The search for exceptional seafood in Ocean County, NJ is a delicious journey worth taking. There’s a certain charm in peeling open a fresh shrimp or dipping a piece of flaky fish into tangy sauce while salt air drifts in from the Jersey Shore. Ocean County hosts a parade of seafood spots—each offering its own twist on classic dishes. Whether you grew up with clam bakes or just appreciate a good lobster roll, this is a place where fresh catches shine.
I remember my first oyster in Ocean County—sitting at a weathered table with a view of the water, a hint of sea breeze cutting through the summer heat. The simple joy of that briny, cold bite convinced me that great seafood finds are hiding everywhere here, if you just know where to look. This guide promises clear, honest picks for seafood lovers who want flavor, freshness, and maybe a little adventure by the sea. Prepare to discover the county’s standouts, each ready to make your next meal memorable.
1. Gregory’s
**Gregory’s is one of those rare places where the seafood speaks for itself.** Tucked away on New Jersey Ave in Manchester Township, it keeps things unfussy while focusing on top-tier freshness and quality. Step through the doors and you’ll notice the laid-back warmth that regulars love.
The first time I tried their broiled scallops, I understood why Gregory’s has a loyal following. The scallops arrived perfectly tender, kissed with a gentle seasoning that let the sea flavor shine. This spot is also well-known for its classic crab cakes, packed with sweet crab meat and very little filler—just how it should be.
Order the flounder sandwich or the shrimp platter if you want to sample what makes Gregory’s stand out. Simple, well-executed, and always satisfying, their dishes are a snapshot of Ocean County’s seafood spirit.
2. Water Street Bar & Grille
**Water Street Bar & Grille nails that breezy, waterfront dining vibe in downtown Toms River.** The spot boasts a massive deck perched above the river, making it easy to lose track of time while watching boats drift past. During my last visit, live music poured out onto the dock, setting the perfect backdrop for a relaxed seafood dinner.
The menu feels tailored for summer days and nights. The grilled salmon and fish tacos are must-tries, beautifully prepared without fuss. If you like to mix and match, their seafood platter offers a great sample of local favorites.
**Freshness and flavor take the lead here**. For anyone looking for a friendly place to unwind, Water Street delivers the complete package—great views, smooth service, and seafood that does the Jersey Shore proud.
3. Red Lobster
**Red Lobster in Toms River delivers a familiar yet satisfying seafood experience, perfect for family dinners or casual get-togethers.** The lively atmosphere feels both welcoming and energetic, thanks in part to friendly service and a constant stream of tempting dishes.
On a recent visit, I found myself drawn to their signature shrimp scampi, which arrives hot and fragrant with just the right amount of garlic. The **grilled fish selections** are also solid, letting the freshness of each catch take center stage.
If you want the classic Red Lobster experience, go for the **Admiral’s Feast**. Piled with crispy seafood favorites, it’s a crowd-pleaser and captures that sense of abundance. Red Lobster nails consistency, which is why it’s a go-to spot in Ocean County for seafood cravings.
4. Monte’s Fish Fry
(732) 886-2119Call
**Monte’s Fish Fry brings that small-town seafood shack energy to Toms River.** The atmosphere is laid-back but the kitchen takes its craft seriously, with a steady stream of regulars picking up generous platters at the counter. My first time here, the aroma of frying fish pulled me in from the parking lot.
The menu covers everything from classic fried flounder to house-made coleslaw that rivals the fish itself. The fish and chips are a must-try; crispy batter, flaky fish, and just the right amount of seasoning show Monte’s keeps things honest and flavorful.
If you’re in the mood for a true Jersey-style seafood meal, order the shrimp basket. **Monte’s Fish Fry keeps things simple—just quality, freshness, and plenty of flavor in every bite.**
5. Bay Treasure Seafood
**Bay Treasure Seafood sits right off Route 9 and lives up to its name as a hidden gem for the freshest catches.** Not only do they serve lunch and dinner, but they’re also a top pick for locals who want to bring home seafood straight from the source. The smell of saltwater and the sight of display cases packed with glistening fillets make every visit memorable.
During my last stop, I was drawn to their grilled fish sandwich—simple, hearty, and brimming with freshness. Bay Treasure’s lobster salad is a frequent favorite, offering real flavor without any unnecessary extras.
If you appreciate top-grade fish prepared with a straightforward touch, this is the kind of place that will keep you coming back. **It’s an honest Ocean County staple.**
6. Trinity Seafood
**Trinity Seafood brings the market experience right to your plate in Lakewood.** Known among locals for its high standards and friendly staff, this spot offers some of the freshest seafood you’ll find without heading to the coast. The bustling case of seafood caught my eye on my first visit—clean, ice-cold, and never lacking variety.
