Seafood lovers in Nutley know there’s something special in the local air—or is it just the scent of sizzling, spiced calamari drifting from a busy kitchen? Nutley’s seafood scene rewards the curious and the hungry alike. From time-honored fish fries tucked away from the main drag to modern spots dabbling with creative shellfish platters, every craving finds its match. I once dove fork-first into a platter of grilled sea bass at a tiny spot near Franklin Avenue and found myself plotting a return visit before the check even arrived.
Finding the best seafood in Nutley isn’t a guessing game. With the right guide, you’ll avoid the bland and zero in on the fresh, the tender, and the memorable. Whether you’re a fan of plump shrimp or classic clam chowder, these local spots have you covered—and then some. Get ready to chart a path through Nutley’s top seafood destinations, where hidden gems and bold flavors await discovery.
Where to find the best seafood in Nutley, NJ
Here are some of the top spots to find the best seafood in Nutley, NJ:
- Woodcroft Steakhouse & Seafood
- Nutley Diner
- Sake Sushi
- New Crab Palace II
- Crockett’s Fish Fry
- Fin Raw Bar & Kitchen
- Joe’s Crab Shack
- Halcyon
- Biggie’ S Clam Bar
- D-Puebla A Veracruz
1. Woodcroft Steakhouse & Seafood
Step into Woodcroft Steakhouse & Seafood, and you’ll notice the rustic charm anchored by that unmistakable steakhouse buzz. This spot combines old-school sophistication with a touch of energy that keeps diners coming back.
It’s easy to focus on the steaks, but the seafood menu deserves the spotlight. After sampling their grilled branzino, I found myself slow down, savoring every forkful with the kind of attention usually reserved for birthdays. The kitchen’s skill shines in dishes like the pan-seared salmon—perfectly crisp outside, silky inside.
If you want something shareable, try their crab-stuffed mushrooms. The flavors are clever without being overdone, letting quality ingredients shine. For seafood fans, Woodcroft makes a dependable go-to in Nutley for a refined but relaxed meal.
2. Nutley Diner
Nutley Diner is the classic local spot where comfort meets endless variety. The inviting energy, welcoming decor, and round-the-clock hours make it a neighborhood staple. It’s not just the pancakes or burgers that pull in the regulars—the seafood offerings surprise with both freshness and value.
I once stopped in for a late lunch and found myself lingering over a generous plate of broiled tilapia. The simple seasoning and flakey texture hit every mark for diner-style seafood. Their shrimp salad platter also stands out as a light yet satisfying choice, perfect for a quick bite any time of day.
If you’re looking for a place where tradition and comfort food come together, Nutley Diner covers every base—including reliably good seafood in a laid-back setting.
3. Sake Sushi
Sake Sushi brings a sleek touch to Centre Street, drawing in both sushi newcomers and purists. The clean decor and attentive staff set the stage for what’s always a satisfying meal. When I sat at the counter, the chef’s delicate approach to plating and fresh flavors impressed me right away.
The salmon avocado roll is a staple—silky, fresh, never heavy. If you’re adventurous, try their yellowtail scallion roll or the chef’s daily sashimi selection, where quality really shines. Each dish arrives artfully arranged, highlighting Sake Sushi’s focus on both taste and presentation.
This is a place where you linger over lunch, savor bright flavors, and leave already craving your next visit. Their seafood offerings always feel light, fresh, and true to Japanese tradition.
4. New Crab Palace II
(973) 624-8889Call
New Crab Palace II brings a lively, no-fuss seafood experience to the University Heights crowd. It’s a casual favorite where big flavors and generous platters set the mood for sharing and digging in. When I last visited with a group, the bustling dining room was packed with families cracking shells and swapping bites.
The crab legs take center stage—sweet, plump, and easy to love. The shrimp boil, tossed in flavorful garlic sauce, is another crowd-pleaser, showing off the kitchen’s approach to bold, comforting tastes.
New Crab Palace II is the place to roll up your sleeves and get your hands dirty. The appeal is in the unfussy, hearty seafood that always brings people together for a satisfying meal.
5. Crockett’s Fish Fry
(973) 746-2114Call
Crockett’s Fish Fry feels like stepping into a seafood joint straight from the coast, tucked neatly in Montclair. The casual setup and scent of fresh fry oil hint at a straightforward, satisfying meal ahead. My last trip had me savoring crispy flounder, fried to a perfect golden crunch—comfort food done with care.
The fried shrimp platter is a standout, always made to order and served with just the right amount of seasoning. For sides, their coleslaw is tangy without overpowering, rounding out each plate perfectly. Even the fish sandwiches, with flaky cod and a soft bun, are a reliable pick for a quick lunch.
If you’re after classic fish fry fare with no filler, Crockett’s delivers every time. This spot keeps things simple, fresh, and delicious, making it a must for seafood fans near Nutley.
