Best Seafood in Panama City Beach, FL

Panama City Beach is a seafood lover’s paradise, where the Gulf of Mexico serves up some of the freshest catches you’ll ever taste. From casual beachside shacks to upscale dining spots, the variety here is as vast as the ocean itself. I’ve spent countless hours exploring the local seafood scene, savoring everything from buttery crab legs to perfectly grilled grouper. Each restaurant has its own charm, and I’ve made it my mission to find the best spots that not only deliver on flavor but also adhere to halal standards, ensuring a worry-free dining experience.

What makes Panama City Beach unique is its ability to blend laid-back coastal vibes with culinary excellence. Whether you’re craving Cajun-inspired dishes, classic Gulf shrimp, or a hearty seafood boil, this guide will steer you toward the top spots that have earned their reputation. I’ve tasted, tested, and talked to locals to bring you a curated list of the best seafood restaurants in the area. So, if you’re ready to dive into a world of flavor, let’s explore the gems that make Panama City Beach a seafood destination worth savoring.

1. Bayou Bill’s Crab House

Bayou Bill’s Crab House is a must-visit for seafood enthusiasts in Panama City Beach. Nestled along Front Beach Road, this charming eatery offers a warm, inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home. During my visit, I was captivated by the friendly staff and the tantalizing aroma of fresh seafood wafting through the air.

What sets Bayou Bill’s apart is its commitment to quality and flavor. The crab legs are a standout, perfectly steamed and served with a side of melted butter that enhances their natural sweetness. For a true taste of the Gulf, don’t miss the shrimp po’boy, which is generously stuffed with crispy shrimp and zesty remoulade.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options available, there’s something for everyone. Bayou Bill’s Crab House is not just a meal; it’s an experience that captures the essence of coastal dining.

2. Dee’s Hang Out

Dee’s Hang Out is a hidden gem in Panama City Beach, tucked away in the Shoppes at Edgewater. This cozy spot offers a laid-back atmosphere with a touch of Southern charm, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

The standout feature of Dee’s is its creative take on Gulf Coast cuisine. They pride themselves on using fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, and their dishes are crafted with care. The menu is a delightful mix of seafood favorites and Southern comfort food, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

During my visit, the blackened shrimp was a highlight—tender, flavorful, and perfectly seasoned. Pair it with their creamy coleslaw for a well-balanced meal. Dee’s also offers vegetarian and gluten-free options, making it inclusive for all diners.

What truly sets Dee’s apart is its commitment to quality and hospitality. It’s a place where you can enjoy a hearty, halal-friendly meal in a warm and welcoming environment. Don’t miss the chance to experience this local treasure.

3. Pompano Joe’s

Pompano Joe’s is a vibrant Caribbean-inspired seafood haven on Panama City Beach’s Front Beach Road. Since 1995, it has been a go-to spot for both locals and tourists, offering a unique blend of tropical flavors and Gulf Coast freshness. My visit was a sensory delight, from the colorful decor to the open-air dining with stunning Gulf views.

What makes Pompano Joe’s stand out is its bold Caribbean flair. The Garlic Crusted Grouper is a must-try—tender, flaky, and bursting with flavor. For a lighter option, the Reggae Rolls, stuffed with shrimp and crab, are a crowd-pleaser. Each dish reflects the restaurant’s commitment to quality and creativity.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options, Pompano Joe’s caters to diverse dietary needs. It’s a place where halal-conscious diners can enjoy a memorable meal in a lively, welcoming atmosphere. Don’t miss this Caribbean gem on the Gulf Coast.

4. Schooners

Schooners isn’t just a restaurant – it’s a Panama City Beach institution where Gulf views and fresh seafood collide in the best possible way. My evening here began with toes in the sand and ended with one of Florida’s most spectacular sunsets painting the sky – all while digging into some of the coast’s most memorable dishes.

The “Local’s Catch” special changes daily but always delivers the Gulf’s freshest flavors with simple, perfect preparation. For something uniquely Schooners, try their signature Bushwacker shrimp – plump Gulf shrimp with a kick of their famous frozen cocktail. Their commitment to quality extends to accommodating various dietary needs with thoughtful vegetarian and gluten-free options.

What truly sets Schooners apart is its magical alchemy of elements – great food, stunning location, and that unbeatable “barefoot luxury” beach vibe that keeps people coming back year after year.

5. The Back Porch Seafood & Oyster House

The Back Porch Seafood & Oyster House is a Panama City Beach classic, serving Gulf Coast flavors since 1974. My visit felt like stepping into a timeless coastal retreat, where the unpretentious vibe and stunning Gulf views create a perfect backdrop for a memorable meal.

What makes The Back Porch stand out is its rich history and commitment to tradition. Their chargrilled Amberjack, a dish they pioneered, is a must-try—flaky, smoky, and bursting with flavor. For a true taste of the Gulf, the raw oysters are fresh, briny, and served with a tangy mignonette sauce.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options, The Back Porch ensures everyone can enjoy their coastal fare. It’s a place where halal-conscious diners can savor the essence of Gulf seafood in a relaxed, welcoming setting. Don’t miss this iconic spot.

6. Saltwater Grill

Saltwater Grill is a Panama City Beach dining experience that combines culinary excellence with a touch of marine magic. The moment you step in, the massive 25,000-gallon saltwater aquarium sets the stage, offering a mesmerizing backdrop of tropical fish and vibrant coral. It’s a feast for the eyes even before the food arrives.

