Long Beach, NY, is a haven for seafood lovers seeking fresh, flavorful catches right from the Atlantic. Over the years, I’ve discovered that the best seafood spots here don’t rely on fancy gimmicks but focus on delivering quality and authentic taste. Whether it’s a casual shack by the beach or a cozy restaurant with a view, Long Beach offers a variety of options that satisfy even the most discerning seafood enthusiast. Being a fan of good seafood myself, I’ve found that the secret often lies in simple preparations that highlight the ocean’s true flavors.
What makes Long Beach’s seafood scene stand out is its local charm and commitment to freshness. From succulent oysters to perfectly grilled fish, these eateries combine tradition and creativity to craft memorable dishes. If you’re in search of a genuine seafood experience, you’ll want trusted guidance to navigate this vibrant culinary landscape. Rest assured, the spots listed here are selected for their quality, atmosphere, and dedication to serving unforgettable seafood—and they’re sure to satisfy your craving for the best that Long Beach has to offer.
Where to find the best seafood in Long Beach, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Long Beach, NY:
- Five Ocean
- Atlantica Restaurant
- The Ugly Duckling
- Long Beach Inn
- Minnesota’s Grill & Bar
- Shakes & Shuckers
- The Currywurst Company
- WildFeast
- Stone Crab
- The Whales Tails Seafood Bar & Grill
1. Five Ocean
Located at 5 New York Ave, Five Ocean is a standout spot for seafood lovers visiting Long Beach. With its inviting atmosphere and friendly service, it offers a perfect setting for any meal—whether breakfast, lunch, or dinner. I’ve enjoyed their welcoming vibe and fresh dishes, which truly capture the essence of coastal cuisine.
What sets Five Ocean apart is its dedication to quality and variety. The menu features standout items like their signature grilled fish and seasoned oysters, both reflecting the restaurant’s commitment to freshness and flavor. For a true taste of Long Beach seafood, I recommend trying their clam strips and lobster roll—they’re delicious representations of their style. Each bite showcases the chef’s skill in highlighting natural seafood flavors.
2. Atlantica Restaurant
Perched on the mezzanine level at the Allegria Hotel, Atlantica Restaurant offers more than just a meal — it provides a view worth lingering over. I’ve enjoyed the stunning vistas of ships at anchor, the surf crashing on the beach, and breathtaking sunsets that make every dining experience memorable. The elegant interior, with its beveled mirrors and colorful jellyfish-inspired lighting, complements the spectacular scenery outside.
What sets Atlantica apart is its perfect blend of gourmet cuisine and a prime location along Long Beach’s bustling boardwalk. Their seafood dishes, like the fresh lobster and delicately prepared clams, reflect both quality and creativity. I highly recommend their shrimp platter, which showcases their mastery in highlighting natural flavors while maintaining a sophisticated presentation.
3. The Ugly Duckling
Located at 906 W Beech St, The Ugly Duckling offers a cozy yet lively atmosphere blending American classics with fresh seafood. I’ve enjoyed their laid-back vibe during casual dinners, where the friendly staff make everyone feel right at home. Their mix of pub-style ambiance with quality seafood creates a unique spot to unwind.
What makes The Ugly Duckling stand out is its commitment to fresh ingredients and hearty flavors. Their clam chowder and grilled fish tacos are favorites, displaying a perfect balance of flavor and freshness. For a satisfying seafood experience, I recommend trying their crab cakes—they’re crispy, flavorful, and reflect the restaurant’s dedication to quality and comfort.
4. Long Beach Inn
Situated at 943 W Beech St, Long Beach Inn is a local favorite for flavorful seafood and hearty American dishes. I’ve enjoyed their inviting atmosphere during my visits, where the friendly staff makes every meal feel like a small celebration. The cozy setting makes it perfect for casual family dinners or a relaxed outing with friends.
What makes Long Beach Inn special is its consistent quality and versatile menu. Their clam strips and classic fish and chips showcase their expertise in preparing fresh seafood. For a satisfying bite, I recommend their shrimp basket—crispy, flavorful, and made with fresh ingredients, reflecting their commitment to quality and comfort.
5. Minnesota’s Grill & Bar
Located at 959 W Beech St, Minnesota’s Grill & Bar has been a staple in Long Beach since 1994. I’ve always appreciated its lively atmosphere, especially when enjoying live music and its bustling bar scene. The recent renovations have made it even more inviting, blending casual comfort with a touch of modern style.
