Tracking down good seafood in Nanuet is a bit like hunting for pearls—most people wander past the hidden gems. Over time, exploring local menus and chatting with chefs taught me that Nanuet’s seafood scene quietly spoils anyone willing to look beneath the surface. Whether you search for a classic shrimp cocktail, grilled branzino, or something as simple as a fresh, flaky fillet, Nanuet surprises with a range far beyond what you’d expect for a town its size.
Every restaurant on this list has put its own stamp on seafood, offering something for every taste and occasion. The real delight? Some spots serve up rustic, hands-on experiences, while others plate up elegantly crafted dishes you’ll remember long after. So if your cravings point you towards salmon, tuna, or even a bowl of savory mussels, you’re in just the right place. Let’s dive into the standout seafood spots that make Nanuet a destination worth the trip.
Where to find the best seafood in Nanuet, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Nanuet, NY:
- Banchetto Feast
- White Castle
- Rockland Seafood
- Red Lobster
- No1 Sushi
- Patsy’s Pizzeria
- 103 Prime at Valentino’s
- Maura’s Kitchen
- Ramapo Seafood Corp
- La Madrina Deli Restaurant
1. Banchetto Feast
Banchetto Feast has the warm feeling of an Italian family gathering, right in the heart of Nanuet. Seafood here isn’t just another menu item—it’s a main attraction. The chefs coax subtle flavors out of simple, high-quality ingredients, making each plate memorable.
The linguine with fresh clams stands out—the sauce is light, the clams are tender, and the balance of garlic and herbs feels effortless. If you prefer something richer, the seafood fra diavolo brings a little kick without overpowering the natural flavors.
It’s a place where you can settle in for a long lunch or take dinner to go and still feel you’ve treated yourself. For anyone after comfort, freshness, and a bit of elegance, Banchetto Feast is a can’t-miss spot for seafood in Nanuet.
2. White Castle
If you think of White Castle for burgers alone, a visit to the Nanuet location rewrites the script. This spot serves up a dose of nostalgia with a modern twist—quick service, signature sliders, and a playful sense of humor.
Seafood fans can turn to options like the fish sliders, which arrive hot and crispy with a punchy tartar sauce. Paired with crinkle-cut fries, these sliders are a satisfying detour from the usual fare.
There’s no pretense—just straightforward, tasty bites for anyone in a hurry or looking for something reliable. If you need a late-night seafood fix or an easy lunch, White Castle provides just that, with a side of charm only they can deliver.
3. Rockland Seafood
(845) 624-3660Call
Rockland Seafood is a quiet favorite among local seafood lovers. This isn’t a flashy spot, but the quality of their seafood speaks louder than décor ever could. Out of all my visits, the freshness always stands out—the kind you notice as soon as the first bite hits.
The broiled salmon is a must-try—moist, flavorful, and cooked just right. If you lean toward shellfish, ask for their shrimp platter. Everything arrives simply prepared, letting the ingredients carry the meal.
It’s a go-to when you want traditional seafood without fuss or frills. The friendly staff make it easy to order exactly what you crave. For anyone who prizes freshness above all, Rockland Seafood is a clear winner in Nanuet.
4. Red Lobster
Red Lobster in Nanuet draws a loyal crowd for a reason. The menu covers nearly every seafood craving, from lighter grilled fare to hearty classics. I’ve found it’s a reliable place when you want a consistent, flavorful meal and a welcoming atmosphere.
The grilled trout stands out for its fresh taste and tender texture, while the shrimp scampi offers a buttery punch without feeling too heavy. If you’re with family or friends, the create-your-own seafood feast lets everyone find something to love.
Service is friendly and prompt, which makes lingering over those famous Cheddar Bay Biscuits even nicer. For straightforward seafood in a comfortable setting, Red Lobster nails it every time.
5. No1 Sushi
No1 Sushi is where I go when the craving for fresh, artfully sliced fish hits. This spot manages to serve elegant sushi without ever feeling pretentious, and there’s always a pleasant, relaxed vibe inside.
The salmon and tuna sashimi consistently impress—delicate, melt-in-your-mouth slices that show off the chef’s skill at balancing flavors and textures. For those who want a little more variety, their signature rolls are packed with creative touches and generous portions of seafood.
Whether it’s a casual lunch or you’re catching up with friends, No1 Sushi keeps the focus on quality and freshness. Every bite proves why it’s considered one of Nanuet’s best for Japanese seafood classics.
6. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Patsy’s Pizzeria is far more than just a neighborhood pizza joint. It’s the kind of place where wood-fired dough meets a love for fresh seafood. There’s a genuine charm in the bustling dining room and the steady stream of regulars.
The shrimp scampi pizza is something I keep coming back for—perfectly cooked shrimp on a crispy crust with garlic, olive oil, and a touch of lemon. If you’re craving comfort, the seafood linguine delivers, blending pasta and shellfish in a light yet flavorful sauce.
Patsy’s balances tradition with a touch of creativity, making it a standout for those who want their seafood and Italian classics in one stop. It’s casual, lively, and never disappoints.
7. 103 Prime at Valentino’s
(201) 391-2220Call
103 Prime at Valentino’s feels a bit like discovering a secret corner of Italy right over the border in Park Ridge. This upscale spot brings together steakhouse elegance and coastal seafood simplicity, striking a balance few restaurants manage.
The bronzino is a highlight—grilled whole and finished with olive oil and lemon. Each bite captures what makes Mediterranean seafood special: fresh, bright, and never overdone. The seafood risotto is another winner, blending plump shrimp and scallops with perfectly cooked rice for a rich, satisfying plate.
Service is attentive but never stiff, and each meal feels special without being over the top. 103 Prime is the pick for a night out when you want seafood with a dash of style and warmth.
8. Maura’s Kitchen
Maura’s Kitchen brings the bold flavors of Peru to Nyack in the most inviting way. This intimate bistro offers a homey mix of soulful recipes and modern flair, making it hard to pick just one favorite. Every visit serves up new surprises and steady favorites, thanks to a menu that celebrates fresh seafood with Latin warmth.
The ceviche here is a showstopper—zesty, bright, and swimming with the day’s freshest fish. Paired with sweet potatoes and corn, it’s a perfect starter or light meal. Another dish to try? The arroz con mariscos, a Peruvian spin on seafood rice bursting with flavor and vibrant spices.
Maura’s Kitchen is the spot for anyone craving a departure from the ordinary, all in a lively, colorful setting.
9. Ramapo Seafood Corp
(800) 794-7262Call
Ramapo Seafood Corp is where serious seafood lovers go when they want quality straight from the source. This market-restaurant hybrid takes freshness to another level, with a selection that feels like it came in on the morning tide.
The grilled tilapia is something I always return to—clean, flaky, and simply seasoned to let the fish shine. If you’re in the mood for variety, the mixed seafood platter offers a generous sampling of whatever’s best that day.
For those who enjoy cooking at home, the market side offers pristine fillets and shellfish to take back to your own kitchen. Ramapo Seafood Corp keeps things honest, making it easy to trust that what’s on your plate is the real deal.
10. La Madrina Deli Restaurant
(845) 459-6449Call
La Madrina Deli Restaurant is an unassuming stop on Main Street that surprises with bold, comforting flavors. It blends classic deli comfort with a creative touch in its seafood fare. You know you’ve found a gem when regulars recommend what to order before you even sit down.
The seafood stew takes center stage here. Each spoonful brings tender pieces of fish and shellfish together in a broth rich with herbs and just enough spice. The portions are hearty, perfect for lunch or dinner when you want something warming and memorable.
If you want quick, delicious seafood that feels homemade, La Madrina delivers the kind of satisfaction only a local favorite can provide.
More Things to Try in Nanuet, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood dishes are most popular in Nanuet, NY?
Crowd favorites include grilled salmon, shrimp scampi, seafood linguine, and classic fish tacos. Many restaurants also offer creative takes like seafood pizzas and Peruvian ceviche.
Are there any good sushi spots in Nanuet?
Yes, No1 Sushi stands out with fresh salmon sashimi, signature rolls, and an easygoing vibe. It’s a top pick for Japanese-style seafood in the area.
Can I find gluten-free or vegetarian seafood options in Nanuet?
Several restaurants, including Banchetto Feast, offer gluten-free seafood dishes and vegetarian-friendly choices. Always ask the server about specific menu accommodations.
Which seafood restaurants offer takeout?
Most local favorites—like Red Lobster, Patsy’s Pizzeria, and Rockland Seafood—provide takeout options so you can enjoy seafood at home or on the go.
Are there upscale seafood restaurants near Nanuet?
If you want a more polished setting, try 103 Prime at Valentino’s or Oceanos Oyster Bar & Sea Grill. Both serve refined seafood dishes in elegant surroundings.
