Finding great seafood in North Babylon feels a bit like uncovering a hidden pearl in an oyster. My first visit had me chasing recommendations from locals who hinted at crab boils that sell out before sundown, and fried fish so fresh it might as well have leaped from the bay and onto your plate. There’s a certain thrill in discovering which kitchens are sending steam and brine into the air, and I’ve strolled these blocks—fork in hand, curiosity leading the way—tasting, talking, and, at times, marveling at just how much variety one small area can hold.
What sets North Babylon’s seafood scene apart isn’t just freshness, but sheer character and creativity. You’ll find family run spots where the owners might tell you the story behind the day’s catch, bustling grills that mix seafood with local flavor, and laid-back clam shacks that serve comfort on a tray. If you’re searching for not just the best seafood, but the right seafood for any mood or craving, you’re in the right place. Dive in and let’s take a closer look at the spots that make North Babylon a must for seafood lovers.
Where to find the best seafood in North Babylon, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in North Babylon, NY:
- Voo Doo Crab
- Hibachi Grill
- B&B Fish and Clam Inc.
- the main catch
- Babylon Fish & Clam
- Crab Shack
- Southside Fish & Clam
- Nicky’s Clam Bar
- Chowder Bar
- Seagull Restaurant and Bar
1. Voo Doo Crab
Voo Doo Crab on Deer Park Avenue captures the art of the seafood boil with real skill. Step inside and you’ll catch the aroma of signature spices mingling with fresh shellfish. My first visit turned into a feast; gloves and bibs on, I dove into their classic crab legs and shrimp boil. The juices, rich with garlic and citrus, set a new standard for me.
What makes Voo Doo Crab unique is its laid-back, lively atmosphere—perfect for messy hands and a good laugh with friends.
If you’re ready to try the heart of their menu, order a seafood combo with crab, shrimp, and mussels. The sauces, from mild to spicy, show off why this spot draws steady crowds. Everything here feels fresh, bold, and just right for sharing.
2. Hibachi Grill
(631) 274-0888Call
Hibachi Grill isn’t just a buffet—it’s a seafood lover’s playground on Deer Park Ave. The sheer scale of this place is impressive, with row after row of fresh selections and a hibachi station that brings the sizzle right to your plate. My personal highlight? Piling my plate with salmon, shrimp, and mussels, then handing it over to the hibachi chef for a made-to-order masterpiece.
The variety sets Hibachi Grill apart in North Babylon. With a spread of over 350 items, there’s something here for every palate. If seafood is your focus, don’t miss the butter shrimp or the salmon right off the grill. Their sushi options add another layer of freshness, perfect for mixing and matching.
Whether you’re in for a quick bite or a family feast, this spot delivers plenty of fresh flavors and a sense of abundance that’s hard to beat.
3. B&B Fish and Clam Inc.
B&B Fish and Clam Inc. blends old-school fish market charm with a cozy spot to eat right on Merrick Road. This is the kind of place where you can see exactly where your seafood is coming from before it’s cooked up. I stopped in for a quick lunch and found myself chatting with the staff about the morning’s deliveries.
The menu keeps it classic but never dull. Go for the fried flounder sandwich or a cup of clam chowder—both deliver on freshness and flavor. Their clam strips, always crisp, make a great snack or side.
B&B stands out for honest portions, simple prep, and true market-to-table spirit. If you love discovering neighborhood gems, this is a must-try in the North Babylon area.
4. the main catch
(631) 486-8864Call
The Main Catch makes it clear from the start: Freshness comes first. The kitchen sources prime seafood from local Long Island waters, and you can taste the difference in every bite. I remember sitting along the window, savoring perfectly grilled scallops as the staff chatted about the morning’s fluke delivery.
The atmosphere is relaxed but polished, perfect for anything from a family meal to a casual date night. Their signature oyster platter and sushi rolls are both crowd-pleasers. If you want to get a true sense of the menu, try the combo brimming with clams, mussels, and shrimp.
Main Catch’s unwavering focus on quality and presentation makes it a standout near North Babylon. This spot is a safe bet when cravings for clean, bright seafood hit.
5. Babylon Fish & Clam
Babylon Fish & Clam has long been a local favorite for classic seafood, tucked just off Fire Island Ave. Step through the doors and you’re met with a cozy, no-fuss setting and the smell of perfectly cooked fish wafting from the kitchen. My first stop had me sampling their clam chowder, which was creamy, balanced, and packed with flavor.
What makes this spot memorable is its knack for simple, honest seafood done right. The flounder filet is well-loved—always lightly battered, fried crisp, and served with a smile. Their steamed clams deliver a burst of sea freshness that’s tough to beat.
