Finding the best seafood in Melbourne, FL, means discovering a range of eateries that serve fresh, flavorful catches. Over the years, I’ve explored numerous local spots, each offering its own unique take on seafood — from perfectly grilled fish to succulent shrimp dishes. This guide aims to highlight those that stand out for quality, atmosphere, and authentic flavors, ensuring you get the most out of Melbourne’s coastal culinary scene.
Whether you’re craving a laid-back Tiki bar vibe or an elegant riverside dinner, the city has something for every seafood lover. My goal is to help you navigate this vibrant dining landscape confidently. Dive into this list and uncover some of Melbourne’s top seafood destinations — places where the ocean’s bounty is celebrated and served with care.
Where to find the best seafood in Melbourne, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Melbourne, FL:
- Grills Riverside Seafood Deck & Tiki Bar
- Squid Lips
- Chart House
- Shells of Melbourne
- Ichabod’s Dockside
- Downtown Melbourne Seafood Station
- Coastal Crab Company
- Red Lobster
- Frigate’s Waterfront Bar & Grill
- Pineda Inn Bar & Grill
1. Grills Riverside Seafood Deck & Tiki Bar
Set along the scenic Indian River, Grills Riverside Seafood Deck & Tiki Bar blends tropical charm with serious seafood expertise. I first visited after a kayak trip nearby — and didn’t expect the blackened mahi to rival anything I’d had in South Florida. It did.
The menu focuses on freshly prepared local catches, and the location itself adds to the experience. Think waterfront views, friendly staff, and a lively crowd of locals and travelers alike. It’s relaxed but refined.
Start with the sesame seared ahi tuna or the smoked fish dip, both ideal introductions. For mains, the grilled catch of the day is your best bet — always seasonal, always reliable.
Grills stands out by serving honest food that’s flavorful without trying too hard. It’s seafood for people who actually care about seafood.
2. Squid Lips
Squid Lips is one of those places where the name catches your attention, but the food keeps you coming back. I stopped in after a long afternoon exploring the Eau Gallie Arts District, and the grilled scallops were the kind of surprise that makes you rethink casual dining.
The waterfront setting adds a breezy charm, and the menu leans into bold flavors without overcomplicating things. It’s laid-back, but the kitchen knows what it’s doing.
Try the bacon-wrapped scallops or the smoked fish dip — both are house favorites that showcase Squid Lips’ knack for balancing comfort with quality. The grilled mahi sandwich is another solid pick if you want something hearty but fresh.
Squid Lips stands out for its consistency. It’s not trying to be fancy, just good — and it succeeds.
3. Chart House
Perched along the picturesque Indian River Lagoon, Chart House offers a refined dining experience that combines stunning views with exceptional seafood. I visited during sunset, and the sight of the sky reflecting off the water paired perfectly with a fresh, perfectly cooked Mac Nut Mahi. It’s clear this place takes pride in delivering quality with style.
What sets Chart House apart is its elegant setting and attentive service. The menu balances seafood with hearty options, making it suitable for varied tastes. The atmosphere is both relaxed and sophisticated—ideal for a special dinner or relaxed gathering.
For a seafood highlight, try the Savory Grouper or the shrimp scampi. Pair it with a craft cocktail for a memorable night. This restaurant’s blend of quality, ambiance, and views makes it a standout in Melbourne.
4. Shells of Melbourne
+1 321-722-1122
See Menu
Shells of Melbourne offers a relaxed and friendly atmosphere perfect for enjoying fresh, Florida seafood. I stopped by during lunchtime and was impressed by their signature clam chowder — creamy, flavorful, and clearly made from scratch. It’s a place that values quality and simplicity.
Their focus on fresh, regional seafood makes Shells of Melbourne a standout. From shrimp to oysters and lobster, each dish highlights the ocean’s bounty with a casual flair that never compromises on taste.
For a must-try, order the crab cake sandwich or the shrimp and grits. Both showcase the restaurant’s commitment to flavorful, well-prepared seafood that reflects Florida’s best offerings.
5. Ichabod’s Dockside
Ichabod’s Dockside blends relaxed waterfront charm with reliably good seafood. Tucked along Melbourne Harbor Marina, it’s the kind of place where I found myself losing track of time watching the boats drift by while my order arrived. The vibe feels local—unpretentious, yet confident in its flavor game.
The menu leans on fresh Florida catch, but it’s the consistent preparation that impressed me. Their grilled mahi sandwich had a subtle smokiness that paired beautifully with their crisp slaw. And the clam strips? Crunchy, tender, and exactly what I was craving on a warm afternoon.
If you’re visiting, go for the stuffed flounder or blackened shrimp tacos. These highlight the kitchen’s knack for seasoning without overcomplicating the fish’s natural flavor. It’s classic dockside dining, done right.
