Curiosity about seafood in Manorville, NY often leads to a delightful tangle of choices. The first time I tried to answer the simple question, “Where do I get the best lobster roll in this corner of Long Island?” I ended up with a notepad full of names, ranging from hidden fish markets to busy, family-run clam bars. Manorville and its nearby towns offer a string of gems for anyone who likes their fish fresh and their shellfish memorable. Some sit along quiet highways, others are tucked beside bustling marinas, but each one brings its own style to the table.
What’s the real difference between a classic crab shack, a local market, and a pizzeria serving up perfect calamari? I’ve made it my mission (and dinner) to find out. Consider this your road map to the best spots for seafood, from the understated local favorites to the spots that draw crowds all summer. This guide highlights not only where to eat, but what makes each place stand out. Hungry yet? Let’s dig into Manorville’s top seafood experiences.
Where to find the best seafood in Manorville, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Manorville, NY:
- Joe’s Crab Shack
- Atlantic Seafood Fish Market
- Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria
- Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery
- Citi Island Seafood
- Buoy One
- California Fish and Chips
- John Scott’s Surf Shack
- Westhampton Raw Bar and Seafood Market
- Popei’s Clam Bar
1. Joe’s Crab Shack
Joe’s Crab Shack is one of the most recognizable names for seafood in the Manorville area. The Riverhead location brings relaxed, nautical charm and plenty of lively energy. On my last visit, co-workers dragged me in after a long day; we ended up laughing over a mountain of snow crab legs and juicy shrimp. It’s a place where friends or families can crack shells and make a mess together.
The menu leans into crowd-pleasing favorites. You can’t go wrong with the classic steampots—a mix of crab, potatoes, and corn steamed in seasoned broth. The fish and chips, served crisp and golden, is another local favorite. If you’re in the mood for variety, the sampler platters give a great sense of the kitchen’s range, from fried seafood to delicate grilled fish.
2. Atlantic Seafood Fish Market
(631) 878-8406Call
Atlantic Seafood Fish Market has that rare market-meets-eatery vibe that gives seafood lovers options, whether you want to cook at home or let someone else handle the stove. Right on Main Street in Center Moriches, it has a low-key, local feel—no pretense, just honest freshness. I once popped in for a quick look and couldn’t resist walking out with a bag of their just-caught flounder and a made-to-order shrimp roll.
One of its real strengths is variety. You’ll find everything from live clams to fresh salmon, displayed on ice and ready for your next meal. If you’re eating in, the fried platters usually draw a crowd, but the grilled fillets offer a lighter alternative, each seasoned perfectly and showcasing straight-from-the-water flavor.
3. Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria
(631) 849-6622Call
Papa Francescos Restaurant And Pizzeria is much more than a neighborhood pizza spot. It’s tucked away on Whitestone Road, but everyone in the area seems to have a story about a memorable meal here. During my last visit, a friend insisted I try their seafood pizza. I was skeptical, but the thin crust piled high with tender shrimp and calamari won me over—flavorful and not weighed down by sauce or cheese.
If you want something a little more traditional, the linguine with white clam sauce hits all the right notes. The clams are always fresh, and the simple garlic-wine sauce lets their flavor shine. Their seafood-based specials rotate often, so there’s always a new reason to return. This spot balances Italian comfort with coastal freshness.
4. Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery
Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery delivers a rare combination of top-quality seafood and a polished dining atmosphere. I remember ducking in after a rainy afternoon along the Long Island Sound; the bright, inviting space and aroma of grilled fish set the scene for a memorable meal. The market next door teems with fresh selections, but the dining room is where Chef Jose’s twenty years of experience shine through.
Standouts on the menu include the blackened fish tacos and the pan-seared scallops. Each dish showcases careful technique and an appreciation for local ingredients. For those seeking variety, the daily specials are always worth asking about. The dining experience here balances comfort with a touch of elegance, making Oceans 5 a destination for both casual lunches and special occasions.
5. Citi Island Seafood
(631) 772-7227Call
Citi Island Seafood is one of those hidden spots where seafood cravings get answered fast. Tucked in Shirley, it draws a loyal crowd that knows real flavor doesn’t need a white tablecloth. My last stop here was a cold weeknight, but the fried fish sandwich made it all worth it—lightly battered, flaky, and paired with simple, zesty slaw.