Everything here screams fresh. The grilled salmon stands out for its simplicity and bold, pure flavors. The shrimp platter also gets high marks, with perfectly cooked shrimp that need little more than a squeeze of lemon.
If you’re after the true taste of Ocean County seafood, let the staff point you toward their daily specials. **Trinity Seafood focuses on quality over fuss, serving up seafood that’s honest and thoroughly satisfying.**
7. A1 Seafood Center
(732) 929-1118Call
**A1 Seafood Center has earned its name as one of the top spots for freshly caught seafood in Toms River.** Walk in and you’re met with a clean, bustling market atmosphere and a staff that’s genuinely excited about seafood. On my first visit, I wandered in for takeout but ended up picking out fish to cook at home, drawn by the quality and selection on ice.
The grilled flounder is prepared just right—tender, with a mild flavor that reminds you how fresh it is. If you want something hearty, the jumbo shrimp platter hits the spot, served with a side of their house-made cocktail sauce.
**A1 Seafood Center is all about providing options, whether you want a quick, satisfying meal or ingredients for your own seafood feast.** They’re a true Ocean County staple for good reason.
8. Crab’s Claw Inn
**Crab’s Claw Inn in Lavallette has been a local go-to for decades, thanks to its lively vibe and impressive seafood lineup.** Sitting on Grand Central Ave, this place is open year-round and caters to both locals and beach-goers looking for a true Jersey Shore meal. I remember walking in on a chilly evening—the bustling bar, warm lighting, and the scent of fresh seafood hit instantly.
The walls are filled with nods to the shore and regulars often rave about the blue claw crab cakes. These are packed with sweet, fresh crab and hardly any filler, stealing the show every time. For something a bit lighter, try the grilled shrimp salad loaded with crisp veggies and chilled house dressing.
**Crab’s Claw Inn blends comfort, quality, and a bit of beach-town nostalgia into every meal.**
9. Crab Shack
**Crab Shack in Brick delivers seaside charm without the fuss, making it a favorite for locals and summer regulars alike.** The place has an easygoing market feel—walk up, glance at the ice-packed seafood counter, and you know you’re in expert hands. I stumbled in once after a long beach day, craving something simple and fresh, and found exactly that.
The steamed crabs are the highlight, served piping hot and bursting with that unmistakable Jersey Shore flavor. Their broiled scallops and shrimp platters also hit the sweet spot, light on extras and heavy on fresh taste.
Crab Shack stands out for its consistency and lack of pretense. **If you love straightforward seafood with no distractions, this spot will feel just right.**
10. Pisces Seafood
**Pisces Seafood on Route 37 East is all about classic comfort and honest flavors.** The casual, family-style setting is perfect for weeknight dinners and makes everyone feel like part of the regular crowd. My first visit, I was greeted by the aroma of grilled fish and the sound of happy chatter from packed tables—always a good sign.
The broiled scallops and flounder fillet are standouts, both cooked to let the seafood’s natural sweetness come forward. Their fish chowder has a loyal local following, with hearty pieces of fresh fish in each spoonful.
Pisces Seafood is BYOB, which is ideal for those looking to pair a favorite drink with their meal. **Come for the inviting vibe and stick around for food that does Ocean County proud.**
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best seafood restaurants in Ocean County, NJ?
Ocean County is packed with standout seafood spots like Gregory’s, Crab’s Claw Inn, Pisces Seafood, and Crab Shack. Each has its own style, from casual takeout counters to sit-down restaurants with waterfront views.
Where can I find fresh seafood markets in Ocean County?
You’ll find quality seafood markets at places like A1 Seafood Center, Bay Treasure Seafood, and Skipper’s Seafood Market. These spots let you pick up the day’s catch and prepare it at home or order something cooked on the spot.
Are there Ocean County seafood restaurants with waterfront dining?
Yes, Water Street Bar & Grille in Toms River and The Lobster Shanty in Point Pleasant offer riverside or bay views that pair perfectly with their menus.
What seafood dishes should I try in Ocean County?
Classic options include broiled scallops, crab cakes with minimal filler, grilled flounder, and shrimp platters. These dishes let the region’s fresh catches take center stage.
Is it easy to find casual, family-friendly seafood restaurants?
Absolutely. Places like Red Lobster, Monte’s Fish Fry, and Pisces Seafood all offer a relaxed vibe, friendly service, and menus that work for all ages.
Can I order takeout seafood in Ocean County?
Many seafood restaurants and markets offer takeout or prepared meals. Some even have counters with ready-to-go options, making it easy to enjoy fresh seafood anywhere.