6. Downtown Melbourne Seafood Station
Downtown Melbourne Seafood Station combines a casual, city-center setting with high-quality seafood. I stopped by on a lively weekday and was quickly struck by the welcoming atmosphere and diverse menu options. The staff’s attentive service made the experience even better.
What makes this spot stand out is their commitment to fresh ingredients and accommodating dietary needs, with plenty of gluten-free options. The menu offers a balanced mix of classic and creative seafood dishes that appeal to all tastes.
Highly recommended are the shrimp po’ boy and the seared scallops. Both showcase their ability to deliver flavorful, well-prepared seafood in a relaxed, welcoming setting—perfect for a quick lunch or casual dinner.
7. Coastal Crab Company
Coastal Crab Company offers a laid-back vibe perfect for enjoying fresh, succulent seafood. I visited during dinner and was immediately drawn to their vibrant, friendly atmosphere, which felt like a true local hangout. Their focus on crab and shellfish makes it clear they know their way around Florida’s coast.
What sets Coastal Crab apart is their emphasis on quality and simplicity. The dishes are straightforward but flavorful, highlighting the freshness of their seafood. The staff is attentive, making every visit feel welcoming and relaxed.
For a highlight, try the crab boil or the shrimp basket. Both dishes are prepared with care and showcase their commitment to delivering authentic, satisfying seafood in a comfortable setting.
8. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Melbourne offers a dependable stop for those craving classic seafood dishes in a family-friendly setting. I’ve often found it a go-to for a quick, satisfying meal after a busy day. The atmosphere is casual, making it a comfortable choice for all kinds of diners.
What distinguishes this location is its consistent quality and wide selection. Whether you’re in the mood for lobster, shrimp, or seasonal fish, the menu balances tradition with variety. They also provide gluten-free options, accommodating different dietary needs.
The Wild-Caught Snow Crab Legs and Parrot Isle Jumbo Coconut Shrimp stand out as favorites, showcasing the fresh flavors and signature preparation that Red Lobster is known for nationwide.
9. Frigate’s Waterfront Bar & Grill
Frigate’s Waterfront Bar & Grill offers a laid-back vibe with stunning views of the Eau Gallie River. I enjoyed my evening there, sitting outside as boats drifted by, feeling the cool breeze while savoring fresh seafood. It’s a perfect spot for relaxing and unwinding.
Their Florida-Caribbean menu combines local catches with bold, flavorful seasonings that transport you beyond just a typical seafood restaurant. The outdoor seating amplifies the experience, making each meal feel special.
Order the blackened grouper sandwich or the shrimp tacos — they’re both flavorful and showcase the restaurant’s commitment to quality. Frigate’s stands out by offering fresh, well-prepared seafood in a scenic setting with a relaxed atmosphere.
10. Pineda Inn Bar & Grill
Pineda Inn Bar & Grill offers a welcoming, casual atmosphere with outdoor seating that’s perfect for enjoying Melbourne’s relaxed vibe. I visited during a lively weekend evening, and the friendly staff made me feel right at home while I savored some of the freshest seafood the area has to offer.
What makes Pineda Inn stand out is their commitment to quality and community atmosphere. The menu features a variety of seafood and classic American favorites, prepared simply but with care, emphasizing freshness and flavor.
Try the shrimp basket or the fish tacos. Both dishes highlight the straightforward style that Pineda Inn is known for — hearty, flavorful, and satisfying. It’s a local gem for seafood lovers seeking good eats in a friendly setting.
More Things to Try in Melbourne, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: What are some popular seafood dishes in Melbourne, FL?
A: Popular seafood dishes include grilled fish, shrimp scampi, crab cakes, oysters, and lobster. Many local restaurants also offer fresh catches like grouper and snapper, highlighting Florida’s coastal flavors.
Q: Are there family-friendly seafood restaurants in Melbourne, FL?
A: Yes. Many establishments like Red Lobster and Shells of Melbourne provide casual settings suitable for families, with menu options that cater to all ages, including lighter dishes and gluten-free choices.
Q: Can I find vegetarian or vegan seafood alternatives in Melbourne?
A: While true seafood alternatives are limited, some restaurants offer vegetarian or vegan options like seafood-style plant-based dishes, salads, or sides that complement seafood meals.
Q: Do seafood restaurants in Melbourne, FL offer gluten-free options?
A: Many places, including larger chains like Red Lobster and local favorites, provide gluten-free options for seafood dishes. It’s always best to ask your server about specific dietary needs.
Q: Are seafood restaurants in Melbourne, FL accessible by boat?
A: Several waterfront locations, like Frigate’s Waterfront Bar & Grill, welcome boaters. It’s advisable to call ahead to confirm docking arrangements and reservations.