Seafood cravings are real, and when they hit in Johnstown, PA, you want more than just an average plate. The city’s best seafood spots blend old-school comfort with creative twists, satisfying locals and visitors alike. I remember my first seafood platter here—the subtle crunch of perfectly fried fish, the tang of fresh lemon, and a side of hushpuppies that vanished before I even noticed. That meal sparked a personal mission: hunt down the places that get seafood right, every time.
Johnstown’s restaurants offer more than nostalgia. You’ll find fresh catches, house-made specials, and unexpected flavors tucked into every corner of the city. Curious where to dig in next? This guide puts you on the path to great seafood without the tiresome guesswork. Dive in, and taste for yourself where Johnstown’s real seafood gems are hiding.
1. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Johnstown is where cravings for classic seafood meet a polished, dependable setting. The welcoming staff keeps things easy, whether you’re popping in for lunch or settling in for dinner with family. I recall a late afternoon visit where the biscuits seemed to vanish the moment they arrived. There’s something comforting in their familiar flavors.
The Garlic Shrimp Scampi and Wild-Caught Snow Crab Legs both deliver on Red Lobster’s promise of approachable, tasty seafood. The scampi comes sizzling, bathed in a fragrant garlic butter, and the crab legs are always sweet and tender. Both dishes feel both celebratory and accessible—a balance Red Lobster has long mastered.
Choose their Ultimate Feast for a well-rounded introduction to their menu. You’ll get shrimp, crab, and fish, all done with a steady hand that never overcomplicates the basics.
2. The Fish Boat
The Fish Boat is a Johnstown staple where local tradition and fresh flavor meet. This family-run gem has been serving the city since the days when fish sandwiches ruled Main Street. Stepping inside feels like joining a hometown ritual, where friendly faces and sizzling skillets greet you at the door.
Their baked haddock filet is a standout for its tender texture and subtle seasoning. Every bite brings you a taste of home-cooked care, making it easy to see why people keep coming back. I’m convinced that nothing beats their classic flounder sandwich for a quick, satisfying lunch.
For a taste of East Coast comfort, try the Maryland Crab soup. It’s hearty, brimming with rich flavor, and feels just right on a chilly Pennsylvania afternoon.
3. Long John Silver’s
Long John Silver’s brings the taste of the coast right to Scalp Avenue. The place lures you in when you crave crispy, golden seafood without any fuss. My last visit ended with a table full of conversation and a plate polished clean—there’s a reason these baskets are favorites for quick, filling meals.
The wild-caught Alaska pollock is a reliable pick. Its battered coating stays light and avoids overwhelming the flakey fish inside. Each piece offers a crunch that pairs perfectly with their signature tartar sauce.
Their classic combo meals give you a taste of everything—fish, shrimp, and fries. For those chasing nostalgia or needing dinner on the go, Long John Silver’s never complicates a simple pleasure.
4. Carrie’s Kitchen
(814) 535-7899Call
Carrie’s Kitchen on Main Street serves comfort with every bite, blending seafood with soul food in a way that feels both familiar and fresh. The relaxed, homespun atmosphere draws you in before you even catch the inviting aroma from the kitchen. My go-to, after a long week, has been their shrimp and grits—a dish that always reminds me of simple joys and Southern hospitality.
The shrimp and grits here stand out for their creamy texture and just-right seasoning. They never shy away from bold flavors, but nothing ever feels overdone. If you’re feeling adventurous, order fish and grits for a hearty take on a staple that sticks with you all day.
Come hungry, leave happy—that’s the Carrie’s Kitchen way.
5. Surf n’ Turf Inn
(814) 536-9250Call
Surf n’ Turf Inn brings a touch of refinement to Johnstown’s seafood scene. The inviting space blends the comfort of a classic family restaurant with a menu that highlights fresh ingredients and careful preparation. I once celebrated a birthday here with friends; laughter and the scent of broiled fish filled the air, making it an evening to remember.
The broiled salmon is a highlight, arriving perfectly flaked with a subtle zest that complements its natural richness. Each bite signals thoughtfulness in the kitchen, and sides like crisp salads or baked potatoes complete the meal.
If you’re after variety, the seafood platter features an assortment—from shrimp to delicate fillets—showcasing the Inn’s dedication to freshness and balance. Here, every meal feels a little special.
6. Main Moon Chinese Restaurant
(814) 262-9190Call
Main Moon Chinese Restaurant on Scalp Avenue puts a flavorful spin on seafood in Johnstown. The buffet lets you explore a range of dishes, all fresh and inviting. On a rainy afternoon, I found myself warming up with a plate of their steamed shrimp—an ideal antidote to gray skies and soggy shoes.
