Cracking into a freshly steamed crab leg while the Neuse River murmurs in the distance—that’s a memory I still taste. New Bern might be known for its colonial charm, but the seafood here rivals its history in richness and flavor. Whether you’re searching for a quiet dockside supper or a lively oyster bar, this town knows how to serve the coast on a plate. I’ve explored far more menus than I care to admit, and each dish reaffirmed one thing: New Bern’s seafood scene isn’t just fresh—it’s fiercely local and proudly diverse.
This guide dives into the best places to find top-notch seafood in New Bern, NC. From raw bars humming with energy to quiet taverns plating up Southern seafood classics, we’ll cut through the noise and steer you straight toward the kind of meals that linger in memory. If you’re serious about flavor without the fluff, you’re exactly where you need to be.
Where to find the best seafood in New Bern, NC
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in New Bern, NC:
- MJ’s Raw Bar & Grille
- Persimmons Waterfront Restaurant
- The Chelsea
- Morgan’s Tavern & Grill
- Carolina Grill
- Saltwater Grill At River Bend
- Pirates Cove Seafood and Oyster Bar
- Kuma Sushi Bar
- Front Street Fish Co.
- Friday’s 1890 Seafood
1. MJ’s Raw Bar & Grille
MJ’s Raw Bar & Grille feels like the soul of Middle Street. The casual vibe pairs perfectly with a menu that means business when it comes to seafood. Tucked inside a restored building, this spot delivers coastal fare without pretension. The oysters come in fresh daily, and you can taste it.
I sat at the bar once, watching the shuckers work with focus and rhythm—like seafood jazz. The shrimp and grits stood out for its buttery finish and hint of spice. If you’re new to MJ’s, the crab cakes are a no-fail first pick. Lightly seared, minimal filler, packed with flavor.
Service is prompt, and the space gets lively without getting loud. Whether you’re with friends or solo, this spot nails that New Bern hospitality with ease.
2. Persimmons Waterfront Restaurant
Persimmons Waterfront Restaurant is where the Neuse River becomes part of your meal. I remember arriving just before sunset—the view alone was worth the reservation. But it’s the food that kept me seated long after the sky dimmed. This place blends modern coastal cuisine with a relaxed, upscale atmosphere, and it does so without missing a beat.
The pan-seared scallops are a standout, served with seasonal vegetables that actually taste like they came from a local farm. If you’re in the mood for something richer, the catch-of-the-day risotto is consistently well-executed, creamy without being heavy. The chef clearly respects the ingredients.
Dining on the outdoor deck adds another layer to the experience. The breeze, the boats, the soft clink of glasses—it’s New Bern at its most refined, without being fussy.
3. The Chelsea
The Chelsea feels like dining in a piece of New Bern’s legacy. It’s housed in the historic building where Pepsi was invented, but the focus now is on elevated Southern flavors with a strong local twist. I remember walking in during a quiet weekday lunch—the high ceilings and exposed brick struck a balance between elegance and comfort. This spot draws locals for special occasions, but it’s just as good for a casual seafood fix done right.
The shrimp penne pasta tossed in a house-made cream sauce is a highlight. It’s simple, but well balanced, letting the ingredients speak. For a lighter option, the grilled Atlantic salmon paired with rice pilaf and sautéed greens hits the mark.
The staff is attentive without hovering. Whether you’re tucked into a booth or seated by the large upstairs windows, The Chelsea serves up consistency in both flavor and service.
4. Morgan’s Tavern & Grill
Morgan’s Tavern & Grill combines a relaxed, welcoming vibe with an emphasis on quality ingredients. I had the pleasure of visiting on a lively weekend afternoon, where the bustling atmosphere made me feel right at home. The staff’s friendly service set the tone for a memorable meal. This spot stands out by balancing comfort with a focus on fresh, local seafood.
The blackened catfish sandwich is a must-try, with bold seasoning and crispy edges. For a more refined option, the shrimp and grits offer a perfect balance of spice and creaminess. Both dishes exemplify Morgan’s commitment to flavor and quality.
Whether for lunch or dinner, Morgan’s offers hearty portions and a casual environment perfect for any occasion. It’s an ideal choice for those wanting good seafood in a friendly setting.
5. Carolina Grill
Carolina Grill offers a relaxed yet polished dining experience just outside downtown New Bern. I once visited on a warm evening, and the inviting patio made the perfect backdrop for savoring fresh seafood. The staff’s friendly service and attentive recommendations made me feel genuinely cared for. This restaurant shines for its clarity in delivering hearty, quality Southern-inspired dishes.
The grilled mahi-mahi tacos are flavorful, with a smoky kick and fresh toppings. For a classic seafood choice, the shrimp and oyster platter presents oysters perfectly shucked, showcasing freshness and skill. Both dishes highlight the restaurant’s dedication to quality and flavor.
Whether dining in or taking out, Carolina Grill’s consistent excellence makes it a top pick for seafood lovers. It’s a place where good weather and good food come together seamlessly.
6. Saltwater Grill At River Bend
Saltwater Grill At River Bend offers a scenic dining experience alongside the Neuse River. I recall settling into a waterfront table just as the sun began to dip, casting a golden glow over the water. The relaxed atmosphere combined with attentive service made it an ideal spot for a seafood-focused evening. What sets Saltwater Grill apart is its dedication to fresh, locally-sourced seafood crafted with precision.
The blackened Ahi tuna salad is a favorite, showcasing rich flavors and perfect seasoning. For a satisfying main, the shrimp and scallop linguine pairs tender seafood with a savory sauce that elevates every bite. Both dishes reflect the restaurant’s commitment to quality and depth of flavor.
