coating, tender fish, and generous portions. The seafood platter also deserves a mention, especially if you like a bit of variety on your plate.
Ron Don’s keeps things relaxed with unfussy food that delivers on taste. It’s comfortable, casual, and a local go-to when you’re craving classic seafood without any pretense.
More Things to Try in Ithaca, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the freshest seafood in Ithaca?
Many locals agree that The Boatyard Grill and Maxie’s Supper Club regularly serve some of the freshest seafood around. Both places get daily deliveries and offer menus packed with well-prepared fish and shellfish options.
Are there seafood restaurants in Ithaca with vegetarian or gluten-free options?
Yes, several top seafood spots such as Taste of Thai Express, Kelly’s Dockside, and Maxie’s Supper Club have vegetarian and gluten-free choices, making dining easy for groups with different dietary needs.
Which Ithaca seafood restaurants offer a lake or waterfront view?
The Boatyard Grill and Glenwood Pines both boast relaxing water views, making any meal feel special. These spots are perfect if you want your seafood dinner paired with scenery.
Can I find Asian-style seafood dishes in Ithaca?
Absolutely. Taste of Thai Express and Tokyo Hibachi both offer excellent Asian-inspired seafood selections, from Thai curries to hibachi-grilled shrimp and sushi rolls.
What seafood dishes should I try in Ithaca?
Don’t miss the grilled salmon at The Boatyard Grill, shrimp pad Thai at Taste of Thai Express, or the crab cakes at Glenwood Pines. These dishes showcase each restaurant’s strengths and have built loyal followings over the years.