What truly sets Saltwater Grill apart is its dedication to fresh, Gulf-sourced seafood. Their blackened grouper is a standout—crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and bursting with flavor. Another must-try is the seafood pasta, a rich dish brimming with shrimp, scallops, and a creamy garlic sauce.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options, Saltwater Grill ensures inclusivity. The combination of stunning views, high-quality seafood, and halal-conscious options makes it a must-visit for anyone seeking a refined yet approachable dining experience.

7. Dat Cajun Place

Dat Cajun Place brings the vibrant flavors of Louisiana right to Panama City Beach. With a lively atmosphere and live entertainment, it’s a perfect spot for those looking to enjoy authentic Cajun and Creole cuisine. Upon entering, the upbeat vibes and the tantalizing aroma instantly transport you to a cozy New Orleans eatery.

What sets Dat Cajun Place apart is its bold, flavorful dishes made from scratch. Their shrimp and grits are a revelation—plump shrimp, rich sauce, and creamy grits that scream comfort. Another standout is the seafood gumbo, packed with a variety of seafood and a perfectly spiced broth.

The restaurant also offers vegetarian and gluten-free options, making it a welcoming place for everyone. With its warm hospitality and hearty meals, Dat Cajun Place is a must-visit for seafood lovers looking for a taste of Cajun culture.

8. J Michael’s

J Michael’s is a Panama City Beach gem that combines a laid-back vibe with exceptional seafood. My visit was marked by the warm, welcoming atmosphere and the aroma of freshly prepared dishes that filled the air. It’s the kind of place where you can unwind and enjoy a great meal.

What makes J Michael’s stand out is its focus on fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. Their blackened mahi-mahi is a must-try—perfectly seasoned and cooked to flaky perfection. Another standout is the seafood platter, which offers a variety of Gulf favorites like shrimp, oysters, and fish, all expertly prepared.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options, J Michael’s ensures everyone can enjoy their coastal fare. The combination of quality seafood, friendly service, and halal-conscious options makes it a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Panama City Beach.

9. Bayou On The Beach Cafe

Bayou On The Beach Cafe transports diners straight to Louisiana with its authentic Cajun flavors and homey coastal charm. The moment you step inside, the aroma of spices and seafood tells you this isn’t your typical beachside joint – it’s a family recipe-packed experience where every dish tells a story.

What makes this cafe exceptional is its commitment to scratch-made Cajun classics. Their shrimp étouffée, simmered in a rich roux with just the right kick, showcases generations of perfected technique. For seafood purists, the hand-battered fried shrimp platter delivers Gulf-caught sweetness with a satisfyingly crisp coating.

With generous portions and gluten-free options, Bayou satisfies all appetites while staying true to its Louisiana roots. The recent addition of their Steamers & Mercantile shop lets you take their famous boiled seafood home – perfect for enjoying Panama City Beach’s freshest catch with authentic Cajun flair.

10. Mike’s Cafe and Oyster Bar

Mike’s Cafe and Oyster Bar is a Panama City Beach institution, offering a cozy, unpretentious spot to enjoy fresh Gulf seafood. My visit was marked by the warm, welcoming atmosphere and the sight of locals and tourists alike enjoying hearty meals. It’s the kind of place that feels like home.

What sets Mike’s apart is its focus on simplicity and quality. Their oysters, served raw or chargrilled, are a must-try—plump, briny, and bursting with flavor. The seafood platter, featuring a variety of Gulf catches, is another standout, showcasing the restaurant’s commitment to freshness.

With vegetarian and gluten-free options, Mike’s ensures everyone can enjoy their coastal fare. The combination of quality seafood, friendly service, and halal-conscious options makes it a top choice for a memorable dining experience in Panama City Beach.

Frequently Asked Questions

What’s the best seafood restaurant in Panama City Beach?
Panama City Beach offers diverse options, but standout spots include Schooners for beachfront dining and Pompano Joe’s for Caribbean-style seafood. For authentic Cajun flavors, Dat Cajun Place is a local favorite. The “best” depends on your preference—whether you want fine dining, casual beach eats, or specialty cuisines.

Where can I find fresh oysters in Panama City Beach?
Mike’s Cafe and Oyster Bar and The Back Porch Seafood & Oyster House are top choices for fresh oysters, served raw, grilled, or fried. Both emphasize Gulf-sourced seafood and offer a laid-back atmosphere perfect for oyster lovers.

Are there halal-friendly seafood options in Panama City Beach?
While not all restaurants are halal-certified, many—like Saltwater Grill and J Michael’s—offer seafood dishes prepared without alcohol or non-halal ingredients. Always confirm with staff about preparation methods to ensure compliance.

Which Panama City Beach seafood spots have waterfront views?
Schooners and The Back Porch offer stunning Gulf views, while Saltwater Grill features a mesmerizing saltwater aquarium. For a lively dockside vibe, check out Dee’s Hang Out.

What’s a must-try seafood dish in Panama City Beach?
Don’t miss the chargrilled amberjack at The Back Porch or the blackened grouper at Saltwater Grill. For something unique, try the Reggae Rolls (shrimp-stuffed wontons) at Pompano Joe’s.

Are there seafood buffets in Panama City Beach?
Most top seafood spots focus on à la carte dining, but some—like Bayou Bill’s Crab House—offer all-you-can-eat crab legs on select nights. Call ahead for buffet availability.

What’s the best budget-friendly seafood restaurant?
Mike’s Cafe and Bayou On The Beach Cafe offer generous portions at reasonable prices. Lunch specials at Dee’s Hang Out are also a great value.

Where can I get Cajun-style seafood?
Dat Cajun Place and Bayou On The Beach Cafe serve authentic Louisiana flavors. Try the gumbo or shrimp étouffée for a true taste of Cajun cuisine.