New Haven may be known for its pizza, but those in the know will tell you that the seafood scene here deserves just as much hype. Whether you’re chasing down ocean-fresh oysters or plotting your next elegant date night, there’s a quiet thrill in finding that perfect spot by the water’s edge—or discovering a neighborhood gem tucked away from the crowds.
After plenty of personal forays for just the right crispy calamari or the kind of grilled fish that actually tastes like it saw the sea, I’ve put together this list with precision and care. Each place here has earned its stripes, and you’ll find something for every craving, from sushi to platters piled high with shellfish. Settle in and cast your net a little wider—New Haven’s best seafood awaits.
Where to find the best seafood in New Haven, CT
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in New Haven, CT:
- Shell & Bones Oyster Bar And Grill
- Atelier Florian
- D’Amato’s Seafood II
- Fair Haven Oyster Co.
- Kevins Seafood
- Westville Seafood
- Cajun Boiled Seafood CT
- Otaru Sushi Bar
- Pacifico Restaurant
- The Deck At Amarante’s
1. Shell & Bones Oyster Bar And Grill
It’s easy to see why Shell & Bones Oyster Bar And Grill reels in both locals and visitors. Nestled right on the waterfront, the views alone are worth the trip, but the real star is the seafood lineup. On my last visit, I snagged a seat by the window and watched the sun set over rows of glistening oysters.
Their award-winning clam chowder is a solid opener—creamy and brimming with flavor, it’s no wonder it snagged top honors at The Big Taste competition. If you’re in the mood for something bold, try the whole roasted branzino. It’s expertly prepared, highlighting their commitment to freshness and classic technique.
Between the attentive staff, made-in-house desserts, and the glowing atmosphere, Shell & Bones sets the bar high for seafood in New Haven.
2. Atelier Florian
Set on bustling Chapel Street, Atelier Florian combines a fresh, coastal vibe with the refined touch of Belgian cuisine. The relaxed space feels just right for a laid-back lunch or an unhurried dinner with friends. On my last visit, the staff guided me toward their pristine seafood options, and the results didn’t disappoint.
The real standout here is the Moules Frites, a classic Belgian dish done with a Connecticut flourish. The mussels arrive in aromatic broths that bring out the sea’s subtle flavor, while the crisp fries serve as perfect partners. Each plate is a reminder of their dedication to local, sustainable ingredients.
If you want to branch out, try the grilled seafood platter. Atelier Florian’s thoughtful approach guarantees each bite is as fresh as it gets.
3. D’Amato’s Seafood II
+1 203-498-2722
D’Amato’s Seafood II keeps things straightforward but delivers exactly what seafood fans crave—freshness and flavor, no frills attached. A neighborhood staple, this place feels like a well-kept local secret, tucked into Whalley Avenue’s mix of storefronts. My last stop in was for a quick lunch, and I found myself eyeing the counter brimming with the day’s catches.
The highlight here is the fried fish platter. It’s golden, crisp, and cooked just right, letting the quality of the fish shine through. If you’re a fan of clams, their clam strips are a satisfying classic—lightly battered and never greasy.
Pair your meal with their simple sides and you’ll see why regulars return week after week. D’Amato’s isn’t fancy, but it’s real—and sometimes that’s exactly what you want.
4. Fair Haven Oyster Co.
Perched by the riverside, Fair Haven Oyster Co. brings a cool, laid-back energy to New Haven’s seafood roster. The dining room offers a welcoming space that feels just right for a relaxed evening with friends. When I visited, the chatter and clinking of glasses created a warm backdrop for some seriously good seafood.
The menu doesn’t stray far from its roots—start with the fresh oysters, locally sourced and expertly shucked. Each one tasted like a briny breeze, proof that Fair Haven knows how to showcase quality. The grilled fish options rotate with the market, and every dish I’ve tried is packed with flavor and handled with care.
For anyone craving a down-to-earth spot with top-tier seafood, this place delivers on all fronts.
5. Kevins Seafood
Kevins Seafood doesn’t bother with fancy frills—it lets the food do all the impressing. Tucked on Kimberly Avenue, this spot turns out hearty portions that never skimp on freshness or flavor. My first visit started with the classic fish and chips, and I still think about that crispy bite.
The menu is full of straightforward favorites, but the shrimp platter stands out. Each shrimp arrives perfectly golden, with a light crunch that gives way to sweet, tender seafood beneath. Sides are simple but satisfying, letting the main attraction really shine.
