Lumberton, NC may not be a coastal town, but don’t let that fool you—its seafood scene punches well above its weight. Whether you’re craving buttery shrimp, flaky fried fish, or a hearty crab boil, this small city delivers with spots that prioritize fresh, halal-friendly options. I’ve spent weekends chasing the perfect seafood platter here, from no-frills joints to hidden gems where the hushpuppies are crisp and the oysters don’t disappoint.
What stands out isn’t just the quality but the care these places take in sourcing and preparation. Halal-conscious diners can breathe easy; several spots go the extra mile to ensure compliance without skimping on flavor. Below, we’ll dive into the top picks—where the tartar sauce is zesty, the service is warm, and the seafood tastes like it jumped straight from the ocean to your plate.
1. Pier 41 Seafood
Pier 41 Seafood is a standout in Lumberton, offering a family-style dining experience that feels both welcoming and authentic. Located on East Elizabethtown Road, this spot has become a go-to for seafood lovers, thanks to its commitment to fresh, flavorful dishes. The moment you step in, the aroma of fried flounder and broiled shrimp sets the tone for a memorable meal.
What makes Pier 41 special is its balance of variety and quality. While their seafood shines—think perfectly seasoned shrimp and tender scallops—they also cater to diverse tastes with non-seafood options. For halal-conscious diners, their broiled fish dishes are a safe and delicious choice, prepared with care and attention to detail.
Don’t miss their flounder, lightly fried to golden perfection, or the devil crab, a local favorite that’s rich and satisfying. Pair it with their hushpuppies for a true Southern touch. Pier 41’s dedication to fresh ingredients and warm hospitality makes it a must-visit for anyone craving seafood in Lumberton.
2. Roys Country Corral
Roys Country Corral, nestled on Wire Grass Road, is a hidden gem in Lumberton that combines rustic charm with hearty, satisfying meals. This family-friendly spot feels like a warm embrace, with its cozy atmosphere and attentive service. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind after a long day and enjoy a meal that feels like home.
What sets Roys apart is its focus on fresh, locally sourced ingredients, especially when it comes to seafood. Their broiled fish dishes are a standout, offering a lighter yet flavorful option for halal-conscious diners. The shrimp platter, served with a side of their signature coleslaw, is another must-try, showcasing their commitment to quality and taste.
For a true taste of Roys, go for their flounder—lightly seasoned and perfectly cooked. Pair it with their hushpuppies for a classic Southern touch. Roys Country Corral’s dedication to simplicity and flavor makes it a standout choice for seafood in Lumberton.
3. Captain D’s
Captain D’s on North Roberts Avenue brings fast, affordable seafood to Lumberton without sacrificing flavor. While it’s a chain, this location nails the basics—crispy batter, tender fish, and service that’s quicker than you’d expect. I’ve stopped here after long drives when only hot, golden-brown shrimp would hit the spot, and they’ve never disappointed.
What makes this Captain D’s work is its consistency. Their grilled tilapia—mild, flaky, and halal-friendly—is a reliable choice for those avoiding fried options. The batter-fried cod, though, is the star: crunchy outside, moist inside, with just enough seasoning to let the fish shine. It’s classic fast-food seafood done right.
Order the two-piece fish combo with crispy fries and their oddly addictive hushpuppies. For halal diners, stick to grilled items and sides. No frills, no fuss—just solid seafood that hits the craving every time.
4. Village Inn Seafood and BBQ
Village Inn Seafood and BBQ, located on Martin Luther King Jr Drive, is a Lumberton staple that combines Calabash-style seafood with Southern BBQ in a way that feels both generous and authentic. The moment you walk in, the aroma of pit-cooked meats and fried seafood sets the stage for a hearty meal. It’s the kind of place where portions are large, and the hospitality feels like family.
What makes Village Inn stand out is its commitment to freshness and flavor. Their broiled fish dishes, a halal-friendly option, are simple yet satisfying, letting the quality of the seafood speak for itself. The shrimp platter, served with their in-house slaw and hushpuppies, is a crowd-pleaser that showcases their attention to detail.
For a true taste of Village Inn, try their flounder—lightly fried and perfectly crisp. Pair it with their coleslaw for a refreshing contrast. Village Inn’s dedication to hearty, flavorful meals makes it a must-visit for seafood lovers in Lumberton.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Are there halal-friendly seafood options in Lumberton, NC?
Yes, several seafood restaurants in Lumberton offer halal-friendly options, such as broiled or grilled fish dishes. Always confirm with the restaurant to ensure compliance with halal standards.
Q: What’s the best seafood restaurant for families in Lumberton?
Pier 41 Seafood is a great choice for families, offering a welcoming atmosphere and a diverse menu that includes both seafood and non-seafood options.
Q: Where can I find Calabash-style seafood in Lumberton?
Village Inn Seafood and BBQ specializes in Calabash-style seafood, known for its light, crispy batter and generous portions.
Q: Are there affordable seafood options in Lumberton?
Captain D’s provides fast, affordable seafood with consistent quality, making it a popular choice for budget-conscious diners.
Q: Do seafood restaurants in Lumberton offer takeout?
Yes, most seafood restaurants in Lumberton, including Roys Country Corral and Village Inn Seafood and BBQ, offer takeout options for convenience.