What sets Minnesota’s apart is its dedication to good vibes and quality. Their seafood options, like the crispy fish tacos and lobster rolls, perfectly capture the restaurant’s fun, fresh approach. For a satisfying meal that showcases their attention to flavor, I recommend the seafood platter—laden with a variety of fresh catches and ideal for sharing or enjoying solo.
6. Shakes & Shuckers
Situated at 1 Lincoln Blvd, Shakes & Shuckers offers a fresh take on classic seafood. I’ve visited a few times and always appreciate the casual, welcoming vibe that makes it feel like a seaside retreat. Their focus on quality seafood and lively atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed yet satisfying meal.
What makes Shakes & Shuckers stand out is their commitment to freshness and variety. Their oysters and shrimp baskets are standout dishes, showcasing natural flavors with minimal fuss. For a true taste of Long Beach seafood, I recommend trying their stone crab claws—they’re a prime example of the quality and expertise reflected in their offerings.
7. The Currywurst Company
(516) 665-3150Call
Located at 10 W Park Ave, The Currywurst Company offers a unique fusion of flavors, blending traditional seafood dishes with international spices. I enjoyed their vibrant atmosphere and creative menu, which makes dining here feel both fun and flavorful. Though known for their diverse cuisine, their seafood options shine for their freshness and bold seasonings.
What makes The Currywurst Company stand out is its inventive approach to seafood, like the flavorful shrimp curry and spiced fish tacos. These dishes reflect their commitment to quality and a delightful sensory experience. For a memorable bite, I recommend trying their calamari—lightly seasoned and perfectly cooked, it perfectly showcases their style of combining global influences with fresh ingredients.
8. WildFeast
(516) 442-7284Call
Located at 10 W Park Ave, WildFeast is a go-to spot for seafood lovers seeking fresh, flavorful dishes. I’ve often enjoyed their relaxed atmosphere during weekend brunches, where the quality of their seafood consistently impresses. Their versatile menu caters to breakfast, brunch, and lunch, making it a perfect place for any time of day.
What makes WildFeast stand out is its dedication to freshness and bold flavors. Their clam chowder and grilled fish sandwiches are favorites, highlighting their commitment to quality ingredients. For a satisfying experience, I recommend their seafood platter—generous, well-prepared, and packed with taste that truly reflects their style of culinary excellence.
9. Stone Crab
(516) 280-8700Call
Located at 888 W Beech St, Stone Crab is a beloved seafood restaurant in Long Beach’s West End. I’ve enjoyed their inviting atmosphere and the fresh, expertly prepared dishes every time I visit. It’s a place that feels like a neighborhood gem, perfect for relaxing dinners with friends or family.
What makes Stone Crab stand out is its focus on quality seafood and classic flavors. Their stone crab claws and calamari are standout items, showcasing their commitment to freshness. For a true taste of Long Beach, I recommend trying their lobster roll, which offers a rich, buttery flavor—an authentic reflection of their dedication to top-tier seafood.
10. The Whales Tails Seafood Bar & Grill
At 916 W Beech St, The Whales Tails Seafood Bar & Grill offers a lively atmosphere with a focus on fresh seafood and classic grill favorites. I’ve enjoyed their welcoming vibe and well-executed dishes, making it my go-to spot for a satisfying seaside meal in Long Beach’s West End.
What makes The Whales Tails stand out is its combination of quality ingredients and a fun bar scene. Their grilled salmon and coconut shrimp are excellent choices, showcasing their dedication to flavorful, well-prepared seafood. For a real treat, I suggest trying their seafood platter—generous portions that embody their commitment to fresh, quality seafood with a hint of upscale flair.
More Things to Try in Long Beach, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are the best seafood restaurants in Long Beach, NY?
A: Some top-rated spots include Five Ocean, Atlantica Restaurant, WildFeast, and Stone Crab. These places are known for their fresh seafood and great atmosphere.
Q: Are there seafood options for breakfast or brunch in Long Beach?
A: Yes, restaurants like WildFeast offer breakfast and brunch dishes featuring seafood, such as shrimp and fish specials, perfect for a mid-morning or early afternoon treat.
Q: Do seafood restaurants in Long Beach serve healthy options?
A: Absolutely. Many places focus on fresh, grilled, or baked seafood options that are both flavorful and nutritious, like grilled salmon or seafood salads.
Q: Can I get fresh oysters in Long Beach?
A: Yes, several seafood spots, including Shakes & Shuckers, serve fresh oysters daily, highlighting the local bounty of the Atlantic.
Q: Are there seafood restaurants with outdoor seating?
A: Yes, several venues, including Minnesota’s Grill & Bar, offer outdoor seating where you can enjoy fresh seafood with a view of the beach or boardwalk.