If you’re searching for unfussy, real-deal seafood in the North Babylon area, Babylon Fish & Clam hits the mark every time.
6. Crab Shack
(631) 920-5960Call
Crab Shack on Straight Path delivers the authentic seafood boil experience without any pretense. The moment you walk in, you get a sense that this spot is all about letting the food do the talking. I still remember cracking into a pile of steaming crab legs, savoring the subtle spice and buttery juices that set everything apart.
Generous portions and unfussy sides make Crab Shack a go-to for casual seafood fans. Their combo platters with shrimp, lobster, and snow crab are perfect for sharing—or, truthfully, for ambitious solo eaters.
If you’re craving hands-on eating with big flavors, this is where you want to be. Crab Shack’s straightforward approach and fresh ingredients keep regulars coming back.
7. Southside Fish & Clam
Southside Fish & Clam mixes local seafood favorites with a touch of Italian flair on Montauk Highway. The space feels both welcoming and lively, perfect for family gatherings or a relaxed evening out. When I stopped in, I couldn’t pass up the linguine with fresh clams—a simple dish elevated by tender shellfish and bright herbs.
The menu goes beyond the basics, offering a range of dishes that highlight what’s fresh and local. Try the broiled scallops or the catch of the day, both reflecting the kitchen’s commitment to quality and flavor.
Southside’s blend of comfort and creativity makes it a favorite for those looking for more than just the standard fare in the North Babylon area.
8. Nicky’s Clam Bar
Nicky’s Clam Bar brings waterfront dining to life on Maple Ave with a casual spirit and a love for local seafood. The bustle of the marina sets the mood, whether you’re inside or taking in the view from the patio. My first meal here was a plate of steamed littleneck clams—tender, briny, and just the thing to kick off a summer afternoon.
Nicky’s charms come from a menu that’s big on Long Island classics. The baked clams, served golden and hot, never disappoint. For those who like a little spice, the fra diavolo with shrimp and clams is a standout.
From clam strips to daily specials, Nicky’s offers a taste of tradition that keeps seafood lovers coming back.
9. Chowder Bar
Chowder Bar on Maple Ave is the down-to-earth spot where locals gather for no-frills, well-prepared seafood. The friendly buzz of conversation mixes with the aroma of homemade soups and fresh fish from the kitchen. My last visit was all about their creamy New England clam chowder—silky, full of clams, and genuinely comforting on a chilly day.
This place stands out for its approachable prices and unwavering quality. Besides chowder, the fried oyster sandwich and the seafood platter both bring generous portions and real flavor. The menu’s variety, from light salads to hearty seafood, lets you build your perfect meal.
Chowder Bar’s charm rests in consistency and honest cooking. It’s an easy pick for anyone craving straightforward seafood near North Babylon.
10. Seagull Restaurant and Bar
(631) 620-3340Call
Seagull Restaurant and Bar captures that easy-going bayfront vibe where summer never quite ends. The patio here is a favorite spot—salty air, the sound of water, and the kind of relaxed energy families love. My first bite was their broiled flounder, which tasted fresh and light, just as it should with a waterfront view.
What sets Seagull apart is its commitment to classic, crowd-pleasing seafood with no fuss. The grilled shrimp skewers and scallops get high marks for flavor and a perfectly cooked finish. For a group, the seafood platter makes sharing easy and keeps the conversation going.
This is a great choice for anyone searching for a breezy meal with plenty of fresh seafood near North Babylon.
More Things to Try in North Babylon, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in North Babylon, NY?
Some of the most popular spots include Voo Doo Crab, Crab Shack, Hibachi Grill, and Babylon Fish & Clam. Each offers fresh seafood and a range of specialties worth trying.
Which restaurants offer seafood boils near North Babylon?
Voo Doo Crab and Crab Shack are known for standout seafood boils loaded with crab, shrimp, and more. These places are great for a hands-on, flavorful dining experience.
Are there affordable seafood options in North Babylon?
Yes, places like Chowder Bar and Hibachi Grill make it easy to enjoy seafood without spending too much. Look for lunch specials or family-style platters.
Where can I find the freshest catch in North Babylon?
B&B Fish and Clam Inc. and the main catch are highly rated for fresh, local seafood. Both have a strong market-to-table vibe and daily specials that highlight what’s in season.
Do any seafood spots offer takeout or delivery?
Many seafood restaurants in North Babylon, including Voo Doo Crab and Chowder Bar, offer takeout. It’s best to call ahead or check their websites for the latest options.