Milwaukee is a city that wears its seafood crown with pride. From the bustling markets along the waterfront to charming restaurants tucked away in neighborhoods, there’s a feast waiting for every palate. The diversity of options reflects not just the city’s rich maritime history but also its vibrant foodie culture. Whether you’re in the mood for fresh catch of the day or an exciting seafood boil, there’s something special here that captures the essence of the Great Lakes.
On a recent wander through the city’s seafood scene, I was reminded why Milwaukee is a hidden gem for seafood lovers. It’s not just about the food; it’s the experience, the flavors, and the warmth of the chefs who pour their hearts into each dish. Join me as we explore some of the best spots to indulge your cravings for the ocean’s bounty, where you’ll find everything from traditional favorites to innovative dishes that redefine what seafood can be. Trust me, you won’t want to miss these culinary adventures.
Where to find the best seafood in Milwaukee, WI
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Milwaukee, WI:
- St. Paul Fish Company
- Harbor House
- Third Coast Provisions
- Barnacle Bud’s
- Maxie’s
- Sail Loft
- Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack
- The King Crab Shack
- Jj Fish
- J J Fish & Chicken
1. St. Paul Fish Company
St. Paul Fish Company in the Milwaukee Public Market is a seafood lover’s paradise. The moment you step inside, the aroma of fresh seafood greets you, setting the stage for a delightful experience. The extensive menu boasts an impressive array of dishes, from succulent oysters on the half shell to perfectly grilled salmon, reflecting the quality and freshness that make this spot a favorite.
What truly sets St. Paul Fish Company apart is its commitment to sourcing local and sustainable seafood. This dedication not only enhances the quality of their offerings but also supports the community. If you’re unsure what to order, the seafood chowder is a local staple, rich and flavorful, while their grilled octopus showcases the kitchen’s skill and creativity.
For a more laid-back experience, grab a drink at the outdoor tiki bar and savor the lively atmosphere. Each visit feels like a celebration of all things seafood, making it a must-stop on your culinary journey through Milwaukee.
2. Harbor House
Harbor House offers a stunning lakeside dining experience that’s hard to beat in Milwaukee. With its bright, airy decor and breathtaking views of Lake Michigan, this New England-style seafood haven draws both locals and visitors. I still recall my first visit, where I indulged in their oysters, freshly shucked and delightfully briny, setting a high standard for my seafood adventures.
What truly makes Harbor House stand out is its dedication to freshness, with seafood flown in daily from both coasts. For a signature order, the grilled octopus is a must-try—perfectly charred and seasoned, it highlights the kitchen’s flair. Don’t miss the Sunday brunch either; the raw bar is a seafood lover’s dream.
With an extensive menu that also accommodates vegetarian and gluten-free options, Harbor House caters to everyone, making it a perfect spot for any occasion.
3. Third Coast Provisions
Third Coast Provisions is an inviting spot that brilliantly combines contemporary flair with Midwestern charm in its seafood offerings. On my recent visit, the comfortable ambiance and attentive service immediately set the tone. The restaurant’s emphasis on seasonal ingredients and artisanal techniques shines through in every dish, making the dining experience feel both special and relatable.
What sets Third Coast Provisions apart is its dedication to merging traditional seafood with local flavors. The oyster selection is consistently fresh, offering a variety that pleases both novices and connoisseurs alike. For something truly memorable, you can’t go wrong with the pan-seared scallops, which are beautifully cooked and paired with local produce, showcasing the best of Midwestern cuisine.
With breakfast offerings and a stylish bar, Third Coast Provisions stands out as a versatile destination for seafood lovers and those looking for a taste of Milwaukee.
4. Barnacle Bud’s
Nestled on the shores of Milwaukee, Barnacle Bud’s offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for seafood enthusiasts seeking comfort and flavor. My first visit was unforgettable, as I enjoyed the lively outdoor seating with friends, soaking in the stunning views while savoring a delicious meal. The casual vibe strikes a perfect balance, making it a wonderful spot for lunch or late-night cravings.
Barnacle Bud’s stands out with its variety of seafood dishes that highlight local ingredients. The fish tacos are a must-try, piled high with fresh toppings and flavors that transport you straight to the coast. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the seafood boil is an abundant feast, showcasing an assortment of shellfish that celebrates the bounty of the lakes.
With a fully stocked bar and friendly service, Barnacle Bud’s captures the essence of Milwaukee’s seafood scene. It’s casual and inviting, making every visit feel like a mini-vacation.
5. Maxie’s
Maxie’s brings a delightful taste of Southern flair to Milwaukee, showcasing a menu brimming with seafood and comfort food. My first experience there was both fun and flavorful—enjoying the lively atmosphere while savoring dishes inspired by the South. The oyster bar, in particular, is a highlight, with its selection that pairs perfectly with their Happy Hour specials.
What makes Maxie’s stand out is its diverse offerings that blend traditional Southern cooking with fresh seafood. Don’t miss the shrimp and grits, a creamy, indulgent dish that embodies the spirit of Southern cuisine. Their catfish po’ boy is equally impressive, featuring crispy fish in a soft bread, delivering a comforting vibe that feels like a warm hug.
With vegetarian and gluten-free options available, Maxie’s is a welcoming spot for everyone, making each visit a Guaranteed Good Time.