The standout dish here is their shrimp platter. Fresh shrimp are seasoned, fried, and served crisp, making it a satisfying option for lunch or dinner. House-made sides, like their fries and coleslaw, round out the meal. Citi Island’s approach is all about generous portions and solid quality, so it’s perfect for when you want seafood done right without any fuss.
6. Buoy One
Buoy One blends the easy energy of a roadside seafood shack with the careful sourcing of a true fish market. My first meal here was at one of their outdoor picnic tables, where a salty breeze made the fresh catch taste even better. It’s the kind of place where you see both locals and vacationers tucking into big, satisfying plates.
The grilled local fish is the way to go. It’s always perfectly done and never over-seasoned, letting the natural sweetness stand out. Their raw bar—stocked with Long Island clams and oysters—brings the flavors of the bay right to your plate. Everything on the menu feels honest, making Buoy One a reliable choice for fresh, no-nonsense seafood near Manorville.
7. California Fish and Chips
(631) 731-3474Call
California Fish and Chips combines a classic coastal vibe with quick, quality service—a rare find in Mastic Beach. My first visit involved a simple order of fish and chips, but the golden, crisp batter and flaky white fish had me coming back. There’s something timeless about getting seafood made right, without fuss or frills.
The star here is the fish and chips basket. Each piece comes out hot and light, with fries that strike the perfect salty balance. If you want to branch out, the fried shrimp are another winner, offering crunch and freshness in every bite. The menu is tight but focused, making this spot dependable for anyone who wants honest comfort food by the bay.
8. John Scott’s Surf Shack
John Scott’s Surf Shack brings a breezy, toes-in-the-sand attitude to Dune Road in Westhampton Beach. It’s the kind of oceanfront spot that feels like summer, no matter the season. I first stopped in after a long beach walk, and the casual energy matched the sunny view perfectly.
The grilled fish tacos are the dish to try here. Light, zesty, and topped with fresh slaw, they capture the Surf Shack’s laid-back spirit. If you’re in the mood for something shareable, the seafood sampler offers a bit of everything—great for a group. Whether you drop by in flip-flops or need a break after sunbathing, this spot makes local seafood effortlessly fun.
9. Westhampton Raw Bar and Seafood Market
(631) 998-3269Call
Westhampton Raw Bar and Seafood Market strikes a balance between fresh seafood retail and casual, coastal dining. Walking in, the glass cases packed with clams, oysters, and whole fish set the tone: this is a place focused on serious quality. My most recent visit turned into a spontaneous lunch, and the raw bar selections tasted like they’d come straight off the boat.
The little neck clams and oysters are must-tries. Their briny, clean flavor says it all about freshness. For something more filling, go for the grilled fish sandwich, served on a toasted bun and dressed simply to let the fish shine. This spot makes seafood feel both approachable and special, with market finds just a few steps away from the dining counter.
10. Popei’s Clam Bar
Popei’s Clam Bar is a staple for anyone exploring the seafood scene near Manorville. There’s an easy, welcoming vibe here, built on decades of serving the community. My first visit was on a recommendation; I ordered the classic clam chowder and never looked back. The staff greets regulars by name, but newcomers are always treated like family.
The fried clam strips are a hallmark: golden, tender, and never greasy. If you want something more substantial, the broiled seafood platter brings a bit of everything, always cooked just right. Popei’s stands out for high turnover and fresh supply, so every dish has that straight-from-the-water quality you hope for in a true clam bar.
More Things to Try in Manorville, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Manorville, NY?
The area around Manorville is packed with options. Favorites include Buoy One, Popei’s Clam Bar, Atlantic Seafood Fish Market, and Oceans 5 Seafood Market and Eatery. Each has its own style, from casual shacks to sit-down dining.
Where can I get fresh, local fish near Manorville?
Atlantic Seafood Fish Market and Westhampton Raw Bar and Seafood Market both offer fresh catches daily. They’re great for everything from fillets to shellfish—either to take home or enjoy cooked on site.
Are there casual seafood spots for families?
Yes, Joe’s Crab Shack, Buoy One, and California Fish and Chips are all good for families, with easygoing atmospheres and menus that keep everyone happy.
Which places have gluten-free seafood options?
Many seafood spots in and around Manorville, including Oceans 5 and Buoy One, offer grilled fish or shellfish dishes that suit gluten-free diets. Always double-check with your server to be sure.
Do any seafood restaurants have outdoor seating?
Several local favorites, like John Scott’s Surf Shack and Buoy One, offer outdoor seating. It’s a great way to enjoy the meal and the Long Island air at the same time.
