Finding good seafood in Lexington, KY is a bit like finding a pearl inside a landlocked oyster—you don’t expect much, but once you get a taste, you want to tell everyone about it. I remember my first seafood dinner here. I was skeptical, expecting bland shrimp and soggy fries. Instead, I stumbled into a local spot where the grilled salmon was bright, tender, and unforgettable. Since then, I’ve uncovered a handful of local gems I almost want to keep secret.
If you’ve wandered Lexington’s streets craving something fresh from the sea, you know it’s not about the fanciest menu or the biggest plate. It’s about finding that sweet spot between quality, flavor, and atmosphere. I’ve waded through baskets of catfish, towers of oysters, and sushi rolls that made me question if I was still in Kentucky. Stick around, and you’ll get a short, honest tour of the best seafood spots in Lexington—no bait and switch.
1. Zen Sushi & Sake
Nestled in Lakecrest, Zen Sushi & Sake is a treasure for seafood lovers who crave authenticity. The moment you walk in, the laid-back vibe and friendly staff set a refreshing tone that’s anything but stuffy. I once tried the chef’s omakase here and found myself savoring every bite, never missing the coast for a second.
What makes Zen truly stand out is their dedication to freshness. Fish arrive straight from Japan three times a week, so every plate bursts with quality. The nigiri and sashimi are pristine—go for the fatty tuna or salmon. Their specialty rolls, like the Lakecrest Roll, showcase both inventive flavor and skill. If you’re searching for the real deal, Zen delivers.
2. Tony’s of Lexington
Tony’s of Lexington combines a classic steakhouse vibe with polished, modern touches. My visit there was memorable for the lively atmosphere and attentive staff who never hovered but never missed a beat, either.
Though known for steaks, Tony’s does seafood justice. The sea bass stands out—light, flaky, and full of rich, subtle flavor. The shrimp cocktail arrives perfectly chilled and snappy, and the seafood pastas rival anything on the menu for freshness.
If you only order one thing, make it the sea bass. Freshness is front and center, and the careful preparation lets each ingredient shine. Tony’s makes seafood the star, even without an ocean nearby.
3. Palmers Fresh Grill
Palmers Fresh Grill offers more than just great food—it’s about the details. The lakeside patio, live music, and laid-back yet sophisticated ambiance make it feel like a hidden retreat. I still remember a quiet dinner there while the sun set over the water, the air filled with warmth and jazz.
What really sets Palmers apart is their focus on fresh, seasonal flavors. Their seafood is always on point. The blackened mahi-mahi is bright and zesty, while the grilled salmon is tender and flaky, paired with imaginative sides like basil rice or roasted vegetables. Seafood lovers will appreciate the rotation of weekly specials that put the spotlight on what’s in season.
If you see the seared scallops offered, dive in. They’re seared to a perfect golden edge, paired with light sauces that don’t overpower. Palmers matches their relaxed style with seafood that’s equally memorable and fresh.
4. Bonefish Grill
Bonefish Grill brings a polished take on seafood with a menu built around bold flavors and reliable freshness. I’ve stopped by more times than I care to admit, drawn by the crackle from the open kitchen and the glow of hand-cut fish hitting the wood-fired grill.
The signature touch here is that perfect grill char, noticeable from your first bite of their grilled salmon or the delicately spiced mahi-mahi. The Bang Bang Shrimp is a local legend for those who like a little kick, always crisp and never greasy. Even the sides—like their seasonal vegetables—keep things fresh and light.
If you enjoy trying chef creations, ask for their Partner Selection. There’s always something new, and you never walk away feeling underwhelmed. Bonefish nails the familiar and the adventurous in every plate.
5. Smithtown Seafood
Smithtown Seafood is tucked beside West Sixth Brewing, and it quickly won me over with its no-nonsense comfort and a menu that punches above its weight. My first visit felt like visiting a friend’s kitchen—relaxed, inviting, and filled with the smell of golden, just-fried fish.
Smithtown shines by keeping things simple and letting the seafood do the talking. The catfish is always crisp and flavorful, making it a must-try if you’re new. I’m a regular for their blackened tilapia, which delivers big taste without being heavy. If you’re hungry, try a seafood platter for variety. All are best with their house-made sauces, tangy and sharp.
No need for white tablecloths here—it’s about good food, fast service, and seafood cooked the way it should be.
6. The Ketch Seafood Grill
The Ketch Seafood Grill feels like a beach vacation dropped right in the heart of Lexington. My last trip in left me wishing I could bottle the laid-back vibe and take it home. With friendly service and walls adorned with nautical kitsch, it’s as cozy as it is unpretentious.