6. Sail Loft
Sail Loft is a charming restaurant that perfectly captures the spirit of Wisconsin’s waterfront dining. On my first visit, I was immediately drawn in by the casual yet inviting atmosphere. The stunning views of the water complemented the laid-back vibe, making it easy to settle in and enjoy a meal with friends.
What stands out at Sail Loft is its focus on fresh, local seafood combined with a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. The grilled salmon is a standout, perfectly cooked and served with seasonal veggies that enhance its flavors. Their clam chowder is another must-try, rich and comforting—it’s like a warm embrace in a bowl.
With plenty of vegetarian and gluten-free options, Sail Loft is an excellent choice for everyone, making it a go-to spot on Milwaukee’s culinary map.
7. Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack
Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack offers a lively crab house experience with a casual and fun atmosphere. On my first visit, I was delighted by the vibrant decor and the scent of mouthwatering seafood wafting through the air. It’s a place that invites you to relax and indulge in fresh flavors with friends or family.
What truly sets Twisted Fisherman apart is its focus on a variety of seafood preparations that cater to all tastes. The standout dish here is undoubtedly the King Crab legs, served with drawn butter that makes every bite a savory delight. For those who enjoy something a bit different, the seafood boil is a flavorful adventure packed with shrimp, mussels, and more, all seasoned to perfection.
With ample outdoor seating and a friendly staff, Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack is an ideal spot for seafood lovers looking to unwind and enjoy a flavorful meal.
8. The King Crab Shack
The King Crab Shack is a hidden gem that brings a unique blend of Cajun, Creole, and Vietnamese flavors to Milwaukee’s seafood scene. During my first trip, the energetic atmosphere and friendly staff made me feel right at home. With the enticing scent of spices and seafood wafting through the air, I knew I was in for a treat.
This restaurant stands out for its varied menu that highlights bold flavors and fresh ingredients. The signature crab boil is an absolute must-try, overflowing with succulent crab, corn, and potatoes, all bathed in a flavorful sauce. Another delightful option is their spicy shrimp pho, which perfectly balances warmth with rich, complex flavors.
With a welcoming environment and hearty portions, The King Crab Shack is a perfect spot for indulging in delicious seafood.
9. Jj Fish
+1 414-873-4747
Jj Fish is a beloved local spot that offers a genuine taste of seafood in a relaxed setting. I remember my first experience there; the moment I walked in, the welcoming atmosphere and the delicious aroma of fried fish made me feel right at home. It’s clear that this place is all about serving up fresh, hearty meals.
What makes Jj Fish stand out is its focus on crispy, flavor-packed dishes that never disappoint. The catfish fillets are a must-try, fried to golden perfection and served with a tangy dipping sauce that elevates the dish. For a satisfying option, their fried shrimp basket pairs perfectly with seasoned fries, offering a true taste of comfort food.
Casual yet inviting, Jj Fish is perfect for a quick bite or a laid-back meal with friends.
10. J J Fish & Chicken
+1 414-355-1000
J J Fish & Chicken is a cozy spot that brings together delightful seafood and comforting chicken dishes. On my first visit, I was struck by the friendly vibe and the delicious scent that filled the air. It’s the kind of place where you know the food is made with care and attention.
This restaurant stands out for its emphasis on freshly prepared seafood that satisfies cravings without breaking the bank. The fish sandwich is a highlight—lightly breaded and perfectly fried, served with all the right toppings. Their fried shrimp is also a winner, delivering great flavor and a satisfying crunch that keeps you coming back for more.
With a menu that blends comfort and quality, J J Fish & Chicken is a great choice for a casual meal.
More Things to Try in Milwaukee, WI
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the best seafood restaurants in Milwaukee?
Some of the top seafood spots include St. Paul Fish Company, Harbor House, and Sail Loft. Each offers a unique atmosphere and a diverse menu featuring fresh seafood options.
2. Is seafood in Milwaukee fresh?
Yes, many seafood restaurants in Milwaukee source their ingredients from both local and national suppliers, ensuring that the seafood is fresh and of high quality.
3. Are there any seafood options for non-seafood eaters?
Absolutely! Many seafood restaurants in the area offer a variety of non-seafood dishes, such as pastas, salads, and grilled meats, catering to all tastes.
4. Can I find gluten-free seafood options?
Many seafood restaurants in Milwaukee, like Maxie’s and Harbor House, offer gluten-free options. It’s always a good idea to check with the staff about their menu offerings.
5. What is a seafood boil?
A seafood boil is a popular dish that includes a mix of shellfish, such as shrimp, crab, and clams, often seasoned and boiled together with vegetables. The King Crab Shack is a great place to try one!
6. When is the best time to enjoy seafood in Milwaukee?
The seafood scene in Milwaukee is lively year-round, but summer brings a special charm with outdoor seating and fresh catch specials. Happy hours at various restaurants often feature reduced prices on seafood.
7. Are there any seafood festivals in Milwaukee?
Yes, Milwaukee hosts seafood-related events and festivals throughout the year, particularly during the summer, which showcase local seafood and dining culture.
8. Can I get takeout seafood in Milwaukee?
Many seafood restaurants, including Twisted Fisherman Crab Shack and J J Fish & Chicken, offer takeout options, so you can enjoy your meal at home or on the go.
9. Is it okay to bring kids to seafood restaurants?
Definitely! Most seafood restaurants in Milwaukee are family-friendly and have kids’ menus that include simpler options suitable for younger diners.