Whether you’re enjoying lunch, dinner, or brunch, Saltwater Grill consistently delivers an exceptional taste of the coast. It’s a true gem for seafood enthusiasts in New Bern.
7. Pirates Cove Seafood and Oyster Bar
Pirates Cove Seafood and Oyster Bar captures the maritime spirit of New Bern with its lively atmosphere and maritime décor. I once sat on their outdoor patio, watching boats drift by while enjoying a fresh oyster platter. The vibrant, friendly vibe instantly puts you in a coastal state of mind. This spot stands out for its wide selection of fresh oysters and down-to-earth service.
The oysters on the half shell are a must-try, boasting a briny, plump quality that reflects their freshness. For a hearty main, the fish tacos are packed with flavor and topped with a spicy remoulade, perfect for seafood lovers craving bold tastes.
Pirates Cove balances casual fun with quality seafood that never disappoints. It’s an ideal spot to savor local flavors in a relaxed setting.
8. Kuma Sushi Bar
Kuma Sushi Bar brings a refined, minimalist charm to downtown New Bern. Tucked along Pollock Street, it’s a quiet retreat where the focus is squarely on quality and precision. The atmosphere is calm, the service attentive, and the presentation consistently sharp.
What sets Kuma apart is its commitment to freshness and balance. The seafood is clean, expertly sliced, and never overworked. I once tried the salmon nigiri and yellowtail sashimi, and each bite was smooth, cool, and delicately seasoned—no soy sauce needed.
For something more filling, the New Bern Roll is a standout. It’s a local favorite that blends crisp cucumber, buttery avocado, and fresh tuna in a way that feels both indulgent and light.
Kuma Sushi Bar is where precision meets flavor, making it a top pick for seafood lovers seeking something elegant yet approachable.
9. Front Street Fish Co.
Front Street Fish Co. sits quietly along the waterfront, offering seafood with roots deep in local tradition. The setting is relaxed, with the Neuse River just steps away, and the seafood is just as memorable as the view.
What makes Front Street Fish Co. stand out is its commitment to honest sourcing. Decades-long relationships with regional fishermen mean everything on the plate speaks to North Carolina’s coastal heritage. I once tried their grilled flounder, caught just miles away, and the flavor was fresh, delicate, and clean—no frills, just fish done right.
If you’re stopping by, ask for the shrimp basket or seared tuna wrap. Both are local favorites that balance simplicity and boldness without overwhelming the seafood itself.
Front Street Fish Co. is where quality meets care, offering diners a straightforward, satisfying seafood experience grounded in local pride.
10. Friday’s 1890 Seafood
Friday’s 1890 Seafood feels like stepping into a time capsule—one that smells like hush puppies and salt air. Styled after a late 19th-century fishing vessel, this locally owned spot on Neuse Boulevard leans into its maritime roots with a menu that’s all about classic coastal fare.
What sets Friday’s apart is its generous portions and Calabash-style frying, which keeps the seafood crisp without drowning it in batter. I once ordered the jumbo shrimp and scallop platter, and the balance of texture and seasoning was spot on—no gimmicks, just well-executed seafood.
If you’re unsure what to try, go for the stuffed flounder with deviled crab or the broiled trout. Both dishes reflect the kitchen’s knack for keeping things simple and letting the seafood shine.
Friday’s 1890 Seafood isn’t flashy, but it’s dependable. It’s the kind of place where locals return for the shrimp creole and stay for the familiarity.
More Things to Try in New Bern, NC
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What seafood is New Bern known for?
New Bern is known for its freshwater and coastal seafood, especially shrimp, flounder, trout, and crab. Many restaurants also offer Calabash-style fried seafood, a North Carolina tradition that emphasizes light, crispy batter.
2. Are there any waterfront seafood restaurants in New Bern?
Yes. Persimmons Waterfront Restaurant offers riverfront dining with a seasonal menu that highlights local seafood. It’s a popular spot for both the view and the food.
3. Where can I find casual seafood in New Bern?
For a laid-back experience, try MJ’s Raw Bar & Grille or Friday’s 1890 Seafood. Both serve classic Southern seafood dishes in a relaxed setting.
4. Is there a seafood market where I can buy fresh catch?
Yes. Front Street Fish Co. is a local favorite for fresh, local, and Alaskan seafood. You can buy to-go or dine in at their small restaurant.
5. Do any places offer halal or haram-free seafood options?
While most seafood in New Bern is naturally halal, it’s best to ask about preparation methods. Stick to grilled, broiled, or steamed options and avoid dishes with alcohol-based sauces or non-halal meats.
6. What’s the best place for sushi or Asian-style seafood?
Kuma Sushi Bar and Sake, Sushi Grill, BBQ & Bar both offer fresh sushi and seafood boils. Kuma is known for its clean flavors and minimalist presentation.
7. Are there seafood options for people who don’t eat fried food?
Absolutely. Many restaurants, including The Chelsea and Morgan’s Tavern & Grill, offer broiled, grilled, or blackened seafood dishes that are light and flavorful.
8. Is seafood in New Bern expensive?
Prices vary. Upscale spots like The Chelsea are pricier, while places like Carolina Grill and Saltwater Grill at River Bend offer affordable seafood plates without compromising on quality.
9. Are reservations required at popular seafood restaurants?
Not always, but for places like Persimmons or Morgan’s Tavern & Grill, reservations are recommended, especially on weekends or during tourist season.
10. Can I find seafood options at grocery stores in New Bern?
Yes. Harris Teeter has a reliable seafood section, including fresh fish and sushi. It’s a good option if you’re cooking at home.