Whether you come for takeout or stay awhile, Kevins offers a taste of reliable, fuss-free seafood that keeps regulars happily coming back.
6. Westville Seafood
Westville Seafood keeps things classic, serving up generous plates that haven’t lost their New England roots. This spot always feels familiar, with a steady flow of regulars swapping stories as they wait for their meals. My last order—a quick takeout—turned into a picnic of pure comfort.
Here, the sea scallop dinner deserves special mention. It’s an unfussy plate: just sweet, tender scallops with a side of crispy fries. Their fried fish is flaky and light, proof there is art in simplicity when the ingredients are top notch.
If you’re after honest, satisfying seafood prepared with zero pretension, Westville is certain to earn its spot on your list.
7. Cajun Boiled Seafood CT
If you’re looking for a lively escape from New England tradition, Cajun Boiled Seafood CT delivers. The moment you walk in, there’s a buzz—piles of seafood, diners donning bibs, and the unmistakable scent of spices in the air. My first visit was a deliciously messy affair that left me craving more.
The real draw here is the customizable seafood boil. Choose from shrimp, crab, or clams, then pick your heat level and sauce. Each combo arrives in a steaming bag, loaded with corn and potatoes for a feast that’s bold, hands-on, and packed with flavor. You’ll want to roll up your sleeves for this one.
Cajun Boiled Seafood CT blends Southern spice with local ingredients, offering a unique experience that stands out in New Haven’s seafood scene.
8. Otaru Sushi Bar
Otaru Sushi Bar is where seafood takes an elegant turn, right in downtown New Haven. The intimate setting feels both modern and welcoming, perfect for an unhurried dinner or a quick bite before a show. I first wandered in on a whim and found myself quickly converted by the chef’s attention to detail.
What sets Otaru apart is the standout sushi and sashimi, always served fresh and artfully presented. The signature rolls are a treat, but for purists, their simple nigiri lets the fish speak for itself—each piece is supple and never overwhelmed by sauce. If you’re curious, ask about the specials, which often feature creative combinations using the best of the day’s catch.
Otaru excels at blending Japanese tradition with a distinct local freshness, making it a must for seafood lovers.
9. Pacifico Restaurant
Pacifico Restaurant brings a dash of Latin flair to New Haven’s seafood landscape, right in the heart of downtown. The space glows with a spirited energy, and every dish delivers both color and depth of flavor. My own dinner here felt like a quick trip to the coast of South America—minus the plane ticket.
The true centerpiece is the Seafood Paella, overflowing with shrimp, clams, and more, nestled in saffron-infused rice that packs subtle but memorable spice. For those looking for something lighter, try the caramelized salmon, which arrives golden and smooth with citrus undertones.
Pacifico nails that hard-to-find mix of inventive cooking and unwavering quality, easily making it a top pick for seafood in New Haven.
10. The Deck At Amarante’s
The Deck At Amarante’s is all about atmosphere—perched over the water, it’s the kind of place where sea breezes pair naturally with a plate of seafood. During a recent visit, I found it hard to focus on the menu with such a stunning waterfront view, but the food easily matched the setting.
The star here is the grilled catch of the day. It’s prepared simply, which lets the freshness shine, making every bite taste straight from the ocean. The lobster salad comes packed with flavor and just the right amount of zest, an ideal choice when you want something both satisfying and light.
If eating outdoors is your thing, The Deck offers that laid-back coastal vibe with memorable seafood to match.
More Things to Try in New Haven, CT
Frequently Asked Questions
What seafood is New Haven known for?
New Haven’s reputation starts with fresh local oysters and clams, thanks to its coastal location. Many restaurants also serve standout fish dishes and creative seafood platters.
Where can I find halal or kosher seafood options in New Haven?
Fin And Scale – Kosher Sushi & Bar is a popular choice for kosher seafood. For halal, it’s best to check with each restaurant directly about ingredient sourcing and preparation.
Which seafood restaurants have waterfront views?
Shell & Bones Oyster Bar And Grill and The Deck At Amarante’s both offer beautiful waterfront dining experiences with menus to match.
Do New Haven seafood restaurants offer vegetarian options?
Several spots, such as Atelier Florian, Pacifico Restaurant, and Shell & Bones, offer varied vegetarian and gluten-free choices alongside their seafood selections.
Is takeout available at seafood restaurants in New Haven?
Yes, many places—including Kevins Seafood, Westville Seafood, and Otaru Sushi Bar—offer convenient takeout for enjoying seafood at home.