In Medford, NY, seafood spots are a conversation topic all their own. Whether you’re craving classics like grilled salmon or searching for the perfect bowl of clam chowder, there’s always somewhere new to discover. I’ve spent many evenings chasing down the freshest catch, sometimes guided by the flicker of neon signs and sometimes by the buzz of locals sharing tips in line at local markets. The hunt becomes a little adventure, especially when you stumble upon a plate of tender calamari so good, it prompts silent nods of approval among friends.
Finding great seafood in Medford is not about luck; it’s about knowing where to look. This guide brings you all my favorite haunts—from the bustling clam bars to the cozy dockside grills. I’ve dug through menus, asked probing questions, and sidestepped any spot with a tired fish tank in the front. If you’re ready to taste the best, this list will point you in the right direction. Hungry yet? Let’s get to it.
Where to find the best seafood in Medford, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Medford, NY:
- Mama Bella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Long Island Seafood
- Harbor Crab
- Lombardi’s on the Bay
- Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
- The Cull House
- Oar Steak & Seafood Grill
- Nancy’s Crab Shack
- Catch Oyster Bar
1. Mama Bella’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
If you think “pizza” every time you hear Mama Bella’s, you’re only half right. **The menu reads like a local’s wish-list**, with Italian comfort, classic American, and enough seafood to keep you curious. I once ducked in for a late lunch and was lured away from my pizza order by the sight of seafood linguine arriving at the next table—steaming, garlicky, and loaded with plump shrimp.
**Their seafood pasta is the real star**, featuring perfectly cooked shellfish tangled in fresh, al dente noodles. Don’t skip the baked clams—they’re golden, herby, and hit with just enough citrus. Even the fried calamari has a loyal crowd, crisp without being greasy.
**Mama Bella’s stands out for generous plates, unfussy comfort, and staff who know their regulars by name**. This is a friendly spot for a relaxed, satisfying meal, especially when you pull up a chair and let the seafood lead.
2. Long Island Seafood
(631) 627-8644Call
Long Island Seafood delivers a straight-up, no-nonsense seafood experience. **Step inside, and you’re greeted by the clean, ocean-fresh aroma—always a good sign.** On my last visit, I watched as a regular picked out fillets for dinner, while I leaned toward the hot counter, tempted by the battered filets and daily specials.
**What sets this spot apart is the blend of fish market freshness and fast-casual service.** You can grab fresh catches to cook at home or let their kitchen handle it for you. The fried flounder sandwich is a local favorite: flaky, lightly breaded, and never greasy.
If you’re feeling indecisive, the **seafood combo platter** gives you a taste of everything, perfect for sharing or satisfying big cravings. Long Island Seafood is all about quality without fuss, making it a solid pick for both busy weeknights and lazy weekends.
3. Harbor Crab
Harbor Crab balances casual charm with a bit of riverfront excitement. **Sip your drink over two levels of waterfront seating** while the boats drift past—on my last visit, the sun set as live music floated from the bar. It’s a spot where every table feels like the “good one.”
**Their menu brings seafood to center stage**, from sweet, meaty crab legs to their coconut shrimp, which manages to be both crisp and tender. There’s plenty here for those chasing variety, but the lobster roll deserves your attention: it comes generously filled and never overdressed.
What makes Harbor Crab stand out is the combination of atmosphere and taste. **Good food, friendly staff, and a view that turns dinner into an easy-going escape**—that’s why locals keep coming back.
4. Lombardi’s on the Bay
Lombardi’s on the Bay brings together grand waterfront views and classic Italian-American flair. **I once reserved a window seat for a milestone dinner and found the sunset almost as impressive as the menu.** It’s an elegant space that manages to feel relaxed—whether you’re inside or out on the terrace.
**Seafood is handled with the attention it deserves here.** The branzino shines, simply grilled with herbs, letting the flavor of the fresh fish come through. Their seafood fra diavolo stands out too: a generous heap of shellfish in a sauce with just the right amount of heat.
It’s a favorite for anyone wanting **refined, well-executed seafood in Medford with a premium backdrop.** If you want the kind of meal you’ll talk about later, this is your table.
5. Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant
Popeis Clam Bar and Restaurant feels like a casual beacon for seafood lovers. **Pull up a stool, grab a paper menu, and settle in for unfussy, fresh fare.** I still remember my first visit for a late lunch; the place buzzed with families sharing big platters and friends toasting over baskets of fried seafood.