The real draw is the variety. Fried catfish and hand-breaded cod are crowd-pleasers, crisp and light without being oily. The grilled salmon is another highlight—perfectly cooked and never overshadowed by heavy sauces. Their seafood basket is ideal if you want to sample a bit of everything.
This is the kind of spot where families linger over hush puppies and regulars always order the day’s fresh catch. It’s simple, local, and consistently good.
7. Charlie’s Fresh Seafood
Charlie’s Fresh Seafood is a local staple for anyone craving top-tier takeout or looking to pick up quality fish to cook at home. My first visit was a classic case of under-promising and over-delivering—one bite into their fried tilapia and I wondered why I’d waited so long to try it.
This spot stands out for its fresh selection and no-frills approach. You’ll find cases of beautiful, ready-to-cook fish beside a well-loved menu of fried and grilled options. The fried catfish and hand-breaded shrimp have a loyal following; both come out crisp and satisfyingly light.
If you’re short on time but picky about quality, Charlie’s gets it right. Grab a platter and discover why locals swear by this hidden gem.
8. Red Lobster
Red Lobster delivers on its reputation for accessible seafood, making it a familiar favorite whether you’re dining with family or just craving something you trust. On my last visit, the staff was cheerful, and the menu gave me that “something-for-everyone” comfort that’s sometimes hard to find.
What sets Red Lobster apart in Lexington is consistency. The wood-grilled salmon is a go-to—moist, flavorful, and never disappointing. The grilled shrimp skewers are reliably good, ideal if you’re after something light that still packs a punch. Fans of variety can build their own combination platters, which always land with plenty of sides and signature cheddar biscuits.
Red Lobster’s straightforward style means you can relax, settle in, and let the seafood do the talking. It’s reliable, family-friendly, and always fresh.
9. Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse, Lexington
Jeff Ruby’s Steakhouse, Lexington is the sort of place where every meal feels like an event—a little glitz, a little glamour, and plenty of attentive service. My experience here felt more like a polished performance than ordinary dining, with each course perfectly timed and plated.
While famous for steak, their seafood offerings truly impress. The pan-seared scallops are impossibly tender, while the chilled seafood tower is a conversation starter all its own, loaded with fresh selections that suit any craving. The sushi is unexpectedly refined, and the salmon is always cooked just right—never dry, always flavorful.
When you want seafood with upscale flair in Lexington, Jeff Ruby’s delivers. The quality, presentation, and energy here can make even the simplest meal feel memorable.
10. Red Lobster
Red Lobster on Alysheba Way offers the same trusted experience as its sister locations—dependable, friendly, and tailored for groups who want it easy. My last meal there was seamless, with fast service and that signature warmth that puts you at ease.
What keeps people coming back is their variety. Platters with wood-grilled salmon or shrimp hit the mark for fresh flavor every time. If you like a little bit of everything, their create-your-own combo is a crowd-pleaser and always generously portioned. The cheddar biscuits, of course, are impossible to resist.
Red Lobster isn’t chasing trends; it’s sticking to what works—reliable seafood, clean presentation, and fast, helpful staff that keep things moving without ever feeling rushed.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Lexington, KY?
Some local favorites include Zen Sushi & Sake, Tony’s of Lexington, Palmers Fresh Grill, The Ketch Seafood Grill, and Smithtown Seafood. Each spot puts its own spin on fresh, high-quality seafood.
Where can I find fresh fish or seafood to cook at home?
Charlie’s Fresh Seafood offers a well-stocked fish market along with their takeout menu. Local supermarkets and specialty stores sometimes carry good options, but Charlie’s is known for consistent quality.
Are there halal or vegetarian seafood options available?
Several places such as Zen Sushi & Sake and Palmers Fresh Grill offer vegetarian and vegan selections. For halal-friendly options, it’s best to call ahead and ask about menu specifics since most locations focus on regional seafood.
Which seafood dishes should I try in Lexington?
Go for signature offerings like Zen’s nigiri and sashimi, Tony’s sea bass, the blackened mahi-mahi at Palmers, or Smithtown Seafood’s catfish. Each dish reflects the chef’s style—with a focus on freshness and balance.
Can I get takeout from local seafood restaurants?
Yes, most seafood spots in Lexington, including Smithtown Seafood, The Ketch, and Charlie’s, offer convenient takeout for those nights when you want top-tier seafood at home.