The seafood options here shine for their consistency and generous servings. The shrimp with broccoli stands out, offering crisp vegetables paired with tender, perfectly cooked shrimp in a light, savory sauce. Their fish with black bean sauce is another solid pick, delivering complex flavors you’ll want to revisit.
Main Moon’s appeal lies in its mix of comfort food and Asian flair, keeping loyal customers coming back for seconds.
7. 56 Buffet
(814) 262-7888Call
56 Buffet offers a seafood adventure that doesn’t break the bank or require reservations. Step inside and you’ll face a spread that feels endless—rows of steaming seafood and vibrant veggies ready for your plate. My fondest memory here involves a table of friends, eyes wide at the sheer variety, weighing our next round with equal parts strategy and curiosity.
The made-to-order hibachi is a must-try, letting you watch shrimp and scallops sizzle to perfection in front of you. The kitchen’s consistency means you rarely end up with anything but tender, well-seasoned bites. Don’t sleep on their fish fillets or the steamed mussels—both deliver simple flavor done right.
56 Buffet stands out for its fresh options and the thrill of sampling several seafood favorites in one meal.
8. Vinco Pizza
(814) 322-1509Call
Vinco Pizza blends neighborhood comfort with a surprisingly robust seafood selection. The casual, welcoming vibe makes you want to linger over good food and conversation. My last visit here, I found myself lured by more than just the pizza—the seafood offerings have their own devoted following.
The shrimp scampi pizza is unique, pairing juicy shrimp with a garlicky sauce and a crisp crust. It’s the sort of specialty pie that keeps you talking about dinner the next day. Their baked cod hoagie is another unexpected winner—flaky white fish tucked into a soft roll with tangy sauce.
Vinco stands out by offering quality, variety, and a little creativity on every plate.
9. Franklin Street Bar & Grill
Franklin Street Bar & Grill is where locals gather for easygoing dining and a menu with plenty of surprises. Tucked on a corner in downtown Johnstown, this spot is known for its casual energy and well-executed comfort food. I spent a rainy evening here once, watching regulars greet each other over plates of crispy fish and chatter drifting from the bar.
Their fish fry sandwiches come out golden and generously portioned—ideal for anyone craving something filling and familiar. The kitchen keeps things simple, letting the freshness of the seafood shine. For more variety, try the shrimp platter, which pairs plump shrimp with sides that actually do them justice.
Franklin Street’s charm lies in its no-fuss, welcoming attitude matched by reliable seafood plates.
10. South Yankee BBQ & Fish Fry
(814) 446-8363Call
South Yankee BBQ & Fish Fry sits just outside Johnstown and brings together two of the region’s great food traditions—barbecue and seafood. The rustic atmosphere and laid-back service make it easy to settle in. On my first visit, the scent from the fryer hit me before I even saw the sign, and I knew I’d made the right choice.
The fried fish here is crisp and flavorful, never oily, with portions that fill you up fast. Each basket comes with sides that feel homemade, perfect for a low-key meal that satisfies. Their fish sandwich, a local lunchtime legend, pairs flaky white fish with a soft bun and house sauce.
If you’re after comfort food with a regional touch, this spot never disappoints.
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood restaurants in Johnstown, PA are known for fresh fish?
Many locals recommend The Fish Boat for its freshly prepared fish sandwiches and platters. Red Lobster and Surf n’ Turf Inn are also popular for consistently fresh seafood options.
Are there any takeout seafood options in Johnstown?
Yes, most seafood restaurants in Johnstown, such as Long John Silver’s, Red Lobster, and The Fish Boat, offer takeout. Several, like 56 Buffet and Main Moon, provide buffet and carryout as well.
Which places have seafood and other menu choices for non-seafood eaters?
Spots like Vinco Pizza, Franklin Street Bar & Grill, and Carrie’s Kitchen serve seafood alongside a full range of pizzas, sandwiches, and comforting sides.
Where can I find seafood with a unique twist in Johnstown?
Try Carrie’s Kitchen for shrimp and grits or Vinco Pizza’s shrimp scampi pizza if you want something different from the usual fried fish platters.
Do Johnstown seafood restaurants offer gluten-free or healthier seafood choices?
Red Lobster and Surf n’ Turf Inn offer grilled and broiled seafood options for a lighter meal. Always check the menu or call ahead for specific requests, as options may change.