**Their clam strips set the tone**—light, crispy, and never rubbery. The lobster bisque comes rich and silky, packed with flavor rather than filler. If you’re aiming for variety, the seafood sampler lets you taste your way across fried and broiled favorites.
Popeis stands out for delivering **generous portions at wallet-friendly prices**, with the kind of reliability that builds regulars. For classic seafood without pretense, this local staple makes it easy to keep coming back.
6. The Cull House
The Cull House is a seafood lover’s hideaway, steady and welcoming since the late ’70s. **Walking in, you can almost feel the history—this is a place people return to over decades.** My last outing became a two-hour feast, with locals chiming in about their favorite dishes and staff offering tips on the daily catch.
**Oysters here are a must—ice-cold, briny, and bright with a dash of lemon.** The broiled scallops, sweet and perfectly cooked, are another standout. For those who like a little adventure, the fisherman’s stew simmers with fresh fish and shellfish, soaked in a subtly spicy broth that keeps you reaching for more bread.
It’s the sense of tradition and fresh variety that makes **The Cull House a go-to for seafood fans looking for both comfort and quality in Medford’s orbit.**
7. Oar Steak & Seafood Grill
Oar Steak & Seafood Grill feels like stepping into a local legend. **Decorated with oars signed by loyal regulars, the space buzzes with a friendly vibe only years of good service can build.** My last visit lasted well into sunset—the view over the Patchogue River made every dish feel just a little more special.
**Seafood is always front and center here.** The grilled swordfish is firm and juicy, dressed lightly to highlight the fish, while the seared scallops arrive with a whisper of sweetness that pairs perfectly with the house-made sides. Those in the know order the seafood risotto; it’s creamy, rich, and generous with plump shrimp and tender shellfish.
Oar stands out for atmosphere as much as flavor—**a place where the setting and menu are equally memorable**. If you want a relaxed meal with confident cooking, this riverfront gem is a satisfying choice.
8. Nancy’s Crab Shack
(631) 447-6833Call
Nancy’s Crab Shack is where you’ll find seafood with a homespun touch. **Step inside, and you’re greeted with a laid-back vibe—nothing fancy, just baskets piled high and cracked shells underfoot.** There’s often a local crowd swapping stories over picnic tables, which says a lot about the place.
**The crabs are the headliner here.** Steamed, seasoned, and served piping hot, they arrive messy by design, with just the right amount of spice. I once made an afternoon out of sharing a mountain of crabs and buttery corn on the cob—simple, but memorable.
For something extra, the shrimp boil is generous, brimming with fresh shrimp and plenty of potatoes. **Nancy’s is perfect for anyone craving straightforward, satisfying seafood in Medford’s orbit.**
9. Catch Oyster Bar
Catch Oyster Bar nails the blend of modern style and nautical charm. **Walking in, you’re met with a gleaming raw bar and a menu that feels fresh and adventurous.** My first visit was driven by local whispers about the oysters—and they didn’t disappoint. Each shell was bracingly cold and precisely shucked, with a rotating mix that kept things interesting.
**Beyond oysters, the crudo selections and daily fish specials are where the kitchen really shines.** Light sauces and bright herbs lift the flavors without overpowering the seafood. Order the scallop ceviche or the grilled day-boat fish. Both celebrate the catch without fuss.
For anyone who appreciates **well-sourced seafood and a laid-back atmosphere**, Catch Oyster Bar brings something special to the Patchogue and Medford scene.
More Things to Try in Medford, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood dishes are popular in Medford, NY?
You’ll find a mix of classics here—think shrimp scampi, fried flounder, lobster rolls, and fresh oysters. Clam chowder and seafood pastas are mainstays, reflecting both local ingredients and family-friendly tastes.
Are there any seafood restaurants in Medford with waterfront views?
While Medford itself is inland, nearby Patchogue offers several riverfront seafood spots like Harbor Crab and The Oar Steak & Seafood Grill, where the scenery pairs well with the menu.
Can I find fresh local fish and shellfish in Medford?
Absolutely. Many restaurants and fish markets—such as Long Island Seafood—feature catches straight from Long Island’s waters, so local options are always at hand.
Do any seafood restaurants in Medford offer takeout?
Most seafood restaurants here provide takeout, from casual clam bars to sit-down spots. It’s a convenient way to enjoy fresh seafood at home.
Is it easy to find halal or vegetarian seafood options in Medford?
While most menus feature classic seafood, you’ll often spot vegetarian sides and pasta. For strict dietary needs, call ahead to confirm ingredient details or request custom preparation.