6. Fin Raw Bar & Kitchen
Fin Raw Bar & Kitchen elevates seafood dining in Montclair with its modern style and fresh, market-driven menu. The bright, contemporary space sets the mood for a relaxed yet refined experience. My last visit started at the marble-topped raw bar, where oysters glistened and the vibe was unmistakably lively.
The selection of East Coast oysters is a highlight—briny, plump, and served over shimmering ice. If you lean toward the warm side, the grilled branzino offers delicate flavors that showcase the chef’s skill with simple ingredients. The seafood risotto brings together creamy textures and ocean-fresh taste in every bite.
Fin is the perfect place for sampling, lingering, and enjoying seafood at its peak. You’ll walk away with a new favorite on the menu and a reason to come back.
7. Joe’s Crab Shack
Joe’s Crab Shack delivers a spirited seafood experience not far from Nutley, blending a playful vibe with a wide-ranging menu. The lively atmosphere makes it a go-to for groups eager to roll up their sleeves and crack into a feast. On my recent visit, I couldn’t help but be drawn in by the aroma of seasoned crab legs steaming out of a classic metal bucket.
The steamed Dungeness crab is always reliable—tender, lifted with just the right touch of spice and lemon. Their seasoned shrimp bowls are great for sharing, while the fish tacos balance crispness with tangy slaw. Portions are hearty, and every platter brings a bit of sunny shore-town energy to the table.
At Joe’s, seafood dining feels uncomplicated and fun. It’s a solid choice close to Nutley for anyone after good seafood and laughter in equal measure.
8. Halcyon
(973) 744-4450Call
Halcyon brings refined seafood dining to Montclair, fusing French inspiration with local freshness. The polished art deco interior and attentive staff create an elegant escape just minutes from Nutley. The last time I dined here, there was a sense of calm from the start—each plate arrived as a small work of art.
The pan-seared scallops are among the best in the area—delicate, sweet, and perfectly cooked. Their roasted branzino also stands out, pairing flaky fish with light, seasonal vegetables for a balanced dish. Every element feels thoughtfully prepared, right down to the sauces.
Halcyon is the kind of place where seafood gets star treatment. It’s ideal for a memorable night out or celebrating something special, offering both style and substance in every bite.
9. Biggie’ S Clam Bar
Biggie’s Clam Bar is the kind of spot where casual dining meets serious seafood tradition. The Carlstadt location has a lively, no-pressure vibe—think classic Jersey clam bar with a few surprises. My last trip was a midday detour turned delight, thanks to a perfectly chilled plate of freshly shucked littleneck clams.
Raw clams and oysters headline the menu, served ice-cold and bright with a splash of lemon. Their steamed mussels in garlic broth strike a balance between comfort and bold flavor, while the crab cake sandwich boasts plenty of real crab and minimal filler.
Biggie’s keeps it simple but satisfying. If you’re near Nutley and craving fresh shellfish or straightforward, expertly prepared seafood, it’s a stop worth making.
10. D-Puebla A Veracruz
(973) 916-9977Call
D-Puebla A Veracruz brings coastal Mexican flavors to Passaic, offering a menu that’s both lively and comforting. The wide tables, friendly staff, and bustling atmosphere make it feel like a family gathering every night. I still remember the first time I tried their seafood soup—every spoonful was brimming with fresh taste and just the right touch of spice.
The ceviche at D-Puebla A Veracruz stands out—zesty, crisp, and perfect for sharing. Their grilled fish tacos offer a taste of the coast with each bite, wrapped in warm tortillas and topped with bright, tangy salsas. There’s real balance here between freshness and bold flavors.
If you want a spot where seafood comes with a Latin twist near Nutley, this is the place to savor authentic comfort and lively dishes.
More Things to Try in Nutley, NJ
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of seafood can I find in Nutley, NJ?
Nutley’s seafood spots serve everything from classic fried fish and shrimp to sushi, oysters, branzino, and crab legs. You’ll also find Latin and Asian twists on fresh seafood dishes at area favorites.
Are there any seafood restaurants in Nutley that offer halal or alcohol-free options?
Some local restaurants may offer halal seafood dishes—calling ahead is a good idea to confirm options. Many focus on family dining where alcohol isn’t central to the experience.
Which restaurants are best for a casual seafood meal in or near Nutley?
Nutley Diner, Crockett’s Fish Fry, and New Crab Palace II all offer laid-back settings and crowd-pleasing menus. Grab a platter and settle in for comfort food done right.
What’s the best place for special-occasion seafood dining close to Nutley?
Halcyon and Fin Raw Bar & Kitchen, both in Montclair, are favorites for refined, beautifully-plated seafood perfect for date nights, anniversaries, or celebrations.
Do any seafood places in Nutley offer takeout or delivery?
Yes, most of Nutley’s top seafood restaurants offer takeout, and several partner with delivery services for easy at-home meals. Check restaurant websites for up-to-date ordering options.
Can I find fresh, non-fried seafood dishes in Nutley?
Absolutely. Many spots, including Woodcroft Steakhouse & Seafood and Sake Sushi, focus on grilled, broiled, or raw preparations that let the seafood shine without frying.