Finding great seafood in Mohegan Lake, NY is a bit like fishing in sparkling waters—you never know what delightful catch you might land. There’s something about the mix of old-school fish shacks, cozy Italian eateries, and upscale spots here that makes searching for that perfect plate of shrimp or scallops a fun adventure. I still remember my first Mohegan Lake clam chowder: the kind you taste, then immediately plan your next bowl. It’s a memory that reminds me why the search for fresh seafood in this area is worth the effort.
Just when you think you’ve settled on a favorite, another local gem surfaces. Whether you crave classic fish fry, creative seafood pasta, or the simple pleasure of expertly grilled salmon, the establishments here deliver on freshness and flavor. If you want something special for a weekend dinner or a spot to bring out-of-town guests, you’re about to discover a lineup of places that know how to treat the fruits of the sea right. Read on for the best seafood Mohegan Lake has to offer, and bring your appetite—you’ll need it.
Where to find the best seafood in Mohegan Lake, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Mohegan Lake, NY:
- Ravenna Osteria
- On the Spot for Spot
- Rick’s Seafood
- Tsagarakis Pete
- White House
- Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc
- Mt Kisco Seafood
- Gilligan’s Clam Bar & Grill
- Mt Kisco Smokehouse
- Pepettini
1. Ravenna Osteria
(914) 736-0292Call
Ravenna Osteria blends Mediterranean charm with a relaxed, neighborhood feeling at its cozy Peekskill address. This is the spot where seafood meets Italian comfort, set beneath warm lighting that makes you linger over dinner.
I once dropped by for their branzino and was hooked. The fish arrived perfectly grilled, with lemon and herbs highlighting its natural flavor—proof that sometimes simplicity wins.
If you’re after variety, the seafood risotto is a top pick. It’s silky, generously studded with shrimp and scallops, and packs every spoonful with the taste of the sea.
Ravenna Osteria stands out for its fresh ingredients and unfussy style. For anyone craving seafood prepared with care and a hint of Italy, this place is a must.
2. On the Spot for Spot
(914) 930-1242Call
On the Spot for Spot might sound like a place with a playful spirit, but make no mistake—their seafood is all business. This local favorite has a knack for serving up fish and shellfish that always tastes like it just left the docks.
I remember their grilled whole fish—an honest, no-frills plate where freshness does all the talking. It was flaky, seasoned with care, and didn’t need much more than a squeeze of lemon.
The crab cakes here also deserve attention. Crisp on the outside, tender inside, each bite is packed with sweet crab and herbs. Order them for a taste of why this spot stands out among seafood lovers in the area.
3. Rick’s Seafood
(845) 621-2489Call
Rick’s Seafood is where quality and tradition meet. Set right on Route 6 in Mahopac, this spot doubles as a full seafood market and a restaurant, making it easy to find something fresh and satisfying any day of the week.
One trip here, and I was sold on their grilled salmon. The taste was clean, the texture spot-on, and the presentation straightforward yet classic. You can tell they know their product from the market side—everything is handled with care.
For a taste of the sea, try the shrimp platter. Each shrimp is juicy and perfectly cooked, letting the natural flavors shine through. Rick’s Seafood stands out for its dedication to freshness and consistency, and it shows in every bite.
4. Tsagarakis Pete
(914) 271-2059Call
Tsagarakis Pete delivers a neighborhood touch with serious seafood credentials. Tucked away on South Riverside Avenue, it’s the kind of spot everyone wishes they had around the corner: unpretentious, friendly, and always reliable.
I stopped in for their grilled shrimp and was met with plump, smoky-sweet bites that needed little more than a wedge of lemon. You get the sense that freshness is the bare minimum here.
Their seafood combo plates are ideal if you’re indecisive. A mix of shrimp, fish, and delicate calamari keeps things interesting and flavorful. Tsagarakis Pete stands out for honest service and seafood that skips the fuss, letting each ingredient’s quality shine through.
5. White House
(845) 897-2990Call
White House sits right in the heart of Cold Spring, offering seafood with an unfussy charm that keeps regulars coming back. The interior brings a sense of hometown comfort—think crisp tablecloths and a view of Main Street’s bustle from your window seat.
My visit for their broiled flounder was an easy sell. It arrived flaking apart and topped with herbs. There was nothing fancy, just classic execution done well, and that’s the kind of meal you remember.
The seafood chowder is another highlight. Each spoonful is rich with tender white fish and fresh vegetables, perfect for those cooler nights. White House stands out by focusing on skill and fresh ingredients, leaving no need to overcomplicate what works.
6. Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc
(914) 666-6929Call
Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc carries a legacy as rich as its menu. In business since 1894, the Conte family has turned seafood into an art form at their Mount Kisco location. The combination of market and restaurant means you can spot your dinner before it hits the grill.
Stepping inside, I went straight for the grilled snapper. The fish, so fresh you’d think it swam in that morning, tasted clean and delicate, brought to life with just a brush of olive oil and herbs.
Another gem is the seafood stew, bursting with tender fish, shrimp, and clams. Conte’s stands out by blending experience and tradition, serving up seafood the way it’s meant to be—pure, skillful, and never overdone.
7. Mt Kisco Seafood
Mt Kisco Seafood is a trusted stop for locals chasing the freshest catch. With both a seafood market and a restaurant under one roof, you know every plate starts with the best ingredients in town.
I came by for their grilled swordfish, and it made me a return customer on the spot. The steak was thick, juicy, and lightly seasoned so the flavor held center stage. That level of care shows up, bite after bite.
If you’re feeling adventurous, the cioppino—a generous seafood stew—is loaded with clams, fish, and shrimp in a light tomato broth. Mt Kisco Seafood stands out for straightforward dishes where freshness always takes the lead.
8. Gilligan’s Clam Bar & Grill
Gilligan’s Clam Bar & Grill brings a lively, seaside vibe to Pomona without needing a map or boat ride. Here, casual meets quality, and every meal feels like a neighborhood celebration.
My first order? The classic clams on the half shell. They were ice-cold and briny, just as they should be. Each bite was a reminder of how simple, top-notch ingredients can outshine complicated recipes.
The grilled seafood platter is another favorite. Loaded with shrimp, salmon, and scallops, it’s a great way to sample what Gilligan’s does best. Gilligan’s Clam Bar & Grill stands out for keeping things fun and fresh, and making sure every dish honors the seafood itself.
9. Mt Kisco Smokehouse
Mt Kisco Smokehouse has earned fame for doing seafood a little differently. Smoky, rich aromas greet you at the door, hinting at the treat that waits inside. If you think all smoked fish tastes the same, prepare to be surprised.
On my last visit, their smoked salmon opened my eyes. Silky, mild, with just enough smoke to lift the natural sweetness—this wasn’t supermarket fare.
The smoked whitefish salad is another staple. Scoop it onto a crisp cracker for the kind of bite that lingers. Mt Kisco Smokehouse stands out by putting a creative twist on seafood, keeping it fresh and memorable for anyone craving bold flavor and originality.
10. Pepettini
Pepettini is an Italian treasure tucked into an old bank building beside the Hudson. The charm of the original vault and exposed stonework gives each meal here a historic, intimate vibe. You can almost taste the tradition before your first bite lands.
When I visited, the grilled octopus caught my eye. It was perfectly charred—tender, smoky, and finished with a bright squeeze of lemon. Simple but full of flavor, it reminded me how Italian kitchens let quality seafood do the talking.
The linguine ai frutti di mare is another must. Tossed with clams, shrimp, and calamari in a light tomato sauce, every forkful channels the southern coast of Italy. Pepettini stands out for its genuine approach, blending Italian heritage and local freshness.
More Things to Try in Mohegan Lake, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best place for fresh seafood near Mohegan Lake, NY?
If you want the freshest catch, Rick’s Seafood, Mt Kisco Seafood, and Conte’s Quality Seafood Inc have built their reputations on consistent quality and daily deliveries.
Which seafood restaurants near Mohegan Lake, NY offer takeout or delivery?
Many spots—including Mt Kisco Smokehouse, Brothers Fish & Chips, and Gilligan’s Clam Bar & Grill—offer takeout. It’s smart to call ahead or check their websites for updated hours and delivery options.
Are there any seafood spots in Mohegan Lake with a casual vibe?
Yes. Places like On the Spot for Spot and White House focus on friendly service and relaxed dining perfect for weeknights or low-key weekends.
Can I find Mediterranean-style seafood near Mohegan Lake?
For Mediterranean flavors, Ravenna Osteria and Pepettini shine, with menus full of simply prepared, high-quality fish and shellfish.
Is it easy to find halal or non-haram seafood near Mohegan Lake?
Seafood is naturally a great option for many dietary needs. Most restaurants on this list focus on fresh, simple seafood with no haram items, especially when choosing grilled or classic dishes.
